Doctrine on transgender

  • Thread starter Thread starter FireFromHeaven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think it can be argued that SRS is for therapeutic medical reasons if it successfully brings people relief and keeps them from committing suicide. In addition, there are many transgender people who have not and do not intend to have surgery.

Do you know whether the quoted passage is mainly about tyranny and terror, or does this apply to people willingly altering their appearances, too?
It is about both and a male having his genitals removed is simply mutilation of his body, has nothing to do with therapeutic medical reasons, and in addition to contradicting Church teachings the man is still a man.
It makes absolutely no difference what a man thinks, feels, does, how he dresses, what drugs he takes or operations he has someone who is born a biological male remains a male for life!
 
It is about both and a male having his genitals removed is simply mutilation of his body, has nothing to do with therapeutic medical reasons, and in addition to contradicting Church teachings the man is still a man.
It makes absolutely no difference what a man thinks, feels, does, how he dresses, what drugs he takes or operations he has someone who is born a biological male remains a male for life!
So you believe that a person who has the neurobiological structures of a woman is 100% a man if their external genitalia is male?
 
I am in total agreement with you on this. To be an official document of the church it had to be signed by cardinal ratzinger.
CDF issues official doctrinal documents. The alleged document deals mainly with canon law status of transgedered persons, so it would be outside’s CDF’s jurisdiction – it could come out of Congration of Clergy or some such.

If so, you could argue that if it’s not from CDF then it’s not binding for the faithful 🙂
 
CCC 2297 Kidnapping and hostage taking bring on a reign of terror; by means of threats they subject their victims to intolerable pressures. They are morally wrong. Terrorism threatens, wounds, and kills indiscriminately; it is gravely against justice and charity. Torture which uses physical or moral violence to extract confessions, punish the guilty, frighten opponents, or satisfy hatred is contrary to respect for the person and for human dignity. Except when performed for strictly therapeutic medical reasons, directly intended amputations, mutilations, and sterilizations performed on innocent persons are against the moral law.
It appears that the main issue here is that the phrase from CC 2297 is being quoted out of context. Read in context, it means that forced mutilation is against the moral law.

I would make the following arguments in favor of SRS:

(1) SRS is performed for a valid medical reason, hence it would be fall under above exclusion

(2) even if you say that SRS has no valid therapeutic reasons, it is willed by the subject, so it falls under self-mutilation. It is not exactly clear if Catholicism absolutely prohibits self-mutilation, because it seems to have a long tradition (cf Matthew 18:9 and wide acceptance of mortification of the flesh).
 
It makes absolutely no difference what a man thinks, feels, does, how he dresses, what drugs he takes or operations he has someone who is born a biological male remains a male for life!
But it is not exactly sure that a trangender person is completely born male. The brain appears to be female from the beginning.

You’re essentially arguing that a person is defined by genitals, and I find this very… materialistic.
 
But it is not exactly sure that a trangender person is completely born male. The brain appears to be female from the beginning.

You’re essentially arguing that a person is defined by genitals, and I find this very… materialistic.
A person is and remains what they are biologically born.

By the way a transgender is either born male or female. A transgender is not a hermaphrodite.
 
A person is and remains what they are biologically born.

By the way a transgender is either born male or female. A transgender is not a hermaphrodite.
A hermaphrodite is also born either male or female. There is no such thing theologically as someone in between genders. So if, logically, a female person can have male genitalia or a male person female genitalia from hermaphrodism, could not a male person (as determined by their neurological structure and innate identity) have female genitalia or vice versa?

Note that I am not saying that this is the case. I am just saying people should not be arguing that there is no possible way on Earth that this could ever be true, when there is no doctrinal statement on the issue and considering that it can be reconciled with Catholic doctrine and theology.
 
A hermaphrodite is also born either male or female.
Well, no. There are two kinds of intersex conditions. In the first, a person is indeed genetically either male (XY) or female (XX) but hormonal situations such as androgen insensitivity for example, or inadequate testosterone during gestation, interfere with external genitalia development. So with androgen insensitivity, a genetic male can have female external genitals, and will be sterile.

A true hermaphrodite, a rare condition, had problems at the genetic level, such as XXY (Klinefelter’s syndrome) and 47XXY, 46XX/46XY, or 46XX/47XXY. These can be born with both ovarian and testicular tissue, and ambiguous external genitalia.

We have no proven idea yet, about intersex conditions that are primarily at the brain level, but evidence suggests definite brain differences in transsexuals. Which I think is why the Church is reluctant to pronounce herself on transgender issues. When the Church in the past has fallen behind the science, the results were often disastrous.
 
Well, no. There are two kinds of intersex conditions. In the first, a person is indeed genetically either male (XY) or female (XX) but hormonal situations such as androgen insensitivity for example, or inadequate testosterone during gestation, interfere with external genitalia development. So with androgen insensitivity, a genetic male can have female external genitals, and will be sterile.
I am not talking on a genetics or bodily level. I am saying that a hermaphrodite, theologically, is either male or female, period. We are all created male OR female. So I was pointing out that hermaphrodites’ gender identities are typically deferred to, but they are still only created as one gender, despite having genitalia of both. Thus, one could consider this when making a Catholic case for the legitimization of transgender individuals’ identities.
 
I am not talking on a genetics or bodily level. I am saying that a hermaphrodite, theologically, is either male or female, period. We are all created male OR female. So I was pointing out that hermaphrodites’ gender identities are typically deferred to, but they are still only created as one gender, despite having genitalia of both. Thus, one could consider this when making a Catholic case for the legitimization of transgender individuals’ identities.
In some cases, such as true hermaphrodites, it’s much more than just having the genitalia of both. It’s genetic, which is the very basic physiological foundation of our identities.

So I don’t think it’s as clear cut as being one or the other. May of these unfortunate individuals have a host of other physiological and psychological issues and mental handicaps in any case, and a theological definition of their gender is probably the least of their worries.
 
In some cases, such as true hermaphrodites, it’s much more than just having the genitalia of both. It’s genetic, which is the very basic physiological foundation of our identities.

So I don’t think it’s as clear cut as being one or the other. May of these unfortunate individuals have a host of other physiological and psychological issues and mental handicaps in any case, and a theological definition of their gender is probably the least of their worries.
Well, maybe so, but we’re talking about whether a transgender person’s identity can truly be their gender theologically in this forum. So the theological definition of gender is what’s important here. And every single person, no matter what their condition, is either male or female, period, for all eternity, and they will never be the other gender.
 
The teaching on this can be found in the first pages of the Bible which the Catholic Church accepts as the inspired and inerrant word of God. Whatever sex someone was born as was because God made them that way. When one thinks about it, an operation to try to change one’s sex is just as ridiculous as if one day they had a race change operation for people who are unhappy with the race they were born as. We should just accept the body God gave us from birth because God made us the way he did for a purpose. I was born half black and half white and experienced a lot of racism in my youth. For most of my years growing up, I had wished that I would have been born all one race. But I came to accept the body that God gave me, and I have been at peace about it ever since.

So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them. And God blessed them, and God said to them, “Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth and subdue it; and have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the air and over every living thing that moves upon the earth.”… And God saw everything that he had made, and behold, it was very good. And there was evening and there was morning, a sixth day. (Genesis:27-28,31)
 
So if you are born an MTF transsexual you will remain an MTF transsexual, surgery notwithstanding…
If you are born biological a male then nothing changes that. Your state of mind makes no difference, how you feel, how you think, how you dress, how you act, no matter what drugs you take or whatever surgery you have.
Born a male always a male. Wishful thinking and surgery do not change that.
 
It wouldn’t be superseding the CCC. The CCC does not address transgender issues, nor does it address the issue of surgery. Even the one section on forcibly mutilating prisoners lists exemptions for therapeuthe document itself lists as the only reason the surgery could be morally licit.

I also find it suspect that a then-heavily publbishops or theologist document in Catholic circles would draw literalcomment from Cardinal Ratzinger if he had no knowledge of it whatsoever, especially not if (as people here seem to argue) it directly countered Catholic doctrine. e that if the document were fake, Cardinal Ratzinger would not take a blatant risk of allowing it to be perpetuated as from the Vatican.
This is my exact problem with the document you are mentioning. Cardinal ratzinger didn’t sign that document hence you can’t say it is an official document from the Vatican. I am not saying the document is fake what I saying is that is very unlikely that it was am official position of the church and the CCC supersedes. Also it seems to me that you think if something has a theological error the vatican is going to immediately jump om it and is not like that. Keep in mind that there are many documents with awful theological errors and the Vatican doesn’t get to them. Even Anthony De mello who publishes multiple documents against catholic doctrine took many years before getting a reprimend and still all they did was a one paragraph statement saying he is wrong. Nothing else and his theology is still taught some places so no the Vatican doesn’t jump when something is against the doctrine unless is setting like De mello.
 
A person is and remains what they are biologically born.

By the way a transgender is either born male or female. A transgender is not a hermaphrodite.
Exactly and the actual statement made by the church in 2000 says exactly this, a sex change operation does not change the sex the person was born with. They remain the sex they wereborn.
 
It appears that the main issue here is that the phrase from CC 2297 is being quoted out of context. Read in context, it means that forced mutilation is against the moral law.

I would make the following arguments in favor of SRS:

(1) SRS is performed for a valid medical reason, hence it would be fall under above exclusion

(2) even if you say that SRS has no valid therapeutic reasons, it is willed by the subject, so it falls under self-mutilation. It is not exactly clear if Catholicism absolutely prohibits self-mutilation, because it seems to have a long tradition (cf Matthew 18:9 and wide acceptance of mortification of the flesh).
As to #1 again that is actually a cosmetic procedure so I hardly can see how it can fit as a strict medical procedure.

As to #2 first you have Paul in the bible stating that your body is a temple of the holy spirit and that your body does not belong to you; then you have CCC 2288 telling you you have to take care of your life and health and then if you notice here followthissite.com/list-of-sins.php self mutilation IS listed as a sin, get all that together with the section of bodily integrity and with cardinal’s ratzinger statement that the sex doesn’t get change and the conclusion is quite easy.
 
Exactly and the actual statement made by the church in 2000 says exactly this, a sex change operation does not change the sex the person was born with. They remain the sex they wereborn.
Well this is true, obviously, since our gender is immutable and permanent. But nowhere in the document does it say what that gender is. If someone has the genitalia of a woman and neurological structure of a man or vice versa, I feel like their identity should still be deferred to. I can’t imagine the Church seeing gender as obvious in these circumstances. 99% of the time, someone is born unequivocally one gender. There has already been medical evidence that transgender individuals do have key biological differences to their legal birth sex.

Tldr: while our genders are known before we are born and can never change, I do not believe that gender is obvious for every single person. Certainly it is not for hermaphrodites, but non-hermaphroditic intersex individuals have already started being deferred to, and I’d imagine that transgender individuals will be deferred to eventually, provided they have medical evidence of their own gender dimorphism. What I don’t believe, though, is that transgender individuals will ever be able to marry.
As to #1 again that is actually a cosmetic procedure so I hardly can see how it can fit as a strict medical procedure.
Saying it’s a cosmetic procedure is like arguing that allowing genital surgery for a hermaphrodite is cosmetic. If a person’s true gender is female but their external genitalia is male (making the assumption for the sake of argumentation that transgenderism is legitimate), they would receive a medical procedure to correct that. If a hermaphrodite’s true gender is female, they would receive a medical procedure to eradicate them of the partial male genitalia they have. In both cases, the procedure is not necessary whatsoever for the physical health of the person, but in both cases, the procedure is done for therapeutic reasons.
 
Well this is true, obviously, since our gender is immutable and permanent. But nowhere in the document does it say what that gender is. If someone has the genitalia of a woman and neurological structure of a man or vice versa, I feel like their identity should still be deferred to. I can’t imagine the Church seeing gender as obvious in these circumstances. 99% of the time, someone is born unequivocally one gender. There has already been medical evidence that transgender individuals do have key biological differences to their legal birth sex.

Tldr: while our genders are known before we are born and can never change, I do not believe that gender is obvious for every single person. Certainly it is not for hermaphrodites, but non-hermaphroditic intersex individuals have already started being deferred to, and I’d imagine that transgender individuals will be deferred to eventually, provided they have medical evidence of their own gender dimorphism. What I don’t believe, though, is that transgender individuals will ever be able to marry.

Saying it’s a cosmetic procedure is like arguing that allowing genital surgery for a hermaphroditdysphoria etic. If a person’s true gender is female but theibody. The transgendeternal genitalia is male (making the assumption for the sake of argumentation that transgenderism is legitimate), they would receive a medical procedure to correct that. If a hermaphrodite’s true gender is female, they would receive a medical procedure to eradicate them of the partial male genitalia they have. In both cases, the procedure is not necessary whatsoever for the physical health of the person, but in both cases, the procedure is done for therapeutic reasons.
I just want to bring attention to the words you are using “gender”
The term gender is a term pushed by radical feminism as the idea that male and female are societal constructs, is an idea to push the concept that men and women are androginous and that there is no actual difference between sexes. The church is never going to address any gender concept because (besides that the church has a very clear idea of sexes) is an anti life concept that goes against its doctrine so of course you won’t see anything from the church talking about gender because they are against that word.

Now eliminating the gender idea. If you are talking about sex, on the issue of actual hermaphrodites my understanding is that there is always a sex that is predominamt and most doctors would go with that one. Hermap hrodites won’t fall into cosmetic because there is an actual physical issue that must be resolved. The process is similar to as a person who is born with four arms or three legs or conjoined twins, there is an actual physical deformity which makes it necessary. Surgeries to correct deformities are not cosmetic.

People who are not hermaphrodite are having a cosmetic surgery because in their case there is no deformation. Their sex organs are perfectly ok and they are mutilating a healthy organ.

Now I have to confess I don’t like that conversation too much because let’s be real, there is a major pressure In society to push homosexuality on people and to make these conducts be seen normal so most of the medical research in these areas is biased and exaggerated. Because of that I don’t trust it. I do know there are people with Klinefelter syndre, the lack of the y receptor syndrome (can’t recall the name) but Ithink those cases are very rare and that those rare cases are being grabbed like the war horse of the movement to manipulate people’s feelings (very similar to the pro choice argument what about rape to try to justify abortion when 99% of abortions have nothing to do with rape). Let’ s face reality for the vast majority of people trangenderism is not because they have a different sex in their brain. It is a disordered conduct. In fact, if you want my opinion (and specially since I was someone who probably now a days would have been diagnosed with severe gender dysphoria) transgenderism has to do with self hatred of your body. They look at their body and they hate their body. They want to be something else because they hate their bodies. Is all about self hathred and I assure you that if instead of promoting to people who suffers these problems to run and cut their genitals to learn to love and accept themselves there would be many many less transgenders in the world.
 
Now I have to confess I don’t like that conversation too much because let’s be real, there is a major pressure In society to push homosexuality on people and to make these conducts be seen normal so most of the medical research in these areas is biased and exaggerated. Because of that I don’t trust it. I do know there are people with Klinefelter syndre, the lack of the y receptor syndrome (can’t recall the name) but Ithink those cases are very rare and that those rare cases are being grabbed like the war horse of the movement to manipulate people’s feelings (very similar to the pro choice argument what about rape to try to justify abortion when 99% of abortions have nothing to do with rape). Let’ s face reality for the vast majority of people trangenderism is not because they have a different sex in their brain. It is a disordered conduct. In fact, if you want my opinion (and specially since I was someone who probably now a days would have been diagnosed with severe gender dysphoria) transgenderism has to do with self hatred of your body. They look at their body and they hate their body. They want to be something else because they hate their bodies. Is all about self hathred and I assure you that if instead of promoting to people who suffers these problems to run and cut their genitals to learn to love and accept themselves there would be many many less transgenders in the world.
Well, as far as rarity goes, the rate of intersex disorders such as Klinefelter’s or PAIS/CAIS (the Y receptor disorder you were thinking of) or de la Chapelle’s syndrome is actually about 5-10 times that of the rate of transgender disorders (estimated at only about 150,000 people out of 300 million in the United States). If it was a matter of simple self-hatred, don’t you think the rate would be significantly higher? After all, what percentage of people are happy with their bodies?

Secondly, if someone’s neurological structure was definitively shown to biologically model that of their identified sex, would you consider them to be transgender or intersex? That is an important question for any discussion to occur.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top