P
Pete_Holter
Guest
Hello again, Brian!
Earlier you wrote that you do not deny the virgin birth. In saying this, are you saying that you believe that the birth itself was miraculous and that Mary retained her virginal integrity throughout? If not, here are some thoughts that I’ve found helpful.
Isaiah 7:14 says that “LORD Himself will give you a sign. Behold, the virgin shall conceive and bear a Son.” Christians are used to seeing the virginal conception in this verse. But the text also says that the Virgin will bear a Son. Now if her bearing a Son is part of the “sign,” then we should be led to believe that it too is miraculous, just as the conception is miraculous. And if we look at the verse a little closer, we see that it is pointing towards the fact of the virginal birth. The reason for this is that once a virgin conceives, there is nothing remarkable about her also giving birth. It would no longer be a “sign,” but would follow as a matter of course. But if she remained a virgin even while bearing a Son, only then can we clearly see how this is likewise an integral part of the sign from the LORD Himself! That the added detail about bearing a son is not required information in the giving of the sign can be seen by comparison with Job 3:3: “A man is conceived!” Compare also with Luke 1:36 where we are told that Elizabeth “conceived a son.” So it wasn’t necessary, linguistically speaking, that this added detail be in the prophecy. And the fact that it was included, not being necessary, points to its miraculous import, especially when we hold that the conception portion of the sign was likewise miraculous. Now, if Scripture is desirous to show that Mary remained a virgin even during birth, it follows that the less miraculous condition of permanently refraining from marital relations is easily subsumed in such a notion.
In terms of the Gospels, we typically go to Matthew and Luke to learn about Jesus’ birth. But John also tells us about His birth using these words: “The True Light, which enlightens everyone, was coming into the world” (John 1:9). You may want to limit this to only the conception, but it is also fair to see in this a description of the manner of His birth because Jesus associates entrance into the world with birth in John 16:21. As light passing through a window without breaking it, Jesus, the True Light, was born into the world. This is in keeping with our understanding of the Trinity in that Jesus is described by the Creed as the “only Son of God, eternally begotten of the Father: God from God, Light from Light, True God from True God, begotten not made.” Just as Jesus is eternally begotten of the Father as Light from Light, so, by comparing this Scripturally based faith with other Scriptures such as the just mentioned passages of Isaiah 7:14 and John 1:9, we gain a better understanding of the miraculous nature of Jesus’ birth: “I have come into the world as light” (John 12:46). Lest the citation of this final verse seem too crass and contextually disjointed, note how literally Jesus fulfilled the prophetic dimension of Psalm 77:19 when He walked upon water: “Your way was through the sea, your path through the great waters; yet your footprints were unseen.” Neither were His “footprints” seen in Mary’s giving birth to Him.
We might also, together with Gregory of Nyssa, see a foreshadowing of Mary’s untouched virginity in the preincarnate theophany at the burning bush (cf. John 8:58):
From this we learn also the mystery of the Virgin: The light of divinity which through birth shone from her into human life did not consume the burning bush, even as the flower of her virginity was not withered by giving birth (The Life of Moses, Bk. 2, No. 21).
Do you see how the fiery Christ also came into the world “as light” in this Scripture, and yet did not diminish the physical integrity of the natural implement through which He came?
Here is a thought from Cyril of Alexandria in his commentary on the Gospel of Luke:
“In answer to those who argue that, if He were brought forth in the flesh, the Virgin was corrupted: and if she were not corrupted, that He was brought forth only in appearance, we say; the prophet declares, ‘the Lord, the God of Israel, hath entered in and gone out, and the gate remaineth closed’ (Ezekiel 44:2). If, moreover, the Word was made flesh without sexual intercourse, being conceived altogether without seed, then was He born without injury to her virginity” (cf. Is. 7:14) (Sermonic Commentary on Luke 2:5).
Your brother in the Lord,
Pete
Earlier you wrote that you do not deny the virgin birth. In saying this, are you saying that you believe that the birth itself was miraculous and that Mary retained her virginal integrity throughout? If not, here are some thoughts that I’ve found helpful.
Isaiah 7:14 says that “LORD Himself will give you a sign. Behold, the virgin shall conceive and bear a Son.” Christians are used to seeing the virginal conception in this verse. But the text also says that the Virgin will bear a Son. Now if her bearing a Son is part of the “sign,” then we should be led to believe that it too is miraculous, just as the conception is miraculous. And if we look at the verse a little closer, we see that it is pointing towards the fact of the virginal birth. The reason for this is that once a virgin conceives, there is nothing remarkable about her also giving birth. It would no longer be a “sign,” but would follow as a matter of course. But if she remained a virgin even while bearing a Son, only then can we clearly see how this is likewise an integral part of the sign from the LORD Himself! That the added detail about bearing a son is not required information in the giving of the sign can be seen by comparison with Job 3:3: “A man is conceived!” Compare also with Luke 1:36 where we are told that Elizabeth “conceived a son.” So it wasn’t necessary, linguistically speaking, that this added detail be in the prophecy. And the fact that it was included, not being necessary, points to its miraculous import, especially when we hold that the conception portion of the sign was likewise miraculous. Now, if Scripture is desirous to show that Mary remained a virgin even during birth, it follows that the less miraculous condition of permanently refraining from marital relations is easily subsumed in such a notion.
In terms of the Gospels, we typically go to Matthew and Luke to learn about Jesus’ birth. But John also tells us about His birth using these words: “The True Light, which enlightens everyone, was coming into the world” (John 1:9). You may want to limit this to only the conception, but it is also fair to see in this a description of the manner of His birth because Jesus associates entrance into the world with birth in John 16:21. As light passing through a window without breaking it, Jesus, the True Light, was born into the world. This is in keeping with our understanding of the Trinity in that Jesus is described by the Creed as the “only Son of God, eternally begotten of the Father: God from God, Light from Light, True God from True God, begotten not made.” Just as Jesus is eternally begotten of the Father as Light from Light, so, by comparing this Scripturally based faith with other Scriptures such as the just mentioned passages of Isaiah 7:14 and John 1:9, we gain a better understanding of the miraculous nature of Jesus’ birth: “I have come into the world as light” (John 12:46). Lest the citation of this final verse seem too crass and contextually disjointed, note how literally Jesus fulfilled the prophetic dimension of Psalm 77:19 when He walked upon water: “Your way was through the sea, your path through the great waters; yet your footprints were unseen.” Neither were His “footprints” seen in Mary’s giving birth to Him.
We might also, together with Gregory of Nyssa, see a foreshadowing of Mary’s untouched virginity in the preincarnate theophany at the burning bush (cf. John 8:58):
From this we learn also the mystery of the Virgin: The light of divinity which through birth shone from her into human life did not consume the burning bush, even as the flower of her virginity was not withered by giving birth (The Life of Moses, Bk. 2, No. 21).
Do you see how the fiery Christ also came into the world “as light” in this Scripture, and yet did not diminish the physical integrity of the natural implement through which He came?
Here is a thought from Cyril of Alexandria in his commentary on the Gospel of Luke:
“In answer to those who argue that, if He were brought forth in the flesh, the Virgin was corrupted: and if she were not corrupted, that He was brought forth only in appearance, we say; the prophet declares, ‘the Lord, the God of Israel, hath entered in and gone out, and the gate remaineth closed’ (Ezekiel 44:2). If, moreover, the Word was made flesh without sexual intercourse, being conceived altogether without seed, then was He born without injury to her virginity” (cf. Is. 7:14) (Sermonic Commentary on Luke 2:5).
Your brother in the Lord,
Pete