Defending Mary's Virginity

  • Thread starter Thread starter philipmarie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
as a realisation/magnification of the divinity of Jesus

mary’s words …’…my sould doth magnify the lord…"
How does Mary’s perpetual virginity do this? Mary’s words “…my soul doth magnify the Lord” would apply whether or not she remained a virgin would they not?
 
Hey Brian!

“They thought, then, that He was the son of Joseph and Mary. But some say, basing it on a tradition in the Gospel According to Peter, as it is entitled, or The Book of James, that the brethren of Jesus were sons of Joseph by a former wife, whom he married before Mary. Now those who say so wish to preserve the honour of Mary in virginity to the end, so that that body of hers which was appointed to minister to the Word which said, ‘The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Most High shall overshadow thee’ (Luke 1:35), might not know intercourse with a man after that the Holy Ghost came into her and the power from on high overshadowed her. And I think it in harmony with reason that Jesus was the first-fruit among men of the purity which consists in chastity, and Mary among women; for it were not pious to ascribe to any other than to her the first-fruit of virginity” (, Bk. 10, No. 17Commentary on Matthew).

One additional point that we couldn’t see before was that Origen mentions two works. Now, if you ask me, what Origen is saying is that “those who say so” are basing it on a tradition – and here’s the word that I will insert to make his meaning clear – found in these two works, but not necessarily originating with these two books. Unless we want to try and establish that both of these works came from the same community, having both the Gospel of Peter and the Book of James make this claim demonstrates that we already have at least two strands of Christian tradition holding this same view in the safeguarding of Mary’s virginity. The authors of these works took this belief from somewhere, and if you date these works to the first half of the second century, then you have this Christian belief going back to within decades of the deaths of the last of the apostles. It is therefore very plausible to assign this teaching to apostolic times and, assuming that it conforms to Scripture (which it does :)), as coming from the apostles themselves. So again, I think that Origen is locating the basis on an early tradition, and simply identifying these two works as places where this tradition can be found.

To clarify what’s being said here… in this commentary, Origen is presenting the idea that “the brethren of Jesus were sons of Joseph by a former wife.” We can tell from his manner of speaking that more than one Christian position can be held on this question. He refers to “those who say so” and doesn’t suggest that it’s not OK for others to say otherwise. But we also know that Origen did not hold that this same freedom was available to us on the question of whether Mary remained a virgin. For in his homilies on Luke he also wrote the following:
At this point we ought to refute the heretics’ usual objections; otherwise some simpler people might be deceived. Someone or other gave vent to his madness and claimed that the Savior had repudiated Mary because she had been joined to Joseph after his birth. This is what he said. I hope he knows what the state of his mind was when he said it. If heretics ever raise an objection like this to you, answer them and say, “Elizabeth surely was filled with the Holy Spirit when she said, ‘Blessed are you among women.’ If the Holy Spirit called Mary ‘blessed,’ how could the Savior repudiate her?” Furthermore, they assert that Mary had marital relations after the birth of Jesus. But they have no source of proof. For the children who were called Joseph’s were not born of Mary. There is no passage in Scripture that mentions this (Homily 7, No. 4).

Origen says that it is heretics who assert that Mary had marital relations. He evidently believes that he is presenting apostolic teaching when he says that Mary remained a virgin.

We also have Origen’s predecessor, Clement of Alexandria, teaching the same “tradition” as mentioned above:

Jude, who wrote the Catholic Epistle, the brother of the sons of Joseph, and very religious, whilst knowing the near relationship of the Lord, yet did not say that he himself was His brother. But what said he? “Jude, a servant of Jesus Christ,”–of Him as Lord; but “the brother of James.” For this is true; he was His brother, (the son) of Joseph (Comments on the Epistle of Jude).

Here we can note that the brothers are called by Clement the sons of Joseph only. Not the sons of Joseph and Mary.

The Papias quote seems to be rejected by some and accepted by others. This is true of many ancient texts. But I don’t know enough to say in this case. 🤷

In response to Tertullian’s view, that Mary did not remain a virgin, Jerome said “no more than that he did not belong to the Church” (The Perpetual Virginity of Blessed Mary).

What do you think of Luke 1:34? Thanks!

Your brother in the Lord,
Pete
 
I’m doing research on Catholics view on Mary. Please help me to understand.

In Mathew 13:55

How does the church interrupt the brother word? Are they not Jesus’s blood brothers?

These idea as stated in Matthew 27:56, Mark 3:31, and other passages.
According to the Douay-Rheims, Matthew 13:55-56, “Is not this the carpenter’s son? Is not his mother called Mary, and his brethren James, and Joseph, and Simon, and Jude: 56 And his sisters, are they not all with us?”

With the following explination given: 55 “His brethren”… These were the children of Mary the wife of Cleophas, sister to our Blessed Lady, (St. Matt. 27. 56; St. John 19. 25,) and therefore, according to the usual style of the Scripture, they were called brethren, that is, near relations to our Saviour.

Something that was pointed out to me, though, note, whenever Jesus brothers (relatives) are brought up, and even His sisters, it is HIS brothers and/or sisters. It is His relatives. We hear of His kinsmen. The point I’m making is we see that they are His brethren, not sons of Mary. When we see anything about Jesus’ relatives, it’s in relation to Him; we do not have ANY passage that says, “The son’s of Mary.”
 
Originally Posted by panevino View Post
as a realisation/magnification of the divinity of Jesus
mary’s words …’…my sould doth magnify the lord…"
How does Mary’s perpetual virginity do this? …
Mary gave birth to the son of God and was made pregnant by God.
as St ignatius wrote in one of his letters

letter to ephesians 7 “…fruit of God and Mary’s seed…”

God is the Father.

Perpetual virginity - is a product of Mary’s dedication/commitment/honour to God and his/her Son.

Luke 1:38 KJV And Mary said, Behold the handmaid of the Lord; be it unto me according to thy word. And the angel departed from her.
 
In Mary Immaculate,

Regarding original sin: yes, we had to mention original sin as it could not only have affected the dignity of Mary Most Holy, but also Her Virginity. What, with the inclination towards evil and all that.

Regarding early Church references: no, the Apostles could not have thaught everything, everything. There had to be ways of how further teaching could be developed. For example, we do not see in the Bible somebody explicitly teaching about the Virginity of Mary Most Holy or some other things. We do not see even the apostles teaching faith alone as protestants believe, or making alot of treatesis and all that.

As for early Church references:209.85.135.132/search?q=cache:tHsnbDF_mogJ:campus.udayton.edu/mary/resources/virofmary.htm+saint+justin+and+tertulian+on+the+Virginity+of+Mary&cd=3&hl=mt&ct=clnk&gl=mt

Excuse me Brian but, I mean not to be rude but, why do you not bring some objections and arguments against the Virginity of Mary? I am sorry but, what you are doing is to try to cast doubt upon my(and the Blessed Virgins’) arguments. There was a certain Saint(an early Saint who must not have been knowing what he was doing) who denied Her Virginity during birth but affirmed that She was a Virgin before birth. But this was only the opinion of some guy. The Church alone can teach a correct doctrine and define it, and it does so through it’s Bishops and the Pope.

And say not that because there are heretical Bishops and heretical Priests then, the Church differs in doctrine like how that two faced Mizzi asserts. It is not true. They are only showing their oppinion. Just because Saint peter denied Christ and that judas betrayed Him, does that mean that the Chuch of Christ fell? How about Peter, he thought that there are certain unclean foods and all that, while Christ his Master affirmed that ther is no such thing as unclean food?
 
How does Mary’s perpetual virginity do this? Mary’s words “…my soul doth magnify the Lord” would apply whether or not she remained a virgin would they not?
Regarding this: well, not exactly. A married man can praise God yet he is not a Virgin. Mary though gave Herself all to God and so yes, as some subscriber said above, it could have shown that She gave Herself to God in the temple.
 
Pete,

You will notice from Origen’s commentary on Matthew, he said believing that Mary remained in her virginity is reasonable, but he himself never committed to the belief.
You are not the first to counter something Origen wrote with something Origen supposedly said. His homilies are altogether unreliable; they originated from stenographers who could only do their best to transcribe what they heard. On top of that, it is anybodies guess what happened to them after they were transcribed. The quote you presented from his homily has aspects of it that are completely contrary and out of character from his commentary that he himself wrote. Origen had many opportunities to express the opinion that those who do not believe in her perpetual virginity are heretics, yet he never even comes close to doing that.

Origen expounds quite a bit on the subject in his commentary on John; here is an excerpt that I think offers him the opportunity to accuse those who deny Mary’s perpetual virginity of heresy.

“We may therefore make bold to say that the Gospels are the first fruits of all the Scriptures, but that of the Gospels that of John is the first fruits. No one can apprehend the meaning of it except he have lain on Jesus’ breast and received from Jesus Mary to be his mother also. Such an one must he become who is to be another John, and to have shown to him, like John, by Jesus Himself Jesus as He is. For if Mary, as those declare who with sound mind extol her, had no other son but Jesus, and yet Jesus says to His mother, Woman, behold your son, and not Behold you have this son also, then He virtually said to her, Lo, this is Jesus, whom you bore. Is it not the case that every one who is perfect lives himself no longer, but Christ lives in him; and if Christ lives in him, then it is said of him to Mary, Behold your son Christ. What a mind, then, must we have to enable us to interpret in a worthy manner this work, though it be committed to the earthly treasure-house of common speech, of writing which any passer-by can read, and which can be heard when read aloud by any one who lends to it his bodily ears? What shall we say of this work? He who is accurately to apprehend what it contains should be able to say with truth, we have the mind of Christ, that we may know those things which are bestowed on us by God.” (Commentary on John, 1:6)

Origen expresses that there are those of sound mind that believe Mary had no other son, he, possibly, being one of them. He does not say, “as tradition teaches,” or “as handed down from the apostles,” he says, those who extol her. And in his commentary on Matthew he shows where that idea comes from. In the many times Origen speaks of Mary in his commentaries, he never once refers to those on either side of the issue as heretics.

Clement’s comment makes sense in light of the fact that he was Origen’s teacher. It is apparent that when you consider comments from Origen and Clement together, the origin of the doctrine is not apostolic.

Now here is an excerpt from Irenaeus that strongly suggests he believed Mary did had sexual relations with her husband after Jesus was born.

“For the one and the same Spirit of God, who proclaimed by the prophets what and of what sort the advent of the Lord should be, did by these elders give a just interpretation of what had been truly prophesied; and He did Himself, by the apostles, announce that the fullness of the times of the adoption had arrived, that the kingdom of heaven had drawn near, and that He was dwelling within those that believe in Him who was born Emmanuel of the Virgin. To this effect they testify, saying, that before Joseph had come together with Mary, while she therefore remained in virginity, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost.” (Against Heresies; 3:4)

Tertullian’s comments are perfectly inline with what Irenaeus suggested here. Jerome, on the other hand, was one who exhaled Mary and, as one might expect, differed with Tertullian’s understanding. But did Jerome ever demonstrate that Tertullian was unorthodox in his time? His comment about Tertullian I find amusing: “Of Tertullian I say no more than that he did not belong to the Church.” The comment is no doubt a reference to Tertullian’s Montanism, which has absolutely nothing to do with his views regarding Mary’s virginity.

Why are you asking me what I think of Luke 1:34? Do you think I am denying the virgin birth? Nobody here is denying the virgin birth. This is about whether or not Mary remained a virgin throughout her life. And more to the point, at least for me, it’s about refuting the absurd claim that those who deny her “perpetual” virginity are heretics bound for hell.

The OP hit the nail on the head when he said the apostles did not teach this doctrine, but your pope and bishops have defined it.

In Christ, Brian
 
{snip}
The OP hit the nail on the head when he said the apostles did not teach this doctrine, but your pope and bishops have defined it.

In Christ, Brian
The bolded part is pure speculation on both our your parts. You have demonstrated no knowledge on which to base this claim. And arguments from silence are considered logical falacies.
 
…arguments from silence are considered logical falacies.
Good point David! Now apply that to your leadership who, with no apostolic evidence, demand that you believe their doctrine or suffer the wrath of God.

Brian
 
pure speculation on both our your parts. You have demonstrated no knowledge on which to base this claim. And arguments from silence are considered logical falacies.
That’s just one of my “problems” with the Dogma of the Perpetual Virginity of Mary. At most, it is pure speculation from silence, that non-existent foundation then followed by a chain of illogical falacies.

But most of all, I just consider it moot at best and perhaps an invasion of marital privacy.

.
 
It’s not pure speculation from silence. It’s been stated through the ages. ALL mainstream Christians believed it until the 1800s.

I didn’t know that about Origen’s homilies. Is that common knowledge or anti-apostolic wishing?
 
Pete,

You will notice from Origen’s commentary on Matthew, he said believing that Mary remained in her virginity is reasonable, but he himself never committed to the belief.
You are not the first to counter something Origen wrote with something Origen supposedly said. His homilies are altogether unreliable; they originated from stenographers who could only do their best to transcribe what they heard. On top of that, it is anybodies guess what happened to them after they were transcribed. The quote you presented from his homily has aspects of it that are completely contrary and out of character from his commentary that he himself wrote. Origen had many opportunities to express the opinion that those who do not believe in her perpetual virginity are heretics, yet he never even comes close to doing that.

Origen expounds quite a bit on the subject in his commentary on John; here is an excerpt that I think offers him the opportunity to accuse those who deny Mary’s perpetual virginity of heresy.

“We may therefore make bold to say that the Gospels are the first fruits of all the Scriptures, but that of the Gospels that of John is the first fruits. No one can apprehend the meaning of it except he have lain on Jesus’ breast and received from Jesus Mary to be his mother also. Such an one must he become who is to be another John, and to have shown to him, like John, by Jesus Himself Jesus as He is. For if Mary, as those declare who with sound mind extol her, had no other son but Jesus, and yet Jesus says to His mother, Woman, behold your son, and not Behold you have this son also, then He virtually said to her, Lo, this is Jesus, whom you bore. Is it not the case that every one who is perfect lives himself no longer, but Christ lives in him; and if Christ lives in him, then it is said of him to Mary, Behold your son Christ. What a mind, then, must we have to enable us to interpret in a worthy manner this work, though it be committed to the earthly treasure-house of common speech, of writing which any passer-by can read, and which can be heard when read aloud by any one who lends to it his bodily ears? What shall we say of this work? He who is accurately to apprehend what it contains should be able to say with truth, we have the mind of Christ, that we may know those things which are bestowed on us by God.” (Commentary on John, 1:6)

Origen expresses that there are those of sound mind that believe Mary had no other son, he, possibly, being one of them. He does not say, “as tradition teaches,” or “as handed down from the apostles,” he says, those who extol her. And in his commentary on Matthew he shows where that idea comes from. In the many times Origen speaks of Mary in his commentaries, he never once refers to those on either side of the issue as heretics.
Hey Brian! I enjoy our exchanges.

I’m not sure how reasonable it is to dismiss his homilies. John Paul II quoted from them without qualm. I see what you’re saying about it being a homily, but we’re not talking about an ambiguous statement in an uncertain context. The thought of Origen would have had to have been severely distorted by his amanuensis to ruin his meaning, and all of the other mishaps that you mentioned could equally befall something he wrote himself.

Doesn’t what Origen says in this commentary on John make you think that it would be a person of unsound mind who thinks that she had other children? Wouldn’t a person of unsound mind be a heretic? The two are at least very agreeable to each other. Origen says that it is “those… with sound mind” who understand Jesus to be Mary’s only son. And then, after explaining the interpretation of Scripture that is derived from this understanding, he is struck by “What a mind, then, must we have to enable us to interpret in a worthy manner this work.” He seems to me to be referring back to the sound mind leading to the interpretation he just gave. And he goes on to identify this mind with the very mind of Christ. I think that we cannot escape the conclusion that Origen includes himself among these people.

Here is Clement again:

“[M]any even down to our own time regard Mary, on account of the birth of her child, as having been in the puerperal (= pertaining to or connected with childbirth) state, although she was not. For some say that, after she brought forth, she was found, when examined, to be a virgin” (, Bk. 7, Ch. 16The Stromata).

He says that “some say” that she was found to be a virgin after birth, and we can see from his first sentence that he agrees with them that she certainly was a virgin because he says that even though many others think the opposite, “she was not” what these latter supposed. Note also that, while some say she was examined and found thereby to be a virgin, this testimony is not necessarily true. Nevertheless, as we’ve already gathered from his first sentence, the fact that she was a virgin after birth is true.
Now here is an excerpt from Irenaeus that strongly suggests he believed Mary did had sexual relations with her husband after Jesus was born.

“…] To this effect they testify, saying, that before Joseph had come together with Mary, while she therefore remained in virginity, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost.” (Against Heresies; 3:4)
This is simply a quote from Matthew 1:18 with Irenaeus adding the explanatory note, “while she therefore remained in virginity.”

Your brother in the LORD,
Pete
 
When I asked you about Luke 1:34, I was asking, “Doesn’t her reaction necessarily imply that Mary intended to remain a virgin? Here are some thoughts that helped me.

The crucial point about this verse being that the conception is in the future. The angel says that she “will conceive” (Luke 1:31), and Mary wonders how this “will” happen (Luke 1:34). That she is currently a virgin would not have bearing on a future conception unless she intended to remain a virgin even while married to Joseph to whom she was already “betrothed” (Luke 1:27).

Think about how important her virginity is to her as well. This may sound strange at first, but consider what the angel had just told her. Her Son is going to reign as King forever, being Son of the Most High God! His name is going to be Jesus: the LORD saves! She is being told all of this by one of the archangels who stands “in the presence of God” (Luke 1:19) and whose words are as the very words of God (cf. Luke 1:45). And after hearing all of this from this fearsome heavenly creature, the focus of her concern is on maintaining her virginity as the handmaid of the LORD! This is an amazing response and one that the angel respects. It stands in stark contrast with the incredulous response from Zechariah given earlier in the chapter (cf. Luke 1:18-20).

To my mind, Mary’s question (and the ensuing dialogue) lacks historical plausibility unless you presuppose a vow of virginity. Imagine that you are building a rocket ship. It is very near completion, and just then an angel appears to you. He tells you that you will go to the moon, that you’re going to build a castle and alien armies are going to join you in a crusade against your enemies. You will overcome them in victory and reign supreme over your enemies forever. At this point in the dialogue, the absolute last question you would ask is, “How will I get to the moon?”

The only person who is going to ask such a question is a person who is not in the midst of building a rocket. It is just the same in Mary’s case. She is betrothed to Joseph. The angel says that she will conceive. If she has not resolved to remain a virgin, then she would naturally assume that the conception will take place after having intercourse with her soon-to-be husband. The angel didn’t mention anything miraculous in connection with the conception. For her to ask about the nature of the conception after hearing what the angel said reveals that she has no laid-plans of pursuing natural relations with her future husband.

In the scenario with the rocket ship, the person building the rocket asks how he will get to the moon. If the angel had responded by saying that he will be magically teleported, I hope you see how this conversation would appear entirely staged. A false dialogue fabricated by someone in the know who simply wants to convey some truth by a made-up conversation. To my mind, the same would be true in Mary’s case if she intended to have sex with her future husband and had asked the question she did.

Scripture indicates that Mary and Joseph were married prior to Jesus’ birth. After the first dream of the angel, Joseph “took his wife, but knew her not until she had given birth to a son” (Matthew 1:24-25). Matthew is concerned here to make sure we know that Mary remained a virgin all the way up to the birth of Jesus so that we see in her the fulfillment of the prophecy of Isaiah 11:14, that a virgin will not only conceive, but also bear a son. Now, Joseph’s taking her to be his wife happened after “she was found to be with child” (Matthew 1:18). It is not my impression that Mary withheld knowledge of her pregnancy from Joseph, and so I think we’re talking about a 9 month period here. But even if we go with something less, say 6 months, Scripture is giving us explicit confirmation that they lived as husband and wife for a considerable length of time without having intercourse. If this was all we knew, we should be inclined to think that they maintained this virginal state even after Jesus was born. The other option is to think that Mary and Joseph are knowingly doing these things in order to fulfill prophecy. So that once they deemed that they had fulfilled Isaiah 11:14, they knew they could have sex at that point and did so. But it seems more likely to think that this was all happening to them unwittingly, and certainly at the direction of angelic visitations, while only later was it realized – after Jesus “opened their minds to understand the Scriptures” (Luke 24:45; cf. John 2:22 & John 12:16) – that God had orchestrated the fulfillment of all of these prophecies through the histories of their lives. Do you see how we are led by this explicit period of celibate marriage, and by Luke 1:34, to embrace the fact that the celibacy continued?

Joseph and Mary went to Bethlehem when Mary was very pregnant. We know this because there wasn’t any room for them at the inn (cf. Luke 2:7), indicating that they had just arrived. While they are on their way to Bethlehem, Luke refers to Mary as Joseph’s “betrothed” (Luke 2:5), and he never moves beyond this to say anything more of their relationship. And yet, we know from Matthew’s account that they were already married at this point because Joseph took Mary to be his wife just after he found out that she was pregnant (cf. Matthew 1:18-20, 24). And so the question is, Why does Scripture refer to Mary as being his betrothed, rather than as being his wife, when they were clearly already married? I am going to answer this by saying that it is because their “marriage” was a special kind of marriage, and one that didn’t involve all of the regular marital activities but had a higher calling. And so although Joseph was certainly “the husband of Mary” (Matthew 1:16), we are led by Scripture to think that Mary was also, in a sense, always Joseph’s “betrothed.”

In Christ,
Pete
 
Pete,

I will comment briefly on the ECFs, and then I will take aim at your exegesis on Luke 1:34 and see if I can’t shoot a few holes in it. 😉
Doesn’t what Origen says in this commentary on John make you think that it would be a person of unsound mind who thinks that she had other children?
No, if anything you are helping to make my point; Origen undoubtedly implies that the belief of her continued virginity is deduced from written Scripture. If you look at my post again you will see what my objection is:
He does not say, “as tradition teaches,” or “as handed down from the apostles,” he says, those who extol her. And in his commentary on Matthew he shows where that idea comes from. In the many times Origen speaks of Mary in his commentaries, he never once refers to those on either side of the issue as heretics. (Me)
Origen’s comment, “For if Mary, as those declare who with sound mind extol her…” does no imply that those who do not extol her are not of sound mind, and are therefore, heretics. With all due respect, your conclusion reaches well beyond the context of Origen’s commentary. If by sound mind he means those who have interpreted Scripture to reflect that belief (typical of Origen), he has certainly excluded a very large number of Christians.

What I am trying to show from this excerpt and the one from his commentary on Matthew is that Origen clearly demonstrates that the doctrine did not come from apostolic tradition.

–

Concerning Luke 1:34, you asked the question, “Doesn’t her reaction necessarily imply that Mary intended to remain a virgin?”

Now just to make sure I understand you correctly, your answer to that question is yes; based on the fact she was betrothed yet answered the question by saying, “How can this be, since I am a virgin?” You seem to be concluding logically that since she would be married anyway she should not have wondered how it could happen. Technically you are right, but I don’t think you are giving Mary the credit she deserves. And she certainly is not implying her intension to remain in virginity. Let me explain.

Your conclusion suggests that Mary was oblivious as a Jew. It is as if you have not considered the fact that she was well aware of Isaiah’s prophecy, “Behold*, the virgin shall conceive and bear a Son, and shall call His name Immanuel*.” (Isa. 7:14) Before Mary ever answered, the angel, Gabriel, revealed to her that her future Son is the Messiah – “…the throne of His father David;” “He will reign over the house of David forever.” Surely Mary had no doubt what was happening here, she realized that she is the chosen virgin that Isaiah prophesied would bring forth Messiah. Her answer was both a confirmation of her virginity and a curiosity of the process, “How can this be, since I am a virgin?”

Since Mary was going to be married, why would she ask, “How can this be?” Wouldn’t it have been obvious to her how it could be? And if she had vowed to remain a virgin, as you suggest, wouldn’t she have responded in accordance to that vow? She said, “How can this be, since I am a virgin,” not, “How can this be, since I vowed to remain a virgin”? But on the other hand, if she understood that Isaiah’s prophecy was being fulfilled in her, the response she gave makes perfect sense.

Why do you not fail to see Isaiah’s prophecy, yet fail to see that Mary saw the prophecy too?

In Christ, Brian
 
Since Mary was going to be married, why would she ask, “How can this be?” Wouldn’t it have been obvious to her how it could be? And if she had vowed to remain a virgin, as you suggest, wouldn’t she have responded in accordance to that vow? She said, “How can this be, since I am a virgin,” not, “How can this be, since I vowed to remain a virgin”? But on the other hand, if she understood that Isaiah’s prophecy was being fulfilled in her, the response she gave makes perfect sense.
Would Mary’s response, “How can this be since I am a virgin” make more sense to us if we view the word “virgin” not as a temporary state but as a permanent vocation?

For example, when we say that someone is a priest, this tells us something about that person’s vocation in life. Similarly, when Mary called herself a virgin, she was not merely revealing something about her sexual experience but as a proclamation of her vocation in life.

IOW, Mary was not merely saying, “I’m a virgin like all the other young girls my age who have never had sexual relations with a man.” Instead, she was asking how she would bear a child given her commitment to being a [perpetual] Virgin consecrated to God.
 
Origen’s comment, “For if Mary, as those declare who with sound mind extol her…” does no imply that those who do not extol her are not of sound mind, and are therefore, heretics. With all due respect, your conclusion reaches well beyond the context of Origen’s commentary.
Perhaps. I am certainly allowing what is said in the Lucan homilies to guide my interpretation. But he does seem to have in mind only one mind throughout this part of his commentary on John: the sound mind, the insightful mind, the very mind of Christ.
Origen undoubtedly implies that the belief of her continued virginity is deduced from written Scripture.
Origen clearly demonstrates that the doctrine did not come from apostolic tradition.
Does Origen think that the belief comes from Scripture, i.e., from the apostolic preaching, or not? 🙂

Rather, what his writings seem to demonstrate is
  • the idea that the “brothers” of the Lord are sons of Joseph from a previous marriage is not necessarily of apostolic origin, and
  • the doctrine concerning her lifelong virginity is derived from Scripture and therefore of apostolic origin.
Unless, of course, we eliminate his homilies on Luke. Things get a little more hazy when we do this, except that the first bullet would still stand. But thinking again about his homilies, even when Origen is writing his commentaries, do you think that he never employed scribes? I’m not familiar enough with Origen to know, but I know that Jerome certainly employed them. And if so in Origen’s case, then we may very well think that these as well as his homilies were reviewed by him before their release. I still don’t see much of a difference between them the more I think about it. Do you?
 
Your conclusion suggests that Mary was oblivious as a Jew. It is as if you have not considered the fact that she was well aware of Isaiah’s prophecy, “Behold*, the virgin shall conceive and bear a Son, and shall call His name Immanuel*.” (Isa. 7:14) Before Mary ever answered, the angel, Gabriel, revealed to her that her future Son is the Messiah – “…the throne of His father David;” “He will reign over the house of David forever.” Surely Mary had no doubt what was happening here, she realized that she is the chosen virgin that Isaiah prophesied would bring forth Messiah. Her answer was both a confirmation of her virginity and a curiosity of the process, “How can this be, since I am a virgin?”

Since Mary was going to be married, why would she ask, “How can this be?” Wouldn’t it have been obvious to her how it could be? And if she had vowed to remain a virgin, as you suggest, wouldn’t she have responded in accordance to that vow? She said, “How can this be, since I am a virgin,” not, “How can this be, since I vowed to remain a virgin”? But on the other hand, if she understood that Isaiah’s prophecy was being fulfilled in her, the response she gave makes perfect sense.

Why do you not fail to see Isaiah’s prophecy, yet fail to see that Mary saw the prophecy too?

In Christ, Brian
The reason I do not think that Mary saw the prophecy is because I think that most of the evidence points against it.

First of all, let me apologize for referring to this passage in my previous post as Isaiah 11:14 instead of 7:14. Thanks to “7-Eleven,” I get these numbers mixed up in my memory sometimes. 🙂 This may have caused some confusion for other readers.

Here is why I don’t think Mary saw the prophecy. The New Testament repeatedly makes the point that Jesus’ disciples did not understand things until after His rising. In my previous post I wrote that “it seems more likely to think that this was all happening to them unwittingly, and certainly at the direction of angelic visitations, while only later was it realized – after Jesus ‘opened their minds to understand the Scriptures’ (Luke 24:45; cf. John 2:22 & John 12:16) – that God had orchestrated the fulfillment of all of these prophecies through the histories of their lives.” Please take another look at these verses.

If we look at the prophetic fulfillments in the infancy narratives, we see that each fulfillment takes place at the instigation of an angelic visitation or for other reasons, but not for the purpose of knowingly fulfilling Scripture. Matthew tells us that Christ’s birth in Bethlehem fulfilled the prophecy of Micah. But Luke tells us that Joseph and Mary travelled to Bethlehem, not in order to fulfill prophecy, but on account of the census. Luke tells us that they wrapped Jesus in swaddling cloths and laid Him in a manger because there was no room at the inn. If you consider that the detail of the swaddling cloths is an integral part of the sign (cf. Luke 2:12), and therefore as a subtle reference to the Wisdom of Solomon 7:3-13, we have another prophecy being fulfilled at the instigation of Joseph and Mary’s historical circumstances, and not because they are trying to fulfill Scripture. Matthew tells us that Joseph went to Egypt after the angel told him to go there. The reason supplied by the angel was that Herod was going to attempt to kill Jesus. This is why they fled to Egypt, and yet it resulted in the fulfillment of another prophecy. The prophecy of Jeremiah was fulfilled by Herod. Again, not because Herod was trying to fulfill this prophecy, but because he simply wanted to kill his rival king. The Holy Family returned to Nazareth only after being warned in a dream, and not in order to fulfill the prophecy that He be called a Nazarene.

From these, we turn to the prophecy of Isaiah 7:14 itself. We see Joseph taking Mary to be his wife after the angel appeared to him, and knowing her not. Matthew sees this as a fulfillment of Isaiah, and it certainly is. And that’s why I do not fail to see Isaiah’s prophecy. 🙂 But we see Mary and Joseph doing these things at the direction of the angel, and not at the direction of their interpretation of the Old Testament. We gather this from the fact that the prophecy explicitly says that the Child’s name will be Immanuel. But the angel tells them that His name will be Jesus. They end up naming Him Jesus in accordance with the words of the angel, rather than Immanuel in accordance with the prophecy, and this leads us to think, together with the pattern of all of the other fulfillments, that they only saw themselves as fulfilling Isaiah 7:14 in hindsight.

All of these considerations make me think that they do not realize beforehand that they are fulfilling this specific prophecy. And that Mary’s response to the angel in Luke 1:34 therefore implies her perpetual virginity.

Again, if she already realizes that she is fulfilling Isaiah 7:14 when she asks this of the angel, the way she frames her question would be a very awkward way of speaking. Almost as if she would be saying, How will I be fulfilling Isaiah 7:14 about a virgin conceiving and bearing a son, since I am a virgin?

There are other ways of looking at it, and as we move on to consider more and more Scriptures, we will better see why heresy is first of all a “choice” of the will. I’m not saying that you have to read the Scriptures exactly the way I do. You can certainly believe that Mary knew that she was fulfilling Isaiah 7:14. But we are not free to say that she did not remain a virgin after its fulfillment.

Your brother in Christ,
Pete
 
Peter Holter:
The reason I do not think that Mary saw the prophecy is because I think that most of the evidence points against it.
There is an additional consideration; In the Hebrew Isaiah “Alma” was a young woman (although usually a virgin.) Therefore it wasn’t crystal clear that a Virgin would bear the Messiah to 2nd Temple Jews. In fact, the very reason it was so important for everyone to marry in Judaism, was the very belief that the Messiah was immanent, and would therefore require parents. So even if the glorious Virgin Mary had been aware of the prophecy in Isaiah, it may not have seemed applicable to her; yet another reason she is not trying to "fulfill the prophecy.’’ The contrary is more likely the case. The Blessed Virgin Mary, in her sublime humility, has removed herself (as being unworthy) to bear the Messiah, and that may have been an important basis for her vow of perpetual virginity. Although, in my own opinion, her true reason was so that she would belong to no one other than God. (fulfilling still more prophecies about the secret and walled garden.) Yet her obedience kept her will aligned with God’s will, hence her question “how can this be, as I know not man?” IOW, her very humility in removing herself as a potential mother of the Messiah, made her worthy to be His mother!
 
Pete and AmbroseJS,

This is not one of those obscure prophecies that could only be seen well after the fact, the angel told Mary she would bring forth Messiah. How would she not recognize that as fulfillment of Prophecy? How could she not realize that she is the one that was foretold would bring forth Messiah when the angel told her exactly that? There was nothing obscure about it. Now Mary probably did not know the specific prophecy or even that it was to be a virgin that would bring forth Messiah, but she certainly knew she had been chosen as the one to bring Him fourth.

I am sure you realize that your claim of Mary making a vow of virginity is without merit. There is no evidence that she ever made such a vow. Your conjuncture that her response to the angel is evidence of a vow of virginity is awkward in the context of the discussion between her and the angel. “How can this be, since I am a virgin” in no way implies that she made a vow of virginity.

Not only does your exegesis make the discussion awkward, it becomes even more awkward when you consider the angel’s answer. “The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Highest will overshadow you; therefore, also, that Holy One who is to be born will be called the Son of God.” What does this answer; it answers the question directly. It does not answer to any claim of a vow.

To summarize, you have absolutely no evidence that Mary made any vow of virginity – unless of course you count the spurious Protoevangelium of James. In fact, if you think about it, your entire doctrine is based on a spurious work, and in my opinion, a work of pure fiction.

In Christ, Brian
 
Before Christ, I think that most people are going to see the “sign” of Isaiah 7:14 as being fulfilled in the time of Ahaz’s generation.

“Therefore the LORD Himself will give you a sign. Behold, the virgin shall conceive and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel. He shall eat curds and honey when he knows how to refuse the evil and choose the good. For before the boy knows how to refuse the evil and choose the good, the land whose two kings you dread will be deserted. The LORD will bring upon you and upon your people and upon your father’s house such days as have not come since the day that Ephraim departed from Judah—the king of Assyria” (Isaiah 7:14-17).

“And I went to the prophetess, and she conceived and bore a son. Then the LORD said to me, ‘Call his name Maher-shalal-hash-baz; for before the boy knows how to cry “My father” or “My mother,” the wealth of Damascus and the spoil of Samaria will be carried away before the king of Assyria’” (Isaiah 8:3-4).

“So Ahaz sent messengers to Tiglath-pileser king of Assyria, saying, ‘I am your servant and your son. Come up and rescue me from the hand of the king of Syria and from the hand of the king of Israel, who are attacking me.’ …] And the king of Assyria listened to him. The king of Assyria marched up against Damascus and took it, carrying its people captive to Kir, and he killed Rezin” (2 Kings 16:7, 9). The fall of Samaria occurred about 5 years after Ahaz’s death (cf. 2 Kings 17:6), and during his life we see the strength of Samaria sapped by the defeat of its ally and its “spoil” taken in the capture of surrounding cities and territories (cf. 2 Kings 15:29 and 2 Chronicles 28:8-15), and the threat of the assaulting King Pekah removed by assassination (cf. 2 Kings 15:30).

Why would Mary think that this prophecy was going to be fulfilled in her when it was clearly already fulfilled with the defeats of Syria and Samaria before Maher-shalal-hash-baz came of age? Again, I will assert that seeing its fulfillment only makes sense in hindsight, when the apostolic community became aware of the fact that Jesus fulfilled this prophecy in a way that went beyond what “the heart of man imagined” before His coming (1 Cor. 2:9).

Justin Martyr said to Trypho:

But since you and your teachers venture to affirm that in the prophecy of Isaiah it is not said, ‘Behold, the virgin shall conceive,’ but, ‘Behold, the young woman shall conceive, and bear a son;’ and [since] you explain the prophecy as if [it referred] to Hezekiah, who was your king, I shall endeavour to discuss shortly this point in opposition to you, and to show that reference is made to Him who is acknowledged by us as Christ (, Ch. 43Dialogue with Trypho).

And Trypho responded with this:

The Scripture has not, ‘Behold, the virgin shall conceive, and bear a son,’ but, ‘Behold, the young woman shall conceive, and bear a son,’ and so on, as you quoted. But the whole prophecy refers to Hezekiah, and it is proved that it was fulfilled in him, according to the terms of this prophecy (, Ch. 67Dialogue with Trypho).

And this: “The utterances of God are holy, but your expositions are mere contrivances, as is plain from what has been explained by you” (, Ch. 79Dialogue with Trypho). We learn from this that the Jews (Trypho and his teachers) were not expecting this specific prophecy to be fulfilled again after its immediate fulfillment in the time of Ahaz.

I hope this serves you in seeing why Mary’s question about her virginity points more so to a personal decision she has made to “not know man,” rather than to exposing a curiosity she has about how she as a virgin will be the virgin of Isaiah 7:14.

In Christ,
Pete
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top