Determining Severity of Sin

  • Thread starter Thread starter Herculees
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was picking you up on your wording.
You will find no single Canon in the CCC that combines “mortal sin” with “kind and number” as you opined.

This indicates a complication that you are glossing over…

You may not agree that you are glossing over, but you must agree I am correct re your wording.

I am not going to continue this particular pedantic to and fro, I have made my point.
No your missing mine.

Yes the Roman Code used the term “grave sin” not mortal sin. But what it is referring to is mortal sin (or serious sin).

The Eastern Code use the term “serious” not grave or mortal.

The terms mean the same thing.

What is one obliged to confess? Venial sins? No. Mortal sins. That is the obligation being referred to. The terms get switched out in various documents.

Hold on a moment I will give you some examples of use in the Church.
 
Grave sin, Mortal sin, and Serious sin

Are different words for the same thing. The same reality (they just highlight different aspects of it -see Hardon’s Catholic Dictionary for Grave sin).

The Compendium of the Catechism

"304. Which sins must be confessed?

1456

All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins is the only ordinary way to obtain forgiveness."

(note the use of the term grave sins and serious sins …in the same breath.)

ECCLESIA DE EUCHARISTIA --Pope John Paul II

“If a Christian’s conscience is burdened by serious sin, then the path of penance through the sacrament of Reconciliation becomes necessary for full participation in the Eucharistic Sacrifice.”

In the Message of Pope John Paul II to the participants of a course on confession organized by the Apostolic Penitentiary in March 1998

“The sacrament of Penance is meant to take away personal sins committed after Baptism: first of all mortal sins, then venial. If the penitent has committed more than one mortal sin, they can only be remitted all at once. In fact, the remission of serious sin consists in the infusion of the sanctifying grace which has been lost, and grace is incompatible with any and every serious sin. Venial sins are to be regarded differently…”

Notice he used “mortal sin” and “serious sin” interchangably.

Pope Benedict XVI in his Catecheses with Children said:

"Only in that case, when you are in a state of “mortal” sin, in other words, grave (sin), is it necessary to go to confession before Communion. This is my first point. "

vatican.va/holy_father/be…ildren_en.html

and here

“The faithful, in their turn, must seek to receive and to venerate the Most Holy Sacrament with piety and devotion, eager to welcome the Lord Jesus with faith, and having recourse, whenever necessary, to the sacrament of reconciliation so as to purify the soul from every grave sin.” vatican.va/holy_father/be…brazil_en.html

There Pope Benedict refers to "grave sin’.

This is how the Church uses the terms and that is how the get translated in official documents into English.

So when Canon law refers to being ‘conscious of grave sin’ it means that the person is conscious of actually committing a grave sin with full knowledge and full consent.

“A member of the Christian faithful is obliged to confess in kind and number all grave sins”

And the Catechism and Compendium also note that all of them must be confessed…

“All mortal sins of which penitents after a diligent self-examination are conscious must be recounted by them in confession”

“All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins is the only ordinary way to obtain forgiveness.”

All three of the above are referring to the same obligation.

One can call it a grave sin or a mortal sin or a serious sin. same thing that the person is conscious of.
 
Killing is not in itself a grave sin.
I think many Catholics would be surprised to hear that killing is not a grave sin.
Do you consider adultery to be a grave sin?

The Commandments are pretty clear “Thou shall not kill.”

The Commandments are traditionally put forward as listing sins of grave matter.
“1853 Sins can be distinguished … according to the commandments they violate.”
“1858 Grave matter is specified by the Ten Commandments, corresponding to the answer of Jesus to the rich young man: “Do not kill, Do not commit adultery…”
 
Yes right. Different terms have been used by the Church for the same reality.

The terms get used to refer to the same sin.

What is one obliged to confess? (and in number and kind) --Mortal sin. The terms “grave sin” and “serious sin” refer to the same sin …and the same obligation to confess.

One is not obliged to confess venial sins…even if they contained grave matter but not full consent or full knowledge. One is obliged to confess grave sin (mortal sin).
You missed the footnote:
:“see also, on the canonical avoidance of distinctions between “grave” and “mortal” sins”
The COCL is ambiguous on purpose, there seems more to this than your simple equivalence hypothesis.
It suggests “serious sin” is a mixture of “mortal sins” and “venial sins of grave matter”.
So it is not the clean distinction between mortal and venial sins that you maintain.
It certainly isn’t re Canon 915 and its ambiguous in Canon 988.
 
I think many Catholics would be surprised to hear that killing is not a grave sin.
Do you consider adultery to be a grave sin?

The Commandments are pretty clear “Thou shall not kill.”

The Commandments are traditionally put forward as listing sins of grave matter.
“1853 Sins can be distinguished … according to the commandments they violate.”
“1858 Grave matter is specified by the Ten Commandments, corresponding to the answer of Jesus to the rich young man: “Do not kill, Do not commit adultery…”
That means though shalt not murder (kill unjustly).

Killing can be without any sin (certain cases of self defense and capital punishment…and of course killing cows for hamburgers…)

I think your reading my posts too quickly. I gave adultery as an example of grave sin several times.

Adultery yes is a grave sin as is murder.
 
You missed the footnote:

The COCL is ambiguous on purpose, there seems more to this than your simple equivalence hypothesis.
It suggests “serious sin” is a mixture of “mortal sins” and “venial sins of grave matter”.
So it is not the clean distinction between mortal and venial sins that you maintain.
It certainly isn’t re Canon 915 and its ambiguous in Canon 988.
No your mistaken.

Please see the other posts above.

Moral sin and grave sin and serious sin refer the same sin.

I already noted that there can be different senses too in which the terms get used…as in the thing it self (murder is a grave sin) abstracting the person doing the act - and as in the culpability of the person (I committed a grave sin).
 
Grave sin = mortal sin = serious sin.

Grave sin, Mortal sin, and Serious sin

Are different words for the same thing. The same reality (they just highlight different aspects of it -see Hardon’s Catholic Dictionary for Grave sin).
**
The Compendium of the Catechism**

"304. Which sins must be confessed?

1456

All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins …

(note the use of the term grave sins and serious sins …in the same breath.)

ECCLESIA DE EUCHARISTIA --Pope John Paul II

“If a Christian’s conscience is burdened by serious sin, then the path of penance through the sacrament of Reconciliation becomes necessary for full participation in the Eucharistic Sacrifice.”

In the Message of Pope John Paul II to the participants of a course on confession organized by the Apostolic Penitentiary in March 1998

“The sacrament of Penance is meant to take away personal sins committed after Baptism: first of all mortal sins, then venial. If the penitent has committed more than one mortal sin, they can only be remitted all at once. In fact, the remission of serious sin consists in the infusion of the sanctifying grace which has been lost, and grace is incompatible with any and every serious sin. Venial sins are to be regarded differently…”

Notice he used “mortal sin” and “serious sin” interchangably.

Pope Benedict XVI in his Catecheses with Children said:

In MISERICORDIA DEI it is also noted:

“Individual and integral confession and absolution are the sole ordinary means by which the faithful, conscious of grave sin…

and in this document: vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/speeches/1998/march/documents/hf_jp-ii_spe_19980320_cardeal-baum_en.html

"Only in that case, when you are in a state of “mortal” sin, in other words, grave (sin), is it necessary to go to confession before Communion. This is my first point. "

vatican.va/holy_father/be…ildren_en.html

Note Pope Benedict uses both terms for the same sin in the same sentence…

and Pope Benedict XVI here

“The faithful, in their turn, must seek to receive and to venerate the Most Holy Sacrament with piety and devotion, eager to welcome the Lord Jesus with faith, and having recourse, whenever necessary, to the sacrament of reconciliation so as to purify the soul from every grave sin.” vatican.va/holy_father/be…brazil_en.html

There Pope Benedict refers to "grave sin’.

This is how the Church uses the terms and that is how the get translated in official documents into English.

So when Canon law refers to being ‘conscious of grave sin’ it means that the person is conscious of actually committing a grave sin with full knowledge and full consent.

“A member of the Christian faithful is obliged to confess in kind and number all grave sins”

Compendium of the Catechism issued by Pope Benedict XVI:
  1. What is required to receive Holy Communion?
1385-1389
1415

To receive Holy Communion one must be fully incorporated into the Catholic Church and be in the state of grace, that is, not conscious of being in mortal sin. Anyone who is conscious of having committed a grave sin must first receive the sacrament of Reconciliation before going to Communion.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html

Note well that in the very same paragraph - referring to thing (a sin that must be confessed and that keeps one from communion- serious sin) they use the term “mortal sin” in one place and “grave sin” in another…all referring to the same kind of sin and obligation. Synonyms get used to vary things when writing - to better the writing and not make it repetitive.

And the **Catechism **and Compendium also note that all of them must be confessed…

“All mortal sins of which penitents after a diligent self-examination are conscious must be recounted by them in confession”

“All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins is the only ordinary way to obtain forgiveness.”

All three of the above are referring to the same obligation.
One uses “mortal sin” for the obligation and two use “grave sin” for the same obligation to confess them.

One can call it a grave sin or a mortal sin or a serious sin. The Church in fact uses all three of these terms to refer to same obligation to confess and what is to be confessed.
 
That means though shalt not murder (kill unjustly).

Killing can be without any sin (certain cases of self defense and capital punishment…and of course killing cows for hamburgers…)

I think your reading my posts too quickly. I gave adultery as an example of grave sin several times.

Adultery yes is a grave sin as is murder.
The commandment is Thou shall not kill.
Therefore killing is a sin of grave matter, which grave sin surely encompasses.

So if adultery be a grave sin so too be killing.
 
The commandment is Thou shall not kill.
Therefore killing is a sin of grave matter, which grave sin surely encompasses.

So if adultery be a grave sin so too be killing.
Yes direct and intentional killing - is a grave sin.

One must though take"to kill" only in the sense meant in Scripture and by the Church.

The Hebrew basically means unjustified killing of innocents.

The simplest way to explain what is meant is the term “murder”.

Murder and forms of murder - abortion, euthanasia…etc

Such “killing” means unjust killing not just killing.
 
Yes direct and intentional killing - is a grave sin.

One must though take"to kill" only in the sense meant in Scripture and by the Church.

The Hebrew basically means unjustified killing of innocents.

The simplest way to explain what is meant is the term “murder”.

Murder and forms of murder - abortion, euthanasia…etc

Such “killing” means unjust killing not just killing.
I’m sure you don’t do this for applause, but it’s hard not to note your patience and constancy in the face of so much abject confusion. Thanks for that.
Why do I care? We have catechumens and candidates who come here with questions about morality, and honestly, they don’t always get clarity, to say the least.
 
I’m sure you don’t do this for applause, but it’s hard not to note your patience and constancy in the face of so much abject confusion. Thanks for that.
Why do I care? We have catechumens and candidates who come here with questions about morality, and honestly, they don’t always get clarity, to say the least.
Thanks for you kind words. We are all in it together 🙂

I too came into the Full Communion with the Church so many years ago…I pestered the poor Priest…so I know what is like to have questions as a person coming in from the outside.
 
We have catechumens and candidates who come here with questions about morality, and honestly, they don’t always get clarity, to say the least.
I know myself what is like to have some initial confusion and lots of questions --when I came into Full Communion with the Church so many years ago I pestered the poor monks with my questions …🙂
 
Yes direct and intentional killing - is a grave sin.

One must though take"to kill" only in the sense meant in Scripture and by the Church.

The Hebrew basically means unjustified killing of innocents.

The simplest way to explain what is meant is the term “murder”.

Murder and forms of murder - abortion, euthanasia…etc

Such “killing” means unjust killing not just killing.
If you were correct the best transation of the 5th should be Thou shall not murder.
But you would be gravely mistaken.
No individual may directly kill…though the State acting with God’s authority may.
No individual may directly adulter likewise.

When you can demonstrate the best translation is Thou shall not murder I will treat your view as having some credibility.
 
I’m sure you don’t do this for applause, but it’s hard not to note your patience and constancy in the face of so much abject confusion. Thanks for that.
Indeed. I second this. 🙂

It’s our job here to correct those who are woefully (or even partially) misinformed and confused about Catholicism.
 
The commandment is Thou shall not kill.
Therefore killing is a sin of grave matter, which grave sin surely encompasses.

So if adultery be a grave sin so too be killing.
We don’t read the commandment “Thou shalt not kill” through the tortured lens of a fundamentalist.

Rather, we understand it through the lens of the Church.

As such, we know that “thou shalt not kill” references not all killing (else, there would be a prohibition on antibiotics, and hamburgers, and insecticides, no?).

If anger reaches the point of a deliberate desire to kill or seriously wound a neighbor, it is gravely against charity; it is a mortal sin.
 
We don’t read the commandment “Thou shalt not kill” through the tortured lens of a fundamentalist.
By all means explain how Thou shall not kill is inconsistent with other Church teaching?
Clearly I see it as reconcilable with exceptions…but not on the tortured basis that they really meant to translate it as Thou shall not murder…and somehow forgot to so so in the CCC which always prefers my translation even though you personally cannot accept this :o.
 
Clearly I see it as reconcilable with exceptions…
Excellent.

'nuff said.

You should retract, then, the above erroneous argument you were asserting.

It’s good to see you in line with Catholic teaching here. 👍
 
If you were correct the best transation of the 5th should be Thou shall not murder.
But you would be gravely mistaken.
No individual may directly kill…though the State acting with God’s authority may.
No individual may directly adulter likewise.

When you can demonstrate the best translation is Thou shall not murder I will treat your view as having some credibility.
Read again my post

Yes direct and intentional killing - is a grave sin.

One must though take"to kill" only in the sense meant in Scripture and by the Church.

The Hebrew basically means unjustified killing of innocents (if you want more - Jimmy Akin can explain the Hebrew in detail).

The simplest way to explain what is meant is the term “murder”.

Murder and forms of murder - abortion, euthanasia…etc

Such “killing” means unjust killing not just killing.
 
Read again my post

Yes direct and intentional killing - is a grave sin.

One must though take"to kill" only in the sense meant in Scripture and by the Church.

The Hebrew basically means unjustified killing of innocents.

The simplest way to explain what is meant is the term “murder”.

Murder and forms of murder - abortion, euthanasia…etc

Such “killing” means unjust killing not just killing.
👍
 
that they really meant to translate it as Thou shall not murder…and somehow forgot to so so in the CCC which always prefers my translation even though you personally cannot accept this :o.
No one said they meant to really meant to translate it with the word murder. Only that such is a simply way to explain what it basically means.

Various translations have though chosen to use “murder” for the English Translation (as Jimmy Akin has noted). The Hebrew is not as I understand it a easy word to render perfectly in English.

To use “thou shalt not kill” is perfectly fine (it is the one I prefer too).

One though must understand what is meant morally (such does not mean that there cannot be legit capital punishment or say unintentioned necessary killing in self defense…).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top