A
ajecphotos
Guest
Please explain@OP, contemplation is the exact opposite of what has happened to this thread.
Please explain@OP, contemplation is the exact opposite of what has happened to this thread.
I was replying to how the other chap recited the rosary not about contemplation as such. To be ‘there’ one has to think about it, thus also concentrating on ‘where’ is.+JMJ+
If you want to contemplate using the Rosary, do not “concentrate”, just “be there”. Also, choosing a specific set of Mysteries just because it “means so much” for you is NOT contemplation! In acquired contemplation, you let God be Himself, not letting your own ideas, feelings, nor preferences dictate Who He is, and that means, for the Rosary, praying ALL Mysteries without preference for any one nor any set of them.
I was thinking about this the other day. I wondered if the mainstream protestant churches had any history of meditation. I don’t know of any that do except the Quakers. Their founder George Fox was a Christian mystic. I do not understand why so many denominations adopt the cross, the Bible, the building style, etc from Catholicism, but then throw out other sacred traditions. They pitch the baby with the bathwater. Perhaps blinded people make better “followers”.Just recently, I did a google search on Contemplative Prayer.
I was amazed at the number of Fundamentalist-Christian sites condemning Contemplative Prayer.
Jim
Me too! Husband and father of 4 … employeer of 20. Chaos everywhere I look (kidding of course)! But it’s entirely possible to live a contemplative life in the midst of everyday “noise.” It makes our relationships deeper, stronger … more enduring.Thank you very much. I should clarify that it would be as a lay Carmelite. (I’m married and have children.)
The Quakers are in truth, as you say, the only purely contemplative, long-lasting, mystical tradition to come out of Protestant Christianity, although they are not considered “orthodox” by the normative, mainstream churches.I was thinking about this the other day. I wondered if the mainstream protestant churches had any history of meditation. I don’t know of any that do except the Quakers. Their founder George Fox was a Christian mystic. I do not understand why so many denominations adopt the cross, the Bible, the building style, etc from Catholicism, but then throw out other sacred traditions. They pitch the baby with the bathwater. Perhaps blinded people make better “followers”.
Protestants generally rejected mystical theology. Despite his acquaintance with medieval mystical writings, Martin Luther had a well-known antipathy for mysticism. Some Protestants in most periods retained an interest in the mystical tradition, although they should not necessarily be considered mystics. But mainstream Protestantism has generally mistrusted or been openly hostile toward a mystical dimension of the spiritual life
Hi Fred -Can anyone explain what the difference is between just sitting and looking at a picture of the Sacred Heart or another picture of Jesus, and contemplation?
Anyone?
2715 Contemplation is a gaze of faith, fixed on Jesus. “I look at him and he looks at me”: this is what a certain peasant of Ars in the time of his holy curé used to say while praying before the tabernacle. This focus on Jesus is a renunciation of self. His gaze purifies our heart; the light of the countenance of Jesus illumines the eyes of our heart and teaches us to see everything in the light of his truth and his compassion for all men. Contemplation also turns its gaze on the mysteries of the life of Christ. Thus it learns the “interior knowledge of our Lord,” the more to love him and follow him.
Hope this helps!2717 Contemplative prayer is silence, the “symbol of the world to come” or “silent love.” Words in this kind of prayer are not speeches; they are like kindling that feeds the fire of love. In this silence, unbearable to the “outer” man, the Father speaks to us his incarnate Word, who suffered, died, and rose; in this silence the Spirit of adoption enables us to share in the prayer of Jesus
Prayer of Loving AttentionCan anyone explain what the difference is between just sitting and looking at a picture of the Sacred Heart or another picture of Jesus, and contemplation?
Anyone?
“…We should accustom ourselves to nourish our soul by a simple and loving look on God and on Jesus Christ; and for this we must disengage it gently from reasoning, discourse, and the multitude of affections, in order to keep it in simplicity, regard, and attention, and so bring it nearer and nearer to God. The soul should not stay in meditation, for by its fidelity in mortification and recollection, it ordinarily receives a purer and more intimate prayer, which may be called 'prayer of simplicity, consisting in a simple looking or loving attention to a divine object, be it God Himself or one of His perfections, or Jesus Christ or one of His mysteries. The soul quitting reasoning, uses a sweet contemplation, which keeps it peaceful, attentive, and receptive of any divine impressions the Holy Spirit may communicate…”
Perceptible icons/pictures of a mystery of faith, or Jesus, can be used. St. John of Damascus wrote, “we are led by perceptible Icons to the contemplation of the divine and spiritual” (PG 94:1261a).- Jacques-Bénigne Bossuet (1627 – 1704), French bishop & theologian
Originally by ajecphotos
I think I already pray the rosary as you now do as I always think of the mystery while praying the decade. I try to imagine being with Jesus while he is in the garden or at the pillar etc. This is right yes? I concentrate on the scene while reciting the prayers.
The four Rosary Mysteries, from Joyful to Luminous, to Sorrowful, to Glorious, is walking through all important parts of our Lord’s life. I often pray all Four Mysteries in one day. If time allows, I do them in sequence, in one session, at the tabernacle, with the comfort of Jesus’ Real Presence. Walking through the Lord’s life from Conception to Resurrection does much good to my soul. The Passion of the sorrowful mysteries absolutely means much, but so are every other parts of our Lord’s life. That is why we are given four Mysteries instead of one.I only ever pray the Sorrowful mystery as it is the one that really means so much to me.
Thank you for your really nice explaination.Prayer of Loving Attention
In this kind of prayer one deliberately quietens the intellect, under the impulse of grace, from the normal tendency to chatter, obsesses, dream and imagine. The will alone, that is our intention or desire is focused upon God either in a non-distinct way (in the sense of closing one’s eyes and focusing simply on the word “God”, or opening them and gazing into thin air with one’s intent focused towards God without imagining anything about Him in any way), or indeed on an external object, such as your picture of the Sacred Heart, which is one of the mysteries of faith.
In meditation, you might usually think about Christ’s infinite love for you, his self-sacrificing love on the cross, or his mercy.
In contemplative prayer, you don’t do this with the image.
When looking at it, you should not reason or think about its meaning. You should rather let God give you meaning without any active thought on your part.
Bousset explains it well:
Perceptible icons/pictures of a mystery of faith, or Jesus, can be used. St. John of Damascus wrote, “we are led by perceptible Icons to the contemplation of the divine and spiritual” (PG 94:1261a).
However I prefer not to use an external “object”, such as an icon or picture, because I am still making use of the sense of sight, whereas God cannot be seen, tasted, heard or thought about as He is in Himself. To use sight is to limit Him and his silent, inner encounter with us.
As the Bible tells us, “I will give you what eyes have not seen, ears have not heard and what has not arisen in the human heart”.
How can you describe what you can’t see, can’t hear or cannot envision with your mind? That’s the fruit of contemplation, an intuitive experience of this.
Nevertheless whatever you feel more comfortable with, and called to do, then do it.
Pictures and icons can be very useful to many people, so long as the temptation to “think” about it discursively in any way is avoided.
Don’t listen to me or anyone else, the Holy Spirit is your guide and teacher with regards to prayer![]()
Not trying to cut in here …Now looking at the picture, I just can’t help but have thoughts, especially thoughts of love for our dear saviour. So I am to suppress those thoughts of love and affection? To do that seems so contrary to me.
What do you think?
I can relate to that. I have been in front of the blessed sacrament and simply gazed knowing his presence without really saying anything. But I felt sort of guilty for not entering into conversation with him. It just seemed like I should be adoring him or appreciating him.Not trying to cut in here …
Fred, we should never force things. St. John of the Cross teaches that we should continue to work our mind in prayer as you describe (meditation) so long as we draw profit from it. You will “know” when you’re being called to pray in a more contemplative manner when your overwhelming desire will be to simply remain attentive to Him in a non-conceptual way … in loving attentiveness to use his term. This is one of his “3-signs” on when to let go of meditation.
The soul may in fact then need counsel from a director, though, thinking this “new way” is mere idleness (it’s not). Often the result is to force things *in the other direction *by returning to meditation … which has served it’s purpose. This tension is a big part of what St. John teaches in the passive night of sense.
Dave![]()
Dear FredNow I don’t want to seem difficult when I say this, but to empty my mind seems like a sin to me since it seems like wasting time. It fact it rather sounds like a day dream or just plain stairring without any thought, which again seems like there are better things to do.
Now looking at the picture, I just can’t help but have thoughts, especially thoughts of love for our dear saviour. So I am to suppress those thoughts of love and affection? To do that seems so contrary to me.
What do you think?
The desire to do this must be there. If it isn’t, then God is not yet calling you to contemplate.“…it [the mind] must first have learned to shut out from its eyes all the phantasmata of earthly and heavenly images, and to spurn and tread underfoot whatever presents itself to its thought from sight, from hearing, from smell, from bodily touch or taste, so that it may seek itself interiorly as it is without these sensations…”
As St. John explains, if someone is called to contemplation they should not think that they are wasting their time doing nothing.“…The way that souls should behave in this night of the senses is that they should not concern themselves at all with discourse and meditation, for it is no longer a suitable time for such things. Let them leave the soul in tranquillity and quietness, even though it may seem to them that they are doing nothing and are wasting time…And although further scruples may come to them – that they are wasting their time and that it would be well for them to do something else, because they can neither do nor think anything in prayer – let them suffer these scruples and remain in peace … If such a soul should desire to make any effort of its own with its interior faculties, it will hinder and lose the blessings which … God is instilling into it and impressing upon it…”
“…This takes place where a pure, humble, and resigned soul, burning with ardent love, is carried above itself by the grace of God, and through the brilliancy of the divine light shining on the mind, it loses all consideration and distinction of things, and lays aside all, even the most excellent images, and all liquified by love, and, as it were, reduced to nothing, it melts away into God…And although it knows not what God is, to Whom it is united by pure charity, although it sees not God as He is in His glory, it yet learns by experience that He infinitely transcends all sensible things, and all that can be apprehended by the human intellect concerning Him. It knows God by this intimate embrace and contact better than the eyes of the body know the visible sun. This soul well knows what true contemplation is…”
Wow! We think alike! I said almost the exact same thing to Him below without first reading your post (because it wasn’t posted yet when I clicked to replyNot trying to cut in here …
Fred, we should never force things.
This sounds to me like contemplation. You are being led away, naturally encouraged by God’s grace, from reasoning and discursive thinking. The faculties of your soul are undergoing silencing by God and are as a result increasingly bereft of their ability to function normally, hence why you find that you “cannot get my mind to work” or “concentrate”.But most of the time I just get lost in a simple gaze of just knowing His presence. Sometime it is Our Blessed Mother Mary’s presence I get lost in. It is like I can not get my mind to work at thinking about the Mystery. It is like it is keeping me from going to Him and even though I just let go and go I am left with wondering if I am not doing something right because I can not seem to consenttrate on them.
This seems to be more of a supernatural, visionary type of experience in answer to your prayer of petition for help. In this case God has used your senses as a medium to communicate a message to you. This would not be contemplation but rather an ecstatic vision meant to inspire you in faith.Then there was a time not so long ago that I know Jesus was pulling at my heart strings because I had this longing to be with Him that just kept growing and no prayers seemed to be able to quench it. It was like I felt so broken and no prayer was fixing what ever it was that was that needing to be fixed so that I could follow Him So I just started taking time to just kneel in front of my little Icon of Him and begged Him to please fix in me whatever it was that needed to be fixed. I saw many faces come over His face. I took each face to represent some kind of sin.
Christ is letting you know that despite your low view of yourself (I assume), that he has infinite love for you and compassion for your sins. He wants to communicate that burning love and fill you with it, so as to help you move on and let the past go.One face had a look of “oh pity me” another was of greed and another was of sloth but the one that came across His face the most was one that I could only describe as being avarice. Then there was His face. So full of love for me. Just His love pouring into me. How those looks of love just pulled me to Him and as He poured His Love into my soul I just drank and the longing seemed to subside for a bit.
Again a visionary experience in which God excites our imagination.It all pure sweet illuminating light that even though all I could see was light it was not blinding. I can only describe this Light as being Jesus poiring Himsel into me and I know if He had not let me go I would not be here typing this out to you all. This encounter with Him made me realize in a very real way how Jesus is our Eternity and we really need to learn how to live and breath Him as much as we can in this life. If we don’t we will find breathing very dificult in Eaternity. The other thing it made me realize is how we will not be lacking in anything in Eternity. He will fill us to our brim and we will not long for anything else.
These are special graces and gifts to comfort you. Accept them humbly, yet do not become too attached to them. Above these gifts and graces, God must be sought purely for His love and not for anything that can be given. The so-called “dark night of the soul” is in part the purification of reliance on these earlier graces and gifts from God. Right now, God is like a mother and you are the child at her breast, being weaned. When the time is right, God will cease giving you these graces and allow you the freedom to walk on your own. After enduring this “dark night” you will be purified of sensual experiences, ecstasies and visions; as well as these gifts and graces; and simply rest in the kind of contemplative prayer you described at the beginning, without concepts or images. Just the Presence.For the most part my prayer life consists of just talking to Him about everyhing or just thinking of Him and every once in a while He seems to gently carress my check in a gentle, reasuring way with a gentle breeze or He seems to send me a kiss in the form of a dart that pierces my very soul and with every little dart it is like I can feel Him getting me ready for the time when He is ready to consummate myself to Him for Eternity
I believe that you have had some contemplative experiences, or at least one as described in the first part of your post, yet your latter experiences are visionary, ecstatic and signs of special graces from God.So what are your thoughts or insights into all of this. Do you beleive it is contemplative prayer or something else entirely from what is being discussed here…
"…In the first stage, that of jubilatio, a person becomes intensely aware of the dear signs of his love that God has marvellously given us in the heavens and on earth, how marvellously much good he has done for us and all creatures, how everything blossoms, sprouts forth, and is filled with God, and how unimaginable the generosity of God has inundated all creatures with his great gifts and how God has gone searching for him, showered him with gifts, carried him, advised him, waited for him, cared for him…and to what inexpressible nearness he has invited him, and how the most Holy God has expectantly awaited him eternally so that he might be filled with joy forever…
The second stage is like this: When God has drawn a person so far away from all things, and he is no longer a child and he has been strengthened with the comfort of sweetness. Then indeed one gives him coarse rye bread. He has become a man and has reached maturity. Solid, strong food is what is good and useful for a grown man. Here a person becomes so divinized that everything he is and does, God does and is in him shouldn’t be given milk and soft bread any longer, and such is withheld from him. He is then led on a terribly wild path, very gloomy and forsaken. And on this path God takes back from him everything that he had ever given him
When our Lord has prepared a person in this unbearable state of misery - for this prepares him much better than all the spiritual practices that all people might be able to accomplish - then our Lord comes and leads him to the third stage. In this stage the Lord removes the cloak from his eyes and reveals the truth to him. Bright sunshine appears and lifts him right out of all his misery. It seems to this person just as though the Lord had raised him from the dead. In this stage the Lord leads a person out of himself into himself. He makes him forget all his former loneliness and heals all his wounds…"
As you will be able to see by reading it, stage one on Tauler’s tripartite path fits your experiences perfectly- Johannes Tauler (c.1300 – 1361), Dominican mystic
Providence I guessWow! We think alike! I said almost the exact same thing to Him below without first reading your post (because it wasn’t posted yet when I clicked to reply).
Everything you say is so true.
Bless you DBT. The feeling is mutual. And what a beautiful sentiment, I heartily agreeProvidence I guess
I very much enjoy your posts … here and elsewhere. I learn so much from them!
And what I value more than anything in this thread is that so many can say essentially the same things … but in their own personal way. That fascinates me! Like so many differing flowers in the field … yet still flowers all the same.
Dave![]()