Cross row stokes Christian anger

  • Thread starter Thread starter Magicsilence
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hmm…if BA wanted every employee to look uniform, why are they allowing Sikh Turban and Islamic Hijab? Obviously, they practise double standards and are hypocrites like the Pharisees.

Christians could fax and e-mail our complaints to British Airways management. Also, we could stage protests and demonstrations outside British Airways office, in the way the Muslims do, we could get our rights!

Hmm…Perhaps if you are British national, you may want to inform your local Torries/Conservative MP to organise this protest?
You know in all the years I have flown BA I have never seen a turban being worn by a BA employee or a Hijab…go figure
 
There is no requirement for muslims to wear a hijab (the one covering the face) but they get away with it.
On BA? I don’t think so. They can wear headscarves but not covering the face (for the reason you say).
It’s a shame that only non-Christian faiths are allowed to display their religious affiliation in the over politically correct world we call Britain :rolleyes:
Well, if the Christian faith had a visible requirement, then we would be allowed. But I think it is quite clear in scripture and the teachings of the Church, that we express our faith in our actions, not in what clothes we wear.

I don’t find people beating their breast and wailing about their not being able to wear a sign of Christianity particularly attractive. I much prefer people who live their faith, not moan about not being able to wear a piece of jewellry to work.

Mike
 
I’ve no doubt some here will be outraged.

Personally, I can’t say I care. Her job requires wearing a uniform, and this kind of jewelry is not allowed with that uniform. If she feels deeply about wearing a crucifix, she can wear it under her clothes.

Wearing a sign around your neck saying ‘I’m a Christian’ isn’t a necessary part of being a good Christian. And frankly, given the number of people who commit very un-Christian acts while wearing crosses, crucifixes, and even rosaries around their necks, some covering up may even be a good thing.

Mike
Woah…interesting post.
 
I’ve no doubt some here will be outraged.

Personally, I can’t say I care. Her job requires wearing a uniform, and this kind of jewelry is not allowed with that uniform. If she feels deeply about wearing a crucifix, she can wear it under her clothes.

Wearing a sign around your neck saying ‘I’m a Christian’ isn’t a necessary part of being a good Christian. And frankly, given the number of people who commit very un-Christian acts while wearing crosses, crucifixes, and even rosaries around their necks, some covering up may even be a good thing.

Mike
BA regs require jewellery to be worn under the uniform - a Sikh bracelet is jewellery but doesn’t have to be worn under a uniform, and turbans and hijabs are ok even thu they can’t be hidden by the uniform.

Whether wearing a cross makes one a good christian is irrelevant. That u don’t like Christians is also not relevant to this debate (its obvious from ur post btw).

The fact is that BA should have one rule for all and not discriminate against one or some faiths while respecting others.
 
BA regs require jewellery to be worn under the uniform - a Sikh bracelet is jewellery but doesn’t have to be worn under a uniform, and turbans and hijabs are ok even thu they can’t be hidden by the uniform.
Because they are required by the religion. Conversely, a crucifix is not required by Christianity.
Whether wearing a cross makes one a good christian is irrelevant. That u don’t like Christians is also not relevant to this debate (its obvious from ur post btw).
😃 I think you’ve missed the point somewhere.
The fact is that BA should have one rule for all and not discriminate against one or some faiths while respecting others.
It does. It has a uniform policy. That’s the rule for everyone.

Mike
 
Because they are required by the religion. Conversely, a crucifix is not required by Christianity.
islam does not require the hijab. i have plenty of muslim friends who don’t wear it. There are also Sikhs who don’t wear the turban. but if both of these groups choose to wear their garb, BA allows it. But not for Christians

MikeWM said:
😃 I think you’ve missed the point somewhere.

i might have 😛
40.png
MikeWM:
It does. It has a uniform policy. That’s the rule for everyone
my point exactly - the rule for everyone. BA is discriminating in favour of every religion but Christianity, and that is wrong. if BA discriminated against someone on grounds of race while favouring white pple, would u have the same view?
 
islam does not require the hijab. i have plenty of muslim friends who don’t wear it. There are also Sikhs who don’t wear the turban. but if both of these groups choose to wear their garb, BA allows it. But not for Christians
But most Muslims require the hijab, and most Sikhs (indeed, I thought all Sikhs) require a turban. There may be some who don’t follow all the rules, or some in odd sects, but basically their religion requires it.

I’ve not heard of any type of Christianity that requires the wearing of a crucifix around the neck,
i might have 😛
I’m a (Roman) Catholic, if that helps. It says so in my profile.
my point exactly - the rule for everyone. BA is discriminating in favour of every religion but Christianity, and that is wrong. if BA discriminated against someone on grounds of race while favouring white pple, would u have the same view?
I don’t think it would be right for a company to say that you need to break the rules of your religion to work there. But wearing a crucifix or not is not a rule of Christianity.

If BA were allowing Muslims special time off to attend Friday prayers and not allowing Christians similar time to attend Sunday mass, then that would indeed be wrong, and I’d be protesting against them myself. But that’s not the kind of thing happening here.

Mike
 
I would assume that a headcovering Christian employee would also be allowed to wear a headdress, and that a Muslim or Sikh employee would also be forbidden from wearing necklaces. It isn’t my personal ideal work environment, but then that has little to do with whether I would be able to wear a necklace or not.
 
Im an “in your face” type of guy when my someone belittles my beliefs. So, wearing a very obvious cross or displaying an icon would not be a problem for me. I figure they have a problem not me.
Actually, you would have the problem because you would be unemployed for vilolating corporate guidelines.
 
Im an “in your face” type of guy when my someone belittles my beliefs. So, wearing a very obvious cross or displaying an icon would not be a problem for me. I figure they have a problem not me.
Perhaps the necklace will feed your family when you get fired for breaking your employment agreement.
 
I’m not really outraged, but is she has a right to sue, then she has a right to take BA to court. It sounds like a reasonable enough argument to at least make a case that there is a double standard or at least the explicated policy isn’t exactly the actual policy. Also what an individual feels they need to meet their spiritual/religious obligation can be any mix between what the individual feels and what whatever type of religious institution the individual adheres to feels. If there is are legal questions out there, the court is the place to go to sort it out.
 
But most Muslims require the hijab, and most Sikhs (indeed, I thought all Sikhs) require a turban. There may be some who don’t follow all the rules, or some in odd sects, but basically their religion requires it.
No, I live in a city with a decent Muslim population and whilst a lot of them wear a headscarf, I have only seen a handful at most wearing a hijab. Quite a few don’t bother with it at all. So saying that most require the hijab isn’t quite true 😉
 
No, I live in a city with a decent Muslim population and whilst a lot of them wear a headscarf, I have only seen a handful at most wearing a hijab. Quite a few don’t bother with it at all. So saying that most require the hijab isn’t quite true 😉
I think we’re all getting confused about what these terms mean (I’m not sure Muslims have a lot of consistency either), so let’s be descriptive rather than use proper names.

I think it reasonable to say that Muslim women are supposed to wear headscarves. Far fewer, and probably not really mandated by their religion, cover their face too. I don’t believe they are allowed to cover their face on BA, but they are allowed to wear a headscarf, which makes sense to me.

Mike
 
I think we’re all getting confused about what these terms mean (I’m not sure Muslims have a lot of consistency either), so let’s be descriptive rather than use proper names.

I think it reasonable to say that Muslim women are supposed to wear headscarves. Far fewer, and probably not really mandated by their religion, cover their face too. I don’t believe they are allowed to cover their face on BA, but they are allowed to wear a headscarf, which makes sense to me.

Mike
Clear as mud. If they want to make exceptions to the stated policy, I have no problems and find it reasonable for her to take it to court, so long as she thinks it’s worth the risk of getting nothing but legal bills.
 
Clear as mud. If they want to make exceptions to the stated policy, I have no problems and find it reasonable for her to take it to court, so long as she thinks it’s worth the risk of getting nothing but legal bills.
It’s not an exception to the stated policy though. The policy clearly defines the uniform, with allowances for a Muslim headscarf and a Sikh turban.

She can take on the policy itself in court, but I doubt she’s going to get very far, and frankly I don’t think she should.

Mike
 
Silence has been the notable response from the bishops of the Church of England to the decision by British Airways to forbid employees from visibly wearing even a tiny cross on a necklace. It is understandable that the bishops might not wish to become embroiled in the specific case of the check-in worker Nadia Eweida. Nor would they wish to antagonise Muslim sentiment. But to pass up the opportunity to explain the centrality of the cross in Christianity and a Christian society is baffling.

Perhaps the bishops do not see Britain as a Christian country. The evidence is to the contrary. The Church of England is established by law; the Head of State is the Supreme Governor of that Church. Christian culture, the majority culture of the country, is exemplified all around us, in reality not just theory, by the cross. From the seven-ton cross atop St Paul’s Cathedral, to the cross on the crown of the Queen on every postage stamp, the symbol is everywhere.

Full article…
 
It’s not an exception to the stated policy though. The policy clearly defines the uniform, with allowances for a Muslim headscarf and a Sikh turban.

She can take on the policy itself in court, but I doubt she’s going to get very far, and frankly I don’t think she should.

Mike
For me, I can say I don’t know much espcially when it comes to spacifics on the Judical system in Britian, or did I think a lot of the news reports have reported on the exact policy of BA. For here in the US, I think this case would get real sticky because of the Free Exercise Clause in the First Admendment, and how the US Supreme Court has come to define religion. I don’t really know what the basis of religious exercise and employment law is like there.

A business here in the US does have some leeway in what they can require, espcially when it comes to how burden some the issue at hand is. I cannot say that allowing one to wear a necklace would be too burden some for a business to permit. The same laws in the US that would allow those exceptions such as a Muslim headscarf and a Sikh turban, could also provide the basis for her to be allowed to wear her necklace.
 
For me, I can say I don’t know much espcially when it comes to spacifics on the Judical system in Britian, or did I think a lot of the news reports have reported on the exact policy of BA. For here in the US, I think this case would get real sticky because of the Free Exercise Clause in the First Admendment, and how the US Supreme Court has come to define religion. I don’t really know what the basis of religious exercise and employment law is like there.

A business here in the US does have some leeway in what they can require, espcially when it comes to how burden some the issue at hand is. I cannot say that allowing one to wear a necklace would be too burden some for a business to permit. The same laws in the US that would allow those exceptions such as a Muslim headscarf and a Sikh turban, could also provide the basis for her to be allowed to wear her necklace.
What everyone fails to realize is that BA is not saying to this woman “You can not wear a necklace” what they are saying is “You can wear a necklace as LONG AS IT IS UNDER YOUR UNIFORM”…
British Airways says all jewellery and religious symbols on chains must be worn under the uniform
 
For me, I can say I don’t know much espcially when it comes to spacifics on the Judical system in Britian, or did I think a lot of the news reports have reported on the exact policy of BA. For here in the US, I think this case would get real sticky because of the Free Exercise Clause in the First Admendment, and how the US Supreme Court has come to define religion. I don’t really know what the basis of religious exercise and employment law is like there.
We don’t have a constitution, unfortunately. There seems to be increased interest towards instituting one again, an issue which has been dead here for quite some time, which is an interesting sign.

The only thing that is probably relevant is the European Convention on Human Rights (article 9). That says that people must be free to practice their religion. I’m pretty sure that any court would say that wearing a crucifix wasn’t necessary to practice Christianity, however, so I doubt she’ll get any (legal) help from that. IANAL, but I doubt it.
A business here in the US does have some leeway in what they can require, espcially when it comes to how burden some the issue at hand is. I cannot say that allowing one to wear a necklace would be too burden some for a business to permit. The same laws in the US that would allow those exceptions such as a Muslim headscarf and a Sikh turban, could also provide the basis for her to be allowed to wear her necklace.
I would guess that BA would prefer not to allow anything at all other than their prescribed uniform, but as those mentioned items are necessary for the practice of those religions, as normally understood, they are forced too, again by the ECHR, to allow them (precisely because they are not too great a burden, though I’m not sure a UK lawyer would phrase it like that. If someone had a religion where they had to spend 20 hours a day in prayer, obviously that would be too great a burden, and they couldn’t be allowed to do that while working for BA).

Whatever our personal preferences, none of us think that wearing a visible crucifix is necessary to being a Christian, and there the difference lies.

Mike
 
What everyone fails to realize is that BA is not saying to this woman “You can not wear a necklace” what they are saying is “You can wear a necklace as LONG AS IT IS UNDER YOUR UNIFORM”…
British Airways says all jewellery and religious symbols on chains must be worn under the uniform
Like I said I don’t know what the employment and free exercise of religion are in Britian. I think it’d be a bit condensending to say, yes the Sikhs can wear a turban, so long as it is not shown to the public, you can wear it in your pocket, if you can get one that fits in there.

Personally I’m not really outraged, but from a legal perspecive, I’ll say in the US this could be a intresting case to see how it’d turn out. The way see it BA has a right to set their policy & the lady has a right to sue.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top