Democrats Have a Religion Problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, I think the Podesta emails are quite in line with Hillary’s thinking. The Church, they believe, is “medieval”, “backward” and “authoritarian”, and said so in the Podesta emails. They were quite open about trying to change the Church in America by supporting dissident “Catholic” organizations. If that isn’t encouraging “changing one’s religion” I don’t know what is. And of course, Kaine thinks the Church will surely affirm homosexual marriage someday (when it’s less “backward”, of course) or at least he says he believes that.

Sometimes the obvious can be reasonably believed.

Certainly the Church decries WMD and rightly so. But never has it declared that the U.S. should unilaterally disarm when others do not. So supporting a nuclear defense system is in no way anti-Catholic.

That’s very different from advocating the unilateral use of them. Maybe someone on CAF has promoted that, but I have never seen it.

And of course there’s the suit against the Little Sisters of the Poor, disqualifying Catholic charities from government aid programs because they won’t refer for abortions. It goes on and on.

Glad a person who is at least neutral on the Catholic Church was elected.
The Church takes a stronger stance than that. Firm and unequivocal condemnation is not a soft stance. It is the same as saying intrinsically disordered since they can never be used in a moral way under any circumstances. You are implying they can be used in a peaceful way as a deterrent. The Church disagrees. She even goes further than that and condemns the arms race itself as an impediment to peace. So why isn’t a pro-nuclear weapon Catholic not an anti-Catholic by your own reasoning?
2314 “Every act of war directed to the indiscriminate destruction of whole cities or vast areas with their inhabitants is a crime against God and man, which merits firm and unequivocal condemnation.”[109] A danger of modern warfare is that it provides the opportunity to those who possess modern scientific weapons especially atomic, biological, or chemical weapons - to commit such crimes.
2315 The accumulation of arms strikes many as a paradoxically suitable way of deterring potential adversaries from war. They see it as the most effective means of ensuring peace among nations. This method of deterrence gives rise to strong moral reservations. The arms race does not ensure peace. Far from eliminating the causes of war, it risks aggravating them. Spending enormous sums to produce ever new types of weapons impedes efforts to aid needy populations;[110] it thwarts the development of peoples. Over-armament multiplies reasons for conflict and increases the danger of escalation.
2316 The production and the sale of arms affect the common good of nations and of the international community. Hence public authorities have the right and duty to regulate them. The short-term pursuit of private or collective interests cannot legitimate undertakings that promote violence and conflict among nations and compromise the international juridical order.
I agree with you on the Little Sisters of the Poor. I don’t disagree that the Democrats have a religion problem. They clearly do but I’m not going to demonize people for their ignorance. Hanlon’s Razor comes in handy: “Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity,”. I don’ t like using “stupidity”, ignorance is a much nicer way to put it.
 
Kaine was picked because he is passive.

When Bill was president there was friction between Al Gore and Hillary. Gore had aspirations for the presidency and injected his opinions on White House policy making to much. Al Gore felt since he was number two and destined to be crowned president eventually his opinions meant something. Bill and Hillary saw themselves as a team and they were inseparable. Al Gore was a nuisance to them.

They did not want the same problem with round two of team Clinton presidency.
 
Very, very true.

Look at Hillary’s speech the morning after the election. She stated “the country is more divided than we thought”. That’s code for “Wow, we misjudged how many Christians there are in the country still.”

Toward the end of the election cycle I think some were picking up on it. I started seeing more references to Hillary being a Methodist.

I had to just about change my underwear when Tim Kaine compared Hillary to the owner of a vineyard from the paralbles.
For anyone else who missed this Kaine moment

There’s a beautiful, kind of comical parable in the New Testament about a vineyard owner who hires people to work and says ‘I’m gonna pay you this for a full day.’ Then he hires people at noon, ‘I’m gonna pay you the same thing for half a day.’ Then he hires people for one hour’s worth of work, ‘I’m gonna pay you the same.’ And those who started earlier in the day say, ‘Hold on, we don’t like this. You’re treating everyone who came late just as well as you’re treating us.’

I’m going to tell you something, here’s what I’ve come to know so well about Hillary: the team that she has assembled over the years, of people who are so deeply loyal to her, because she’s so deeply loyal to them, is inspiring. But I’ve seen that same degree of loyalty, and compassion, and sensitivity, extended to the most recent folks who have joined the team, the folks who came to the vineyard just one hour ago. The loyalty and compassion of Hillary and Bill, to people…that is just something so remarkable.

Kaine missed the parable was about mercy, not loyalty, and he thinks Hillary is god.

I don’t think Hillary has any mercy for people who’ve crossed her.
 
The Church takes a stronger stance than that. Firm and unequivocal condemnation is not a soft stance. It is the same as saying intrinsically disordered since they can never be used in a moral way under any circumstances. You are implying they can be used in a peaceful way as a deterrent. The Church disagrees. She even goes further than that and condemns the arms race itself as an impediment to peace. So why isn’t a pro-nuclear weapon Catholic not an anti-Catholic by your own reasoning?
The Church calls on countries to disarm. However, in perusing the language from the USCCB it is clear that there are no illusions of an expectation that there can be immediate disarmament. Further, the USCCB statement, anyway, mentions that “In its nuclear policy the U.S. should commit to never use nuclear weapons first and to reject use of nuclear weapons to deter non-nuclear threats.”

Never first strike, never to deter NON-nuclear threats. There’s silence on the already existing weapons. I wouldn’t presume to fill in gaps or interpret silence but given the reality of the situation I’m quite certain that the bishops don’t advocate the US just destroying all of its nuclear weapons with countries like North Korea, Russia, etc. possessing the ability to create and, in some cases, deploy such weapons.
I agree with you on the Little Sisters of the Poor. I don’t disagree that the Democrats have a religion problem. They clearly do but I’m not going to demonize people for their ignorance. Hanlon’s Razor comes in handy: “Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity,”. I don’ t like using “stupidity”, ignorance is a much nicer way to put it.
Tim Kaine is not ignorant. He’s taken the privately oppose but publicly support position on abortion (100% rating from NARAL) and made the comments about SS marriage. VP Biden conducted the SS civil ceremony. Podesta openly insults Catholics and wants to change Church teaching through subversion (kind of a funny thing about claiming to know and teach the truth of Christ: you lose credibility when you start changing the truth to comport with the thoughts of the people in the pews).

No, it’s not stupidity or ignorance: Kaine, Biden, Podesta, Pelosi, etc. all know Church teaching…and completely disregard it. Unless, of course, they are the only five people in America who don’t know the Church’s stance on SSM and abortion.
 
This article is fantastic. I am certainly glad it was posted.

The more I think about it though it was wrong about one thing. Dems do have a religion. It’s Environmentalism.

That staffer quoted in the article who didn’t understand the biblical reference? I would bet money he/she knows all about carbon footprint, global warming, Gaia, Mother Earth, etc, etc…
 
The Church takes a stronger stance than that. Firm and unequivocal condemnation is not a soft stance. It is the same as saying intrinsically disordered since they can never be used in a moral way under any circumstances. You are implying they can be used in a peaceful way as a deterrent. The Church disagrees. She even goes further than that and condemns the arms race itself as an impediment to peace. So why isn’t a pro-nuclear weapon Catholic not an anti-Catholic by your own reasoning?

I agree with you on the Little Sisters of the Poor. I don’t disagree that the Democrats have a religion problem. They clearly do but I’m not going to demonize people for their ignorance. Hanlon’s Razor comes in handy: “Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity,”. I don’ t like using “stupidity”, ignorance is a much nicer way to put it.
Show me where the Church commands unilateral disarmament in the face of a nuclear armed adversary, and I will then be impressed with your assertion. Otherwise, I won’t be.

When it comes to worldwide arms buildup generally, the Church does condemn it, and not only in nuclear armaments, but in all armaments. But it does not condemn arming for defense, per se.

I do not attribute the persecution of the Little Sisters to ignorance. The government has long, long since been disabused of any notion that the Sisters do not have a conscientious objection to providing birth control and abortifacients for their workers and themselves. No administration could possibly be that ignorant.

And when they call the Church “medieval” and “backward” and deliberately support efforts to undermine the teachings of the Church among Catholics, that’s not ignorance; that’s malice.

Again, some things are so obvious that they really can’t be rationalized away. The Dem party is simply hostile to Catholicism (and not just Catholicism). Maybe someday it will change, and it should. But it hasn’t done so yet in any demonstrable way.
 
The Democrat’s illiteracy and hostility toward faith has been around for decades, but they have kept up an illusion of interest in religion until this election cycle. Just like the interview says, they no longer thought they had to play to religious people. They were wrong. I’m glad to see they have dropped the charade. Now people can see a little clearer what the Democratic Party represents.

It’s leadership has really become a reflection of Marxist ideology. A wolf in sheep clothing; just like a true fabian socialist.

The Democratic Party has one of two ways forward: they can double down on their true ideology, or they can go back to feigning interest in God.
So far they’ve been doubling down. At this point they can afford to since there is no election just around the corner. But this level of arrogance isn’t so easily shut-off either and with discussions of Keith Ellison and Kamala Harris being seen as party leaders, it’s obvious where they are going with this.
 
Kaine was picked because he is passive.
Before Tim Kaine was the VP candidate, he was served as chairman for the DNC. He stepped down and Debbie Wasserman Schulz took over. Schulz ran HRC’s 2008 campaign.

So the DNC chairman is replaced by someone from Clinton’s team, and she is caught rigging the primary in favor of her former boss.

This is something you would expect to see on House of Cards.
 
The left in the US always hoped for America to look like Europe, completely irreligious and the Church uninfluential. But there are some demographers who say it’s hard to predict. Unlike Canada or Australia, which are headed to where Europe is, America is hard to predict because of how resilient traditional Christianity has been. Weakened but not eroded to the extent like that of Canada or Australia.
Despite the religious unaffiliated growing as a proportion, the Christian and particularly Evangelical population continues to grow. There is a very slim chance the growth of the unaffiliated may stall or even reverse if you want to be very optimistic. Though Evangelicals (don’t remember if Catholics were also included) remain stable as a proportion of the US population, they are actually growing in absolute terms because they tend to have children earlier and more of them compared to the unaffiliated who the Democrats are becoming more reliant on. The only thing the Democrats have is immigration since those leaving organized religion may still hold traditional views. And even then there’s no guarantee immigrants and their descendants will remain loyal to the Democrats.
 
The left in the US always hoped for America to look like Europe, completely irreligious and the Church uninfluential. But there are some demographers who say it’s hard to predict. Unlike Canada or Australia, which are headed to where Europe is, America is hard to predict because of how resilient traditional Christianity has been. Weakened but not eroded to the extent like that of Canada or Australia.
Despite the religious unaffiliated growing as a proportion, the Christian and particularly Evangelical population continues to grow. There is a very slim chance the growth of the unaffiliated may stall or even reverse if you want to be very optimistic. Though Evangelicals (don’t remember if Catholics were also included) remain stable as a proportion of the US population, they are actually growing in absolute terms because they tend to have children earlier and more of them compared to the unaffiliated who the Democrats are becoming more reliant on. The only thing the Democrats have is immigration since those leaving organized religion may still hold traditional views. And even then there’s no guarantee immigrants and their descendants will remain loyal to the Democrats.
I think there’s a lot to explore here.

There are two things that are different about America when it comes to religion.
First, the Evangelicals are pretty steadfast people, though I don’t much like the term “Evangelical” for all of them, because they’re so disparate and were never a uniform group. “Biblical Protestants” is probably a better term, of which some can be classified “Evangelicals” but some would normally be termed “Fundamentalists” or even “Non-denominationals” But regardless of what you call them, they’re pretty seriously religious folks, and on a sort of Bible-literal level. I think a large portion of them are in the south and in the border states. Some of that is a matter of heritage, since so very many are of Scots-Irish and Welsh ancestry; places where religion has always been pretty Fundamentalist.

The other thing different about America is that it cast off its moorings from Europe at about the time the bulk of its population left there, and “froze in place”. So, among some groups, at least, and especially among rural people, Germans here are more like 19th Century Germans than they are like 20th Century Germans. Norwegians more like 19th Century Norwegians, Italians more like 19th Century or early 20th Century Italians and so forth.
Europeans would probably call it “arrested development”, but one could also call it “greater fidelity to objective truth”.

A very large part of America missed out on the relativism so ardently accepted in Europe. For one thing, we didn’t have the same kinds of philosophers, theologians and other influencers of thought as Europe did. If you wanted to know about Existentialism in college, for example, you studied French writers. If you wanted to know about perspectivism or philosophical nihilism, you studied Nietszche and later writers.

But you had to study something that was not mainstream here. It has sometimes been remarked that unlike Europe, America missed a stage and “…went from barbarism to decadence without ever having achieved civilization…”

There is some truth to that, though only at the margins initially, and has been slow to creep into the population at large.

As for Catholicism in America, it missed its chance at the “Catholic Century” that was so widely predicted. It missed the chance by unintentional and sometimes intentional neglect of teaching the young. Catholicism, properly considered, is every bit as “Bible-literal” as is Fundamentalist Protestantism as the latter is in America. Properly understood, it is extremely oriented to objective and unchanging truths.

But truth must be taught, lest people invent their own universes. Serious catechesis of the young has been very slapdash in America since roughly the early 1970s. An entire generation has grown up and gotten old without ever learning much of anything about the truths of Catholicism. Indeed, no few churchmen advocate subjectivism and relativism, though we’re still “behind” Europe in that respect. And so, the younger ones had no teachers worthy of the name. Some opt for relativism, and some opt for protestantism.

And that’s why Catholicism is seriously waning among the young in America. We look upon it with surprise, but it should not surprise us in the least.

One hopes that’s changing, and there are some reasons for optimism. But there will be a lot who will, and do, fall away; de facto if not formally.
 
A conversation with Michael Wear, a former Obama White House staffer, about the party’s illiteracy on and hostility toward faith

theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/12/democrats-have-a-religion-problem/510761/
It’s sad, but seems true.

I think it partly has to do with how unchristian many Christians have become in their stance against social justice & environmental justice issues, ignoring how these are part of a fully pro-life position.

Also the anti-science stance, such as rejection of evolution, as bordering on lying or indoctrination that prevents people from accepting the truth.

These are a turn off to many, who then wrongly blame religion, rather than the people who don’t live up to their religion.

I posted my Little Way of Environmental Healing (based on St. Therese’s Little Way of Spiritual Childhood) on an env blog some 10 years ago, and one of the bloggers said he had hated religion, but when he saw my post, didn’t hate it anymore.

From what I’ve seen those who leave (or hate) religion mainly do so because of scruples – they see the religion (actually the religious) being bad and wrong.

My nephew fell away from the Church many years ago, and in a heated argument with him last year, in which he ranted against religion and the hypocrisy, I jumped in with “I think even God doesn’t like religion,” to which he responded, “Yes, God doesn’t like religion…” 🙂

Now I think he’s coming around and wants to baptize his new baby and have his daughters get 1st Communion…

It behooves us religious folks to strive for less hypocrisy. Then maybe anti-religious Democrats, other who hate religion, and apostates will develop a more favorable view of religion, and maybe even start going to church.
 
The left in the US always hoped for America to look like Europe, completely irreligious and the Church uninfluential. But there are some demographers who say it’s hard to predict. Unlike Canada or Australia, which are headed to where Europe is, America is hard to predict because of how resilient traditional Christianity has been. Weakened but not eroded to the extent like that of Canada or Australia.
Despite the religious unaffiliated growing as a proportion, the Christian and particularly Evangelical population continues to grow. There is a very slim chance the growth of the unaffiliated may stall or even reverse if you want to be very optimistic. Though Evangelicals (don’t remember if Catholics were also included) remain stable as a proportion of the US population, they are actually growing in absolute terms because they tend to have children earlier and more of them compared to the unaffiliated who the Democrats are becoming more reliant on. The only thing the Democrats have is immigration since those leaving organized religion may still hold traditional views. And even then there’s no guarantee immigrants and their descendants will remain loyal to the Democrats.
A very interesting book to read on this subject is Shall the Religious Inherit the Earth?: Demography and Politics in the Twenty-First Century by secularist academic Eric Kaufmann. If the case he presents is correct, by the end of the 21st century the secular, nonreligious population will reverse and severely decline while the most religious will grow considerably throughout the entire world. It is an interesting read, if you haven’t read it, yet.
 
And that’s why Catholicism is seriously waning among the young in America. We look upon it with surprise, but it should not surprise us in the least.

One hopes that’s changing, and there are some reasons for optimism. But there will be a lot who will, and do, fall away; de facto if not formally.
Hopefully lessons have been learnt especially the one that depending on wider society to do your work is a bad idea.
Teaching is important but another challenge for all denominations will be to make faith relevant for the young otherwise it turns into ‘schoolwork’.
It behooves us religious folks to strive for less hypocrisy. Then maybe anti-religious Democrats, other who hate religion, and apostates will develop a more favorable view of religion, and maybe even start going to church.
I do pray for this. There should be no room for us being hated because of hypocrisy. We should be hated for doing what’s right all the time. And it would also would help if some stopped using ‘everyone sins’ as a default in cases of hypocrisy and actually address the problems head on.
A very interesting book to read on this subject is Shall the Religious Inherit the Earth?: Demography and Politics in the Twenty-First Century by secularist academic Eric Kaufmann. If the case he presents is correct, by the end of the 21st century the secular, nonreligious population will reverse and severely decline while the most religious will grow considerably throughout the entire world. It is an interesting read, if you haven’t read it, yet.
Thanks. I haven’t read it before. I skimmed through the preview. Not a fan of his tone at times especially implying Evangelicals of the Rick Warren type are equivalent to Salafists.
 
Thanks. I haven’t read it before. I skimmed through the preview. Not a fan of his tone at times especially implying Evangelicals of the Rick Warren type are equivalent to Salafists.
You’re welcome. I’m not a big fan of his tone, either, but for a committed academic secularist I guess his tone is a lot more moderate than many. If his tone is too off putting for you (and I’d understand if it is) you might check out Rodney Stark’s The Triumph of Faith: Why the World Is More Religious than Ever.
 
…I don’t think Hillary has any mercy for people who’ve crossed her.
I think (not at all sure) that might apply to someone on the other side. Can’t mention any names bec I’ll get reported and suspended, so you’ll just have to guess 🙂
 
You’re welcome. I’m not a big fan of his tone, either, but for a committed academic secularist I guess his tone is a lot more moderate than many. If his tone is too off putting for you (and I’d understand if it is) you might check out Rodney Stark’s The Triumph of Faith: Why the World Is More Religious than Ever.
Pitrim Sorokin, a sociologist, wrote The Crisis of Our Age (1941) based on the theory that societies swing over hundreds of years between the “ideational” (reality is spiritual) & the “sensate” (reality is material – sounds like America up thru the 50s) with the “idealistic” (a synthesis of the two) between. In this scheme both capitalism & communism would be “sensate,” while the “dark ages” are “ideational” (and only “dark” from a sensate point of view), with the Renaissance being “idealistic.”

If that is correct then we may be moving away from the sensate, heading thru the idealistic, then go into the ideational or spiritual, maybe in a century or two.
 
Pitrim Sorokin, a sociologist, wrote The Crisis of Our Age (1941) based on the theory that societies swing over hundreds of years between the “ideational” (reality is spiritual) & the “sensate” (reality is material – sounds like America up thru the 50s) with the “idealistic” (a synthesis of the two) between. In this scheme both capitalism & communism would be “sensate,” while the “dark ages” are “ideational” (and only “dark” from a sensate point of view), with the Renaissance being “idealistic.”

If that is correct then we may be moving away from the sensate, heading thru the idealistic, then go into the ideational or spiritual, maybe in a century or two.
Interesting. I learned that the philosophical underpinnings of Nominalism are what really helped to lay the groundwork for the bifurcation between the ideational and sensate that we see today. Sounds like an interesting read.

Edit: I’m not sure how the Rennaissance would be idealism though if it’s so often heralded as a break from the Middle-ages. Sacramentalism is incredibly idealistic, a marriage of the physical and spiritual.
 
Interesting. I learned that the philosophical underpinnings of Nominalism are what really helped to lay the groundwork for the bifurcation between the ideational and sensate that we see today. Sounds like an interesting read.

Edit: I’m not sure how the Rennaissance would be idealism though if it’s so often heralded as a break from the Middle-ages. Sacramentalism is incredibly idealistic, a marriage of the physical and spiritual.
I guess nothing could be purely spiritual, since we have material bodies, so maybe the ideational has some of the sensate, with the idealistic being more toward an equal combo of both.
 
I guess nothing could be purely spiritual, since we have material bodies, so maybe the ideational has some of the sensate, with the idealistic being more toward an equal combo of both.
OTOH, it is about the view of the world, and that is like an analytic perspective that pervades or interpenetrates all.

So in an ideational age most people would be mostly focused on viewing the world thru spiritual lenses – everything as a miracle or godly & divine – tho in the “dark ages” I think much was perceive also frm a negative spiritual perspective, as the work of devils, demons, witchcraft.

So in our more sensate age most tend to view things mostly thru material lenses – like what’s materially in it for me. 🙂 I think that’s why I’ve felt this disconnect since childhood between the workaday world v. Church. Our “default” is to think materially, and it takes effort to think spiritually…pastors have a tough job, like trying to get an autistic child to focus on relationships with people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top