Contemplation. How is it for you?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ajecphotos
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
ajecphotos:

I don’t know if you are familiar with the book* The Practice of the Presence of God* by Brother Lawrence. It is a very good teaching to acquired contemplation. Contemplation is simply a love relationship with God. People who love one another enjoy being with one another. Recollection brings one to be with the Beloved.

Recollection is one key to contemplation. When our attraction to the Lord is intense, our recollection will become natural and habitual. It is like a deer thirsts for water.

Growing of the virtues is another key in acquired contemplation. People who love one another do things to please one another. Contemplation is a loving relationship. When we truly love the Lord, we will do everything to please Him. Living a generous Gospel life and earnestly working toward holiness show our true love to God.

Recollection and growing virtues work hand in hand. They both root in the love of the Lord. When we truly love the Lord, we not only want to stay in front of him we also want to please him by loving others and enhancing all the virtues. A person in true contemplation (acquired) will show fruits of better patience, gentleness, humility, meekness, generosity, faithfulness, self control, etc. Our love of the Lord should motivate us to grow in virtues.

Ideally contemplation does not only happen in a designated time or period,but become an ongoing way of daily life. And we can acquire that with our efforts. God bless!
Waw! Many thanks
 
…
ACQUIRED CONTEMPLATION
Which to me makes the use of “contemplation” in this regards the same as meditation in as much as it is initiated by the Soul.

I see “contemplation” as an “overloaded term” ( think object oriented programming ). It has more than one definition strickly speaking depending updon who is using the term. TBH, anything intitiated by the Soul should be “meditation”. Only that which is initiated and sustained by God should be refferred to as “contemplation”. This done to simplify for beginners. As you can see there is A LOT of room for confussion. N’est-ce pas?
It really can be very simple though.

Meditation is where it comes from us and we think about something or read the Ora

Contemplation is where we bathe in silence and God is the one who comes to us

or I should say God reveals what is already there.
Which is what I have been trying to convey with regard to “simplicity” but not with regards to the “semi-eastern thought” presented above.

It doesn’t have to be as complex as it seems.
How to reach inner silence? Well there are some good teachings about Zazen where you can learn how to silence your mind, Thomas Merton I think would approve. See ‘Zen mind, Beginner’s mind’ by Suzuki.But I must say that Zazen is NOT Christian contemplation but has some useful techniques.

God comes to us in peace.
I would be careful about mixing “eastern” “meditative techniques” with Christian prayer. Merton sorta went off a bit toward the end. His earlier material is more sound. Also, be very very careful with regards to pointing someone “new to prayer” to consult anything other than “very orthodox Catholic” resources on the subject. For people more firm in their faith with the the right mindset, exploration into these subject may not be harmful in as much as they provide what not to do and help in advising why to stay away from them.
 
Cadian and DBT, many thanks. I will keep praying and showing God how much i truly love him and want to know him better. 👍
I hope I am not confusing you. You are on the right track. Keep praying and trust in Jesus.
 
Which to me makes the use of “contemplation” in this regards the same as meditation in as much as it is initiated by the Soul.

I see “contemplation” as an “overloaded term” ( think object oriented programming ). It has more than one definition strickly speaking depending updon who is using the term. TBH, anything intitiated by the Soul should be “meditation”. Only that which is initiated and sustained by God should be refferred to as “contemplation”. This done to simplify for beginners. As you can see there is A LOT of room for confussion. N’est-ce pas?.
So in other words you are trying to impose your personal understanding of contemplation being synonymous with the highest, purely infused state of contemplation from God, on others? Even when your opinion is not shared by the major mystical theologians, and indeed the entirety of church tradition?

What is confusing about (and I am putting this very crudely):
  1. discursive meditation (using images, thoughts, words)
  2. acquired contemplation (one’s own effort aided by grace to quietly focus the mind solely on God without imagining Him)
  3. infused contemplation (a pure gift from God that renders the use of the soul’s faculties silent).
Why do you have such an issue with these age-old, tried and tested distinctions?

In fact there are a good deal many more degrees to contemplation than even the simplified “acquired vs infused” distinction (ie Prayer of Quiet, Simple union, Conforming union, Transforming union). Yet all a person needs to really be aware of at the “beginning”, to use your own concern, is these three simple distinctions.

So in light of the above, I am guessing that Pope Gregory the Great was “wrong” to describe contemplation as such:
“…There is in contemplation a great effort of the mind, when it raises itself up to heavenly things, when it fixes its attention on spiritual things, when it tries to pass over all that is outwardly seen, when it narrows itself that it may be enlarged. And sometimes indeed it prevails and soars above the resisting darkness of its blindness, so that it attains to somewhat of the unencompassed Light…Such a soul, when it strives to contemplate God, as if placed in a wrestle, now comes uppermost, because by understanding and feeling it tastes somewhat of the unemcompassed Light…”
- St. Pope Gregory the Great (540 – 604), Church Father & Doctor of the Church
So Pope Gregory, uniquely a church father, pontiff, Doctor of the Church, theologian and mystic is less qualified to give an accurate definition of contemplation than you are because he regards “effort of the mind” (acquired) as being the true beginning of it?

Forgive me if I find that unacceptable.
 
So in other words you are trying to impose your personal understanding of contemplation being synonymous with the highest, purely infused state of contemplation from God, on others? Even when your opinion is not shared by the major mystical theologians, and indeed the entirety of church tradition?

What is confusing about (and I am putting this very crudely):
  1. discursive meditation (using images, thoughts, words)
  2. acquired contemplation (one’s own effort aided by grace to quietly focus the mind solely on God without imagining Him)
  3. infused contemplation (a pure gift from God that renders the use of the soul’s faculties silent)? Why do you have such an issue with these age-old, tried and tested distinctions?
In fact there are a good deal many more degrees to contemplation than even the simplified “acquired vs infused” distinction (ie Prayer of Quiet, Simple union, Conforming union, Transforming union).

So in light of the above, I am guessing that Pope Gregory the Great was “wrong” to described contemplation as being:

So Pope Gregory, uniquely a church father, pontiff, theologian and mystic is less qualified to give an accurate definition of contemplation than you are because he regards “effort of the mind” (acquired) as being the true beginning of it?

Forgive me if I find that unacceptable.
Yeah sure you can quote all of this all you want but it only serves to confuse the beginner. You don’t see that. This matterial is not for the “101” course in prayer. It is for much later study after the one new to prayer (as the OP seems to have indicated) is more experienced. All of your refferences can be boiled down to:

Intitated by the Soul and Intiated by God.

To someone new, and who may be overwhelmed with such a complex undertaking, parcing it out so that it is easier to understand and digest helps much more than piling on refference after confusing refference ( to the uninitiated ). I don’t see why you and others don’t see this.

All of you experienced theologians need to remember that not everyone is where you are at, and sometimes things need to be explained simply. I see many pedantic attempts to advise on these forums. I don’t presupose to know more than the Doctor’s of the Church but, I do know how to simplify things so that others can latch on to complex topics.

It’s kinda like studying a sport or martial arts. In the beginning you just “do things” because the coach tells you to do them. You don’t have to know why, you just do them. After you get to a certain point the coach starts to tell you why you are doing them when you are ready to understand. Even at that point they don’t give you ALL the information. They allow you to process the information in as much as you can take in for when you are ready and help build on this knowledge and show links to everything else you have been learning so as to get the complete picture. Jumping into advanced discussion for the beginner ( in any subject ) can serve to confuse.
 
I don’t see why you and others don’t see this.
What myself and others fail to see is why you have decided to make yourself the arbiter of what defines “contemplation” from “meditation” rather than accepting the received tradition from the Fathers, scholastics and mystical theologians of the past 2,000.

Your claims as to be doing this simply to help “beginners” are increasingly becoming hollow, since at the beginning your only contention was that what people on here are describing as there personal experiences with “contemplation” are not under the category of contemplation, when they actually are, as if you are the self-elected arbiter of spiritual/mystical experience.

:confused:
 
Whether a beginner should learn “contemplative prayer,” or not is really not up to us, but God.

I’ve met beginners who began with “contemplative prayer.” Through it, they were drawn a deep relationship with Jesus Christ and drawn into the Church.

Something they never thought possible for themselves.

God leads, we follow, regardless of where we are in our spiritual journey.

Jim
 
All of you experienced theologians need to remember that not everyone is where you are at, and sometimes things need to be explained simply. I see many pedantic attempts to advise on these forums. I don’t presupose to know more than the Doctor’s of the Church but, I do know how to simplify things so that others can latch on to complex topics.
Dear brother Cadian,

While your intentions might be noble and commendable, I highly doubt that giving people a faulty idea of the distinction between meditation and contemplation, as well as labelling anything that diverges from your own preconceived definition of what contemplation is as being “new age”, is particularly helpful.
 
Intitated by the Soul and Intiated by God.
But it is not as simple as this because in a sense all prayer requires grace, and so all prayer is in some sense initiated by God even if it is not contemplative, infused and a “special” divine gift. In *acquired contemplation * we find human effort aided by God’s grace, for example.

Even meditation is aided by God and predicated upon the grace of Christ.
 
What myself and others fail to see is why you have decided to make yourself the arbiter of what defines “contemplation” from “meditation” rather than accepting the received tradition from the Fathers, scholastics and mystical theologians of the past 2,000.

Your claims as to be doing this simply to help “beginners” are increasingly becoming hollow, since at the beginning your only contention was that what people on here are describing as there personal experiences with “contemplation” is not contemplation, when it actually is, as if you are the self-elected arbiter of mystical experience.

:confused:
Nice use of Alinsky’s rules for racicals: Use of demonization, comparison to experts and truncation of message. Recharacterise your oponent so as to confuse the message to support your own. Bravo.

I will leave you with this link to the “three expressions of prayer” (Vocal, Meditative and Contemplative) from the Catechism. To my recolection all of what you are saying and others are saying in this thread clearly falls under the definition of meditation. I will conceed the point that there may be an “active” part of the Soul in regards to contemplative prayer but, only in as much as the Soul is on a life long daily journey to walk the path of holiness as best they can to invite God to be with them and come into their lives.
 
Nice use of Alinsky’s rules for racicals: Use of demonization, comparison to experts and truncation of message. Recharacterise your oponent so as to confuse the message to support your own. Bravo.
I have never heard of Alinsky’s rules, so I would not know enough about them to use them in any way. Nor am I trying to demonize you, re-characterise you etc.

I am simply saddened that a thread which began as a beautiful outpouring of the Holy Spirit, with individuals freely giving personal experiences with prayer in a brotherly atmosphere, has developed yet again into a debate and denigrating claims that their experiences are not “contemplation” (when they are), or are “new age” - clear attempts to discredit their experiences entirely and undermine the discussion. That is where I see the real “demonization” at play, the claim that people should cease talking about their experiences with contemplation because it is wrongly assumed to be “a source of pride for those that are doing the confusion” (your own words).

And it does make me sad. I wish that on your part you could understand why this makes me (and others) feel the way that it does.

It stymies brotherly discussion about contemplation and mysticism on, of all places, the spirituality sub-forum of a Catholic forum. Bravo indeed.
 
“hoc est praeceptum meum ut diligatis invicem sicut dilexi vos”

PAX+
 
+JMJ+
As you can see, the CCC says we can always enter into this form of prayer, and that even though the Rosary is valuable, prayer SHOULD go further.
I hope, Alan, that what are you saying is that, though the beginnings of praying the Rosary is valuable, the Rosary SHOULD go further. The Rosary is an eminently contemplative prayer.

The Rosary, precisely because it starts with Mary’s own experience, is an exquisitely contemplative prayer. Without this contemplative dimension, it would lose its meaning, as Pope Paul VI clearly pointed out: "Without contemplation, the Rosary is a body without a soul, and its recitation runs the risk of becoming a mechanical repetition of formulas, in violation of the admonition of Christ: “In praying do not heap up empty phrases as the Gentiles do; for they think they will be heard for their many words” (Mt. 6:7).

, #12Rosarium Virginis Mariae
 
I will leave you with this link to the “three expressions of prayer” .
Excelent resource. We see there:

III. CONTEMPLATIVE PRAYER

2710 The choice of the time and duration of the prayer arises from a determined will, revealing the secrets of the heart. One does not undertake contemplative prayer only when one has the time: one makes time for the Lord, with the firm determination not to give up, no matter what trials and dryness one may encounter. One cannot always meditate, but one can always enter into inner prayer, independently of the conditions of health, work, or emotional state. The heart is the place of this quest and encounter, in poverty and in faith.
 
+JMJ+

I hope, Alan, that what are you saying is that, though the beginnings of praying the Rosary is valuable, the Rosary SHOULD go further. The Rosary is an eminently contemplative prayer.

The Rosary, precisely because it starts with Mary’s own experience, is an exquisitely contemplative prayer. Without this contemplative dimension, it would lose its meaning, as Pope Paul VI clearly pointed out: "Without contemplation, the Rosary is a body without a soul, and its recitation runs the risk of becoming a mechanical repetition of formulas, in violation of the admonition of Christ: “In praying do not heap up empty phrases as the Gentiles do; for they think they will be heard for their many words” (Mt. 6:7).

Bl. John Paul II, Apostolic Letter Rosarium Virginis Mariae, #12
Very true 👍
 
I will leave you with this link to the “three expressions of prayer” (Vocal, Meditative and Contemplative) from the Catechism. To my recolection all of what you are saying and others are saying in this thread clearly falls under the definition of meditation.
No.

In fact, what is described in your link to the catechism regarding “contemplation” is a wonderful recap and synopsis of all that has been said here in this thread … from an acquired point of view!!!

There is very little there in that link under the banner of “contemplation” that is exclusively or even primarily infused in nature.

Goodness.

Dave.
 
Excelent resource. We see there:

III. CONTEMPLATIVE PRAYER

2710 The choice of the time and duration of the prayer arises from ** a determined will**, revealing the secrets of the heart. One does not undertake contemplative prayer only when one has the time: one makes time for the Lord, with the firm determination not to give up, no matter what trials and dryness one may encounter. **One cannot always meditate, but **one can always enter into inner prayer, independently of the conditions of health, work, or emotional state. The heart is the place of **this quest ** and encounter, in poverty and in faith.
Brother Cadian you have provided an excellent source, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, yet can you not see that the words that I have bold clearly refer to the *acquired * aspect of contemplation?
 
I think as I read all those that quote this document or that Saint sound byte and have “many years” of experience are missing the boat with regards to attempting to explain this very complex subject with someone new to it.
But you, with neither scholarly credentials nor experience, come in here and try to “set straight” those who actually do the prayer.

And I’ve already showed you how your claim that there is no such way that humans can initiate contemplative prayer, is completely contradictory to the CCC.

Why do you keep promoting non-Catholic beliefs, that directly contradict the CCC, in regards to this prayer form that you don’t know anything about except maybe the allegorical equivalent of a few bumper stickers, and tell us who have found amazing healing from the Lord through this form of prayer that you say can’t be done that we don’t know what we are talking about.

When I asked you in the other thread for credentials or for how much experience you had, it was a polite way of saying, “consider that those of us who do have experience and/or credentials aren’t completely stupid and ignorant.”

So quit telling us that our kind of prayer, which the CCC says we “should do” in addition to and further than the prayers that are the only ones you say can be done, is impossible.

And quit throwing around vague references and confusing the issue with lame memes like “emptying your mind is new age.” Show me in the CCC where it is impossible to enter into contemplative prayer, and I will show you where the CCC says it’s mandatory that you do.

Alan
 
Yeah sure you can quote all of this all you want but it only serves to confuse the beginner. You don’t see that. This matterial is not for the “101” course in prayer. It is for much later study after the one new to prayer (as the OP seems to have indicated) is more experienced. All of your refferences can be boiled down to:
This from a man with no experience with the prayer. :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top