Democrats Have a Religion Problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s sad, but seems true.

I think it partly has to do with how unchristian many Christians have become in their stance against social justice & environmental justice issues, ignoring how these are part of a fully pro-life position.

Also the anti-science stance, such as rejection of evolution, as bordering on lying or indoctrination that prevents people from accepting the truth.
The anti-science stance is horrible in the humanities where professionals have tried to force the science to fit a secular agenda on nonsense like so-called gay “marriage” and gender fluidity.

Also, the article posted in the first post was not about lack of concern about social justice or the environment, it was instead about abortion and related issues.
 
Anti-Catholic? That’s a bit harsh isn’t it? Would you say the same to all the folks in the thread about nuclear weapons that are in favor of them? They are also considered intrinsically disordered by the Church but many are in favor of them and promote their use publicly. Are they anti-Catholic?

I don’t think one or two points of disagreement make one anti-Catholic. I agree that making it public and attempting to change the Church are problematic but I would say it’s more ignorance than malice.

Also, you are still running with that Podesta stuff. I recommend taking a look at Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good and tell me what about them leads you to believe they are dangerous to the Church. You are also conflating the Podesta emails and a speech that Hillary gave to a global audience about women’s issues in world. They are not related in the least.
An article by the Chairman of the Board of CAFCG

An article from the Catholic League

There’s more out there, like one of the founders spent a few years workg for CCHD.
 
…the article posted in the first post was not about lack of concern about social justice or the environment, it was instead about abortion and related issues.
From my experience with those on the left (and it is true many have problems with religion, more specifically Christianity) this is at least in part due to what they perhaps wrongly perceive is the ignoring of social & environmental justice by the right and by Christians – it turns them off of both the right and of religion. They obviously lack knowledge of Christianity, seeing only angry, uptight Bible-thumpers who don’t care about social & env justice issues. That is why many of them are wonderfully amazed by and attracted to Pope Francis, who breaks this wrong stereotype. (I personally don’t see much difference among JPII, BXVI, and Pope Francis re social and env justice issues.)

However, you are correct – abortion is also an issue. I see the pro-choice stance of many on the left and some on the right as coming out of Western, Enlightenment thinking that we are separate individuals, monads, who roamed around independently before society was established with rights (sort of self-made without parents or others … or these lacked salience). Then for protection against conflicts among other such monads, people came together in a social contract to form society, but only gave up limited rights to achieve that protection, with the self retaining nearly all rights.

It follows a rights-based ethic – and both liberals & conservatives (who are of the same overarching culture) follow this, but differ somewhat in what they consider important rights. So many think women have rights to make choices re their own bodies, that they are sort of like countries unto themselves, mature, and capable of making correct decisions and laws re their bodies. (I disagree with the Western Enlightenment cultural aspect of this and see people as interconnected and intertwined, without rights to do harm to others, including fetuses in their own bodies.)

Past & nonwestern societies (which have their own down-side and problems) considered the person as part of and enmeshed in society. They followed a duty-based ethic – such as the 10 Commandments or dharma in Hinduism. Rights were always in the context of duties, never superseding duties.

I don’t think either the right or the left understand religion adequately, specifically Christianity, but somehow the right has appropriated religion & mixed it up with certain strands of American/Enlightenment culture that makes it abhorrent to many on the left.

I don’t know why those on left who are religious and have a better understanding of Christianity don’t re-appropriate religion and show how it resonates with many left issues (bleeding heart compassion for the poor and marginalized, concern with creation stewardship, etc), except perhaps they are afraid they’ll alienate those who have already been turned off by religion and can’t see past the angry Bible-thumpers with their particular brand of religion.

It’s very sad to lose souls because of such misguided scruples.
 
I don’t know why those on left who are religious and have a better understanding of Christianity don’t re-appropriate religion and show how it resonates with many left issues (bleeding heart compassion for the poor and marginalized, concern with creation stewardship, etc), except perhaps they are afraid they’ll alienate those who have already been turned off by religion and can’t see past the angry Bible-thumpers with their particular brand of religion.
They are not afraid of marginalizing anyone. They are the ones being mariginalized. Talk about a tradional family unit as the best way to solve poverty? No way! Your out on the fringe with an old fashioned idea like that.

There aren’t that many left in the party that are religious to begin either. They have moved on.

The Dems/Libs lost this election. It’s their problem to solve not conservatives. Do they see the writing on the wall or continue to bleed? I think they have bred such an intolerant culture they are not going to change.
 
So many of us, our families and our neighbours have walked away from the left side of politics because it has been taken over by Progressives and the Christian underpinnings of social justice has been prostituted to that of secular political correctness and state control.
 
An interesting article from a year ago explaining the differences among people of Christian faith. The article explains:

White evangelicals tend to support Republicans.

African American churchgoers Democrats.

Liberal Protestants who are members of mainline denominations such as the United Church of Christ, Episcopalian, PCUSA, ELCA subscribe closely to Jesus’ call to aid the poor and shun violence. Big issues for them are economic inequality, LGBT rights, war, climate change, women’s rights, Wall Street greed.

Liberal Catholics emphasize social justice, poverty, the death penalty, gun control, immigration, climate change.

Conservative Catholics place their emphasis on issues such as abortion and SSM and vote Republican.

charlotteobserver.com/living/religion/article56234060.html
 
An interesting article from a year ago explaining the differences among people of Christian faith. The article explains:

White evangelicals tend to support Republicans.

African American churchgoers Democrats.

Liberal Protestants who are members of mainline denominations such as the United Church of Christ, Episcopalian, PCUSA, ELCA subscribe closely to Jesus’ call to aid the poor and shun violence. Big issues for them are economic inequality, LGBT rights, war, climate change, women’s rights, Wall Street greed.

Liberal Catholics emphasize social justice, poverty, the death penalty, gun control, immigration, climate change.

Conservative Catholics place their emphasis on issues such as abortion and SSM and vote Republican.

charlotteobserver.com/living/religion/article56234060.html
I wonder what they make of Mother Teresa.
 
I wonder what they make of Mother Teresa.
👍

Republicans talk about social justice too but it is much more about economic strength, growth, fairness and opportunity rather than economic equality.
 
They? No one can speak for “they”. But here is an example of what one baptized Catholic who does not consider herself Catholic by belief thinks of her. This woman thinks she did a lot of good even though she disagreed with Mother Teresa on abortion and contraception.

huffingtonpost.com/celeste-owenjones/mother-theresa-critics_b_2824776.html
"They"meaning the people who wrote the article. The point is that American politics shows some of the terrible fracturing of Christianity, while Mother Teresa very much embodies historic Christian ethics.
 
And he called Second Corinthians, Corinthians Two :rolleyes:
Not to nitpick, but that’s not what he said. If you want to be so finicky, you should at least make sure your quote is 100% accurate. He said “Two Corinthians.”
 
Not to nitpick, but that’s not what he said. If you want to be so finicky, you should at least make sure your quote is 100% accurate. He said “Two Corinthians.”
It still shows Mr. Trump’s Biblical illiteracy.
 
It still shows Mr. Trump’s Biblical illiteracy.
Less concerned with illiteracy than invincible ignorance:
By Victor Morton - The Washington Times - Thursday, April 14, 2016
Donald Trump was asked about his favorite Bible verse in a Thursday radio interview, and he responded by citing an Old Testament law that Jesus specifically repudiated.
In the interview on news radio WHAM-1180 in Rochester, New York, host Bob Lonsberry asked Mr. Trump whether there was “a favorite Bible verse or Bible story that has informed your thinking or your character through life, sir?”
Mr. Trump responded with a Mosaic law rule an “eye for an eye,” mentioned in several books, most prominently Exodus 21, Buzzfeed reported.
“Well, I think many. I mean, when we get into the Bible, I think many, so many. And some people, look, an eye for an eye, you can almost say that. That’s not a particularly nice thing. But you know, if you look at what’s happening to our country, I mean, when you see what’s going on with our country, how people are taking advantage of us … we have to be firm and have to be very strong. And we can learn a lot from the Bible, that I can tell you.”
Unfortunately, an “eye for an eye” is one of the few Mosaic Law verses that Jesus singled out in the Sermon on the Mount as overcome, by the New Covenant that His death and resurrection would seal.
“You have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth. But I say to you not to resist evil: but if one strike thee on thy right cheek, turn to him also the other,” Jesus says in the famous sermon Matthew 5.
 
So many of us, our families and our neighbours have walked away from the left side of politics because it has been taken over by Progressives and the Christian underpinnings of social justice has been prostituted to that of secular political correctness and state control.
I really hate how that term is associated with left-wing politics. Some of the consequences of their policies, intentional or unintentional, discourage self-control, charity on a personal level, and etc. To me, that’s not progress, it’s regression in that humans are reverting to back to their selfish primal ways.
 
Less concerned with illiteracy than invincible ignorance:
Invincible ignorance is ignorance that is not the person’s fault and which he has no way of overcoming, like a remote tribe on an island which has never been visited by anyone, certainly not someone with access to the internet!

Secondly, an eye for an eye in the OT was to *limit *“retribution,” or to keep it from becoming revenge. Maybe this is helpful to Trump 😉

Also, maybe it would be a helpful guideline for those who think it is ok for a person to be drummed out of his job for supporting the moral stance of no homosexual " marriage."

The role of the government is to protect citizens in a way some ofthem might eschew on a personal basis. Thus, being sly as foxes is more necessary for those in a government role than for private citizens.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top