(continued)
Objective falsehood
The author completely misrepresents nature of the gender indentity disorder. His argument starts with the following premise:
Sexual identity is not a social construction but is an objective fact rooted in our nature as either female or male persons.
But of course! If gender identity WAS a social construct, then gender identity disorder would not exist. Parents tend to raise XX individuals as girls and XY individuals as boys. No potential for gender mismatch here!
But the problem is that the brain DOES, indeed, have gender. Funnily enough, the best evidence for this has been obtained thanks to radical feminists. You see, back in 1970s radical feminists argued that gender is a purely social construct – i.e. its imprinted on the brain by environment. The fact that it was nonsense was apparent even back then simply by looking at anatomical differences between a male and female brain – but, as many times in history, a nonsensical idea gained traction for political reasons. Anyway. Because of that idea, kindergarten education in some countries (e.g. Sweden) is now being conducted in a way which tries to avoid imprinting gender stereotypes on children, and even tries to flip them. For example, children are shown examples of female soldiers and male nurses.
The experiment has been a complete and utter failure. It turns out that children aged 5 or so, when given a free choice of toys and gender roles, tend to assume traditional roles by default: girls play with dolls and want to be nurses, boys play with cars and want to be soldiers. This behavior seems to be hardwired into the brain, and seems to be impossible to eradicate even with outright indoctrination. To use a computer analogy, brain gender seems to be hardware-level feature, not a software-level feature which can be reprogrammed.
If you read testimonies of transgendered individuals, it jumps out at you that at the age 5 or so they preferred toys (and dress etc.) associated with the wrong gender. Usually, there is something along the lines that parents would try to force them to act in line with their body gender – but no amount of parental effort (or outright punishment) would change their behavior.
So there you have it. Contrary to the assertion of the author of this piece, the brain gender CAN be objectively determined, and quite easily at that – it will obviously manifest in person’s behavior at the age of 5 or so. No need for expensive brain scans etc. Further, as the author of this piece himself acknowleges – the brain gender is fixed and cannot be changed.
So basically, the problem with this piece is that the author – for ideological reasons – refuses to acknowledge that transgenderism is simply a mismatch between a brain gender and body gender. He simply does not believe that such thing could exist. But it’s quite obvious from the objective evidence that it does.
Contary to the assertions of the author, it has nothing to do with misguided self-perception. At the most basic level, self-perception arises from the neurological structure of the brain – and it’s mismatched with the rest of body. A transgendered brain below the age of 10 is quite sure what gender is has – except that the people around seem to disagree. Things get nasty after the age of 13 or so, when this brain gets flooded with “wrong” sex hormones, and at this point it gets confused.
And, of course, his strawman that people like me are preaching Gnosticism is just that – a strawman. The reality of transgenderism as a mismatch between (hardware!) brain sex and body sex is wholly contained in the physical realm. It’s a completely materialist argument, it does not involve soul in any way.
Of course it does have theological implications, but these are
implications. Indeed, I tend to argue for a more radical body/soul separation than the Catholic church, but that’s
because the orthodox view cannot be reconciled with reality, not the other way around. I mean, if you want to argue that the soul has gender, then you can equally well argue that black people have black souls, Down syndrome people have intellectually deficient souls, and so on. (Reductio ad absurdum). Not only this is nonsensical, it directly contradicts Galatians 3:28. And we should remember that Galatians is the best authenticated scripture that we have.