D
dshix
Guest
What grannymh was trying to say was saying is that Evolution could not possibly produce a human, immortal soul, no matter how advanced the creature became.
- Status
A
aprilfloyd
Guest
It is not disputed science
A
aprilfloyd
Guest
I
What is a human immortal soul ?
J
JamesCaruso
Guest
Not true.
A
aprilfloyd
Guest
That is accepted medical science
J
JamesCaruso
Guest
Souls do not exist through evolution, They are not matter bur spirit and therefore outside the realm of evolution. They have no genes nor are they influenced by genes. A man is composed of body and soul. The body is where his senses reside, and the soul, his reasoning ability and his free will.
J
JamesCaruso
Guest
The seat of man’s reasoning and will. Ir can exist apart from the body, and in fact, does at death.
J
JamesCaruso
Guest
Aprilfloyd,
A person might engage in masturbation during puberty, or he may not. Such an act does not define puberty in medical science. Masturbation is clearly not a prerequisite for the stage of human development we call puberty. This conversation is getting quite silly. Many would like to call masturbation a morally neutral thing, perhaps to protect their sin in this area, or perhaps to promote a more liberal morality that is forbidden by the Church. The Church clearly forbids all sexual activity outside of marriage, and that has been and will always be the teaching of the Church based on Holy Scriptures and Tradition.
G
grannymh
Guest
The “spiritual principle of human nature” is our spiritual soul. Spiritual means non-material and thus it is not part of our decomposing anatomy. Maybe one has to believe in God before one can understand something that is non-material or super-natural.
A
aprilfloyd
Guest
I have never seen soul mentioned in any medical journal. I don’t appear to have one
A
aprilfloyd
Guest
I can’t see how all these gods can exist. What are they all doing and why do they sit ideal while people die of starvation
J
JamesCaruso
Guest
Now you’re being facetious.
If you are an unbeliever this discussion is going nowhere. As Augustine said, “If you do not believe, then you will not understand.”
J
JamesCaruso
Guest
God sent you. Are you feeding them?
D
dshix
Guest
And that somehow proves something…?
So, if I say that every day invisible pink polka dot dragons fly through the air from Texas to Idaho, and no one attempts to disprove it, then I must be right?
You know the answer to that question.
And that somehow proves something…?
Hmm, that would make sense, wouldn’t it? Kinda like not finding anatomy details in a geography book.
J
JamesCaruso
Guest
You’re being too rational.And that somehow proves something…?
So, if I say that every day invisible pink polka dot dragons fly through the air from Texas to Idaho, and no one attempts to disprove it, then I must be right?
You know the answer to that question.
And that somehow proves something…?
Hmm, that would make sense, wouldn’t it? Kinda like not finding anatomy details in a geography book.
A
aprilfloyd
Guest
God sent me? Yet he could stop suffering but chooses not to.
D
dshix
Guest
Because he has granted us free will.
You know, april, you shouldn’t really try messing around with this God business until you’ve figured out there is a God. It’s a little out of your league right now.
J
JamesCaruso
Guest
He gave to all of us collectively. Now we have to share,
You have to realize that Mankind put itself into this position of a world that has suffering and death by deciding he knew better than God. Once man disobeyed God it was simply the nature of things that suffering and death came into the world, just like if you jump into ocean, you’re going to get wet. The human race has been swimming back to shore ever since!
If God in all fairness could snap His Fingers and all would be well, He would; but that’s like saying why doesn’t God make water dry, then we wouldn’t get wet when we jump into the ocean. You’re asking for a denial of the way things are, a denial of the nature of things. The one thing God cannot do is to contradict Himself. There are certain things that must happen for God to be an All Just God. It is a mystery why things happen the way they do, but it is certain to the believer that God loves them in the midst of all the sufferings of this life.
If you were a believer you would be able to see this, but because you are an unbeliever, all you can see is if there is a God He must be an evil God. The fact is, there is evil in the world, but it’s mankind that caused it, not God.
The way out is to stop your unbelief, believe in God, and you will begin to understand how it all works, and that God loves you more than you ever dreamed you could be loved. Then, go out and begin to share that love with others, including feeding the starving.
B
Blue_Horizon
Guest
JC, AF is not worth the effort. He regularly raises the same old narrow range of boring questions across the Forum and pretends to be a Catholic. That AF posts around 20-40 posts a day on this Forum says it all really. Lets not provide such unproductive time-wasting behaviour the oxygen it seeks.
D
dshix
Guest
Yes. That’s why I don’t spend more than 5 minutes per post in replying to her anymore; I’ve learned that she is not here to get answers but rather to waste the time of the people who attempt to answer her.
Most of the time, now, I just respond for the benefit of any posters who may be spectating.
- Status