Death Pathways

  • Thread starter Thread starter marci
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Mother Teresa said,“Any country that accepts abortion, is not teaching its people to love, but to use any violence to get what it wants”.
I can only imagine what she would have to say about allowing a baby (or anyone) to starve to death on purpose.
What kind of a world do we live in?
A world that is circling the drain…:(:(:(:(:(😦
 
No. Food and water must be provided and received. However, extraordinary means like surgery and stuff may be refused.
With all due respect, I don’t think that is quite true.** If someone is dying** and they are refusing oral food and/or fluids, there is no obligation for them to have a feeding tube inserted against their will. If they want it, sure, but even then if the body has reached the point where this is only going to cause more distress and discomfort it may not be advisable. They still of course need proper nursing care which would include moistening their mouth.

Or as another example, imagine a terminally ill patient who has been deteriorating and gradually taking less and less food and water because they are becoming weaker and closer to death, then they slip into unconsciousness as they approach death. There is no obligation to insert a feeding tube at this time, and it would make no sense to do so.

I believe that the concept of not withholding food and fluids (and this meaning a feeding tube must be inserted) refers to cases where that withholding is what will cause the death, not where death is going to occur anyway.

The situation in the article involves babies so emotions are going to run higher but the same principles apply. (I don’t know if the article is accurate or not but the Daily Mail is not known for its reliability or lack of sensationalism).
 
I couldn’t read all of it, as I’m currently pregnant and I’d rather not think about a lot of scenerios. But this makes my heart hurt. I don’t really understand not fighting for your baby’s life. Letting them die of dehydration is totally beyond me and goes against the basic human instincts and “mama bear” protectiveness a mother should have.
Congratulations!🙂 With all respect, take care of those little ones and teach them to live life for life itself and to never give up. Its better to suffer and have unbreakable resolve then to use others for your own selfish wants and never being whole.
 
dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2240075/Now-sick-babies-death-pathway-Doctors-haunting-testimony-reveals-children-end-life-plan.html

Wow, I mean just bloody wow. If any pro-abortionist moron with his inflated sense of enlightenment came up to me and told me the world is a better place now, I’d show him this and tell him to shove his stupid enlightenment up his *******.
One of the best comments I have read in a while.

👍
 
In other discussions I’ve read on this issue, it was noted that if artificial hydration and nutrition was considered “burdensome” to the point of harming someone, even psychologically, then that person could refuse such measures in good conscience. In addition, it would seem to me that continuing nutrition and hydration in the face of imminent death could be considered to be “disproportionate to the expected outcome”. Again, correct me if I’m mistaken, but wasn’t Pope John Paul II taken off a feeding tube prior to his death?

For my part, I don’t particularly trust the article’s source to give an accurate description of the cases involved. I say that because: 1) It is impossible to assess that amount of pain that someone else is experiencing and 2) the article uses pictures of, what appear to be, perfectly healthy babies, to make its point. Irregardless though, I still think it would be possible, under a narrow set of circumstances, for a parent to ethically refuse hydration and nutrition on behalf of a newborn in an effort to not prolong its death.

If it turns out that I am mistaken on these matters, then I’ll make sure that my family has explicit, written instructions to not take me to a Catholic hospital for any serious illness.
Oh please, as if someone like you who does not provide any context to his writings is going to convince us that killing a disabled baby by refusing nutrition and giving it a slow death is moral. Just don’t think we’re idiots. Thing is, those doctors killed people who otherwise could have lived to see a better day. There are stories of babies being aborted and living. The intention of the doctors is not to prolong death but to keep them alive in order to help them and cure them. Living life for lfie itself is better than abandoning your child because your too bloody lazy to worry about it you know.

Also, the scientists know about the pain the patients feel through a combination of science and common sense. You don’t trust the article? Fine, try casting doubt, just prove to me that this whole affair never happened and I’ll believe you.
 
No. Food and water must be provided and received. However, extraordinary means like surgery and stuff may be refused.
Food and water must be offered and available, but the patient cannot be forced to receive them, and no invasive procedures should be administered to “make” them eat and drink. Deprivation of food and water must not be done for the primary purpose of causing death, either. This was the difference between Terry Schiavo and Pope John Paul II. Terry was denied food and water in order to kill her. Blessed JP2 got to the point where food or water would no longer delay the inevitable.
 
Food and water must be offered and available, but the patient cannot be forced to receive them, and no invasive procedures should be administered to “make” them eat and drink. Deprivation of food and water must not be done for the primary purpose of causing death, either. This was the difference between Terry Schiavo and Pope John Paul II. Terry was denied food and water in order to kill her. Blessed JP2 got to the point where food or water would no longer delay the inevitable.
Excellent explanation.
 
Food and water must be offered and available, but the patient cannot be forced to receive them, and no invasive procedures should be administered to “make” them eat and drink. Deprivation of food and water must not be done for the primary purpose of causing death, either. This was the difference between Terry Schiavo and Pope John Paul II. Terry was denied food and water in order to kill her. Blessed JP2 got to the point where food or water would no longer delay the inevitable.
Exactly! You explained it much better than I did.
 
One small issue:
It is very difficult to predict death. I have seen a “reasonable” number of children recover after being taken off the pathway.
No one claimed that predicting death was an exact science, but if anyone knows more about it than your average layman, it would be doctors.

If the children were taken off the pathway, then apparently the doctors changed their prognosis. If the doctors later felt that the individual’s chance of survival had increased to the point where being on the pathway was no longer an ethical choice, then the doctors should resume treatment.

BTW, I consulted a Catholic priest on the issue and he agreed with my assessment: It would not be either immoral or unethical to withhold food and water from either an adult or an infant, under the circumstances we’ve been discussing.
 
Oh please, as if someone like you who does not provide any context to his writings is going to convince us that killing a disabled baby by refusing nutrition and giving it a slow death is moral. Just don’t think we’re idiots.
What, exactly, are you implying here?
Thing is, those doctors killed people who otherwise could have lived to see a better day. There are stories of babies being aborted and living. The intention of the doctors is not to prolong death but to keep them alive in order to help them and cure them. Living life for lfie itself is better than abandoning your child because your too bloody lazy to worry about it you know.
If doctors were killing people who had a reasonable chance of surviving, I would be opposed to that, but that’s not what we’ve been discussing.
Also, the scientists know about the pain the patients feel through a combination of science and common sense. You don’t trust the article? Fine, try casting doubt, just prove to me that this whole affair never happened and I’ll believe you.
How does one assess the level pain of someone in a coma? If you think it’s that easy to assess pain levels, then why do doctors primarily rely of a patient’s word when making such determinations?
 
What, exactly, are you implying here?

If doctors were killing people who had a reasonable chance of surviving, I would be opposed to that, but that’s not what we’ve been discussing.

How does one assess the level pain of someone in a coma? If you think it’s that easy to assess pain levels, then why do doctors primarily rely of a patient’s word when making such determinations?
I’m implying nothing, my wording was clear: your arguments plain sucked, were unreasonable because they were not backed up by any proof scientific or otherwise.

Also, the article made it clear that the people who were killed only died because they were deprived of nutrition whereas other people suffering from the same disabilities under a competent hospital would survive as so many people in the comments pointed out.

And when do doctors rely on a patients word to assess pain at all times? Are doctors so incompetent today that they need their patients to guide them? Aren’t they the ones who are supposed to check us up and heal us in one way or another? In fact, for someone who critisizes people who don’t know the pain of others, you yourself don’t even know what these people are undergoing or whether they want to live or not. Ever hear of Terry Willis? He woke up from a coma after 19 years. Do you want him dead because of the pain he probably suffered? Thing is, people with disabilities have a reasonable chance to live. Those pople weren’t killed by their own disabilities but because a couple of bastards offed them. Remember that, and the fact that people suffering from same said disabilities survived in other parts of the world because a pair of monsters weren’t around to kill them by starvation.

I’m baffled at how you or anyone can even support such a monstrous practice. Well done, you’d make a GREAT role model:mad:.
 
No one claimed that predicting death was an exact science, but if anyone knows more about it than your average layman, it would be doctors.

If the children were taken off the pathway, then apparently the doctors changed their prognosis. If the doctors later felt that the individual’s chance of survival had increased to the point where being on the pathway was no longer an ethical choice, then the doctors should resume treatment.

BTW, I consulted a Catholic priest on the issue and he agreed with my assessment: It would not be either immoral or unethical to withhold food and water from either an adult or an infant, under the circumstances we’ve been discussing.
As if I’d believe you’d go so far to consult a priest. Yeah, maybe sometimes witholding food and water for the benefit of the patient is good you know, AS LONG AS YOU DON’T HAVE THE INTENTION TO KILL THEM. If doctors are that smart then so are the doctors who would never think of putting children on pathways and who prolong their lives as they should. Oh wait, aren’t those people unethical according to you? Whats a few monster doctors in liverpool have anything to do with the rest of the medical world? Theres a huge diffirence between taking care of people dying and killing them. Get that straight into your thickheaded skull.
 
I’m implying nothing, my wording was clear: your arguments plain sucked, were unreasonable because they were not backed up by any proof scientific or otherwise.
Go back to my first post in this thread and read forward. The only point I’ve been making is that it is neither immoral or unethical to withhold nutrition and hydration from a patient who is unlikely to survive, whose death is determined to be immanent and who has chosen that path for themselves. In the case of infants, the parents are charged with making that decision on behalf of their children. That such decisions are made by family members or spouses and not the incapacitated/incompetent patient in no way changes that.
Also, the article made it clear that the people who were killed only died because they were deprived of nutrition whereas other people suffering from the same disabilities under a competent hospital would survive as so many people in the comments pointed out.
My argument exists independently of the article, but what it and you are ignoring are the people who died from lack of nutrition and hydration because they chose to refuse those measures. They have that right. Parents of infants are also allowed to make those decisions for their children. If you have a problem with the decision those parents made, then I invite you to discuss the issue with them. I also invite you to discuss the issue with your priest. If you include my argument in your discussion, just please accurately characterize it.
And when do doctors rely on a patients word to assess pain at all times? Are doctors so incompetent today that they need their patients to guide them? Aren’t they the ones who are supposed to check us up and heal us in one way or another? In fact, for someone who critisizes people who don’t know the pain of others, you yourself don’t even know what these people are undergoing or whether they want to live or not. Ever hear of Terry Willis? He woke up from a coma after 19 years. Do you want him dead because of the pain he probably suffered? Thing is, people with disabilities have a reasonable chance to live. Those pople weren’t killed by their own disabilities but because a couple of bastards offed them. Remember that, and the fact that people suffering from same said disabilities survived in other parts of the world because a pair of monsters weren’t around to kill them by starvation.
I’m baffled at how you or anyone can even support such a monstrous practice. Well done, you’d make a GREAT role model:mad:.
Again, please confine your arguments to what I’ve actually written. I’ve never claimed that it was ethical or moral to withhold treatment from people who wanted that treatment.***** Like it or not, it is not immoral or unethical for a person to refuse treatment – even nutrition and hydration.

***** If someone else is paying for that treatment, then the recipient has to consider the possibility that there may come a time when that other entity simply can’t afford to do so any longer. Cost/benefit analysis is unpleasant, but necessary. (Just to put some skin in the game, I’ve recorded my decision to refuse all treatment for illnesses with low survivability expectation.)
 
As if I’d believe you’d go so far to consult a priest.
As a matter of fact, I have dinner with a priest two or three times a week – he’s my brother.
Yeah, maybe sometimes witholding food and water for the benefit of the patient is good you know, AS LONG AS YOU DON’T HAVE THE INTENTION TO KILL THEM.
Finally.
If doctors are that smart then so are the doctors who would never think of putting children on pathways and who prolong their lives as they should. Oh wait, aren’t those people unethical according to you?
They are if they’re acting against the wishes of the patients or guardians.
 
I’m going to go a bit further out on the limb here.

As I understand it, it is not even unethical or immoral for a patient to refuse treatment – of any kind – even for illnesses which are survivable through less than so-called heroic measures. For instance, there may come a time when a dialysis patient simply isn’t willing to continue that process and chooses to be allowed to die, even though dialysis, in and of itself, isn’t nearly as burdensome as many other medical procedures. They are, in effect, allowing nature to take its course.
 
I’m going to go a bit further out on the limb here.

As I understand it, it is not even unethical or immoral for a patient to refuse treatment – of any kind – even for illnesses which are survivable through less than so-called heroic measures. For instance, there may come a time when a dialysis patient simply isn’t willing to continue that process and chooses to be allowed to die, even though dialysis, in and of itself, isn’t nearly as burdensome as many other medical procedures. They are, in effect, allowing nature to take its course.
Theres a diffirence between allowing nature to take its course and refusing nutrition because because nutrition in and of tiself is essential in our nature to survive. And no, neither the parents nor the patients themselves have the right to refuse nutrition in order to end their lives. Nobody has the right to suicide; if someone wants to end his life we try to stop them even if it’s against their wishes. Parents don’t have the right to refuse any of their children nutrition in order to kill them because nobody and I mean nobody has the right to do that. If I were to discuss it with them, I’d tell them what a senseless and selfish act they did and how inconsiderate they were of their child or loved one. Go on, call me a jerk but theres a diffirence ebtween being a jerk and making people feel bad than pointing out the wrong that they did and making them repent and resolve enver to do it again.

And don’t finally me. The only time refusing food or water is necessary is if it would complicate a body and an emergency needs to be done in order to remove such complication, such as when they didn’t give Maria Goretti water because of her multiple stab wounds. By the way, here is what Pope John Paul II said about feeding tube removal being IMMORAL, refuting your false statements that the church isn’t against it: illinoisrighttolife.org/2004_2_FeedingTubeRemovalImmoral.htm

If the patients themselves refuse nutrition or if they refuse to undergo a life threatening operation, theres a word for that: recklessness. Not only are they throwing their lives away but throwing out the potential to do more good in the world. They nothing less like those who commit suicide because of despair.
With all respect to your parents, what would you have thought if they ordered that they refused you nutrition if you were sickl
 
My personal belief is that food, water and effective pain management should be provided to all terminal patients…this is simply humane.Where I believe the problems come in is when we continue to treat people for conditions, i.e., dementia, congestive heart failure, various cancers, etc., from which they will never recover.
This, IMHO, is a waste of resources.

Regarding assisted suicide, it has been found that most people, given effective pain management, will opt to die naturally. Pain management is the key.
nrlc.org/euthanasia/asisuid2.html
I know that is how I would feel…but don’t leave me in crushing pain, or I will definitely be looking for a way to end it.
 
My personal belief is that food, water and effective pain management should be provided to all terminal patients…this is simply humane.Where I believe the problems come in is when we continue to treat people for conditions, i.e., dementia, congestive heart failure, various cancers, etc., from which they will never recover.
This, IMHO, is a waste of resources.

Regarding assisted suicide, it has been found that most people, given effective pain management, will opt to die naturally. Pain management is the key.
nrlc.org/euthanasia/asisuid2.html
I know that is how I would feel…but don’t leave me in crushing pain, or I will definitely be looking for a way to end it.
False. People do recover from dementia. My grandma had it just recently and in a few weeks she was cured. She also revealed some pretty, awkward stuff but I don’t want to go into too much detail.
 
Cost/benefit analysis is unpleasant, but necessary. (Just to put some skin in the game, I’ve recorded my decision to refuse all treatment for illnesses with low survivability expectation.)
I feel sorry for you dude. You’re just going to give up instead of keeping on living. Even Hitchens whom I despise didn’t want to die and pushed his rubbish forward even in death. Nobody truly wants to die; they want to keep living in order to fullfill or further their dreams as a man without a dream is empty and a fool.
 
Theres a diffirence between allowing nature to take its course and refusing nutrition because because nutrition in and of tiself is essential in our nature to survive. And no, neither the parents nor the patients themselves have the right to refuse nutrition in order to end their lives. Nobody has the right to suicide; if someone wants to end his life we try to stop them even if it’s against their wishes. Parents don’t have the right to refuse any of their children nutrition in order to kill them because nobody and I mean nobody has the right to do that. If I were to discuss it with them, I’d tell them what a senseless and selfish act they did and how inconsiderate they were of their child or loved one. Go on, call me a jerk but theres a diffirence ebtween being a jerk and making people feel bad than pointing out the wrong that they did and making them repent and resolve enver to do it again.
Emphasis mine. You’re still arguing against a strawman. The intention is to not delay the inevitable; to not needlessly prolong the act of dying.
And don’t finally me. The only time refusing food or water is necessary is if it would complicate a body and an emergency needs to be done in order to remove such complication, such as when they didn’t give Maria Goretti water because of her multiple stab wounds. By the way, here is what Pope John Paul II said about feeding tube removal being IMMORAL, refuting your false statements that the church isn’t against it: illinoisrighttolife.org/2004_2_FeedingTubeRemovalImmoral.htm
When JPII had his feeding tube removed, was he, his medical advisers or all parties acting immorally? JPII isn’t “the church”.
If the patients themselves refuse nutrition or if they refuse to undergo a life threatening operation, theres a word for that: recklessness. Not only are they throwing their lives away but throwing out the potential to do more good in the world. They nothing less like those who commit suicide because of despair.
With all respect to your parents, what would you have thought if they ordered that they refused you nutrition if you were sickl
Within the context of the conditions I’ve been discussing, if those were my wishes, I’d say “Thanks”
I feel sorry for you dude. You’re just going to give up instead of keeping on living. Even Hitchens whom I despise didn’t want to die and pushed his rubbish forward even in death. Nobody truly wants to die; they want to keep living in order to fullfill or further their dreams as a man without a dream is empty and a fool.
If you can’t imagine a situation where the quality of life and/or the prospects for life are so diminished that death would be preferable, then you would seem to either lack imagination or experience. In any case, I’m finished dealing with your invective.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top