Determining Severity of Sin

  • Thread starter Thread starter Herculees
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Then I guess they presumed it was on only one etc.
Strange that in 50 years, 600 or so confessions and 200 or so different priests they all missed my sloppiness.

Or maybe nobody in fact applies this Canon Law as pedantically as some might suggest.
Thank God Confession is a human reality as opposed to a robotic ATM machine.
 
However, as we see in the canons (CIC) the kinds of sins confessed are grave or venial.
Yes, some venial sins are of grave matter and others of light matter.
Only grave sins must be confessed each year I believe…so that we can receive Communion.
 
Yes your right the Code in the west and other documents at times do use such- and they mean mortal sins.

Grave sin = mortal sin.

The Church uses both terms to refer to the same sin. As well as the term serious sin.
Well in intentional change from grave to mortal does seem to gains as this assumption.

In fact I see theologians use “grave sin” all the time to refer to two distinct definitions:
  1. Transgressions of serious matter which may be mortal, venial or mere imperfections
  2. Transgressions of serious malice which of course are always mortal though the outward action may sometimes appear innocuous or even meritorious.
As the CCC nor Canon Law does not bother to clarify these ambiguities one is free to choose which meaning is intended by reason of context until it is clarified for that context.

I suggest the change in Canons 915 and 916 were done for a good reason. Canon Lawyers are not want to change traditional formulations without good reason.
 
Yes, some venial sins are of grave matter and others of light matter.
Only grave sins must be confessed each year I believe…so that we can receive Communion.
1984 RECONCILIATION AND PENANCE OF JOHN PAUL II

Considering sin from the point of view of its matter, the ideas of death, of radical rupture with God, the supreme good, of deviation from the path that leads to God or interruption of the journey toward him (which are all ways of defining mortal sin) are linked with the idea of the gravity of sin’s objective content. Hence, in the church’s doctrine and pastoral action, grave sin is in practice identified with mortal sin.

Here we have the core of the church’s traditional teaching, which was reiterated frequently and vigorously during the recent synod. The synod in fact not only reaffirmed the teaching of the Council of Trent concerning the existence and nature of mortal and venial sins,(95) but it also recalled that mortal sin is sin whose object is grave matter and which is also committed with full knowledge and deliberate consent. It must be added-as was likewise done at the synod-that some sins are intrinsically grave and mortal by reason of their matter. That is, there exist acts which, per se and in themselves, independently of circumstances, are always seriously wrong by reason of their object. These acts, if carried out with sufficient awareness and freedom, are always gravely sinful.(96)

w2.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/apost_exhortations/documents/hf_jp-ii_exh_02121984_reconciliatio-et-paenitentia.html
 
1984 RECONCILIATION AND PENANCE OF JOHN PAUL II

Considering sin from the point of view of its matter, the ideas of death, of radical rupture with God, the supreme good, of deviation from the path that leads to God or interruption of the journey toward him (which are all ways of defining mortal sin) are linked with the idea of the gravity of sin’s objective content. Hence, in the church’s doctrine and pastoral action, grave sin is in practice identified with mortal sin.

Here we have the core of the church’s traditional teaching, which was reiterated frequently and vigorously during the recent synod. The synod in fact not only reaffirmed the teaching of the Council of Trent concerning the existence and nature of mortal and venial sins,(95) but it also recalled that mortal sin is sin whose object is grave matter and which is also committed with full knowledge and deliberate consent. It must be added-as was likewise done at the synod-that some sins are intrinsically grave and mortal by reason of their matter. That is, there exist acts which, per se and in themselves, independently of circumstances, are always seriously wrong by reason of their object. These acts, if carried out with sufficient awareness and freedom, are always gravely sinful.(96)

w2.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/apost_exhortations/documents/hf_jp-ii_exh_02121984_reconciliatio-et-paenitentia.html
If you understand him correctly then unfortunately JPII must have forgotten to tell quite a few other people including the writers of the CCC and the latest Code.

Or maybe this is a knowing over-simplification of somewhat complex matter on his part that doesn’t always work in all contexts. I would observe this univocation does not work re Code 915.
 
If you understand him correctly then unfortunately JPII must have forgotten to tell quite a few other people including the writers of the CCC and the latest Code.

Or maybe this is a knowing over-simplification of somewhat complex matter on his part that doesn’t always work in all contexts. I would observe this univocation does not work re Code 915.
The canon law was revised in 1983 and this came our in 1984. The canons use the term grave sins not grave matters.

CIC

Can. 915 - Ad sacram communionem ne admittantur excommunicati et interdicti post irrogationem vel declarationem poenae aliique in manifesto gravi peccato obstinate perseverantes.

Can. 915 Those who have been excommunicated or interdicted after the imposition or declaration of the penalty and others obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin are not to be admitted to holy communion.

Can. 916 - Qui conscius est peccati gravis, sine praemissa sacramentali confessione Missam ne celebret neve Corpori Domini communicet, nisi adsit gravis ratio et deficiat opportunitas confitendi; quo in casu meminerit se obligatione teneri ad eliciendum actum perfectae contritionis, qui includit propositum quam primum confitendi.

Can. 916 A person who is conscious of grave sin is not to celebrate Mass or receive the body of the Lord without previous sacramental confession unless there is a grave reason and there is no opportunity to confess; in this case the person is to remember the obligation to make an act of perfect contrition which includes the resolution of confessing as soon as possible.

Can. 988 - ง1. Christifidelis obligatione tenetur in specie et numero confitendi omnia peccata gravia post baptismum perpetrata et nondum per claves Ecclesiae directe remissa neque in confessione individuali accusata, quorum post diligentem sui discussionem conscientiam habeat.
ง2. Commendatur christifidelibus ut etiam peccata venialia confiteantur.

Can. 988 §1. A member of the Christian faithful is obliged to confess in kind and number all grave sins committed after baptism and not yet remitted directly through the keys of the Church nor acknowledged in individual confession, of which the person has knowledge after diligent examination of conscience.
§2. It is recommended to the Christian faithful that they also confess venial sins.
 
The canon law was revised in 1983 and this came our in 1984. The canons use the term grave sins not grave matters.

CIC

Can. 915 - Ad sacram communionem ne admittantur excommunicati et interdicti post irrogationem vel declarationem poenae aliique in manifesto gravi peccato obstinate perseverantes.

Can. 915 Those who have been excommunicated or interdicted after the imposition or declaration of the penalty and others obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin are not to be admitted to holy communion.
​

Yes I am aware of this for it was I who just drew it to your attention.
Can you answer my actual observation?
Namely a minister cannot read souls (their mortal sins) bue he can read the objective matter of their serious sins.
Therefore “grave sin” in this context is well identified with sins of grave matter surely?

So if we must say that mortal sin and grave sin are often used interchangeably, which is true, I would suggest it is more accurate to say all mortal sins are grave sins…but not all grave sins are mortal sins.
This is surely closer to what JPII really was saying below given the difficulties a pedantic literal appreciation of his words would imply for Canon 915.​
 
Well in intentional change from grave to mortal does seem to gains as this assumption…
.
Grave sin
Mortal sin
Serious sin

All refer to the same sin.

Be it on the subjective level of “I committed”

Or on the objective level of “such and such is”.
 
Mortal sin = Serious sin = Grave sin

The Church uses these terms in two senses (an objective sense if you will and a subjective sense). And in both senses the terms grave sin, mortal sin, and serious sin are interchangeable.

Here are the two senses:
  1. Objective sense
Murder is a grave sin.
Murder is a serious sin.
Murder is a mortal sin.

(all three mean the same)

this is one way the Church use the term. Talking about the ‘moral object’ of the act or the ‘objective kind of sin’. Referring to the object itself. Like if I said…do not commit murder for that is a mortal sin.

Then there is this way…
  1. Subjective sense…
I committed the grave sin of Murder
I committed the serious sin of Murder
I committed the mortal sin of Murder

(all three mean the same)

This is speaking of when the thing I committed is grave matter …done with full knowledge and deliberate (complete) consent.

Both are true. Both are ways the terms get used in Church documents

Ordinarily I tell people “such and such is a grave matter” for mortal sin and if one does it with full knowledge and complete consent…then one commits a mortal sin.

But sometimes I will say “yes murder is a mortal sin”…etc
 
Yes I am aware of this for it was I who just drew it to your attention.
Can you answer my actual observation?
Namely a minister cannot read souls (their mortal sins) bue he can read the objective matter of their serious sins.
Therefore “grave sin” in this context is well identified with sins of grave matter surely?

So if we must say that mortal sin and grave sin are often used interchangeably, which is true, I would suggest it is more accurate to say all mortal sins are grave sins…but not all grave sins are mortal sins.
This is surely closer to what JPII really was saying below given the difficulties a pedantic literal appreciation of his words would imply for Canon 915.
Yes, a minister only determines the objective nor formal sin. This is to avoid scandal, but does not imply that the person actually is culpable. The error is on the side of avoiding scandal.

In practice grave sin = mortal sin, and St. Pope John Paul II said: “some sins are intrinsically grave and mortal by reason of their matter”.
 
Would you mind quoting where it actually says that in either Canon law or the CCC :rolleyes:.
Ok.

Canon Law:

Can. 988 §1. A member of the Christian faithful is obliged to confess in kind and number all grave sins committed after baptism and not yet remitted directly through the keys of the Church nor acknowledged in individual confession, of which the person has knowledge after diligent examination of conscience.

§2. It is recommended to the Christian faithful that they also confess venial sins.

vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P3H.HTM

Catechism:

1456 Confession to a priest is an essential part of the sacrament of Penance: "All mortal sins of which penitents after a diligent self-examination are conscious must be recounted by them in confession, even if they are most secret and have been committed against the last two precepts of the Decalogue; for these sins sometimes wound the soul more grievously and are more dangerous than those which are committed openly."54

1497 Individual and integral confession of grave sins followed by absolution remains the only ordinary means of reconciliation with God and with the Church.

scborromeo.org/ccc/p2s2c2a4.htm#VII

And I will add the Compendium as a bonus…
  1. Which sins must be confessed?
1456

All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins is the only ordinary way to obtain forgiveness.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html

Again we are only talking about mortal sins not venial.

Now are there some exceptions to such? Yes - various ways that such becomes impossible - such as some brain injury or never remembering things despite a devout examination or the person is dying and has not time (though if they live they are to then confess), in certain cases of scrupulosity, etc.etc. But these are exceptions.

The above is the only ordinary way.
 
Mortal sin = Serious sin = Grave sin

The Church uses these terms in two senses (an objective sense if you will and a subjective sense).
I don’t think so…to talk of “mortal sin” “objectively” is not a rational statement.

Its a bit like the shepherd boy who counts his sheep by their legs and then divides the total by four :confused:.

If “object sense” of a “mortal sin” means anything its simply “grave matter”.
Which is pretty much “a sin of grave matter”…which is pretty much what I have been saying all along, that is, in older times by “mortal sin” people actually meant “sins of grave matter” (“grave sins”). But the two terms are not equivalent.
All mortasl sins are sins of grave matter, but not all sins of grave matter are mortal sins. Some are venial.
And in both senses the terms grave sin, mortal sin, and serious sin are interchangeable.
I believe you will find their are contexts where this is true (all mortal sins are sins of grave matter afterall) and others not so much (not all sins of grave matter are mortal sins).

I believe Canon 915 is not at all about “mortal sins” where the priest must somehow discover if those in the Communion line are in a state of sanctifying grace or not. Try swapping in “mortal sin” in that Canon and advise us if you agree with the theological consequences of doing so?
  1. Objective sense
    Murder is a grave sin.
    Murder is a serious sin.
    Murder is a mortal sin.
I would like to agree, but even if “objective sense” was actually meaningful you seem to have cherry-picked this example.

Try this one and see how it goes:
“Killing is a grave sin”…
 
I don’t think so…the object of a “mortal sin” is “grave matter”.
Meaning that objectively - in itself - such and such is a mortal sin.

Murder is a mortal sin
Adultery is a mortal sin
Fornication is a mortal sin.

Now if one has done such with full knowledge and complete consent then (on the subjective side) one has committed (guilty for) the mortal sin of murder, or adultery or fornication.
 
I would like to agree, but even if “objective sense” was actually meaningful you seem to have cherry-picked this example.

Try this one and see how it goes:
“Killing is a grave sin”…
No cause killing is not per se a grave sin. It is murder or abortion, or euthanasia that are grave sins. Killing is not in itself a grave sin.

Again one can give any number of examples

Adultery is a grave sin
Adultery is a mortal sin
Adultery is a serious sin

Same sin.

Fornication is a grave sin
Fornication is a mortal sin
Fornication is a serious sin

Same sin.

etc.
 
Ok.

Canon Law:

Can. 988 §1. A member of the Christian faithful is obliged to confess in kind and number all grave sins committed after baptism and not yet remitted directly through the keys of the Church nor acknowledged in individual confession, of which the person has knowledge after diligent examination of conscience.

§2. It is recommended to the Christian faithful that they also confess venial sins.

vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P3H.HTM

Catechism:

1456 Confession to a priest is an essential part of the sacrament of Penance: "All mortal sins of which penitents after a diligent self-examination are conscious must be recounted by them in confession, even if they are most secret and have been committed against the last two precepts of the Decalogue; for these sins sometimes wound the soul more grievously and are more dangerous than those which are committed openly."54

1497 Individual and integral confession of grave sins followed by absolution remains the only ordinary means of reconciliation with God and with the Church.

scborromeo.org/ccc/p2s2c2a4.htm#VII

And I will add the Compendium as a bonus…
  1. Which sins must be confessed?
1456

All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins is the only ordinary way to obtain forgiveness.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html

Again we are only talking about mortal sins not venial.

Now are there some exceptions to such? Yes - various ways that such becomes impossible - such as some brain injury or never remembering things despite a devout examination or the person is dying and has not time (though if they live they are to then confess), in certain cases of scrupulosity, etc.etc. But these are exceptions.

The above is the only ordinary way.
I think you have made a mistake.
The statement you made that I queried was:
“One is yes obliged to confess all mortal sins in number and kind.”

None of your above quotes actually say that do they?
 
I believe you will find their are contexts where this is true (all mortal sins are sins of grave matter afterall) and others not so much (not all sins of grave matter are mortal sins).

.
The difficulty is that there is mixing up of terms - grave matter and grave sin.
All *grave sins are mortal sins and serious sins - objectively speaking.

Not all sins that contain grave matter - mean the person has committed grave sin.
 
I think you have made a mistake.
The statement you made that I queried was:
“One is yes obliged to confess all mortal sins in number and kind.”

None of your above quotes actually say that do they?
Yes they do - read them again.

Canon Law expressly notes one is obliged to confess them in number and kind.

“A member of the Christian faithful is obliged to confess in kind and number all grave sins”

And the Catechism and Compendium also note that all of them must be confessed…

'All mortal sins of which penitents after a diligent self-examination are conscious must be recounted by them in confession"

“All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins is the only ordinary way to obtain forgiveness.”

All three of the above are referring to the *same *obligation.

Grave sin = mortal sin = serious sin -they are the same sin.
 
All *grave sins are mortal sins… - objectively speaking.
I do not accept this statement has any rational coherence as a theological proposition.
Its just as bad as Ron Conte’s “objective mortal sin” phraseology.

But if you could find Magisterial support for these sorts of expressions that could change my view.
Not all sins that contain grave matter mean the person has committed grave sin.
I would agree with this statement. This is the alternative meaning of “grave sin” I have already mentioned which is best rephrased as “serious sin” I suppose.

I note that J.P.Beal and J Coriden in “New Commentary on the Code of Canon Law” raise exactly this issue on page 1170 in this book of 2000.

“The fundamental difference between grave and non-grave sins(in Can 988) is taught by the entire tradition of the Church even if important differences in terminologyand in appraisal of individual sins occur.”

There is a footnote 90 to this discussion:
“Report 1983, C, III, 2, Origens 13 (1984) 523; see also, on the canonical avoidance of distinctions between “grave” and “mortal” sins Comm 10 (1978) 70.”

I have no idea what works this footnote refers to but it would be very interesting to find.
Perhaps “Comm” means the Communio Magazine.

I believe the issue is not as simple as you suggest.
 
Yes they do - read them again.
I was picking you up on your wording.
You will find no single Canon in the CCC that combines “mortal sin” with “kind and number” as you opined.

This indicates a complication that you are glossing over…

You may not agree that you are glossing over, but you must agree I am correct re your wording.

I am not going to continue this particular pedantic to and fro, I have made my point.
 
“The fundamental difference between grave and non-grave sins(in Can 988) is taught by the entire tradition of the Church even if important differences in terminologyand in appraisal of individual sins occur.”
Yes right. Different terms have been used by the Church for the same reality.

The terms get used to refer to the same sin.

What is one obliged to confess? (and in number and kind) --Mortal sin. The terms “grave sin” and “serious sin” refer to the same sin …and the same obligation to confess.

One is not obliged to confess venial sins…even if they contained grave matter but not full consent or full knowledge. One is obliged to confess grave sin (mortal sin).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top