Defending Mary's Virginity

  • Thread starter Thread starter philipmarie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m doing research on Catholics view on Mary. Please help me to understand.

In Mathew 13:55
Isn’t this the carpenter’s son? Isn’t his mother’s name Mary, and aren’t his brothers James, Joseph, Simon and Judas?
How does the church interrupt the brother word? Are they not Jesus’s blood brothers?

These idea as stated in Matthew 27:56, Mark 3:31, and other passages.
 
oh never mind. I found another thread which explains the Catholic view point. They see it as Joseph’s children. The claim is Joseph lost his first wife.
 
It offends the Blessed Virgin as it is very offensive and cruel to deny Her sacred Virginity. How on earth can Christ reward those who offend His Holy Mother? He does not reward them, He hurls them into hell if they die denying Her Virginity.
Is it official Catholic teaching that those who deny her perpetual virginity are “hurled in hell?”
The Church never disputed whether Mary is a Virgin or not.
Are you speaking of her “perpetual” virginity? If you are, can you show where this was taught in the early church? Hilary of Poitiers is not exactly an early church reference.
 
Is it official Catholic teaching that those who deny her perpetual virginity are “hurled in hell?”

Are you speaking of her “perpetual” virginity? If you are, can you show where this was taught in the early church? Hilary of Poitiers is not exactly an early church reference.
Why did Jesus give the care of his mother to the apostle John? Why did John (a total stranger) take her into his home to take care of her, if she had other kids?
 
Why did Jesus give the care of his mother to the apostle John? Why did John (a total stranger) take her into his home to take care of her, if she had other kids?
John was a complete stranger to Mary? They never met until Jesus’ crucifixion? Is that what you are saying?

Anyway, your conjecture is weak; what I want to know is, where is your proof that the apostles commanded that we must believe Mary remained a virgin. By what authority do you (philipmarie) say those who refuse to believe that are damned to hell?
 
John was a complete stranger to Mary? They never met until Jesus’ crucifixion? Is that what you are saying?

Anyway, your conjecture is weak; what I want to know is, where is your proof that the apostles commanded that we must believe Mary remained a virgin. By what authority do you (philipmarie) say those who refuse to believe that are damned to hell?
He would have known Mary, no doubt, but not for very long at all. If she supposedly had all these others kids, they sure failed their mother didn’t they. It is not weak. What is (philipmarie) supposed to mean? I am not familiar with that one.

I would hate to know I gave my mother to go live with someone I had only known for a few years when all my brothers were there as well.

Now, you are switching topics. Marys perpetual virginity is what is being discussed not damnation to hell. Stay on track.
 
He would have known Mary, no doubt, but not for very long at all. If she supposedly had all these others kids, they sure failed their mother didn’t they. It is not weak. What is (philipmarie) supposed to mean? I am not familiar with that one.

I would hate to know I gave my mother to go live with someone I had only known for a few years when all my brothers were there as well.

Now, you are switching topics. Marys perpetual virginity is what is being discussed not damnation to hell. Stay on track.
Philipmarie is the OP who made the following statement earlier in the thread.
It offends the Blessed Virgin as it is very offensive and cruel to deny Her sacred Virginity. How on earth can Christ reward those who offend His Holy Mother? He does not reward them, He hurls them into hell if they die denying Her Virginity.
The doctrine originated in the late second century and was never taught by the apostles. So by what authority does the OP make his statement? Is it official Catholic teaching or his own personal opinion?
 
…Are you speaking of her “perpetual” virginity? If you are, can you show where this was taught in the early church? Hilary of Poitiers is not exactly an early church reference.
origen ~248
“The Book [the Protoevangelium] of James [records] that the brethren of Jesus were sons of Joseph by a former wife, whom he married before Mary. Now those who say so wish to preserve the honor of Mary in virginity to the end, so that body of hers which was appointed to minister to the Word . . . might not know intercourse with a man after the Holy Spirit came into her and the power from on high overshadowed her. And I think it in harmony with reason that Jesus was the firstfruit among men of the purity which consists in [perpetual] chastity, and Mary was among women. For it were not pious to ascribe to any other than to her the firstfruit of virginity” (Commentary on Matthew 2:17 [A.D. 248]).

papias - fragments book X (early 100’s) lists bretheren as cousins
extract below

(1) Mary the mother of the Lord; (2) Mary the wife of Cleophas or Alphaeus, who was the mother of James the bishop and apostle, and of Simon and Thaddeus, and of one Joseph; (3) Mary Salome, wife of Zebedee, mother of John the evangelist and James; (4) Mary Magdalene. These four are found in the Gospel. James and Judas and Joseph were sons of an aunt (2) of the Lord’s. James also and John were sons of another aunt (3) of the Lord’s. Mary (2), mother of James the Less and Joseph, wife of Alphaeus was the sister of Mary the mother of the Lord, whom John names of Cleophas, either from her father or from the family of the clan, or for some other reason. Mary Salome (3) is called Salome either from her husband or her village. Some affirm that she is the same as Mary of Cleophas, because she had two husbands.
 
Brian Culliton:
The doctrine originated in the late second century and was never taught by the apostles. So by what authority does the OP make his statement? Is it official Catholic teaching or his own personal opinion?
It is very possible that there was an oral tradition that was not committed to writing (or was lost) regarding the perpetual virginity of the glorious Virgin Mary. It would not have been seen as something to be strongly reinforced. It would have been known, but only to those most deeply knowledgeable about the traditions of the Church. During the time of persecution, very little was committed to writing, and what was, was sometimes “coded.” Therefore Apostolical teachings, in writing, regarding the perpetual virginity of Mary would be rare if non-existent. That does not prejudice the case against her perpetual virginity in any event, as the Church DID eventually get around to proclaiming it explicitly and doctrinally. It also does not mean that it was NOT KNOWN and passed on by the Apostles to those most worthy disciples that would understand and preserve this knowledge. After all, within a few generations we DO start to see references to her perpetual virginity in the few extant writings we have.
 
origen ~248
“The Book [the Protoevangelium] of James [records] that the brethren of Jesus were sons of Joseph by a former wife, whom he married before Mary. Now those who say so wish to preserve the honor of Mary in virginity to the end, so that body of hers which was appointed to minister to the Word . . . might not know intercourse with a man after the Holy Spirit came into her and the power from on high overshadowed her. And I think it in harmony with reason that Jesus was the firstfruit among men of the purity which consists in [perpetual] chastity, and Mary was among women. For it were not pious to ascribe to any other than to her the firstfruit of virginity” (Commentary on Matthew 2:17 [A.D. 248]).

papias - fragments book X (early 100’s) lists bretheren as cousins
extract below

(1) Mary the mother of the Lord; (2) Mary the wife of Cleophas or Alphaeus, who was the mother of James the bishop and apostle, and of Simon and Thaddeus, and of one Joseph; (3) Mary Salome, wife of Zebedee, mother of John the evangelist and James; (4) Mary Magdalene. These four are found in the Gospel. James and Judas and Joseph were sons of an aunt (2) of the Lord’s. James also and John were sons of another aunt (3) of the Lord’s. Mary (2), mother of James the Less and Joseph, wife of Alphaeus was the sister of Mary the mother of the Lord, whom John names of Cleophas, either from her father or from the family of the clan, or for some other reason. Mary Salome (3) is called Salome either from her husband or her village. Some affirm that she is the same as Mary of Cleophas, because she had two husbands.
Your Origen quote demonstrates that the doctrine originated in the second century and how it originated. Based on early church writings, particularly Irenaeus and Tertullian, it is utterly impossible for your Papas quote to be authentic. It is also interesting how contrary those two accounts are to each other.

I would still like for someone to answer my other question though.
 
Your Origen quote demonstrates that the doctrine originated in the second century and how it originated. Based on early church writings, particularly Irenaeus and Tertullian, it is utterly impossible for your Papas quote to be authentic. It is also interesting how contrary those two accounts are to each other.

I would still like for someone to answer my other question though.
Hi Brian! Sorry to bother you in another thread, but I thought I’d answer your other question. This teaching is de fide. Obstinate doubt or obstinate denial of this teaching would constitute heresy.

I think the teaching is most reasonably deduced from Luke 1:34, with other Scriptures offering additional support.

I disagree with your assessment of Origen’s quote. It seems more likely to me that the Protoevangelium of James is not the origination of a teaching, but simply a written witness to a teaching already being believed by Christians.

Could you please explain what you’re saying about the Papias fragment? Thanks!

In Christ,
Pete
 
… Based on early church writings, particularly Irenaeus and Tertullian, it is utterly impossible for your Papas quote to be authentic. It is also interesting how contrary those two accounts are to each other.

…
can you expand on this, what is it that irenaeus & Tertullian said.

i’m aware some inclluding eusebius refute his view on millenialism

thanks
 
Hi Brian! Sorry to bother you in another thread, but I thought I’d answer your other question. This teaching is de fide. Obstinate doubt or obstinate denial of this teaching would constitute heresy.

I think the teaching is most reasonably deduced from Luke 1:34, with other Scriptures offering additional support.

I disagree with your assessment of Origen’s quote. It seems more likely to me that the Protoevangelium of James is not the origination of a teaching, but simply a written witness to a teaching already being believed by Christians.

Could you please explain what you’re saying about the Papias fragment? Thanks!

In Christ,
Pete
Pete,

Good to hear from you again. So the doctrine is de fide? When did God establish this doctrine? I thought the apostles delivered the faith in its entirety. Where was this de fide doctrine hiding in the early church?

Origen was explicit in saying that those who believe Mary remained a virgin did so based on the Protoevangelium of James. I do not see any basis for the claim, which two of you have now made on this thread, that the doctrine was already believed. What is it that makes you think that?

The Irenaeus reference I was thinking of is probably not well suited for responding to the Papias fragment, but Tertullian is. Tertullian obviously believed Mary had children after Jesus; that is quite evident in chapter seven of his work, “On The Flesh of Christ.”

The fragment makes claims I had never heard before, which I found surprising since I have been reading early church writings for some time. So I researched this a little and found this interesting footnote on the CCEL website:
This fragment was found by Grabe in a ms. of the Bodleian Library, with the inscription on the margin, “Papia.” Westcott states that it forms part of a dictionary written by “a mediæval Papias. [He seems to have added the words, “Maria is called Illuminatrix, or Star of the Sea,” etc, a middle-age device.] The dictionary exists in ms. both at Oxford and Cambridge.
After finding this, I wanted to see what the Catholic Encyclopedia said about it but found no mention of fragment 10 in their article on Papias. (I skimmed the article and might have missed some things though.)

You seem to be educated in this stuff Pete, what do you know about the Papias fragment?
 
In the name of the Immaculate Heart,

I am going to make some few other posts. Please wait as I am fighting against my infidelity and laziness.

Blessed be the Holy and Immaculate Conception of the Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
. If somebody comes, and hurts your own Mother feelings, would you not grab him, and throw him off a cliff?
Actually, respectfully, if ANYONE ran around insisting as a dogmatic fact how often my parents have sex (if at all), I would shout to their face that it’s none of their business, and they should respect marital privacy and relationships. And I would tell those who are SO fasinated by the topic to go get a life and embrace some basic, fundamental respect.

I, their own son, don’t know how often they have sex. Or how. Or anything about it. It could be they don’t (after I was born, anyway). Why is THAT my business? Why should I need to know that - as a dogmatic fact? Why would I be obsessed with that tidbit about my parents?

What ever happened to respect? To privacy? To marital intimacy between being two people alone, why must that be made wholly public to all the world?

.
 
Actually, respectfully, if ANYONE ran around insisting as a dogmatic fact how often my parents have sex (if at all), I would shout to their face that it’s none of their business, and they should respect marital privacy and relationships. And I would tell those who are SO fasinated by the topic to go get a life and embrace some basic, fundamental respect.

I, their own son, don’t know how often they have sex. Or how. Or anything about it. It could be they don’t (after I was born, anyway). Why is THAT my business? Why should I need to know that - as a dogmatic fact? Why would I be obsessed with that tidbit about my parents?

What ever happened to respect? To privacy? To marital intimacy between being two people alone, why must that be made wholly public to all the world?

.
Do you have any idea how original sin transmitted? Do you have any idea of what original sin is? What does your Lutheran oral tradition have to say about original sin?
Are the ministers in your Lutheran pulpits infallible when (if) they teach you on this subject. Or are you free to come up with your own ideas on the matter and still be a member in good standing in your congregation?

Who decides in Lutheranism?
 
Do you have any idea how original sin transmitted? Do you have any idea of what original sin is? What does your Lutheran oral tradition have to say about original sin?
Are the ministers in your Lutheran pulpits infallible when (if) they teach you on this subject. Or are you free to come up with your own ideas on the matter and still be a member in good standing in your congregation?

Who decides in Lutheranism?
What does “original sin” have to with this discussion?
 
Of all the Marian Dogma’s the perpetual virginity is, to me the easiest to accept.
Personally I have resolved the issue down by simple common sense.

If one read the Bible, the sequence of events leading up to the Birth of Christ, we see Mary being visited by an Angel and told she will bear the Son of God.
Later we see Joseph, a rightious man, trying to quietly "put her away’, obviously he was not buying the story of how she came to be with child but not wishing to expose her to shame.
Joseph is then visited by and Angel of God and set straight. He is told that Mary is indeed pregnent with God’s own Son and he is to take her into his house.
Now Joseph knows that this woman, Mary is the betrothed of the Most High God.

So now I ask those who question the Perpetual virginity of Mary to answer this.
What would you do in Joseph’s place? Would you choose to have sex with the betrothed of God most High? Would you choose to have sex with the mother of God’s Son?

Just ask them to think about this carefully in the light of WWJD, In this case, "What would Joseph do?

Peace
James
JKRH,

I am not Catholic nor am I planning on becoming Catholic but I agree that of all the various Marian beliefs and dogmas, her perpetual virginity is probably the easiest one to accept.

The question I do have is why did your church make it a dogma (at least I think it’s a dogma of your church)? I can’t think what heresy it could have possibly subverted but I am not a church historian.
 
JKRH,

I am not Catholic nor am I planning on becoming Catholic but I agree that of all the various Marian beliefs and dogmas, her perpetual virginity is probably the easiest one to accept.

The question I do have is why did your church make it a dogma (at least I think it’s a dogma of your church)? I can’t think what heresy it could have possibly subverted but I am not a church historian.
as a realisation/magnification of the divinity of Jesus

mary’s words …’…my sould doth magnify the lord…"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top