Do you find eating mutilated animals to be disgusting?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robert_Sock
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why go that far? I’m sure the big cats wouldn’t mind having any of us for lunch.
What I was thinking.

We once had a Japanese student who fixed us a traditional dish. I was happily eating it. It tasted good. Then I looked at the food and saw tiny fish. My first thougth was YUCK! but then I thought it was good before I saw them and the taste would not have changed. I ate the rest and had more. I guess they wouldn’t qualify as being mutilated though.
 
Also the word disgusting implies that something that is so gross or unappealing that it would cause nausea or sickness. Very little disgusts me.
 
If I am wrong and this thread wasn’t started to stir things up, why was it started?
My experience when I washed my first chicken was so PROFOUND I’ll never forget it; my interest was to see how many people have had similar experiences. Much of my belief system exploded with that experience. I was an atheist back then, but now I look at the whole experience from a religious perspective. Again, I encourage you to empathize with me here and imagine what such an experience did to me. I literately became a different person!
 
Why ask this just before Thanksgiving? Is it because Peta has decried the senseless slaughter of Turkeys?
Now that I’m thinking of a pig roast, I’m thinking the turkey might not be all that on Thanksgiving. But, since my turkey is already thawing in the frig, I’ll have to make do. But, a pig roast sure does sound good.
 
I’m not so sure. Being in Canada, I haven’t heard of bears hunting humans for food. They will attack humans in self defense, but I haven’t heard them attacking humans for food.
Black bears will occasionally do so. Brown bears like grizzly bears never, or virtually never.
 
My experience when I washed my first chicken was so PROFOUND I’ll never forget it; my interest was to see how many people have had similar experiences. Much of my belief system exploded with that experience. I was an atheist back then, but now I look at the whole experience from a religious perspective. Again, I encourage you to empathize with me here and imagine what such an experience did to me. I literately became a different person!
Ok, that I can understand, but using the dramatic/exaggerated terms you did (knowing most people eat meat) and bringing it up to a bunch of people you don’t know in a forum still seem that you were trying to stir up emotion or even offend. The fact that you use such extreme words for it when it makes it sound like you are saying that it is immoral. (even though that doesn’t coincide with Church teaching on the consumption meat) In the Old Testament God called for animal sacrifice and even made rules on how to slaughter animals.

I am not so upset that you brought up the issue and your experience, but using such dramatic terms seems you are just trying to evoke anger, disgust, or pick a fight. Most people eat meat and even love it. They associate it with their favorite family meals, bonding with family, (especially around this time of year) holidays, culture, tradition, ect. It would be like me coming in to a room knowing some have Polish ancestry and saying Polish tradition is disgusting. It is bound to upset some people using such strong terms that are connected with something near and dear to them.
 
Ok, that I can understand, but using the dramatic/exaggerated terms you did (knowing most people eat meat) and bringing it up to a bunch of people you don’t know in a forum still seem that you were trying to stir up emotion or even offend. The fact that you use such extreme words for it when it makes it sound like you are saying that it is immoral. (even though that doesn’t coincide with Church teaching on the consumption meat) In the Old Testament God called for animal sacrifice and even made rules on how to slaughter animals.

I am not so upset that you brought up the issue and your experience, but using such dramatic terms seems you are just trying to evoke anger, disgust, or pick a fight. Most people eat meat and even love it. They associate it with their favorite family meals, bonding with family, (especially around this time of year) holidays, culture, tradition, ect. It would be like me coming in to a room knowing some have Polish ancestry and saying Polish tradition is disgusting. It is bound to upset some people using such strong terms that are connected with something near and dear to them.
I surely apologize if I upset anybody! But I used those terms because they were implanted in my head from the profound experience.
 
My experience when I washed my first chicken was so PROFOUND I’ll never forget it; my interest was to see how many people have had similar experiences. Much of my belief system exploded with that experience. I was an atheist back then, but now I look at the whole experience from a religious perspective. Again, I encourage you to empathize with me here and imagine what such an experience did to me. I literately became a different person!
it’s not too hard to empathize with a person who had some kind of psychological shock, but it’s devilishly hard to understand why one would have one over washing a chicken.

Not trying to belittle you here, but I just don’t think most people can identify with the reaction to that particular experience.
 
I personally can’t stand to touch raw meat and especially raw chicken. It’s not so much a fear of germs as a general gross-out reaction. No problem at all once it’s cooked though.
 
it’s not too hard to empathize with a person who had some kind of psychological shock, but it’s devilishly hard to understand why one would have one over washing a chicken.

Not trying to belittle you here, but I just don’t think most people can identify with the reaction to that particular experience.
So far I got 4 people, 5 including me. I can’t help but believe the experience came from the Holy Spirit!
 
I’m not so sure. Being in Canada, I haven’t heard of bears hunting humans for food. They will attack humans in self defense, but I haven’t heard them attacking humans for food.
Can’t say for sure that some larger animals won’t attack humans for food. Nor do I have any bright ideas to test that theory. Ever visited Churchill, Manitoba? Lets just say you won’t see me taking a leisurely stroll in the evening enjoying the fresh air. Methinks my prime-rib carcass would be too tempting.
google.ca/search?q=Churchill+polar+bears+photos&hl=en&prmd=imvns&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=SuSrUOrMBuaA0AH-24GwCA&ved=0CCYQsAQ&biw=1920&bih=904

Forget the Coca-Cola polar bear idea. :hmmm: I wonder if they prefer Canadian Beer. 😃
 
So far I got 4 people, 5 including me. I can’t help but believe the experience came from the Holy Spirit!
You think the experience of being grossed out over washing a cut-up chicken came from the Holy Spirit? Seriously?
 
So far I got 4 people, 5 including me. I can’t help but believe the experience came from the Holy Spirit!
You think you had a religious experience because you touched raw chicken?

I honestly don’t understand what you experienced or what you are trying to convey.

Hope you get some responses that are helpful to you or are what you are hoping them to be.
 
This thread is more of a Back Fence topic than belonging in a Moral Theology Forum.
 
I surely apologize if I upset anybody! But I used those terms because they were implanted in my head from the profound experience.
Well, don’t use such dramatic terms. Even when talking about experiences that were traumatizing for us, we must remember when they deal with things that are important to people culturally, traditionally, dealing with family (in this case family recipes), things that remind us of holidays and important bonding time, ect. we must be careful with what words you use. When you call meat a disgusting and a form of mutilation, you are saying that our meals we share with family and friends are disgusting, which for many are times they hold dear. Those words weren’t implanted in you head , you chose the words to describe meat. Now it can implant your feelings surrounding meat, which can’t be all that strong since you choose to eat it. It really can’t disgust you, because disgust implies a physically sick reaction, which would prevent you from eating it (except maybe in cases of starvation or extreme hunger).
 
You think the experience of being grossed out over washing a cut-up chicken came from the Holy Spirit? Seriously?
You think you had a religious experience because you touched raw chicken?

I honestly don’t understand what you experienced or what you are trying to convey.

Hope you get some responses that are helpful to you or are what you are hoping them to be.
Yes, the Holy Spirit! It eventually led me back to the Catholic Church. I treasure that experience. I doubt it came from Satan, but I strongly feel that the experience was beyond my doing.
 
So far I got 4 people, 5 including me. I can’t help but believe the experience came from the Holy Spirit!
See, saying that this experience surrounding meat (which is fine to eat according to the Catholic Church) was from the Holy Spirit, doesn’t really add up. Just because some people other than you find eating meat disgusting, doesn’t mean it is from the Holy Spirit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top