G
gilliam
Guest
ARE THE MEDIA running from the Rush story?
Is the Pope German?ARE THE MEDIA running from the Rush story?
The article to which you link is confusing two things: honest reporting concerning “phony soldiers” and the exploitation of the story in order to smear soldiers who criticize the war. Limbaugh used the phrase “phony soldiers” before ever mentioning Macbeth, and in response to the caller’s contrast between “real soldiers” and the soldiers who talk to the media criticizing the war. Limbaugh presented MacBeth as an example corroborating a generalization. That is clear from the transcript Limbaugh himself posted.ARE THE MEDIA running from the Rush story?
Rush Limbaugh criticizing “phony soldiers” is a story in and of itself.
As the transcript of the original call clearly indicates, the “phony soldiers” comment is aimed at any soldier who comes back from Iraq and is critical of the mission. They ipso facto get lumped in with the proverbial “left”.
He should own up to what he said and not resort to the typical exuse that all those who get caught red-handed use
:crying: :crying: *They’re taking what I said out of context :crying: :crying: *
I have complete confidence that Rush is more than a match for Dingy Harry.“Thousands of active troops and veterans were subjected to Mr. Limbaugh’s unpatriotic and indefensible comments on your broadcast,” Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) said in his letter to Clear Channel Chief Executive Mark Mays.
Thank you. His use of the plural is telling.Actually, in the transcript that Limbaugh posted he clearly did extrapolate to a generalization about soldiers who criticize the war. Or more precisely, the caller made broad generalizations and Limbaugh clearly agreed. The caller said that “they” (the antiwar media) “never talk to real soldiers”; Limbaugh responded by referring to soldiers who talk to the media as “phony soldiers.” Plural, not singular. The caller then said that real soldiers were proud to serve, and Limbaugh again agreed: “They joined to be in Iraq.” Only then did he go on to mention Jesse MacBeth, not as an isolated instance but as an example of “who the left props up as heroes.”
Limbaugh is patently misrepresenting himself (!) in now claiming that he was just talking about one person. He used the plural, and he agreed with the caller’s generalizations. The accusation against him is correct, and he should be thoroughly ashamed of himself. (Fat chance!)
Edwin
hmmm…seems to be two interpretations of what Limbaugh has said. Some people see it that he obviously meant phony soldiers as in fakes, and some people see it that he obviously meant phony soldiers as in those who don’t support the war.Actually, in the transcript that Limbaugh posted he clearly did extrapolate to a generalization about soldiers who criticize the war. Or more precisely, the caller made broad generalizations and Limbaugh clearly agreed. The caller said that “they” (the antiwar media) “never talk to real soldiers”; Limbaugh responded by referring to soldiers who talk to the media as “phony soldiers.” Plural, not singular. The caller then said that real soldiers were proud to serve, and Limbaugh again agreed: “They joined to be in Iraq.” Only then did he go on to mention Jesse MacBeth, not as an isolated instance but as an example of “who the left props up as heroes.”
Limbaugh is patently misrepresenting himself (!) in now claiming that he was just talking about one person. He used the plural, and he agreed with the caller’s generalizations. The accusation against him is correct, and he should be thoroughly ashamed of himself. (Fat chance!)
Edwin
You are correct that Mr. Limbaugh extrapolated the “phony soldiers” comment to apply to others beyond Macbeth. However, it is clear in the transcript, which you apparently skimmed and did not read from the beginning, that he was applying the term to anyone who pretended to be a soldier or lied about serving in Iraq, receiving medals, etc.Actually, in the transcript that Limbaugh posted he clearly did extrapolate to a generalization about soldiers who criticize the war. Or more precisely, the caller made broad generalizations and Limbaugh clearly agreed. The caller said that “they” (the antiwar media) “never talk to real soldiers”; Limbaugh responded by referring to soldiers who talk to the media as “phony soldiers.” Plural, not singular. The caller then said that real soldiers were proud to serve, and Limbaugh again agreed: “They joined to be in Iraq.” Only then did he go on to mention Jesse MacBeth, not as an isolated instance but as an example of “who the left props up as heroes.”
Limbaugh is patently misrepresenting himself (!) in now claiming that he was just talking about one person. He used the plural, and he agreed with the caller’s generalizations. The accusation against him is correct, and he should be thoroughly ashamed of himself. (Fat chance!)
Edwin
There is simply no way you could have listened to what he said and came to that conclusion. In addition for him to say that would have contradicted everything he has said about those seving in the war since the day it started. He has talked many times about “phony soldiers” and never implied or stated that that soldiers who opposed the war were phony. You may not like Limbaugh but please dont join in the unsubstantiated slime. You usually dont participate in such.The article to which you link is confusing two things: honest reporting concerning “phony soldiers” and the exploitation of the story in order to smear soldiers who criticize the war. Limbaugh used the phrase “phony soldiers” before ever mentioning Macbeth, and in response to the caller’s contrast between “real soldiers” and the soldiers who talk to the media criticizing the war. Limbaugh presented MacBeth as an example corroborating a generalization. That is clear from the transcript Limbaugh himself posted.
Edwin
You are right, his use of the plural is telling. He is referring to all the other people who lie about their military service. He is bemoaning the fact that so many do what Macbeth does and the leftists and Bush-haters never seem to check them out.Thank you. His use of the plural is telling.
If he had said Jesse Macbeth is a phony soldier, there would be no problem.
The letter from Senate Democrats condemning Rush Limbaugh is on its way to the CEO of Clear Channel Communications, who is being asked to repudiate the conservative talk show host’s “phony soldiers” comment.
Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) singled out Limbaugh on the Senate floor Monday, and proposed the letter criticizing his remarks about members of the military who oppose the war as an “irresponsible, hateful and unpatriotic attack.”
“I am confident we will see Republicans join with us in overwhelming numbers,” Reid said.
Ah, not really.
No Republican signed the letter.
No, he is referring to soldiers who come back opposed to the mission. Read the actual transcript, not Rush’s edited version.You are right, his use of the plural is telling. He is referring to all the other people who lie about their military service.
So many? Funny, but Jesse Macbeth (whoever he is) is the only one I have heard of. Please point out a few of the “so many” who do what Macbeth did.He is bemoaning the fact that so many do what Macbeth does and the leftists and Bush-haters never seem to check them out.
I heard the show-his version was not edited in the least.No, he is referring to soldiers who come back opposed to the mission. Read the actual transcript, not Rush’s edited version.
Heres a website dedicated to exposing phony soldiers.So many? Funny, but Jesse Macbeth (whoever he is) is the only one I have heard of. Please point out a few of the “so many” who do what Macbeth did.
Exactly.No, he is referring to soldiers who come back opposed to the mission. Read the actual transcript, not Rush’s edited version.
59 Senators saw it for the faleshood it was. There are very few people willing to try and continue this charade anymore. Like the Moveon.org ads this blew up in the democats face big time.This thing is going nowhere fast:
It is interesting that Limbaughs detracotrs have been reduced to claiming Limbaugh doctored the transcript(even though the show was heard by millions) and ad hominen attacks on him.Exactly.
By the way - where’s the thread on Rush’s “service” to our country? Can you say, “a boil on the butt?”![]()
I did. That is why I said what I did. The term “phony soldier” is an old term.No, he is referring to soldiers who come back opposed to the mission. Read the actual transcript, not Rush’s edited version.
Boy, you do not really get out much do you. Here is a thread regarding someone else who lied about their service. forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=174672So many? Funny, but Jesse Macbeth (whoever he is) is the only one I have heard of. Please point out a few of the “so many” who do what Macbeth did.
It seems to me like the Democrats are only doing this because they think they owe it to Moveon.org. When you think about it, and the fact that this country is in the control, primarily of congress, that means a lot of people who create the laws in this country are in debt to Moveon.org. It is kinda scary. We shouldn’t have any organization in that much power. Reminds me of the movie Mr. Smith Goes to Washington.59 Senators saw it for the faleshood it was. There are very few people willing to try and continue this charade anymore. Like the Moveon.org ads this blew up in the democats face big time.
Bauchamp is not a phony soldier though and he is not lying about the fact he is serving. He is still fighting in Iraq while we are comfortably typing into our computers in the safety of our offices. I am not sure Rush was thinking about him but he may have been when he was speaking. But Rush runs off at the mouth, he gets paid to do that. He is a talk show host, an entertainer. Reid and other Senators are suppose to be lawmakers not entertainers. It is sad to see them do this sort of thing.Boy, you do not really get out much do you. Here is a thread regarding someone else who lied about their service. forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=174672
Every war generates people who lie about their military service. Only know these people become internet celebrities.