Could you REALLY convince me?

  • Thread starter Thread starter M31
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
what I don’t understand Mr. Agnostic is why you are not being honest in your search for God. I say this because it seems that all the posts that give you really solid answers you ignore and you only “quote” the posts that are weaker and don’t make a good case to prove God (no offense to you guys) Everyone agrees that the ONLY thing that can seperate you from knowing God is YOURSELF, if you are UNWILLING to open your mind and pray to God for faith then their is NOTHING that any human being can do to convince you period. The fact is God does exist so why don’t you ask Him these questions? You are coming across as someone who does believe in God but wishes it weren’t so therefore you come on here and ask 50 questions in a row that would take an entire book to answer. If you were HONEST in your approach you would ask ONE question at a time AFTER praying to God and AFTER reading what Christ taught to humanity…when I was a child it was self-evident that Jesus was God simply from reading His Word. “How do you know it was His Word” it was SELF EVIDENT… GOD REVEALED HIMSELF TO ME AND WILL TO THE SAME FOR YOU IF YOU ASK HONESTLY
First of all, I’m a MISS Agnostic. Not all agnostics are males.

Second of all, I AM sincere…I just happen to ask too many questions…I said that at the beginning of this thread.

And finally, Im willing to believe…only if it’s true. Do you have a problem with people being skeptical??
 
Now you say ‘sorry he’s not going to come down’ and prove himself but here’s a question I would like you to answer truthfully:

Why is it that there have been claims made by people that have seen Jesus/Mary? The amazing part is, they are all Catholics! If God or Mary were truly real like you guys say they are, why cant they appear to atheists, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, Shintos, even anti-Catholics to prove that they do exist and how much they really love humanity?
That is called private revelation. Personally, I don’t believe in some of these. Sometimes, they may have come down to strengthen the faith. And in many of those cases, many were converted. Once again though, the free will part. They may act but they will do so in a way that atheists can ignore it if they are not open to it. To show my point, I would like to see your reaction to the Eucharistic Miracle of Lanciano. You can find info online, probably on this site or wikipedia. The basis is that a doubting priest held up the host which we believe to be the actual body of Christ and it became real flesh and blood dropped from it. The flesh has survived to this day with no trace of perservatives and the cellular evidence would point that the flesh is fresh instead of thousand year old dead flesh. This is a miracle that would prove Catholicism if you believe it. However, most atheists would overlook it and ignore it.
 
**Quote:
Originally Posted by M31
Now you say ‘sorry he’s not going to come down’ and prove himself but here’s a question I would like you to answer truthfully:

Why is it that there have been claims made by people that have seen Jesus/Mary? The amazing part is, they are all Catholics! If God or Mary were truly real like you guys say they are, why cant they appear to atheists, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, Shintos, even anti-Catholics to prove that they do exist and how much they really love humanity? **

If God had to show up for every single person on earth to prove He exists, we would not need Faith. He would have to be here all the time since people are being borne all the time and they would not believe until they saw Him, Just like you.

If you understand how God works, you would know that throughout the history of God’s chosen people beginning wiht the Israelis, God reveal Himself to His chosen ones, and these chosen are sent to give the message.

Remember the word CHOSEN.

Catholics? Yes, because we are the chosen people of God. That is why He shows Himself to some in the Church and they give the message to others. That is how God works. It is all there in the Book although not everything is written much it is.

For example, protestant cannot claim to ever have seen or received any revelation from God because they have not been chosen or sent to teach God’s Word. They picked up the Bible from the Church and begin to preach to people. this is not the plan of God.

There are many miracles within the CC. We cannot tell God how He should do things, He already established how He does it and we are commanded to obey.

Like I said before, you need to ponder on the warning of God to Adam and Eve in teh Garden and the conversation between satan and eve.
 
So if God is powerful, he could eliminate all atheists, right? He’s powerful enough to convert me to a Catholic in 5 minutes if he wanted to, right? If he’s really powerful, why all the contradictions in religions?

Just how powerful is God?
 
**Quote:
Originally Posted by M31
Now you say ‘sorry he’s not going to come down’ and prove himself but here’s a question I would like you to answer truthfully:

Why is it that there have been claims made by people that have seen Jesus/Mary? The amazing part is, they are all Catholics! If God or Mary were truly real like you guys say they are, why cant they appear to atheists, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, Shintos, even anti-Catholics to prove that they do exist and how much they really love humanity? **

If God had to show up for every single person on earth to prove He exists, we would not need Faith. He would have to be here all the time since people are being borne all the time and they would not believe until they saw Him, Just like you.

If you understand how God works, you would know that throughout the history of God’s chosen people beginning wiht the Israelis, God reveal Himself to His chosen ones, and these chosen are sent to give the message.

Remember the word CHOSEN.

Catholics? Yes, because we are the chosen people of God. That is why He shows Himself to some in the Church and they give the message to others. That is how God works. It is all there in the Book although not everything is written much it is.

For example, protestant cannot claim to ever have seen or received any revelation from God because they have not been chosen or sent to teach God’s Word. They picked up the Bible from the Church and begin to preach to people. this is not the plan of God.

There are many miracles within the CC. We cannot tell God how He should do things, He already established how He does it and we are commanded to obey.

Like I said before, you need to ponder on the warning of God to Adam and Eve in teh Garden and the conversation between satan and eve.
Yes but isnt faith a risky thing?? How can you be sure? Why appear to some and not others? Because they lost their faith?

How does God work? Not like science I bet lol.

I doubt Catholics are the “Chosen”…that’s for Jews, no?

And what warning? Good and Evil?
 
I’ll start off with some Aquinas theology:
The First Way: Argument from Motion
Our senses prove that some things are in motion.
Things move when potential motion becomes actual motion.
Only an actual motion can convert a potential motion into an actual motion.
Nothing can be at once in both actuality and potentiality in the same respect (i.e., if both actual and potential, it is actual in one respect and potential in another).
Therefore nothing can move itself.
Therefore each thing in motion is moved by something else.
The sequence of motion cannot extend ad infinitum.
Therefore it is necessary to arrive at a first mover, put in motion by no other; and this everyone understands to be God.

The Second Way: Argument from Efficient Causes
We perceive a series of efficient causes of things in the world.
Nothing exists prior to itself.
Therefore nothing is the efficient cause of itself.
If a previous efficient cause does not exist, neither does the thing that results.
Therefore if the first thing in a series does not exist, nothing in the series exists.
The series of efficient causes cannot extend ad infinitum into the past, for then there would be no things existing now.
Therefore it is necessary to admit a first efficient cause, to which everyone gives the name of God.

The Third Way: Argument from Possibility and Necessity (Reductio argument)
We find in nature things that are possible to be and not to be, that come into being and go out of being i.e., contingent beings.
Assume that every being is a contingent being.
For each contingent being, there is a time it does not exist.
Therefore it is impossible for these always to exist.
Therefore there could have been a time when no things existed.
Therefore at that time there would have been nothing to bring the currently existing contingent beings into existence.
Therefore, nothing would be in existence now.
We have reached an absurd result from assuming that every being is a contingent being.
Therefore not every being is a contingent being.
Therefore some being exists of its own necessity, and does not receive its existence from another being, but rather causes them. This all men speak of as God.

The Fourth Way: Argument from Gradation of Being
There is a gradation to be found in things: some are better or worse than others.
Predications of degree require reference to the “uttermost” case (e.g., a thing is said to be hotter according as it more nearly resembles that which is hottest).
The maximum in any genus is the cause of all in that genus.
Therefore there must also be something which is to all beings the cause of their being, goodness, and every other perfection; and this we call God.

The Fifth Way: Argument from Design
We see that natural bodies work toward some goal, and do not do so by chance.
Most natural things lack knowledge.
But as an arrow reaches its target because it is directed by an archer, what lacks intelligence achieves goals by being directed by something intelligence.
Therefore some intelligent being exists by whom all natural things are directed to their end; and this being we call God.

And springing from that, things do not exist by necessity. In fact, existence does not “exist” by necessity. It’s an action of the will, by the will, due to motive. This “will-er” is who we call God.

Your second question is one called “Theodicy”. It is one of the more deep struggles that we suffer with as fallen humans.
It is very accurate to say that we suffer from one another’s actions, or benefit from one another’s actions. For example, if I killed someone you are close to, you would suffer from it; Not because you are the murderer, but because of the association. The same can be applied to humanity. We are all responsible for our brothers and sisters. This is inclusive of those in Haiti. We are communal beings! That’s simply how we are made. God has given us the will to help our brothers and sisters. He has given us the means of helping our brothers and sisters. He has done his part. The baton is now in our hands to make sure the task is finished. By no means is being rich a sin, but by being rich whenever someone else is poor and starving and you do not care-- that is definitely on our conscience. In helping others, we are helping ourselves. God’s plan is two-fold. It does not always include explicit and miraculous appearances. While you are correct that people are usually rich by his blessing, greed is a blockade to both sides. He wants to save those who are rich and famous just as much as he does those in Haiti.
 
So if God is powerful, he could eliminate all atheists, right? He’s powerful enough to convert me to a Catholic in 5 minutes if he wanted to, right? If he’s really powerful, why all the contradictions in religions?

Just how powerful is God?
:confused::confused:
 
So if God is powerful, he could eliminate all atheists, right? He’s powerful enough to convert me to a Catholic in 5 minutes if he wanted to, right? If he’s really powerful, why all the contradictions in religions?

Just how powerful is God?
God is all-powerful. To answer the top portion, I’ll just say two simple words that you have heard very often from me: Free Will. If you look at a universe that needs a creator and He doesn’t show himself to everyone in the manner you would like, then the rest of the world is going to try and explain it which resulted in the many polytheisms around the world. The other religions which were philosophies like confucianism spread because they spoke moral truths. God isn’t going to take away their free will to believe in these religions. He will leave enough evidence to where anyone who truly seeks the truth can find it.
 
So if God is powerful, he could eliminate all atheists, right? He’s powerful enough to convert me to a Catholic in 5 minutes if he wanted to, right? If he’s really powerful, why all the contradictions in religions?

Just how powerful is God?
The passage below is from the Gospel according to St. Matthew, 13: 24-30
24 Another parable he put before them, saying, "The kingdom of heaven may be compared to a man who sowed good seed in his field;
25 but while men were sleeping, his enemy came and sowed weeds among the wheat, and went away.
26 So when the plants came up and bore grain, then the weeds appeared also.
27 And the servants of the householder came and said to him, Sir, did you not sow good seed in your field? How then has it weeds?' 28 He said to them, An enemy has done this.’ The servants said to him, Then do you want us to go and gather them?' 29 But he said, No; lest in gathering the weeds you root up the wheat along with them.
30 Let both grow together until the harvest; and at harvest time I will tell the reapers, Gather the weeds first and bind them in bundles to be burned, but gather the wheat into my barn.’
 
Yes but isnt faith a risky thing?? How can you be sure? Why appear to some and not others? Because they lost their faith?

How does God work? Not like science I bet lol.

I doubt Catholics are the “Chosen”…that’s for Jews, no?

And what warning? Good and Evil?
Miracles are supplementary to faith. If you have no faith in a God, then there is nothing to supplement.

How does God work? In fact, he works exactly greater than science, because science is the exploration of his very own majesty. We live in a very defined and politically correct society where there is only one right answer. While there is a right way to live based on the objectivity of being human, it is not inclusive of only one aspect in a subjective spectrum of personality. Science, as you call it, p(name removed by moderator)oints a certain answer and defines it. God is not one definite thing. Rather, he is all things to all people. He is infinite!

“Chosen”, as it was used, dictates the common path to salvation. This includes sacred tradition, and scripture; both of which the Jews have in common with Catholics.
 
God is all-powerful. To answer the top portion, I’ll just say two simple words that you have heard very often from me: Free Will. If you look at a universe that needs a creator and He doesn’t show himself to everyone in the manner you would like, then the rest of the world is going to try and explain it which resulted in the many polytheisms around the world. The other religions which were philosophies like confucianism spread because they spoke moral truths. God isn’t going to take away their free will to believe in these religions. He will leave enough evidence to where anyone who truly seeks the truth can find it.
If God is all-powerful, then he can stop a shark from biting that leg off, right? If not, then God is just as “guilty” as rich people who could give to others but doesn’t do anything, right? You will say since God is not part of humanity/world he is not responsible for the shark biting off the leg. If so, why not?

Isnt there anything God is respinsible of? I get annoyed when people say EVERYTHING is our fault. Not everything is.

I think that’s because some religions dont want to blame God because he’s “too holy”. I have a hard time with that.

God has to take some kind of responsibility one way or another…otherwise, he can’t exist.

I mean, you can’t blame humanity for EVERYTHING!
 
God has to take some kind of responsibility one way or another…otherwise, he can’t exist.

I mean, you can’t blame humanity for EVERYTHING!
Why not?

Have you ever read C.S. Lewis’ Mere Christianity?
 
If God is all-powerful, then he can stop a shark from biting that leg off, right? If not, then God is just as “guilty” as rich people who could give to others but doesn’t do anything, right? You will say since God is not part of humanity/world he is not responsible for the shark biting off the leg. If so, why not?

Isnt there anything God is respinsible of? I get annoyed when people say EVERYTHING is our fault. Not everything is.

I think that’s because some religions dont want to blame God because he’s “too holy”. I have a hard time with that.

God has to take some kind of responsibility one way or another…otherwise, he can’t exist.

I mean, you can’t blame humanity for EVERYTHING!
If God did not give us the chance to choose willing against him, then we would have no choice of willing our love for him.
God permits evil, not for the sake of evil, but for our resistance against it, and for him to heal our transgressions against him.

**If God permitted evil, with our concupiscence, we will complain that it (evil) is present.

If God permitted no evil, with our concupiscence, we will complain that there is no way to love our Lord more deeply.

You cannot exercise your body without resistance. The same goes for the spirit.

How could you possibly climb a mountain when there is no mountain to climb?**
 
No I have not. I’ve tried to stay away from God-books ever since I read that crazy book by Rick Warren, “Purpose Driven Life”.
I’d advise you to read it (and I’m not a fan of Rick Warren, either…). I think it would help answer a lot of the questions you’ve posed so far. C.S. Lewis was a former atheist who came to Christianity, and he wrote the book in part to explain how he came to believe in God.
 
It seems that you want to not believe in God. And if there is a God, you want to blame him for the troubles in your life. I’m sorry. You can’t blame God for the terrible things in life. Rain falls on the good and the bad. Bad things will happen to the christian and the atheist. Suffering is used to help bring us closer to Christ who brutally died on the cross and it helps us to show that we are commited to him in the good and the bad. How selfish is it if we, who say that we love him, turn on him in any sign of trouble. Suffering helps us to show God that our love is true love. Would you want a spouse who will ditch you at the first sign of financial trouble? So, God, who wants to be even closer than us than spouses, would want someone who will stay with him throughout everything.
 
I’d advise you to read it (and I’m not a fan of Rick Warren, either…). I think it would help answer a lot of the questions you’ve posed so far. C.S. Lewis was a former atheist who came to Christianity, and he wrote the book in part to explain how he came to believe in God.
Yes, I might consider that. Thank you.

Did he have same questions and doubts like me?
:o
 
Yes, I might consider that. Thank you.

Did he have same questions and doubts like me?
:o
Yes, he did! 🙂 He’s written a series of books, actually – I also recommend “The Problem of Pain,” which is about suffering in the world. “The Screwtape Letters” is excellent as well; it’s written from the perspective of demons in Hell.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top