Divorce

  • Thread starter Thread starter muffindell
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Rainbow - you are so charitable - I find ex-husband to be one of the nicer things I still call him despite the level of forgiveness - but I think sometimes forgiveness is relative to the day and the mood. 😊
Yeah, I don’t even talk about him until after the second cup of coffee…hahahahaha;)
Thanks for making me smile again!
 
But enough about me, I don’t want to hijack the thread.
Yeah I don’t think that’s possible at this point. šŸ™‚ Plenty of stories to be had and loved here. More power to ya, girlfren. I’m learning and connecting with many of you, and I’m so happy to be able to share in a Catholic forum with so many of you who have been through similar things. It’s hard to find this type of conversation, and it makes for a safe and easy place to share and learn from marriage tragedy within the context of our mutual love for the Catholic Church. More power to you, girlfren.
 
…but in a sacramental marriage the two of you would work through it and help each other grow from the mistakes…
Well, it may have been a sacramental marriage and we didn’t work through it … yet. Who knows, Mitch Daniels took his wife back after she left, remarried civily and then returned. Not sure what the future holds, none of us are.
 
No, an epic fail is not even making the attempt. Looking back when you’re 80 wishing there was something you had done that you didn’t do. When you’re 80 you can rest easy, you did the best you could with what you knew at the time. When my my 11/12 year old son told me he felt like he had failed his mom, because he just couldn’t keep going to her home for her, I printed and posted this quote on his door:

ā€œIt is not the critic who counts: not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles or where the doer of deeds could have done better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood, who strives valiantly, who errs and comes up short again and again, because there is no effort without error or shortcoming, but who knows the great enthusiasms, the great devotions, who spends himself for a worthy cause; who, at the best, knows, in the end, the triumph of high achievement, and who, at the worst, if he fails, at least he fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who knew neither victory nor defeat.ā€
Theodore Roosevelt
Excellent!
 
Well, it may have been a sacramental marriage and we didn’t work through it … yet. Who knows, Mitch Daniels took his wife back after she left, remarried civily and then returned. Not sure what the future holds, none of us are.
Yes, I guess that gets us back to discernment…
I have a girlfriend who did go back to her ex and remarried him…they have a bunch of kids now…
Some of us do know that the future doesn’t include the ex, though…I am in that fortunate/unfortunate? bunch… There is a goodness out of knowing , but also a sadness in that finality too…
 
:
Yeah I don’t think that’s possible at this point. šŸ™‚ Plenty of stories to be had and loved here. More power to ya, girlfren. I’m learning and connecting with many of you, and I’m so happy to be able to share in a Catholic forum with so many of you who have been through similar things. It’s hard to find this type of conversation, and it makes for a safe and easy place to share and learn from marriage tragedy within the context of our mutual love for the Catholic Church. More power to you, girlfren.
šŸ‘
 
Rainbow - you are so charitable - I find ex-husband to be one of the nicer things I still call him despite the level of forgiveness - but I think sometimes forgiveness is relative to the day and the mood. 😊
BWAH HA HA! Yes,it would be good to point that out. I bet it is common to many of us. Given the level of mental illness my ex-putative-husband suffers, calling him ex-husband actually dignifies him. It would be far more accurate to call him ā€œthe evil man who deceived me into civil marriage for the purpose of narcissistic abuse and then lies to the tribunal in the hopes that he can still insist that I am his wife.ā€

EX HUSBAND.

Plus, really, it saves a lot of time to call them ex’s, because otherwise you get nosy people wanting to know why we live in separate houses and my kids only live with one of us, etc. Ex-husband tells a Catholic inquirer no more and no less than that we are civilly divorced.
 
Brayan…How 'bout you call the mother of your children, ā€œmy wife who civilly divorced meā€ and I call the biological father of my children ā€œmy ex-husband who probably never was my husband so how could he be an ex-husband?ā€ …and leave it at that?
You must really love her to want to call her that…
Blessings, a-
Good morning Amy, I must say that I am not exactly ā€œin loveā€ with her. But I do hope that I love her… I am commanded to do that. But it doesn’t feel like a command anymore. I can’t imagine not loving her (definitely do not do it perfectly).

I wouldn’t call two men who are ā€œmarriedā€ spouses. Why? Because, although according to the civil law system they are, they really are not. Calling them that would only spread the lie that comes from the father of all lies that two men can be married.

By referring to my wife as my ā€œex-wifeā€ in public circles then I am not standing up for the Truth of the indissolubility of marriage. I am helping to spread the lie that a civil divorce can separate what God joined. There are enough people spreading that lie already. I am to be a witness for the Truth. Maybe, just maybe, someone hears that who is genuinely seeking the Truth and they think, ā€œHmmm, I wonder why that crazy guy still thinks he is married?ā€ Maybe, just maybe that person then dives into a sincere search for the Truth and goes back through history and sees that Christians for 2000 years have upheld this Truth. Maybe, just maybe that person then starts to look at the Catholic Church in a new light.

Anyway, I have no control over all those maybes, I am just to ALWAYS witness to the Truth in words and deeds. And then leave it to the Holy Spirit to move the one who hears and sees.

While I find you personally to be a very kind and funny person, I do not find joking about the perpetuation of a lie to be funny. Calling my wife my ā€œex-wifeā€ would be false. For the Lord will be witness between me and the wife of my youth. Who am I to start calling her my ā€œex-wife?ā€

God bless you Rainbow.

Bryan

LOVE SO AMAZING
 
Good morning Amy, I must say that I am not exactly ā€œin loveā€ with her. But I do hope that I love her… I am commanded to do that. But it doesn’t feel like a command anymore. I can’t imagine not loving her (definitely do not do it perfectly).

I wouldn’t call two men who are ā€œmarriedā€ spouses. Why? Because, although according to the civil law system they are, they really are not. Calling them that would only spread the lie that comes from the father of all lies that two men can be married.

By referring to my wife as my ā€œex-wifeā€ in public circles then I am not standing up for the Truth of the indissolubility of marriage. I am helping to spread the lie that a civil divorce can separate what God joined. There are enough people spreading that lie already. I am to be a witness for the Truth. Maybe, just maybe, someone hears that who is genuinely seeking the Truth and they think, ā€œHmmm, I wonder why that crazy guy still thinks he is married?ā€ Maybe, just maybe that person then dives into a sincere search for the Truth and goes back through history and sees that Christians for 2000 years have upheld this Truth. Maybe, just maybe that person then starts to look at the Catholic Church in a new light.

Anyway, I have no control over all those maybes, I am just to ALWAYS witness to the Truth in words and deeds. And then leave it to the Holy Spirit to move the one who hears and sees.

While I find you personally to be a very kind and funny person, I do not find joking about the perpetuation of a lie to be funny. Calling my wife my ā€œex-wifeā€ would be false. For the Lord will be witness between me and the wife of my youth. Who am I to start calling her my ā€œex-wife?ā€

God bless you Rainbow.

Bryan

LOVE SO AMAZING
Bryan…I didn’t say for you to call her exwife…I said lets make a deal and I call mine what I want and you call yours what you want…surely didn’t mean to hurt feelings.
I am not perpetuating a lie…because I really believe that God never joined my ex and I together. If I kept calling him my husband, I would be wrapping myself in a huge web of deceit. Truly. There are days I so want to call him that…and if you look through the posts sometimes my heart starts melting and I do call him my husband. But believe me, he wasn’t and if he ever was, the Good Lord will so know why I can’t call him that anymore. If your wife treated your children the way my ex treated my children, I think you would not want to call her your spouse either. I feel a great sadness when I read posts saying it is possible maybe to get back together in the future with a spouse…because in my case that could never happen. The psychological damage it would do my children and myself would be off the wall. I also feel a great joy when I read those posts, because in many cases maybe God did join the people together and then something beautiful would be happening if they did get back together. In my own case though, getting back together is an absolute never will happen thing…and I have gone from crying about it every hour of every day to living a very beautiful life filled with joy and lots of love , although not from my ex. If I were to go around calling my ex my husband, then I would most of all be telling a lie to myself. I know my marriage history alot better than anyone, and believe me, if that was God joining two people together, than I would give up on the entire concept of love. But I am chosing, and it takes work, to accept reality and still go on and treasure this beautiful world filled with beautiful people…and lots of love.
One of my favorite songs is by Steven Curtis Chapman…I Will Be Here…have you listened to it? It reminds me that real love is in this world, and I am not going to settle for a counterfeit.
Your wife must be a very special lady for you to continue to want to be with her. I really hope things work out, and will pray for that for you today…
 
Love is here in the world because He died on a cross for our sins, and rose from the dead, and ascended into Heaven and sent His Holy Spirit so we could share in the promise that love will show the way…and He is the way the truth and the life.

Just sayin’! šŸ˜‰
 
Been a busy week giving me few opportunities to post, but been following the discussion…

Last night before bed I was reading St. Claude de la Columbiere’s reflection for yesterday’s Gospel (the Canaanite woman begging Jesus to cast the demon from her daughter and whom he initially refused) and found it really helpful… And if I hadn’t been so tired I would have posted it here then as I’m sure some of you will find it inspiring…
Consider the workings of divine providence and…the refusal you meet…is only God’s strategem to increase your fervor…Remember how he acted towards the Canaanite woman…With what tenderness does he repulse those whom he most wishes to be indulgent to…Take care not to be deceived by it. The more he seems unwilling, the more you must insist.
Do as the woman of Canaan; use against him the very arguments he may have for refusing you…I do not deserve the grace I ask, but I do not ask you to give me what I deserve; I ask it through the merits of my Redeemer…you will be unjust to yourself if you give me only what I deserve. If I were worthier of your benefits it would be less to your glory to give me them. It is unjust to grant favors to a sinner, but I…appeal…to your mercy.
Compel God to throw off the mask and say to you with admiration, ā€œGreat is your faith, be it done as you wish. I can no longer resist you, you shall have what you desire, in this life and the next.ā€
[Ellipses represent cuts I made, but I think I preserved the message. The full text is at Fr. Jean Baptiste Saint-Jure & St. Claude de la Colombiere - Trustful Surrender to Divine Providence near the bottom in a section headed ā€œObstinate Trustā€]
 
By referring to my wife as my ā€œex-wifeā€ in public circles then I am not standing up for the Truth of the indissolubility of marriage. I am helping to spread the lie that a civil divorce can separate what God joined. \
Go back and look at my words again remembering a simple phrase - render unto Cesar.
 
Been a busy week giving me few opportunities to post, but been following the discussion…

Last night before bed I was reading St. Claude de la Columbiere’s reflection for yesterday’s Gospel (the Canaanite woman begging Jesus to cast the demon from her daughter and whom he initially refused) and found it really helpful… And if I hadn’t been so tired I would have posted it here then as I’m sure some of you will find it inspiring…

[Ellipses represent cuts I made, but I think I preserved the message. The full text is at Fr. Jean Baptiste Saint-Jure & St. Claude de la Colombiere - Trustful Surrender to Divine Providence near the bottom in a section headed ā€œObstinate Trustā€]
That is beautiful…reminds me in some ways of the Divine Mercy Prayer…
 
I was unclear. The epic fail was that I spent ten years destroying myself and short changing my kids trying to do the impossible.
Yeah, but you couldn’t know it was impossible without trying. I hope you don’t beat yourself up-- you spent yourself in a worthy cause- total commitment to your vows. To know defeat is not a failure, not achieving the impossible is not the same as failure, certainly not epic. You can wish now you had done things differently, for example left earlier. But then you would be sitting here wondering what would have happened if you’d stayed just a little longer and been beating yourself up for that.
 
I was unclear. The epic fail was that I spent ten years destroying myself and short changing my kids trying to do the impossible.
I try to view the long, hard years of my failed marriage (which seems similiar to yours?) as fertilizer. I believe God uses all of our failings, our blindness, sufferings, and our sins very well. We just need to allow it God’s sunlight and plant His seeds. Otherwise it just sits there and ferments. My children are awesome and strong, and still very beautiful to me and to others. This is God’s beauty! Alleluia!! Alleluia!!

Where would we be without Him?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top