Determining Severity of Sin

  • Thread starter Thread starter Herculees
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It seems from the other thread that this post was missed. There is no question that the Church uses these terms to refer to the same sin.

Grave sin = mortal sin = serious sin.

Grave sin, Mortal sin, and Serious sin

Are different words for the same thing. The same reality (they just highlight different aspects of it -see Hardon’s Catholic Dictionary for Grave sin).
**
The Compendium of the Catechism**

"304. Which sins must be confessed?

1456

All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins …

(note the use of the term grave sins and serious sins …in the same breath.)

ECCLESIA DE EUCHARISTIA --Pope John Paul II

“If a Christian’s conscience is burdened by serious sin, then the path of penance through the sacrament of Reconciliation becomes necessary for full participation in the Eucharistic Sacrifice.”

In the Message of Pope John Paul II to the participants of a course on confession organized by the Apostolic Penitentiary in March 1998

“The sacrament of Penance is meant to take away personal sins committed after Baptism: first of all mortal sins, then venial. If the penitent has committed more than one mortal sin, they can only be remitted all at once. In fact, the remission of serious sin consists in the infusion of the sanctifying grace which has been lost, and grace is incompatible with any and every serious sin. Venial sins are to be regarded differently…”

Notice he used “mortal sin” and “serious sin” interchangably.

Pope Benedict XVI in his Catecheses with Children said:

In MISERICORDIA DEI it is also noted:

“Individual and integral confession and absolution are the sole ordinary means by which the faithful, conscious of grave sin…

and in this document: vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/speeches/1998/march/documents/hf_jp-ii_spe_19980320_cardeal-baum_en.html

"Only in that case, when you are in a state of “mortal” sin, in other words, grave (sin), is it necessary to go to confession before Communion. This is my first point. "

vatican.va/holy_father/be…ildren_en.html

Note Pope Benedict uses both terms for the same sin in the same sentence…

and Pope Benedict XVI here

“The faithful, in their turn, must seek to receive and to venerate the Most Holy Sacrament with piety and devotion, eager to welcome the Lord Jesus with faith, and having recourse, whenever necessary, to the sacrament of reconciliation so as to purify the soul from every grave sin.” vatican.va/holy_father/be…brazil_en.html

There Pope Benedict refers to "grave sin’.

This is how the Church uses the terms and that is how the get translated in official documents into English.

So when Canon law refers to being ‘conscious of grave sin’ it means that the person is conscious of actually committing a grave sin with full knowledge and full consent.

“A member of the Christian faithful is obliged to confess in kind and number all grave sins”

Compendium of the Catechism issued by Pope Benedict XVI:
  1. What is required to receive Holy Communion?
1385-1389
1415

To receive Holy Communion one must be fully incorporated into the Catholic Church and be in the state of grace, that is, not conscious of being in mortal sin. Anyone who is conscious of having committed a grave sin must first receive the sacrament of Reconciliation before going to Communion.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html

Note well that in the very same paragraph - referring to thing (a sin that must be confessed and that keeps one from communion- serious sin) they use the term “mortal sin” in one place and “grave sin” in another…all referring to the same kind of sin and obligation. Synonyms get used to vary things when writing - to better the writing and not make it repetitive.

And the **Catechism **and Compendium also note that all of them must be confessed…

“All mortal sins of which penitents after a diligent self-examination are conscious must be recounted by them in confession”

“All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins is the only ordinary way to obtain forgiveness.”

All three of the above are referring to the same obligation.
One uses “mortal sin” for the obligation and two use “grave sin” for the same obligation to confess them.

One can call it a grave sin or a mortal sin or a serious sin. The Church in fact uses all three of these terms to refer to same obligation to confess and what is to be confessed.
 
I suspect the Church’s interchangeable use of these terms is to preempt those who like to redefine words to find moral space where there is none.
I doubt if it’s an accident.
 
I suspect the Church’s interchangeable use of these terms is to preempt those who like to redefine words to find moral space where there is none.
I doubt if it’s an accident.
Yes that could play a part in the more recent uses of all of them in documents

It is also simply from the various way such sin has been “called” over the centuries too. The Church is rather old 🙂 (and young!)

One will find the terms used down through time - referring to that same sin.

Adding some other variants such as - grievous sin…
 
I suspect the Church’s interchangeable use of these terms is to preempt those who like to redefine words to find moral space where there is none.
I doubt if it’s an accident.
It is no longer interchangeable from what I observe…the Magisterium’s preferred translation is now consistently “Thou shall not kill.”

And all explanations re exceptions to personal killings is also consistently the principle of proportionality and indirect intention.
 
It seems from the other thread that this post was missed.
So lets get back on point.
Originally Posted by Bookcat
Killing is not in itself a grave sin.
Blue Horizon:
I think many Catholics would be surprised to hear that killing is not a grave sin.
Do you consider adultery to be a grave sin?
The Commandments are pretty clear “Thou shall not kill.”
The Commandments are traditionally put forward as listing sins of grave matter.
“1858 Grave matter is specified by the Ten Commandments, corresponding to the answer of Jesus to the rich young man: “Do not kill, Do not commit adultery…”
Therefore killing appears to specify “grave matter” just as much (or as nuanced) as adultery. Therefore killing is a sin of “grave matter”, a grave sin.

That qualifies as determining the “severity of sin” so far as the object is concerned.
It is not the same class of “severity” which mortal versus venial distinguishes…but it is certainly a valid way of analysing severity in a sin.
So there is no inaccuracy in calling such sins “grave” from what I can see.

It is in fact a way of gauging “objective severity” - which is what Canon 915 actually seems to be more about. The Canon is not purely about distinguishing mortal sin from venial sin. That is a different class of “severity”, it is a distinction no priest could ever determine re those coming to Communion.

Little wonder then the 1917 version of the Canon was changed to speak of “grave sins” rather than “mortal sins” … because that better indicates the distinction between these two different meanings of “severity of sin”.

In short the term “grave sin” is intentionally ambiguous.
The gravity can refer to:
(a) the severity of the objective matter of the sin (grave not light);
(b) the severity of the intended malice in the sin (mortal rather than venial)

Which meaning is intended comes from the context.

When we speak of “mortal sin” only severity meaning (b) above is really and primarily possible.
 
So lets get back on point.

Therefore killing appears to specify “grave matter” just as much (or as nuanced) as adultery. Therefore killing is a sin of “grave matter”, a grave sin.
Not correct.
Killing is not necessarily a sin even though it is grave matter.

Before you ask for references again, please go back over the thread and read what the Church teaches.
That qualifies as determining the “severity of sin” so far as the object is concerned.
It is not the same class of “severity” which mortal versus venial distinguishes…but it is certainly a valid way of analysing severity in a sin.
So there is no inaccuracy in calling such sins “grave” from what I can see.
You are confused about “grave matter”, “sin”, “mortal/venial”. Please read the CCC referenced passages.
It is in fact a way of gauging “objective severity” - which is what Canon 915 actually seems to be more about. The Canon is not purely about distinguishing mortal sin from venial sin. That is a different class of “severity”, it is a distinction no priest could ever determine re those coming to Communion.
Little wonder then the 1917 version of the Canon was changed to speak of “grave sins” rather than “mortal sins” … because that better indicates the distinction between these two different meanings of “severity of sin”.
In short the term “grave sin” is intentionally ambiguous.
The gravity can refer to:
(a) the severity of the objective matter of the sin (grave not light);
(b) the severity of the intended malice in the sin (mortal rather than venial)
Which meaning is intended comes from the context.
When we speak of “mortal sin” only severity meaning (b) above is really and primarily possible.
You have a responsibility to provide references to something other than your opinion here. If you were a layman, it would be understandable that some confusion would be present, but you say you are a theologian.
Provide references.
We have catechumens (one of whom is in an irregular relationship) who come here to learn about the faith.
You are leading people astray.
 
So lets get back on point.

Therefore killing appears to specify “grave matter” just as much (or as nuanced) as adultery. Therefore killing is a sin of “grave matter”, a grave sin.

Yes when understood as the Church understands what is meant there by “thou shalt not kill”.

That qualifies as determining the “severity of sin” so far as the object is concerned.
It is not the same class of “severity” which mortal versus venial distinguishes…but it is certainly a valid way of analysing severity in a sin.

Grave matter means that it is serious - grave - mortal matter - yes it is quite severe. But yes I use the term “grave matter” all the time - see here -read all the way to the end forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=14346653&postcount=28

So there is no inaccuracy in calling such sins “grave” from what I can see.

Yes again that is referring to the thing in itself - adultery is a grave sin…murder is a moral sin…murder is a serious sin…

It is in fact a way of gauging “objective severity” - which is what Canon 915 actually seems to be more about. The Canon is not purely about distinguishing mortal sin from venial sin. That is a different class of “severity”, it is a distinction no priest could ever determine re those coming to Communion.

Yes again that is referring to the “objective sense” - the thing itself…adultery IS in itself a grave sin …a mortal sin…a serious sin. In itself - even if the person doing such is for some reason not culpable for grave sin

Little wonder then the 1917 version of the Canon was changed to speak of “grave sins” rather than “mortal sins” … because that better indicates the distinction between these two different meanings of “severity of sin”.

The Church has and does still use the terms grave sin, mortal sin and serious sin - to refer to the same sin. Be it on level of the thing itself or on the level of a persons culpability

In short the term “grave sin” is intentionally ambiguous.

Absolutely not - again- The Church has and does still use the terms "grave sin, mortal sin and serious sin - to refer to the same sin. Be it on level of the thing itself or on the level of a persons culpability
The gravity can refer to:
(a) the severity of the objective matter of the sin (grave not light); (yes the “objective” sense as I noted.)
(b) the severity of the intended malice in the sin (mortal rather than venial) (you mean culpability of the sin - the subjective sense - yes.)

Which meaning is intended comes from the context.

Yes again there is an objective sense (the thing itself) and a subjective (culpablity). Yes.

When we speak of “mortal sin” only severity meaning (b) above is really and primarily possible.

Not according to the Catholic Church -in other words no that is incorrect.

.
The Church has and does still use the terms “grave sin”, “mortal sin” and “serious sin” - to refer to the same sin. Be it on level of the thing itself or on the level of a persons culpability. For both of the “contexts” you note.

Yes there can be a* tendency* to prefer to use one term in a particular context more than the others but they all get used in both contexts.

One cannot take one place of use and draw from it total use.

See the next post. Please take the time to go through it all…not speed reading please.
 
Grave sin = mortal sin = serious sin.

Grave sin, Mortal sin, and Serious sin

Are different words for the same thing. The same reality (they just highlight different aspects of it -see Hardon’s Catholic Dictionary for Grave sin).
**
The Compendium of the Catechism**

"304. Which sins must be confessed?

1456

All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins …

(note the use of the term grave sins and serious sins …in the same breath.)

ECCLESIA DE EUCHARISTIA --Pope John Paul II

“If a Christian’s conscience is burdened by serious sin, then the path of penance through the sacrament of Reconciliation becomes necessary for full participation in the Eucharistic Sacrifice.”

In the Message of Pope John Paul II to the participants of a course on confession organized by the Apostolic Penitentiary in March 1998

“The sacrament of Penance is meant to take away personal sins committed after Baptism: first of all mortal sins, then venial. If the penitent has committed more than one mortal sin, they can only be remitted all at once. In fact, the remission of serious sin consists in the infusion of the sanctifying grace which has been lost, and grace is incompatible with any and every serious sin. Venial sins are to be regarded differently…”

Notice he used “mortal sin” and “serious sin” interchangably.

Pope Benedict XVI in his Catecheses with Children said:

In MISERICORDIA DEI it is also noted:

“Individual and integral confession and absolution are the sole ordinary means by which the faithful, conscious of grave sin…

and in this document: vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/speeches/1998/march/documents/hf_jp-ii_spe_19980320_cardeal-baum_en.html

"Only in that case, when you are in a state of “mortal” sin, in other words, grave (sin), is it necessary to go to confession before Communion. This is my first point. "

vatican.va/holy_father/be…ildren_en.html

Note Pope Benedict uses both terms for the same sin in the same sentence…

and Pope Benedict XVI here

“The faithful, in their turn, must seek to receive and to venerate the Most Holy Sacrament with piety and devotion, eager to welcome the Lord Jesus with faith, and having recourse, whenever necessary, to the sacrament of reconciliation so as to purify the soul from every grave sin.” vatican.va/holy_father/be…brazil_en.html

There Pope Benedict refers to "grave sin’.

This is how the Church uses the terms and that is how the get translated in official documents into English.

So when Canon law refers to being ‘conscious of grave sin’ it means that the person is conscious of actually committing a grave sin with full knowledge and full consent.

“A member of the Christian faithful is obliged to confess in kind and number all grave sins”

Compendium of the Catechism issued by Pope Benedict XVI:
  1. What is required to receive Holy Communion?
1385-1389
1415

To receive Holy Communion one must be fully incorporated into the Catholic Church and be in the state of grace, that is, not conscious of being in mortal sin. Anyone who is conscious of having committed a grave sin must first receive the sacrament of Reconciliation before going to Communion.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html

Note well that in the very same paragraph - referring to thing (a sin that must be confessed and that keeps one from communion- serious sin) they use the term “mortal sin” in one place and “grave sin” in another…all referring to the same kind of sin and obligation. Synonyms get used to vary things when writing - to better the writing and not make it repetitive.

And the **Catechism **and Compendium also note that all of them must be confessed…

“All mortal sins of which penitents after a diligent self-examination are conscious must be recounted by them in confession”

“All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins is the only ordinary way to obtain forgiveness.”

All three of the above are referring to the same obligation.
One uses “mortal sin” for the obligation and two use “grave sin” for the same obligation to confess them.

One can call it a grave sin or a mortal sin or a serious sin. The Church in fact uses all three of these terms to refer to same obligation to confess and what is to be confessed.
 
The Church has and does still use the terms “grave sin”, “mortal sin” and “serious sin” - to refer to the same sin.

Yes there can be a* tendency* to prefer to use one term in a particular context more than the others but they all get used in both contexts.
Try and keep focus, the content of 915 is in question…

So for Canon 915 if grave sin means mortal sin how does a minister determine someone in the Communion line is guilty of mortal sin as opposed to a sin of grave matter?

The context fairly clearly rules out the possibility of mortal sin as defined by the corresponding definition of the CCC?
 
Not correct.
Killing is not necessarily a sin even though it is grave matter.
It depends on one’s definition of “sin” doesn’t it.
What is your definition?

I believe you will find all transgressions against moral laws, whether culpable or not, whether direct or indirect, may legitimately be called sins.

The breaking of a Commandment is a transgression.
Thou shall not kill is certainly a Commandment.
Therefore all killing is an evil.
It may not always be a moral evil, but it is still an objective evil.
That is what grave matter means.
Therefore even guiltless transgressions may still be called sins.
 
Not correct.
You are confused about “grave matter”, “sin”, “mortal/venial”.
By all means defend your challenge with a clear exposition…I haven’t seen one from you as yet 🤷.
 
Try and keep focus, the content of 915 is in question…

So for Canon 915 if grave sin means mortal sin how does a minister determine someone in the Communion line is guilty of mortal sin as opposed to a sin of grave matter?

The context fairly clearly rules out the possibility of mortal sin as defined by the corresponding definition of the CCC?
No it does not.

Again one could write the same canon and say “manifest serious sin” or “manifest mortal sin” - referring to the sin in itself. Not touching culpability.

The fact that one choice is* better* in one context does not mean that all three terms are not all three referring to the same sin. They indeed are.
 
Bluehorizon…

Grave sin = mortal sin = serious sin.

Grave sin, Mortal sin, and Serious sin

Are different words for the same thing. The same reality (they just highlight different aspects of it -see Hardon’s Catholic Dictionary for Grave sin).
**
The Compendium of the Catechism**

"304. Which sins must be confessed?

1456

All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins …

(note the use of the term grave sins and serious sins …in the same breath.)

ECCLESIA DE EUCHARISTIA --Pope John Paul II

“If a Christian’s conscience is burdened by serious sin, then the path of penance through the sacrament of Reconciliation becomes necessary for full participation in the Eucharistic Sacrifice.”

In the Message of Pope John Paul II to the participants of a course on confession organized by the Apostolic Penitentiary in March 1998

“The sacrament of Penance is meant to take away personal sins committed after Baptism: first of all mortal sins, then venial. If the penitent has committed more than one mortal sin, they can only be remitted all at once. In fact, the remission of serious sin consists in the infusion of the sanctifying grace which has been lost, and grace is incompatible with any and every serious sin. Venial sins are to be regarded differently…”

Notice he used “mortal sin” and “serious sin” interchangably.

Pope Benedict XVI in his Catecheses with Children said:

In MISERICORDIA DEI it is also noted:

“Individual and integral confession and absolution are the sole ordinary means by which the faithful, conscious of grave sin…

and in this document: vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/speeches/1998/march/documents/hf_jp-ii_spe_19980320_cardeal-baum_en.html

"Only in that case, when you are in a state of “mortal” sin, in other words, grave (sin), is it necessary to go to confession before Communion. This is my first point. "

vatican.va/holy_father/be…ildren_en.html

Note Pope Benedict uses both terms for the same sin in the same sentence…

and Pope Benedict XVI here

“The faithful, in their turn, must seek to receive and to venerate the Most Holy Sacrament with piety and devotion, eager to welcome the Lord Jesus with faith, and having recourse, whenever necessary, to the sacrament of reconciliation so as to purify the soul from every grave sin.” vatican.va/holy_father/be…brazil_en.html

There Pope Benedict refers to "grave sin’.

This is how the Church uses the terms and that is how the get translated in official documents into English.

So when Canon law refers to being ‘conscious of grave sin’ it means that the person is conscious of actually committing a grave sin with full knowledge and full consent.

“A member of the Christian faithful is obliged to confess in kind and number all grave sins”

Compendium of the Catechism issued by Pope Benedict XVI:
  1. What is required to receive Holy Communion?
1385-1389
1415

To receive Holy Communion one must be fully incorporated into the Catholic Church and be in the state of grace, that is, not conscious of being in mortal sin. Anyone who is conscious of having committed a grave sin must first receive the sacrament of Reconciliation before going to Communion.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html

Note well that in the very same paragraph - referring to thing (a sin that must be confessed and that keeps one from communion- serious sin) they use the term “mortal sin” in one place and “grave sin” in another…all referring to the same kind of sin and obligation. Synonyms get used to vary things when writing - to better the writing and not make it repetitive.

And the **Catechism **and Compendium also note that all of them must be confessed…

“All mortal sins of which penitents after a diligent self-examination are conscious must be recounted by them in confession”

“All grave sins not yet confessed, which a careful examination of conscience brings to mind, must be brought to the sacrament of Penance. The confession of serious sins is the only ordinary way to obtain forgiveness.”

All three of the above are referring to the same obligation.
One uses “mortal sin” for the obligation and two use “grave sin” for the same obligation to confess them.

One can call it a grave sin or a mortal sin or a serious sin. The Church in fact uses all three of these terms to refer to same obligation to confess and what is to be confessed.

Thus one can see more readily now that in the Catholic Church

Grave sin, Mortal sin, and Serious sin

Are different words for the same thing. The same reality.

Either in the objective or subjective context
 
By all means defend your challenge with a clear exposition…I haven’t seen one from you as yet 🤷.
This is baiting.
You have seen quotes extensively and have nothing to offer in return but erroneous opinions.
It’s on you to do something other than make unsupported claims, and then bait others to do what they have already done.
 
Try and keep focus, the content of 915 is in question…

So for Canon 915 if grave sin means mortal sin how does a minister determine someone in the Communion line is guilty of mortal sin as opposed to a sin of grave matter?

The context fairly clearly rules out the possibility of mortal sin as defined by the corresponding definition of the CCC?
There are two senses of mortal sin or grave sin: formal and actual. Formal is used when considering giving scandal. Actual is used for the faithful to determine state of grace.
 
Try and keep focus, the content of 915 is in question…
Can. 915 Those who have been excommunicated or interdicted after the imposition or declaration of the penalty and others obstinately persevering in **manifest **grave sin are not to be admitted to holy communion.
So for Canon 915 if grave sin means mortal sin how does a minister determine someone in the Communion line is guilty of mortal sin as opposed to a sin of grave matter?
If this is all that the law considered, determining either would be impossible for the minister, wouldn’t it?
The context fairly clearly rules out the possibility of mortal sin as defined by the corresponding definition of the CCC?
Not at all. What the minister is to determine is whether a person is “obstinately persevering is *manifest *grave sin.” Manifest means clear to the eye or mind. Thus, if Mr Famous Movie Star, who is living with his girlfriend, shows up, he is not to be admitted to holy communion. If Mr Nobody shows up alone at Mass while on a business trip 200 miles from his home, it is not “manifest” that he is cohabitating, so no one has any obligation regarding admitting him to holy communion.
 
If you were correct the best transation of the 5th should be Thou shall not murder.
But you would be gravely mistaken.
No individual may directly kill…though the State acting with God’s authority may.
No individual may directly adulter likewise.

When you can demonstrate the best translation is Thou shall not murder I will treat your view as having some credibility.
Bookcat explained that he just uses that as an examplle, not as an attempt to provide an alternate translation.

It is quite clear why the Church does not use the word murder in this instance: murder is a legal term, and as such, it is changeable in its meaning and it does jot always align with what the Chirch would consider forbidden killing.

The Church has very clearly explained the use of the word killing in its sinful and non-sinful senses.
 
There are two senses of mortal sin or grave sin: formal and actual. Formal is used when considering giving scandal. Actual is used for the faithful to determine state of grace.
I think you may have your terms mixed up…“formal” is usually opposed to “material” in Thomistic/Aristotelian theology - which Catholic moral theology is based on.
You seem to be using “formal” in the modern colloquial english meaning which is in fact the opposite of what a moral theologian would likely say.

Also, “Actual” is usually opposed to “original” but here you oppose it to “formal”…so I cannot quite work out what you are trying to say. Did you invent the above yourself or are you quoting from somewhere?

What I think you mean to say is that mortal sin can be considered either as material or formal. Formal mortal sin sends a person to hell - no priest can determine such a soul in either the Communion line or the Confessional.

Material mortal sin is determined by observed behaviour that transgresses a law.

So I would agree that material mortal sin is in fact very close to what I am saying “grave sin” means in Canon 915.

But “mortal sin” by itself, as the CCC makes clear, refers to actual, personal fully culpable sins of grave matter (ie formal mortal sin)

That is why Canon 915 CANNOT properly refer to “mortal sin” because it is not formal mortal sin that bars a person from Communion in 915.

It is the outward behaviour, the objective grave matter of the act, the “material mortal sin” that bars them. This is best indicated by the phrase “sins of grave matter” …which I hold is one of the very reasonable meanings of “grave sin” … at least in Canon 915.
 
I think you may have your terms mixed up…“formal” is usually opposed to “material” in Thomistic/Aristotelian theology - which Catholic moral theology is based on.
You seem to be using “formal” in the modern colloquial english meaning which is in fact the opposite of what a moral theologian would likely say.

Also, “Actual” is usually opposed to “original” but here you oppose it to “formal”…so I cannot quite work out what you are trying to say. Did you invent the above yourself or are you quoting from somewhere?

What I think you mean to say is that mortal sin can be considered either as material or formal. Formal mortal sin sends a person to hell - no priest can determine such a soul in either the Communion line or the Confessional.

Material mortal sin is determined by observed behaviour that transgresses a law.

So I would agree that material mortal sin is in fact very close to what I am saying “grave sin” means in Canon 915.

But “mortal sin” by itself, as the CCC makes clear, refers to actual, personal fully culpable sins of grave matter (ie formal mortal sin)

That is why Canon 915 CANNOT properly refer to “mortal sin” because it is not formal mortal sin that bars a person from Communion in 915.

It is the outward behaviour, the objective grave matter of the act, the “material mortal sin” that bars them. This is best indicated by the phrase “sins of grave matter” …which I hold is one of the very reasonable meanings of “grave sin” … at least in Canon 915.
Yes,that should have been:
There are two senses of mortal sin or grave sin: material and actual. Material is used when considering giving scandal. Actual (mortal or venial) is used for the faithful to determine state of grace.

Can. 915 is about giving scandal so material grave sin or material mortal sin or material serious sin (or publicly unworthy) is the sense. Can 916 refers to actual mortal sin or actual grave sin or actual serious sin (but actual venial sin or actual less serious sin would not bar).

CIC Can. 915 Those who have been excommunicated or interdicted after the imposition or declaration of the penalty and others obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin are not to be admitted to holy communion.

CCEO Can. 712 Those that are publicly unworthy are forbidden to receive the Divine Eucharist.

CIC Can. 916 A person who is conscious of grave sin is not to celebrate Mass or receive the body of the Lord without previous sacramental confession unless there is a grave reason and there is no opportunity to confess; in this case the person is to remember the obligation to make an act of perfect contrition which includes the resolution of confessing as soon as possible.

CCEO Can. 711 A person who is conscious of serious sin is not to celebrate the Divine Liturgy nor receive the Divine Eucharist unless a serious reason is present and there is no opportunity of receiving the sacrament of penance; in this case the person should make an act of perfect condition, including the intention of confessing as soon as possible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top