Diminished culpability does make the sin venial in that specific circumstance. That is of course up to the priest to make that call. We don’t have that info (nor should we, seal of confession and all that), but it does appear that the priest doesn’t think that daily confession is the right approach.
As I said above, confession does have a big role to play in addiction. But it might not suffice alone. It needs to be combined with therapy, and care must be take to avoid scrupulosity. I think less frequent confession where we focus on general progress rather than each specific occurrence, might be best, that is confess when progress stops or regresses but not when there’s a marked improvement. We have to remember While God rewards success, He also recognizes genuine effort leading to improvement even if the result isn’t always perfect.
True healing requires deep inner transformation, and learning to let go of the pain that our addiction tries to mask. Confession can help, but too frequent might hurt. It’s a question of balance. Often therapy is required, or at the very least sound spiritual direction. And finding a good therapist willing to work within or at least respect your Catholic boundaries isn’t easy.
I don’t like getting personal on these forums but all I can say is “been there, done that”.
I would go so far as to say that it should be assumed that confession should *never *be expected to suffice alone in the treatment of addiction, or even of habitual sin. If there is an exception, I will bet everything that it proves that rule. Confession and the Eucharist are necessary in our struggle against sin, but that does not mean that confession and Mass alone are sufficient.
I think the OP would do well to make an appointment to talk to a priest about her issues at length, resolving that she will not consult with more than three different priests. At some point, she has to take what they tell her at face value.
One more thing…I should have said this. I finalized my divorce last Monday. The pain is horrendous, I cry non-stop at times and then other times I feel fine. I cannot believe it ripped me up this bad. It was supposed to be a default hearing but he showed up holding hands with his new girlfriend and made some statement to the court about how stupid I am before the judge cut him off. I feel I have no purpose, no point in life except to work to pay bills. I’m falling behind every month and have managed to juggle but the student loans (that can’t be deferred anymore) are killing me. Money is simply not an option. I did find a divorce support group and feel that I can start there.
There is one sex addicts group and it’s co-ed. I can just see how that could be an occasion for sin…not interested in anything co-ed about a sex addiction. I feel this recent relapse is my way of medicating the horrific pain I’m in.
Anyway, it’s hard to know what to post to give people adequate info and I appreciate that all you can offer is based on what you read and I’m totally impressed. You are very giving and I appreciate your compassion and challenges.
Lorrie
You went to court expecting a non-event and instead had your ex very emphatically rub his rejection of you into your wounds. You’ve been emotionally abushed. Don’t punish yourself for being torn. Spiritually and emotionally, you’re a burn patient! Don’t think of pain control as if you had a mild sun burn. Rather, look for any legitimate thing you can find to soften the blow and give yourself some much-needed comfort and self-care.
When the Lord was finally alone with the woman caught in adultery, he said two things: Neither do I condemn you and go and sin no more. Of course you remember that. Remeber that He DID NOT say, neither do I condem you, but I’m going to the next time I see your dragged in front of me.
The Lord will never leave you. Even if you can’t find a confessor, even if you can’t find a place to go to Mass, even if everyone you know turns their back on you, the Lord will never leave you. When I was going through my bad time, I hung this on my bathroom mirror, printed in big letters. It is still there. If you read the whole psalm, it was written in lament of being forced to watch the evildoers, having their day:
*If the LORD were not my help,
I would long have been silent in the grave.
When I say, “My foot is slipping,”
your mercy, LORD, holds me up.
When cares increase within me,
your comfort gives me joy.*
Psalm 94:16-19
Hang in there. God is with you, God advocates for you, and God is not looking for a technicality to catch you with. God only wants you sound and whole and entirely belonging to Him, with no blemish holding you back. You cannot come to Him “good enough”; making you perfect is what God will do for you, not the other way around! So keep up your pursuit of holiness, but remember always that the work is God’s, and try as you might your perfection will have to happen in God’s time. It will happen. Trust God about that.