Defending Mary's Virginity

  • Thread starter Thread starter philipmarie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hello again, Brian!

Earlier you wrote that you do not deny the virgin birth. In saying this, are you saying that you believe that the birth itself was miraculous and that Mary retained her virginal integrity throughout? If not, here are some thoughts that I’ve found helpful.

Isaiah 7:14 says that “LORD Himself will give you a sign. Behold, the virgin shall conceive and bear a Son.” Christians are used to seeing the virginal conception in this verse. But the text also says that the Virgin will bear a Son. Now if her bearing a Son is part of the “sign,” then we should be led to believe that it too is miraculous, just as the conception is miraculous. And if we look at the verse a little closer, we see that it is pointing towards the fact of the virginal birth. The reason for this is that once a virgin conceives, there is nothing remarkable about her also giving birth. It would no longer be a “sign,” but would follow as a matter of course. But if she remained a virgin even while bearing a Son, only then can we clearly see how this is likewise an integral part of the sign from the LORD Himself! That the added detail about bearing a son is not required information in the giving of the sign can be seen by comparison with Job 3:3: “A man is conceived!” Compare also with Luke 1:36 where we are told that Elizabeth “conceived a son.” So it wasn’t necessary, linguistically speaking, that this added detail be in the prophecy. And the fact that it was included, not being necessary, points to its miraculous import, especially when we hold that the conception portion of the sign was likewise miraculous. Now, if Scripture is desirous to show that Mary remained a virgin even during birth, it follows that the less miraculous condition of permanently refraining from marital relations is easily subsumed in such a notion.

In terms of the Gospels, we typically go to Matthew and Luke to learn about Jesus’ birth. But John also tells us about His birth using these words: “The True Light, which enlightens everyone, was coming into the world” (John 1:9). You may want to limit this to only the conception, but it is also fair to see in this a description of the manner of His birth because Jesus associates entrance into the world with birth in John 16:21. As light passing through a window without breaking it, Jesus, the True Light, was born into the world. This is in keeping with our understanding of the Trinity in that Jesus is described by the Creed as the “only Son of God, eternally begotten of the Father: God from God, Light from Light, True God from True God, begotten not made.” Just as Jesus is eternally begotten of the Father as Light from Light, so, by comparing this Scripturally based faith with other Scriptures such as the just mentioned passages of Isaiah 7:14 and John 1:9, we gain a better understanding of the miraculous nature of Jesus’ birth: “I have come into the world as light” (John 12:46). Lest the citation of this final verse seem too crass and contextually disjointed, note how literally Jesus fulfilled the prophetic dimension of Psalm 77:19 when He walked upon water: “Your way was through the sea, your path through the great waters; yet your footprints were unseen.” Neither were His “footprints” seen in Mary’s giving birth to Him. 🙂

We might also, together with Gregory of Nyssa, see a foreshadowing of Mary’s untouched virginity in the preincarnate theophany at the burning bush (cf. John 8:58):

From this we learn also the mystery of the Virgin: The light of divinity which through birth shone from her into human life did not consume the burning bush, even as the flower of her virginity was not withered by giving birth (The Life of Moses, Bk. 2, No. 21).

Do you see how the fiery Christ also came into the world “as light” in this Scripture, and yet did not diminish the physical integrity of the natural implement through which He came?

Here is a thought from Cyril of Alexandria in his commentary on the Gospel of Luke:

“In answer to those who argue that, if He were brought forth in the flesh, the Virgin was corrupted: and if she were not corrupted, that He was brought forth only in appearance, we say; the prophet declares, ‘the Lord, the God of Israel, hath entered in and gone out, and the gate remaineth closed’ (Ezekiel 44:2). If, moreover, the Word was made flesh without sexual intercourse, being conceived altogether without seed, then was He born without injury to her virginity” (cf. Is. 7:14) (Sermonic Commentary on Luke 2:5).

Your brother in the Lord,
Pete
 
posted by Brian culliton…Now here is an excerpt from Irenaeus that strongly suggests he believed Mary did had sexual relations with her husband after Jesus was born.
“For the one and the same Spirit of God, who proclaimed by the prophets what and of what sort the advent of the Lord should be, did by these elders give a just interpretation of what had been truly prophesied; and He did Himself, by the apostles, announce that the fullness of the times of the adoption had arrived, that the kingdom of heaven had drawn near, and that He was dwelling within those that believe in Him who was born Emmanuel of the Virgin. To this effect they testify, saying, that before Joseph had come together with Mary, while she therefore remained in virginity, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost.” (Against Heresies; 3:4)…
Brian,
I disagree with your interpretation of the point that irenaeus is trying to make above.
It is not that had sex after birth of Jesus or is he trying to imply it.
I believe he is trying to make it clear that the Joseph played no part in pregnancy and that Mary was a virgin to fullfill the discussion earlier in the extract/paragraph.

I sturggle to understand why irenaeus would be trying to tell us that they slept together after. The context is to illustrate a virgin giving birth not sexual relaions.
 
Brian,
I disagree with your interpretation of the point that irenaeus is trying to make above.
It is not that had sex after birth of Jesus or is he trying to imply it.
I believe he is trying to make it clear that the Joseph played no part in pregnancy and that Mary was a virgin to fullfill the discussion earlier in the extract/paragraph.

I sturggle to understand why irenaeus would be trying to tell us that they slept together after. The context is to illustrate a virgin giving birth not sexual relaions.
Please cease your struggling, I agree with you 100%. It was not my intent to suggest Irenaeus was saying or teaching anything about Joseph and Mary’s sexual relations after the birth of Jesus. My point was to demonstrate how Iranaeus appears to assume they did. It’s a mater-of-fact statement from Irenaeus that strongly supports the notion that he assumed they had a normal marital relationship. I cannot imagine him wording it like that if he believed Mary remained a virgin all her life.

As Pete pointed out, Irenaeus is quoting from Matthew, which by it’s self is strong evidence, but adds strength to the statement by saying, “While she therefore remained in virginity.”
 
I hope this serves you in seeing why Mary’s question about her virginity points more so to a personal decision she has made to “not know man,” rather than to exposing a curiosity she has about how she as a virgin will be the virgin of Isaiah 7:14.

In Christ,
Pete
In my last post I stated that Mary probably didn’t know the specific prophecy, but she certainly knew Messianic prophecy was being fulfilled. The truth is, neither of us knows what was going on in Mary’s mind. I don’t know if she thought of any particular prophecy and you don’t know that she made a vow to remain a virgin. But I will tell you this; there is no biblical evidence that supports your belief and plenty that supports mine.

BTW, what is the theological significance of the doctrine anyway? What bearing could it possibly have for Christians that makes some want to make believing it mandatory?
 
In my last post I stated that Mary probably didn’t know the specific prophecy, but she certainly knew Messianic prophecy was being fulfilled. The truth is, neither of us knows what was going on in Mary’s mind. I don’t know if she thought of any particular prophecy and you don’t know that she made a vow to remain a virgin. But I will tell you this; there is no biblical evidence that supports your belief and plenty that supports mine.

BTW, what is the theological significance of the doctrine anyway? What bearing could it possibly have for Christians that makes some want to make believing it mandatory?
The importance of Catholic doctrines is that they are considered a part of revelation by Catholics. Catholics believe that the Church is the Divinely inspired oracle of God’s will and word. The Catholic Church derives its doctrinal teaching from Sacred Tradition and Holy Scripture. It expounds (teaches) the Apostolic deposit of Faith in light of Sacred Tradition and Holy Scripture. The doctrines therefore are by extension the teachings of the Holy Spirit. Catholics do not ask “what significance does this doctrine have” but “what are we to believe?” Just as the early Christians asked this of St. Paul and the Apostles, Catholics continue to learn at the feet of their Apostolic successors.
 
In my last post I stated that Mary probably didn’t know the specific prophecy, but she certainly knew Messianic prophecy was being fulfilled. The truth is, neither of us knows what was going on in Mary’s mind. I don’t know if she thought of any particular prophecy and you don’t know that she made a vow to remain a virgin. But I will tell you this; there is no biblical evidence that supports your belief and plenty that supports mine.

Well I do not think that Biblical evidence is necassery. First, I already said how Mary vowed Her Virginity. Second, is your Sola Scriptura is correct, then, why does not Scripture itself say that the only authority you have is the Bible? Why did not Jesus teach that? Why did not Jesus tell His Disciples to write the Bible? The Bible does not even mention which books are supposed to be in the Bible! If Sola Scriptura was true, the Apostles would have written very frequently. And by the way, if it is true that there is Biblical evidence that supports your doctrine, give me some pure Biblical arguments. Christs teachings did not come from the Bible; they came from God and He thaught them with COMMON SENSE.
Brian Culliton;6236284:
BTW, what is the theological significance of the doctrine anyway? What bearing could it possibly have for Christians that makes some want to make believing it mandatory?
If this doctrine(upholding the Virginity of Mary Most Holy) has no theological significance, why are you trying to refute it? Another thing, I am making a new thread, called: Sola Scriptura? not so fast…
 
In my last post I stated that Mary probably didn’t know the specific prophecy, but she certainly knew Messianic prophecy was being fulfilled. The truth is, neither of us knows what was going on in Mary’s mind. I don’t know if she thought of any particular prophecy and you don’t know that she made a vow to remain a virgin. But I will tell you this; there is no biblical evidence that supports your belief and plenty that supports mine.

BTW, what is the theological significance of the doctrine anyway? What bearing could it possibly have for Christians that makes some want to make believing it mandatory?
Greetings in the Lord, my brother!

In agreement with what was presented by Trypho, Rabbi Hillel, who taught “at Jerusalem in the time of King Herod,” is recorded in the Talmud as saying “that Israel has no more to wait for a Messiah, as they have consumed him already at the time of Hezekiah.” The reason he would think this is because of something similar to the case that I presented in my previous post. The problem with his conclusion is that there are other verses written after this point in history that still point to a future Messiah. So although Isaiah 7:14 wouldn’t be taken, prior to Christ, as pointing to a Messiah yet to come, there are other verses that would. The problem that you are going to run into is that this verse from Isaiah is the only Messianic prophecy pertinent to the virginal conception. Please take another look at the historical context of Isaiah 7:14 laid out in my previous post to see that she would not have thought that this was a prophecy still waiting to be fulfilled. What I’m trying to show you is that the Biblical evidence and the interpretation given to it in the time of Jesus actually run against your use of Isaiah 7:14 in trying to understand Mary’s question to the angel.

So if the virginal conception of the Messiah as based on Isaiah 7:14 is not what Mary has in mind in Luke 1:34, the most plausible solution is the one taught by the Church. She’s decided to remain a virgin.

According to Gregory of Nyssa, Momma Mary and the beloved John appeared to Gregory Thaumaturgus in a vision. The purpose of the vision was to “reveal to him the truth of pious faith,” and from the words of the vision Gregory “obtained an exact understanding of the doctrine of the faith.” And we have this Gregory the Wonderworker writing things like this in the mid-200s:

The Virgin spake in turn unto the angel: “My mind swims in thy words as in a sea. How shall this be unto me? for I desire not to know an earthly man, because I have devoted myself to the heavenly Bridegroom. I desire to remain a virgin. I wish not to betray the honour of my virginity” (Concerning the Holy Mother of God, Ever-Virgin).

Some dispute the authenticity of this work, but the present translator does not, and he doesn’t know why there are others who do: “Why [they do so] I cannot understand.” Now if you ask me, the only thing that Thaumaturgus has done here is to reveal the latent meaning of Luke 1:34. May you be blessed to come to a similar conclusion!

I’ll get into the significance of Mary’s virginity later. It may be a while before I can make it back on here. Until then, may the LORD be with you!

By the grace and love towards man of our Lord Jesus Christ,
Pete
 
Well I do not think that Biblical evidence is necassery. First, I already said how Mary vowed Her Virginity.
Now that is quite a statement; why believe the Bible when you have a spurious church-rejected document that tells you exactly what you want to hear. Would you mind showing me where I can find the specific Catholic teaching that states Mary took a vow of virginity? Thanks!
Second, is your Sola Scriptura is correct, then, why does not Scripture itself say that the only authority you have is the Bible? Why did not Jesus teach that? Why did not Jesus tell His Disciples to write the Bible? The Bible does not even mention which books are supposed to be in the Bible! If Sola Scriptura was true, the Apostles would have written very frequently. And by the way, if it is true that there is Biblical evidence that supports your doctrine, give me some pure Biblical arguments. Christs teachings did not come from the Bible; they came from God and He thaught them with COMMON SENSE…Another thing, I am making a new thread, called: Sola Scriptura? not so fast…
That sounds like loads of fun, seeing how you already defined what I believe without so much as even one exchange with me on those topics.
If this doctrine (upholding the Virginity of Mary Most Holy) has no theological significance, why are you trying to refute it?
Why, because when people like you go around telling people who put their trust in Christ that they will be “hurled into hell” for denying a doctrine you cannot substantiate, I have a problem with it.

So what is the theological significance of the doctrine Phillipmarie?
 
Please cease your struggling, I agree with you 100%. It was not my intent to suggest Irenaeus was saying or teaching anything about Joseph and Mary’s sexual relations after the birth of Jesus. My point was to demonstrate how Iranaeus appears to assume they did. It’s a mater-of-fact statement from Irenaeus that strongly supports the notion that he assumed they had a normal marital relationship. I cannot imagine him wording it like that if he believed Mary remained a virgin all her life.

As Pete pointed out, Irenaeus is quoting from Matthew, which by it’s self is strong evidence, but adds strength to the statement by saying, “While she therefore remained in virginity.”
i dont find in his words an illustrattion that he assumes they did. or do i find it implied

he is reinforcing that she was a virgin, and thats all i see… i believe you are reading into it what you hope for. notice the word “therefore”…
your emphasis is uncessarily on the word ‘remained’…

“… To this effect they testify, saying, that before Joseph had come together with Mary, while she therefore remained in virginity, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost.” (Against Heresies; 3:4)…

tertullian (On Monogamy ch8)
For who was more worthily to perform the initiatory rite on the body of the Lord, than flesh similar in kind to that which conceived and gave birth to that (body)? And indeed it was a virgin, about to marry once for all after her delivery, who gave birth to Christ, in order that each title of sanctity might be fulfilled in Christ’s parentage, by means of a mother who was both virgin, and wife of one husband.
 
It was a custom among the Jews to take their daughter to the Temple and leave them for their education, as recorded by Josephus and Suarez(d. AD. 100), Nicephorus, Cedrenus, Suarez, Saint John Damascene, George of Nodemia and Saint Ambrose… and the book of Macchabees(2 Mach III:18-19).

**Loc. cit.; De Fide orth. 1. 4, c. 15; **

Saint Epiphanius and Saint Germanus attest that She was brought into the Temple at age three, the former who says: *In her third year, She was brought to the Temple.*Tertio in Oblata est in tempio. According to Abbot Rupert, Mary vowed to God her Virginity, a vow which She was the first to make(Lib. iii in Cant. c. 4) Saint Jerome even tries to portray the daily schedule of the Queen of Heaven(De Nat. S. Mariæ), and other authors say that She dedicated Her whole life and self to serve God, among them Bernardine de Busti, Cardinal Hugo and many others.

The significance of the Perpetual Virginity is because of the immense esteem which God shows to it. "And the Virgins will follow the lamb whereever he goes’ in the Apocalypse. Mary wanted to remain a Virgin Perpetually because if She lost Her priceless Virginity, She would not be as dear towards God as She used to be. You Protestants yourself seem to admit that Mary was a Virgin before the birth of Christ. Why not after it? I have already shown you, according to Church teaching that how She remained a Virgin.
 
Continued… God does not like a divided heart(Deut. vi. 5) so She had to give Him Her Virginity to be all His. other wise, if not, She would not be all His.

By the way, this getting hurled into hell thing is more specious than real I think. If you were offended for calling you that, tell me, and not trying to prove something which you cannot prove. Why do you not try studying Church doctrine and try making some convincing arguments against the Church? There are some good works of Catholic apologetics in existence. I do not mean those modern apologetics, but one’s like: The History of heresies by Alphonsus Maria de Ligouri; The Catholic Controversory* by Francis de Sales; The Baltimore Cathechism; The Summa Theologica…

these can all be found on the website: www.todayscatholicworld.com in pdf format. These books are the real thing as the books on this website a very old, dating from the 18th century.*
 
i dont find in his words an illustrattion that he assumes they did. or do i find it implied

he is reinforcing that she was a virgin, and thats all i see… i believe you are reading into it what you hope for. notice the word “therefore”…
your emphasis is uncessarily on the word ‘remained’…

“… To this effect they testify, saying, that before Joseph had come together with Mary, while she therefore remained in virginity, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost.” (Against Heresies; 3:4)…

tertullian (On Monogamy ch8)
For who was more worthily to perform the initiatory rite on the body of the Lord, than flesh similar in kind to that which conceived and gave birth to that (body)? And indeed it was a virgin, about to marry once for all after her delivery, who gave birth to Christ, in order that each title of sanctity might be fulfilled in Christ’s parentage, by means of a mother who was both virgin, and wife of one husband.
Tertullian is not saying that Mary remained a virgin after the birth of Christ in your quote. He is speaking of Mary ante-partum, but referring to her as mother in the context of her relationship to Christ. I don’t think anyone denies that Tertullian believed Mary did not remain a virgin after Christ was born. If you read his work, On the Flesh of Christ, I think you will see that for yourself.

Here too is an excerpt from the Catholic Encyclopedia that might help you to see this.

“Here he [Tertullian] emphasizes the reality of Christ’s Body and His virgin-birth, and teaches a corporal resurrection. But he seems to deny the virginity of Mary, the Mother of Christ, in partum, though he affirms it ante partum.” (From the Catholic Encyclopedia on Tertullian)
 
Tertullian is not saying that Mary remained a virgin after the birth of Christ in your quote. He is speaking of Mary ante-partum, but referring to her as mother in the context of her relationship to Christ. I don’t think anyone denies that Tertullian believed Mary did not remain a virgin after Christ was born. If you read his work, On the Flesh of Christ, I think you will see that for yourself.

Here too is an excerpt from the Catholic Encyclopedia that might help you to see this.

“Here he [Tertullian] emphasizes the reality of Christ’s Body and His virgin-birth, and teaches a corporal resurrection. But he seems to deny the virginity of Mary, the Mother of Christ, in partum, though he affirms it ante partum.” (From the Catholic Encyclopedia on Tertullian)
yes i was expecting your response on this and agree to a certain extent.

from what I have read tertullians comments are a little clouded by his debate about the physical existience and birth of Jesus, and his words seem to deny perpetual virginity in his attempt to argue it.

for instance his words in Against Marcion 4.19 seem focused on refuting that jesus denied he actually had a real mother and relatives. I am not convinced that tertullian is definately saying he had brothers in this doc… though I understand that is the widely accepted interpretation.

It remains for us to examine His meaning when He resorts to non-literal words, saying “Who is my mother or my brethren?” It seems as if His language amounted to a denial of His family and His birth; but it arose actually from the absolute nature of the case, and the conditional sense in which His words were to be explained… He did not so much deny as disavow them. And therefore, when to the previous question, “Who is my mother, and who are my brethren?” He added the answer “None but they who hear my words and do them,” He transferred the names of blood-relationship to others, whom He judged to be more closely related to Him by reason of their faith.”

then in the following words - Tertullian, On Monogamy 8

For who was more worthily to perform the initiatory rite on the body of the Lord, than flesh similar in kind to that which conceived and gave birth to that (body)? And indeed it was a virgin, about to marry once for all after her delivery, who gave birth to Christ, in order that each title of sanctity might be fulfilled in Christ’s parentage, by means of a mother who was both virgin, and wife of one husband.”

i understand that this is generally interpreted to mean that tertullian is telling us that as a wife she lived as a normal wife with sexual relationship… but i dont buy it in this partiuclar verse.

tertullian aside for a moment, what do you say to my comment on what ignatius is saying and how I dont agree with you that he assumes sexual relations… ie:
i dont find in his words an illustrattion that he assumes they did. or do i find it implied
he is reinforcing that she was a virgin, and thats all i see… i believe you are reading into it what you hope for. notice the word “therefore”…
your emphasis is uncessarily on the word ‘remained’…
“… To this effect they testify, saying, that before Joseph had come together with Mary, while she therefore remained in virginity, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost.” (Against Heresies; 3:4)…
thanks
 
…

So what is the theological significance of the doctrine Phillipmarie?
Hey Brian,

I’ll try to give you my 2cents here for the discussion

God Made Mary Pregnant

God is the Father

I see perpetual virginity as a mere (but obvious) result of Mary’s honour/respect/dedication to God the Father and Jesus the Son.

I honestly see the birth of other children to Joseph after God as a dishonourable act towards God . I know most wont agree with this, but being from a fairly conservative/italian background, I see parallels with the inappropriateness of this set up in a normal modern day relationship, let alone a woman that just gave birth to Gods son in a highly religious jewish community.

I see perpetual virginity as a bi-product of Marys commitment to serve as his handmaid *(luke 1:38 and mary said, behold the handmaid of the lord; be it unto me according to thy word…) *

based on the above I see it as highly significant…and a huge but unavoidable respect due God

I also agree with the view that Joseph would not of entertained the idea of sleeping with her and producing children by her after God.

I also agree with the idea that Joseph knew about the inner room of the tabernacle and inability of anyone to enter the presence of God apart from the high priest. and the implications this would have on the mind of a man who knows that his wife carried the ‘son of the most high’. yes Jesus/highpriest was no longer within her womb, but come on seriously this woman held the son of the most high within her and he was now walking around …can you imagine…no way in my mind.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brian Culliton
…

So what is the theological significance of the doctrine Phillipmarie?

Thinking about it all over last day or so.
Belief in perpetual virginity is a not an elevation of Mary
it’s a recognition of the honour due god as the Father.

It’s also a magnification of the divinity of Jesus .

It’s a recognition of mary’s view of herself as the handmaiden of the lord.

What do u think?
 
Proof of Mary’s virginity is as simple as this:

When did she become pregnant with our Lord, before or after she was married? The answer is before. Mary is full of grace and therefore sinless. Thus in order for her to be sinless she must not have committed any sins, which include premarital sex. No pre marital sex means Christ came present in Mary’s womb by the Devine power’s of God.
 
Proof of Mary’s virginity is as simple as this:

When did she become pregnant with our Lord, before or after she was married? The answer is before. Mary is full of grace and therefore sinless. Thus in order for her to be sinless she must not have committed any sins, which include premarital sex. No pre marital sex means Christ came present in Mary’s womb by the Devine power’s of God.
In Second Temple Judaism a betrothal is as binding as Marriage, and does in fact constitute marriage under Mosaic Law. Therefore Mary was not visited by the Angel Gabriel until AFTER she was married. That nullifies that “proof.” 😉
 
Good day, Brian!

Let’s continue to weigh the Biblical evidence in favor of this doctrine. Because the greater the foundation we have in the God-breathed testimony of God’s own Word, the greater cause we will find for rejoicing in this truth! And I think that the theological significance will begin to shine through as we move along. I’ll say, before we start, that you will be able to poke many holes in this presentation. I’ll probably leave your points alone unless I think it’s crucial to address them, or if you or someone else asks me to. I don’t present this as the only way of reading the Scriptures. I don’t even say that it’s the best way. But it’s been edifying for me and I hope that you will also derive some benefit from what I’ve learned.

Joseph was “a just man” (Matthew 1:19) who always “did as the angel of the Lord commanded him” (Matthew 1:24; cf. 2:14-15 & 2:21-23) whenever he appeared to him in a dream. The fact that the angel only ever appeared to Joseph in his dreams indicates the greatness of this man’s faith in that he did not need a waking vision to drive him to faith and obedience. Joseph is of the lineage of King David. He so much identified himself with David that when the time of the census came, Joseph relocated his family – at the very difficult time when Mary was very pregnant – “because he was of the house and lineage of David” (Luke 2:4). What about this David? Although the “man after God’s own heart” fell into sexual immorality in his youth, we see that afterwards he was strengthened to an unbreakable resolve. And even though a very beautiful young woman was brought to him to lie in his arms in order to keep him warm, “he knew her not” (cf. 1 Kings 1:1-4). From what we know of Joseph, he seems to have had the same virtuous strength of this aged king and appears to us as one who can “exercise self-control” (1 Cor. 7:9).

As David “knew her not,” so Matthew tells us that Joseph “knew her not until.” Much has been written about this prepositional phrase of conjunctive force: the heos hou construct translated as “until.” Here is why I do not think that Matthew intends a reversal of marital relations by his use of it in this verse: the reversal would naturally take its rise from the event marking the transition. But in this case, the event is when Mary “had given birth to a Son” (Matthew 1:25). Now if the phrase truly entails a reversal at the event marking the transition, then we would be led by Matthew’s statement to think that they started having marital relations right there in the stable! But all hold that there was certainly a delay after the birth, at least until after the time of the 40-day purification had come (cf. Luke 2:22-24). This would include travelling from Bethlehem to Jerusalem, and from Jerusalem back to Nazareth. Depending on how you reconcile the two infancy accounts, it may also include the flight into Egypt (if this took place after the purification and before the return to Nazareth, this might have been the real turning point in their relations). Since Matthew marks off the different periods with the birth itself, we are led to think that he is concerned primarily with demonstrating that Mary gave birth to Jesus as a Virgin in fulfillment of Isaiah 7:14; and we are also thereby led away from thinking that he is intending to imply a reversal of their pre-birth relations.

If Matthew wanted his use of heos hou to imply such a reversal – as terminating the action of the main clause – he would more naturally have chosen the event that truly marked this reversal. In this case, we might imagine him saying that “Joseph knew her not until she had given birth to her son and they had returned to Nazareth after the purification” (cf. Luke 2:39), taking everything after until as the turning event of the subordinate clause. But since he did not word it in such a way, it seems to me that to see a reversal in the text as it currently stands is to place too great a burden upon the phrase, heos hou.

Joseph, in his own right an aged king as the father of the King, took the young Mary and “knew her not.”

The final thought for this post: the Gospels never say that Mary and Joseph had other children. This might seem silly to point out, but it’s worth giving thought to because the Bible, in most places, identifies people by the names of their parents, calling them “So-and-so,” the son of “So-and-so.” Someone already made this point earlier in this thread, and Jerome actually made the very same point: “But as we do not deny what is written, so we do reject what is not written. We believe that God was born of the Virgin, because we read it. That Mary [had sexual relations] after she brought forth, we do not believe, because we do not read it” (The Perpetual Virginity of Blessed Mary).

Just some things to think about in this and subsequent posts, as points here or there make sense to you. 🙂 “Test everything; hold fast what is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21).

Strength will rise as we wait upon the LORD!
Pete
 
A few other correlations that can be made…
  1. Jesus is described as Mary’s firstborn son (cf. Luke 2:7). Bearing on our interpretation of this verse is our interpretation of another verse that refers to Jesus as the firstborn. In Colossians 1:15, Jesus is described as “the firstborn of all creation.” If we interpret this verse from Colossians to mean that Jesus is the first created thing among other created things, then we should similarly interpret His birth to Mary as the firstborn to mean that she had other children. But if we do not see this implication in Colossians, then we should similarly see no such implication when we read that Mary “gave birth to her firstborn Son” (Luke 2:7). Rather, we should see Him as the only one of His kind, as her only Son. And this leads to the next thought.
  2. Jesus is the only Son of God. We are therefore led by analogy to see Him as the only Son of Mary. This and the previous point rely on the assumption that His birth in time is in many ways analogous to His birth in eternity.
  3. Scripture refers to Joseph as Jesus’ “father” (Luke 2:33). But we all accept that he is only Jesus’ step-father. This should warn us against insisting on familial relations any closer than this when we hear about Jesus’ unqualified “brothers and sisters.” In keeping with the way Joseph is named by Scripture, we should think step relations before anything else, and then move from there to consider other possibilities.
These three points are not being presented as deductive arguments. We do not have to necessarily make these assumptions. But what these types of correlations do is to draw from the inner unity of the Scriptures to form a unity of faith concerning our Savior where before we simply had a collection of disjointed and disparate facts about Him.

Continuing on from the third point above, we may perhaps consider Jesus’ brothers and sisters to be cousins – but not just any cousins: cousins who grew up in the same town, and even in the same house (perhaps only at times). To just say “cousins” is not enough because Scripture uses other terms when discussing more distant blood relations who live in other towns (cf. Luke 1:36). But we may, however, think about cousins of more intimate relation when we hear talk about brothers and sisters. In favor of this view, we see the people wondering in Mark’s Gospel, “Is not this the carpenter, the son of Mary and brother of James and Joses and Judas and Simon? And are not his sisters here with us?” (Mark 6:3) And in 15:40 of his Gospel, we may very well have this same James and Joses being identified as the sons of another Mary, providing us with yet another basis for seeing “brothers” and “sisters” as being used in a broader sense.

A question that arises when we consider Mary’s virginity is what we think of Jesus’ own virginity. Scripture does not say that He remained a virgin, i.e., that He remained unmarried. In fact, Jesus Himself said that whoever leaves his wife for the sake of the kingdom will receive eternal life (cf. Luke 18:29-30). And after His disciples declared that “it is better not to marry” (Matthew 19:10), He said that the person who can accept celibacy should accept it (v. 12). Doesn’t He seem to be speaking from the position of one who has firsthand knowledge of these things, of one who has left his wife for the sake of the kingdom and is now encouraging others to avoid marriage altogether? Away with the thought, and I am speaking like a fool! But the point is that Jesus as Virgin is not stated explicitly by Scripture, and there seems to be at least scant Scriptural support for the opposing view. If you have formed a firm opinion on Jesus’ virginity, just know that there is more said in Scripture about Mary remaining a virgin than about Jesus being a virgin.

When Jesus is 12 years old, Mary and Joseph lose him in the temple. Now, this is an argument from silence, but I think it is very appropriate here… Throughout this episode, there is no mention of other children traveling with them either coming from or going back to Jerusalem, and no mention of other arrangements being made for them. If they had other children, we should expect mention of them here, especially considering that the whole episode is about a misplaced child.

So if we have no children after 12 years, and Joseph is most likely dead before Jesus begins His public ministry, then it seems like this would either be a remarkable case of 12 years of barrenness followed by a decade or so of pronounced fruitfulness (if you take the [at least] 6 people mentioned in Mark 6 as being siblings), or we have exactly what the Church has always believed: Mary remained a virgin. What Luke tells us by Mary’s response to the angel in 1:34 covers the latter explanation. But if the former explanation is to be used, then this would again be a very strange omission. No mention of the barrenness. No mention of the grand fertility. These are themes that are very important in Biblical times and we would expect an elaboration on these points.

Furthermore, if Jesus is 12 years old, and there is no mention of other children at this point, and no mention of Mary being pregnant, then his next oldest sibling would be at least 13 years younger than He. With Jesus beginning His public ministry around the age of 30 (cf. Luke 3:23), this would make His oldest brother at most 17, with the youngest at perhaps 9. But I ask you, does not the Gospel of John in Chapter 7:1-9 present these particular “brothers” of Jesus as being more like His peers? Not as youths as mentioned elsewhere (cf. Mark 14:51; Acts 20:9), but as those who have reached His own mature age? :hmmm:

No other cry have I, than to know You more and lift You high!
Pete
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brian Culliton
…

So what is the theological significance of the doctrine Phillipmarie?

Thinking about it all over last day or so.
Belief in perpetual virginity is a not an elevation of Mary
it’s a recognition of the honour due god as the Father.

It’s also a magnification of the divinity of Jesus .

It’s a recognition of mary’s view of herself as the handmaiden of the lord.

What do u think?
Got your PM. Thanks!

I’ll address your four points.
“Belief in perpetual virginity is a not an elevation of Mary it’s a recognition of the honour due god as the Father.”
I agree with your first clause, but belief in her perpetual virginity was the catalyst for other Marian doctrines that do elevate her. Also, for some, belief that she remained a virgin in connection with her being the mother of our Lord is enough reason to exalt her.

I don’t understand how Mary remaining a virgin honors God. Are you implying that if Mary had other children after Jesus it would be dishonorable to God? If so, why?
“It’s also a magnification of the divinity of Jesus.”
Certainly that can be said of the virgin birth, but after? Let’s remember, Jesus received His humanity from Mary, not His divinity.
“It’s a recognition of mary’s view of herself as the handmaiden of the lord.”
You can imagine that if you want to, but nobody can truly answer to how Mary viewed herself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top