For me, I can say I don’t know much espcially when it comes to spacifics on the Judical system in Britian, or did I think a lot of the news reports have reported on the exact policy of BA. For here in the US, I think this case would get real sticky because of the Free Exercise Clause in the First Admendment, and how the US Supreme Court has come to define religion. I don’t really know what the basis of religious exercise and employment law is like there.
We don’t have a constitution, unfortunately. There seems to be increased interest towards instituting one again, an issue which has been dead here for quite some time, which is an interesting sign.
The only thing that is probably relevant is the European Convention on Human Rights (article 9). That says that people must be free to practice their religion. I’m pretty sure that any court would say that wearing a crucifix wasn’t necessary to practice Christianity, however, so I doubt she’ll get any (legal) help from that. IANAL, but I doubt it.
A business here in the US does have some leeway in what they can require, espcially when it comes to how burden some the issue at hand is. I cannot say that allowing one to wear a necklace would be too burden some for a business to permit. The same laws in the US that would allow those exceptions such as a Muslim headscarf and a Sikh turban, could also provide the basis for her to be allowed to wear her necklace.
I would guess that BA would prefer not to allow anything at all other than their prescribed uniform, but as those mentioned items are
necessary for the practice of those religions, as normally understood, they are forced too, again by the ECHR, to allow them (precisely because they are not too great a burden, though I’m not sure a UK lawyer would phrase it like that. If someone had a religion where they had to spend 20 hours a day in prayer, obviously that would be too great a burden, and they couldn’t be allowed to do that while working for BA).
Whatever our personal preferences, none of us think that wearing a visible crucifix is
necessary to being a Christian, and there the difference lies.
Mike