You sound very much like St. Thomas the Apostle.
To answer your question… IMHO, because faith is all we have. When something so irrational such as a love of a God who lived among His people and died (and rose) for them, I think there’s no other recourse but to be captivated and believe. As for me, I want to forget my self for a while and love Him back, because He loved me first. Don’t tell me it’s a biochemical thing in the brain.
That’s right. He walked among us. By that virtue, He’s not anymore another imaginary being from the sky. [This alone makes Christianity very unique and not just some human invention if I may add.]
A God who gave us His life and a lifetime to respond to His love. Even if people didn’t believe in Him, He loved (and still loving) them. People must realize that they have to look beyond themselves to see that love; the proverbial emptying of the cup. Everything that we have is borne out of His love.
As for atheists who stay away from evil and help this planet, I don’t think hell would matter to them, because they don’t believe in its existence either. They believe they only have this earthly life. That’s it. Nothing more. *
As for you, friend… I don’t think all our words put together will convince you. Because if you are to be convinced, that means you have to put faith in our words. You are asking proof from Him. That is between you and your Creator. Why don’t you ask Him.

*
So how do you know that he really walked on Earth and that he was God? Just because it was written down in the bible doesnt mean that it happened…yes, it’s possible but history is screwed up sometimes and people cant get their facts straight.
And, if he did walk this earth, how do you know it was God? What evidence do you have that God can become human?
Christianity, IMO, is not unique. It’s just like any other thousands of beliefs, since from the beginning of mankind.
As for your God dying out of love, how do you know there’s such a thing as love? Maybe your religion made it up, no? As far as Im concerned, I find no true evidence of real love in this universe. Only fake love.
I hope I’m wrong but I see nothing.