Could you REALLY convince me?

  • Thread starter Thread starter M31
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, I would want to be with him…BUT first, he needs to show me that he’s there…and not some fairy tale or imaginary being in the sky. No offense, I just need more proof; how can you guys JUST rely ONLY on faith? 🤷

It’s not that I’m purposely trying to deny that God exists. I would be glad to believe…but just show me some evidence. Not that hard, right 😉

Until then, I really can’t be sure.
Do you want to hear some good fairy tale? I would like for you to post here the conversation that God has with Adam and Eve in the Garden, well, it is not really a conversation but a warning to Adam and Eve. Then, I would also like for you to also post the conversation between Satan, the enemy of God, and Eve. God do has enemies.
and the enemies of God, it is also our enemies.
 
You believe in God you just believe that he is impersonal and probably call him the first cause. I trust the prophets and more importantly Christ himself. I believe he was here and that miracles have happened. Look to those things to trust Christ. It is not so hard to believe in God. It is a question of if you are willing. Any questions you have can be answered. Thats why the majority of humans believe. All you have to do is trust that those prophets weren’t liars and insane men (it doesn’t look like it from accounts of them). Put your faith in something. Trust the prophets. Yes, you might not have been there to see the signs but you also didn’t see the civil war. You only have the accounts and the relics left behind. Trust in the prophets. Have faith that humanity isn’t a frail thing filled with insane men that will die out with the rest of the universe. If God doesn’t exist we are nothing. If God does exist, then we are eternal, we are loved, we are everything. All you have to do is trust the Bible, the prophets, the Church, and most important of all, Christ. Please. It isn’t as hard. The evidence is there. Have faith. You came here because a part of you wants to believe. You know it is possible so please open yourself up to this possibility. I pray that this helps you and that you don’t take any offense from anything I have said. All I am saying is to trust these men and have faith in Christ. Trust that He was real and right when He said what He said.
Well, that’s another problem. We have so many difderent religions, with contradictions. If the same God is worshipped by Judaism, Christianity and Islam, why are they so different? It seems to me that mankind came up with religion, no? They just “stole” ideas from the previous religion…add some more ingredients and there you go…you just “baked” a new religion has been “cooked” and it “smells” good and “ready to eat”.

I dont care how “appetizing” a religion is…that doesn’t mean it’s “healthy”.

It’s better to be safe than sorry.
 
1 Tim 2:4
*God who wants all men to be saved and to come to a knowledge of the truth

Maybe God is waiting for you to do YOUR part to relieve suffering of others. And then that carries over to the rest of the 6 B people on this planet.*

How do you know the bible is the truth written by God…and not by primitive man?

If I was a billionaire, I WOULD go and help third-world countries! But I lack that income so how can God expect me to do that, let alone taking care of myself (yes, I fight and struggle to survive too)?
 
No, that is called Justice. The ever Living Just Judge. He will judge people accordling.

do you think it is fine for us to have justice here on earth but not in Heaven? what kind of thinking is that?
Justice, huh? So where’s the justice on earth, huh? As far as I’ve noticed, there’s hardly any justice ib this world! WHERE IS IT?!

You claim your God is just so he only becomes just after you die but not on earth?

Yeah, I can kinda see how he is!

And how can justice be in heaven when there’s nothing bad happens there?!
 
yes, there is. you live and die. there is certain for sure.

you can’t tell God what to do. We do what God tells us. this is the problem with agnostics theists. they want rule even God.
I meant when it comes to if there is a God and if so, blah blah blah…
 
Why the false claims? Our faith is based on evidence. not fairy tales. The you reject the evidence is not a Catholic’s problem. You either accept the evidence as true or you don’t.

Church teaching indicates that one can know there is a God be using reason and observing the universe.

The Church also testifies to the authenticity of the person, Jesus, who is God who became man. This Jesus taught his followers how to acheive eternal happiness. He also established a Church who He commissioned to teach this way to others.
I’m not making false claims. It’s just a thought. It’s how I think, you got that? Don’t be so defensive.

So what evidence do you guys have to justify your beliefs? Where is it? And if you have it, how do you know it’s from God?

Just observing the universe one can reason that God could exist? Really, it’s that simple?:confused: One can do that and find LOTS of flaws!

You’re right, it’s not a Catholics problem…it’s my problem…but a problem can be good if you know how to solve it.
 
How do you know the bible is the truth written by God…and not by primitive man?
A good and valid question

Actually the bible wasn’t written by God. It WAS written by men, who wrote under the inspiration of God. As far as why believe the bible is truth, we have to go by an authority. As Augustine put it, (paraphrased) I wouldn’t believe in the Gospels if it wasn’t for the authprity of the Catholic Church.

If you’re interested

if you want to listen to a presentation in real audio
M:
If I was a billionaire, I WOULD go and help third-world countries! But I lack that income so how can God expect me to do that, let alone taking care of myself (yes, I fight and struggle to survive too)?
All we’re asked, is to do whatever part we can do, with what we have
 
I’m not making false claims. It’s just a thought. It’s how I think, you got that? Don’t be so defensive.

So what evidence do you guys have to justify your beliefs? Where is it? And if you have it, how do you know it’s from God?

Just observing the universe one can reason that God could exist? Really, it’s that simple?:confused: One can do that and find LOTS of flaws!

You’re right, it’s not a Catholics problem…it’s my problem…but a problem can be good if you know how to solve it.
Observing the universe can have quite the opposite effect for many. When I look at it I see less and less reason to believe any God exists. When I let my emotions take over, I find myself more open to the idea.

I guess I just don’t see my life as “purposeless” now. Nor do I see eternity basking the the presence of God worshipping him in that eternity an act filled with purpose. Maybe because so little can be known about this end reward and more is known about the punishment aspect of God. 🤷

I see beauty in religious art, music, even many other things. The Mass is quite interesting, and calming for me. Yet, I can’t base those things as a reason to accept this God or any other. I would like to think a God would be happy with persons who give this a great deal of thought. Since the Christian God would know what your reasonings were while searching this out, you would think he would be pretty impressed that you wanted to be honest about your acceptance or rejection of him.
 
You sound very much like St. Thomas the Apostle. 🙂

To answer your question… IMHO, because faith is all we have. When something so irrational such as a love of a God who lived among His people and died (and rose) for them, I think there’s no other recourse but to be captivated and believe. As for me, I want to forget my self for a while and love Him back, because He loved me first. Don’t tell me it’s a biochemical thing in the brain. 🙂

That’s right. He walked among us. By that virtue, He’s not anymore another imaginary being from the sky. [This alone makes Christianity very unique and not just some human invention if I may add.]

A God who gave us His life and a lifetime to respond to His love. Even if people didn’t believe in Him, He loved (and still loving) them. People must realize that they have to look beyond themselves to see that love; the proverbial emptying of the cup. Everything that we have is borne out of His love.

As for atheists who stay away from evil and help this planet, I don’t think hell would matter to them, because they don’t believe in its existence either. They believe they only have this earthly life. That’s it. Nothing more. *

As for you, friend… I don’t think all our words put together will convince you. Because if you are to be convinced, that means you have to put faith in our words. You are asking proof from Him. That is between you and your Creator. Why don’t you ask Him. :)*

So how do you know that he really walked on Earth and that he was God? Just because it was written down in the bible doesnt mean that it happened…yes, it’s possible but history is screwed up sometimes and people cant get their facts straight.

And, if he did walk this earth, how do you know it was God? What evidence do you have that God can become human?

Christianity, IMO, is not unique. It’s just like any other thousands of beliefs, since from the beginning of mankind.

As for your God dying out of love, how do you know there’s such a thing as love? Maybe your religion made it up, no? As far as Im concerned, I find no true evidence of real love in this universe. Only fake love.

I hope I’m wrong but I see nothing.
 
So how do you know that he really walked on Earth and that he was God? Just because it was written down in the bible doesnt mean that it happened…yes, it’s possible but history is screwed up sometimes and people cant get their facts straight.

And, if he did walk this earth, how do you know it was God? What evidence do you have that God can become human?

Christianity, IMO, is not unique. It’s just like any other thousands of beliefs, since from the beginning of mankind.

As for your God dying out of love, how do you know there’s such a thing as love? Maybe your religion made it up, no? As far as Im concerned, I find no true evidence of real love in this universe. Only fake love.

I hope I’m wrong but I see nothing.
And that is why you need God.
 
I’d like to address this. Not everyone believes that the whole world is void of coincidences and everything is his will. I believe that God’s will is not so rigid. I think his will is for us to show love and to stand up for what’s right no matter what. He doesn’t care where you live or what job you have as long as those things don’t lead you to evil. If the whole world were just a chess game run by God, free will would once again be a joke. I don’t get a job because it is God’s will, I get a job because I have the right qualities for the job and impressed the people who hired me. God can give you strength and help you through what leads up to that, but God doesn’t change the world to make sure you get the job he wants you to have. Thats why the worlds as ****** as it is, because of our free will. If this was all God’s will, then God’s will is messed up. But the state our world is in is not in God’s will.

You said that you want more proof. I’m sorry he is’t going to come down and show himself. As I have said before, that would make free will a joke. He gave us evidence. First, there is the universe which needs a first cause. Second, there are the prophets and Christ which have come down and spoken on behalf of this God. However, you can deny these things which is why you need to trust that these prophets were not incredibly good liars, but what they said they were. You have to trust these people just a little, just like you have to trust the people who right textbooks for schools.
Hmmm…funny. I’ve heard Catholics say “God wants you to be happy, so if your not happy with your job, relationships, etc. then that is NOT God’s will for you! You will know what God wants for you when you’re happy!”

Tell me, is that a cliche? That means nothing. I mean, look at all the billiond of people in this world, how many are TRULY happy? I will guarantee that number is NOT high. Now, you might say that only in heaven you will be happy but then, that loses meaning.

Now you say ‘sorry he’s not going to come down’ and prove himself but here’s a question I would like you to answer truthfully:

Why is it that there have been claims made by people that have seen Jesus/Mary? The amazing part is, they are all Catholics! If God or Mary were truly real like you guys say they are, why cant they appear to atheists, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, Shintos, even anti-Catholics to prove that they do exist and how much they really love humanity?

Why only to Catholics???

You dont need the moon to appear to just moon-worshippers, duh, it does exist and appears to all.

Dumb comparison but you get my point.
 
So how do you know that he really walked on Earth and that he was God? Just because it was written down in the bible doesnt mean that it happened…yes, it’s possible but history is screwed up sometimes and people cant get their facts straight.

And, if he did walk this earth, how do you know it was God? What evidence do you have that God can become human?

Christianity, IMO, is not unique. It’s just like any other thousands of beliefs, since from the beginning of mankind.

As for your God dying out of love, how do you know there’s such a thing as love? Maybe your religion made it up, no? As far as Im concerned, I find no true evidence of real love in this universe. Only fake love.

I hope I’m wrong but I see nothing.
Religion won’t heal that wound. Other than to tell you God loves you unconditionally.
Feel better now?
Have you read the bible?
 
Can we REALLY convince you? Who knows?

We want you to believe. We want you to believe that your life has a purpose and you are not just worthless protoplasm. The universe is not just rocks smashing into rocks. Far from it.
Well, if God exists, only he can convince me :o

But then again, you guys are in Catholicism for a reason because you believe it’s from God.

Now, does life have a purpose? Maybe it really doesnt and maybe that’s why you guys are in religion; maybe religion is just something to give one meaning, no? But if there is a meaning in life and you Catholics are in it, then your religion needs to prove that it’s the truth…only with evidence. (prayers answered, God/Mary appearing, transubstantiation (sp?) is real, etc.)

For now, I’m just an organism 😉
If you want to show me otherwise that smashing rocks didn’t cause evolution, I’ll be glad to hear. 👍
 
Well, if God exists, only he can convince me :o

But then again, you guys are in Catholicism for a reason because you believe it’s from God.

Now, does life have a purpose? Maybe it really doesnt and maybe that’s why you guys are in religion; maybe religion is just something to give one meaning, no? But if there is a meaning in life and you Catholics are in it, then your religion needs to prove that it’s the truth…only with evidence. (prayers answered, God/Mary appearing, transubstantiation (sp?) is real, etc.)

For now, I’m just an organism 😉
If you want to show me otherwise that smashing rocks didn’t cause evolution, I’ll be glad to hear. 👍
???

What?
 
I don’t think that America is particularly blessed. The Land of the Free has become the Land of Abortion, Pornography, Fornication and Every Deadly Sin. The mind-boggling prosperity has left the people bored, and the above-mentioned activities are how they fill their time.

In contrast, consider how some sort of disaster tends to increase church attendance.
Well, I was talking material-wise. But compared to Haiti…

Yeah I find it ironic that America is the richest country in the world…yet people have no jobs, people are starving, people live on the streets, etc. only if you’re a Hollywood movie star can you live and BE American :rolleyes:

No offense but they need to take “In God We Trust” taking off money…because obviously, God is nowhere to be found.
 
what I don’t understand Mr. Agnostic is why you are not being honest in your search for God. I say this because it seems that all the posts that give you really solid answers you ignore and you only “quote” the posts that are weaker and don’t make a good case to prove God (no offense to you guys) Everyone agrees that the ONLY thing that can seperate you from knowing God is YOURSELF, if you are UNWILLING to open your mind and pray to God for faith then their is NOTHING that any human being can do to convince you period. The fact is God does exist so why don’t you ask Him these questions? You are coming across as someone who does believe in God but wishes it weren’t so therefore you come on here and ask 50 questions in a row that would take an entire book to answer. If you were HONEST in your approach you would ask ONE question at a time AFTER praying to God and AFTER reading what Christ taught to humanity…when I was a child it was self-evident that Jesus was God simply from reading His Word. “How do you know it was His Word” it was SELF EVIDENT… GOD REVEALED HIMSELF TO ME AND WILL TO THE SAME FOR YOU IF YOU ASK HONESTLY
 
Well, if God exists, only he can convince me :o

But then again, you guys are in Catholicism for a reason because you believe it’s from God.

Now, does life have a purpose? Maybe it really doesnt and maybe that’s why you guys are in religion; maybe religion is just something to give one meaning, no? But if there is a meaning in life and you Catholics are in it, then your religion needs to prove that it’s the truth…only with evidence. (prayers answered, God/Mary appearing, transubstantiation (sp?) is real, etc.)

For now, I’m just an organism 😉
If you want to show me otherwise that smashing rocks didn’t cause evolution, I’ll be glad to hear. 👍
The proof is right before thee. the word is to believe. do you believe that we believe?
 
Ok so I asked honestly, “God if you exist, help me believe. If not, then leave me alone!”

Now, let’s wait and see. :cool:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top