Doctrine on transgender

  • Thread starter Thread starter FireFromHeaven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What is the Church’s doctrine on transgenderism? Is it like homosexual urges, something to be resisted, or is it allowable? Should transgenders change their gender to match their percieved gender?
I cannot give more than my personal opinion on the matter - I try…

My believe is, that transgenderism is a form of posession by the Devil.
In the same way homosexuality.

Again, this is my own personal opinion and may or may not reflect the second Vatican Coucil’s final results.
 
I cannot give more than my personal opinion on the matter - I try…

My believe is, that transgenderism is a form of posession by the Devil.
In the same way homosexuality.

Again, this is my own personal opinion and may or may not reflect the second Vatican Coucil’s final results.
It remains what it is, your personal opinion with no scientific value.

I just hope that your personal opinion doesn’t stand in the way of being charitable to gay and transgendered folks.

You see we are all possessed by the devil in some way. It’s called being a sinner. So if you’re going to call homosexuality and transgenderism “possession by the devil”, perhaps it behooves one to work on one’s own possession by the devil before calling others on theirs. Let he who is without sin cast the first stone…
 
The National Catholic Bioethics Center has FAQs on various issues.
Here is their FAQ on transgenderism.
That’s some dangerous nonsense.

I’m sorry, but that’s what it is. It’s (a) self-contradictory (b) denies the existence of immaterial soul and (c) is objectively wrong.

Self-contradiction
…] or some other congenital cause of mixed sexual identity. These disorders present ambiguous sexual identity and certain operations done to confirm a person in the “dominant” sex aims to correct a pathological condition. Such operations should not be thought of as changing a person’s sex, but rather confirming what is originally ambiguous.
We are either male or female persons, and nothing can change that.
Either everyone is male or female, OR there are individuals who have “ambiguous sexual identity”. Of course the later is true, so the former cannot be. Further, the author claims that in individuals with ambiguous gender, there is one sex which is “dominant”. This is nonsense – take CAIS, which produces an XY-genotyped phenotypic female with residual testes. You could really argue the “true” gender of such person either way.

The reason for this mental gymnastics is that the author is perfectly aware that existence of intersex individuals falsifies the “either male or female” notion. So he is trying to divide intersex disorders into real, which cause observable morphological changes to the body – and imaginary, and the latter class, of course, includes transgenderism. Not only is such distinction is abitrary, it is empirically known to be false, because brain scans of transgendered persons show changes in brain structure which are in line with perceived gender not genital / genetic gender.

Denial of existence of soul

The author constructs a very elaborate straw man. He is trying to argue that the pro-SRS camp believes that a transgendered individual has a female soul in male body or vice versa. Although some probably believe that, it should be noted that the argument for SRS does not even rely on the existence of soul (more on that later). However, in an attempt to take down that straw man, the author writes the following:
Once [soul/body dualism] is rejected, and one recognizes that our sex is indicated by our bodies, we can see that sexual identity is an objective, readily discernible fact about us. As some philosophers put it, we are bodies.
If we are bodies, then we cease to exist at the moment of death. Enough said.
 
(continued)

Objective falsehood

The author completely misrepresents nature of the gender indentity disorder. His argument starts with the following premise:
Sexual identity is not a social construction but is an objective fact rooted in our nature as either female or male persons.
But of course! If gender identity WAS a social construct, then gender identity disorder would not exist. Parents tend to raise XX individuals as girls and XY individuals as boys. No potential for gender mismatch here!

But the problem is that the brain DOES, indeed, have gender. Funnily enough, the best evidence for this has been obtained thanks to radical feminists. You see, back in 1970s radical feminists argued that gender is a purely social construct – i.e. its imprinted on the brain by environment. The fact that it was nonsense was apparent even back then simply by looking at anatomical differences between a male and female brain – but, as many times in history, a nonsensical idea gained traction for political reasons. Anyway. Because of that idea, kindergarten education in some countries (e.g. Sweden) is now being conducted in a way which tries to avoid imprinting gender stereotypes on children, and even tries to flip them. For example, children are shown examples of female soldiers and male nurses.

The experiment has been a complete and utter failure. It turns out that children aged 5 or so, when given a free choice of toys and gender roles, tend to assume traditional roles by default: girls play with dolls and want to be nurses, boys play with cars and want to be soldiers. This behavior seems to be hardwired into the brain, and seems to be impossible to eradicate even with outright indoctrination. To use a computer analogy, brain gender seems to be hardware-level feature, not a software-level feature which can be reprogrammed.

If you read testimonies of transgendered individuals, it jumps out at you that at the age 5 or so they preferred toys (and dress etc.) associated with the wrong gender. Usually, there is something along the lines that parents would try to force them to act in line with their body gender – but no amount of parental effort (or outright punishment) would change their behavior.

So there you have it. Contrary to the assertion of the author of this piece, the brain gender CAN be objectively determined, and quite easily at that – it will obviously manifest in person’s behavior at the age of 5 or so. No need for expensive brain scans etc. Further, as the author of this piece himself acknowleges – the brain gender is fixed and cannot be changed.

So basically, the problem with this piece is that the author – for ideological reasons – refuses to acknowledge that transgenderism is simply a mismatch between a brain gender and body gender. He simply does not believe that such thing could exist. But it’s quite obvious from the objective evidence that it does.

Contary to the assertions of the author, it has nothing to do with misguided self-perception. At the most basic level, self-perception arises from the neurological structure of the brain – and it’s mismatched with the rest of body. A transgendered brain below the age of 10 is quite sure what gender is has – except that the people around seem to disagree. Things get nasty after the age of 13 or so, when this brain gets flooded with “wrong” sex hormones, and at this point it gets confused.

And, of course, his strawman that people like me are preaching Gnosticism is just that – a strawman. The reality of transgenderism as a mismatch between (hardware!) brain sex and body sex is wholly contained in the physical realm. It’s a completely materialist argument, it does not involve soul in any way.

Of course it does have theological implications, but these are implications. Indeed, I tend to argue for a more radical body/soul separation than the Catholic church, but that’s because the orthodox view cannot be reconciled with reality, not the other way around. I mean, if you want to argue that the soul has gender, then you can equally well argue that black people have black souls, Down syndrome people have intellectually deficient souls, and so on. (Reductio ad absurdum). Not only this is nonsensical, it directly contradicts Galatians 3:28. And we should remember that Galatians is the best authenticated scripture that we have.
 
It remains what it is, your personal opinion with no scientific value.

I just hope that your personal opinion doesn’t stand in the way of being charitable to gay and transgendered folks.

You see we are all possessed by the devil in some way. It’s called being a sinner. So if you’re going to call homosexuality and transgenderism “possession by the devil”, perhaps it behooves one to work on one’s own possession by the devil before calling others on theirs. Let he who is without sin cast the first stone…
Science has shown that science boils down to theories and most (if not all) peer reviews start with: We think, that our theory, perhaps could be, based on our theories, etc… and by those same people, they cast the first stone. God cannot be studied via arythmetic and PhD’s in physics.

Yes, homosexuality is a sickness as much as transgenderism. Your words won’t heal them unless you teach the Holy Word for those. Else, it’s heresy.

Society is going the split between sane and insane.

What we need is the inquisition without the mistakes of the past.
 
I cannot give more than my personal opinion on the matter - I try…

My believe is, that transgenderism is a form of posession by the Devil.
In the same way homosexuality.

Again, this is my own personal opinion and may or may not reflect the second Vatican Coucil’s final results.
So are heterosexuals, they are guilty of divorce rates of about 50%, guilty of masturbation, watching porn, looking at the other sex with lust, unfaithful to their spouses, guilty of prostitution, greed, power … need I go on? based on Genesis, the whole human race has fallen because of the sin of Adam and Eve.
 
So are heterosexuals, they are guilty of divorce rates of about 50%, guilty of masturbation, watching porn, looking at the other sex with lust, unfaithful to their spouses, guilty of prostitution, greed, power … need I go on? based on Genesis, the whole human race has fallen because of the sin of Adam and Eve.
Of cause, in a certain way they are guilty, by the fact, what is causing it - it is strict Atheism by choice.

Those who truly believe and are truly in communion will get saved.

But the people you refer to - they want everything and nothing ever will satisfy their hearts.
Society, in particular Western society teaches that there is no space for God. it teaches to be selfish as much as posessing and hurting someone elses feelings by exploiting their desires for sexual pleasure. It is no surprise that divorce rates have skyrocketed.
 
The OP posted asking for Church doctrine regarding transgenderism, and I have responded with authentic Church positions from the best minds in Catholic bioethics. This site is frequently recommended by professional Catholic Answers apologists to answer the difficult questions. So your criticism of it as “dangerous nonsense” or “walk a mile in their shoes” should be directed at the NCBC and by extension, the bishops of the Magisterium and the Holy See and Christ Himself who entrusted His sacred Word to us.
 
The OP posted asking for Church doctrine regarding transgenderism, and I have responded with authentic Church positions from the best minds in Catholic bioethics. This site is frequently recommended by professional Catholic Answers apologists to answer the difficult questions. So your criticism of it as “dangerous nonsense” or “walk a mile in their shoes” should be directed at the NCBC and by extension, the bishops of the Magisterium and the Holy See and Christ Himself who entrusted His sacred Word to us.
Still, the NCBC are not part of the Magisterium, and they do not have the mandate to pronounce authoritatively on any matter. SMGS has posted the Vatican’s current (temporary) policy. It surprises me how many people just refuse to accept that the Church actually permits transition/SRS as a last resort, and choose other, non-Magisterial sources, or worse, their own, flawed interpretation of the Catechism, Canon Law or the Bible over Rome - something I’d expect from a Protestant, but not a Catholic.

With that in mind, the NCBC article you posted is “dangerous nonsense” indeed. It contradicts current science, and it contradicts Rome. The article even contradicts itself, as pointed out earlier.

I do understand the unwillingness people have to accept the changes in gender science though, since it does contradict the traditional, philosophic framework of the Church’s world view. But so did heliocentrism - for (most of) the Magisterium at the time, claiming that the Earth is not the center of the universe, and even worse, that the trajectories of planets were not circular, shook the foundations of our world view, and to some extent, doctrine. I think the discovery of modern intersex conditions, bioneurological reasons for transsexualism, etc, shakes some of our foundations too. The difference is, it’s about people this time. People who are raped, murdered, discriminated upon, ridiculed, accused of perversion and lunacy, bullied, and commit suicide because of all this combined with their own, internal struggles, while the faithful watch with everything from contempt, lack of compassion, and even anti-compassion. And then there are some wonderful, life-saving exceptions. Rome is somewhere in between, with its current policy - it is tolerable, if not much more.

But the Church burned Her hands on Galileo. He was right, and the Magisterium was, and it’s not easy for me to say so, wrong. Infallibility only covers faith and morals, not science. Since then, harshly and rashly condemning scientific breakthroughs has been avoided by the Church (unless they are intrinsically evil - like abortion techniques etc. So-called ‘mutilation’ is not, since that would mean even amputating necrotic tissue, or correcting a cleft palate, would be sinful). Evolution was simply met with neither rejection nor acceptance. With the current changes with regards to how science views gender, the Church seems to have chosen a “watchful waiting” strategy. I hope the wait won’t be centuries long, because this is people we’re talking about, but I fear it could be decades. In the meantime, if everyone could submit to the current policy of the Church, at least it’s possible for a transgender person to find his or her place in the Church (albeit with several difficult, but not unbearable, for most people, limitations), rather than leave the Church, or worse, be driven to suicide. Isn’t that something everyone would prefer? Or is your own, private theology more important than other people’s lives?
 
Still, the NCBC are not part of the Magisterium, and they do not have the mandate to pronounce authoritatively on any matter. SMGS has posted the Vatican’s current (temporary) policy. It surprises me how many people just refuse to accept that the Church actually permits transition/SRS as a last resort, and choose other, non-Magisterial sources, or worse, their own, flawed interpretation of the Catechism, Canon Law or the Bible over Rome - something I’d expect from a Protestant, but not a Catholic.

I do understand the unwillingness people have to accept the changes in gender science

?
Rin the problem that most people are having with that has nothing to do with unwillingness to accept, it has to do with the fact that what you call the “Vatican policy” does not seem to be an official documemy from the Vatican. The official document by the Vatican in 2000 only says that a sex change operation does not change the sex of the person. Nothing else. This so called policy while is mentioned in blogs and media at the time it is nowhere to be found as an official document of the Vatican and cardinal ratzinget would never have sent an underground document. This means that the document is not “official” and is not mandatory on the faithful, is not part of the magisterium either and is exactly at the same level as the NCBC.
 
Rin the problem that most people are having with that has nothing to do with unwillingness to accept, it has to do with the fact that what you call the “Vatican policy” does not seem to be an official documemy from the Vatican. The official document by the Vatican in 2000 only says that a sex change operation does not change the sex of the person. Nothing else. This so called policy while is mentioned in blogs and media at the time it is nowhere to be found as an official document of the Vatican and cardinal ratzinget would never have sent an underground document. This means that the document is not “official” and is not mandatory on the faithful, is not part of the magisterium either and is exactly at the same level as the NCBC.
The document says that transition can be morally licit when it will lessen the patients internal turmoil, in “extreme cases”. Every summary I’ve seen notes that. Links have been posted, look it up.

It seems you’re not familiar with the so-called Pontifical Secret, which is similar to “classified documents” in secular government. Issuing documents “under secrecy”, or “sub secretum” is completely normal; one instance is the appointment of a new Ordinary in a diocese, where all communication between the Nuncio and Rome is secret. It has nothing to do with being “underground” - in this specific case, it was probably because they expect things to change in the future. Also, this is definitely not something Cardinal Ratzinger “would never have sent” - on the contrary, he almost certainly did, and even more certainly so as Pope.

But you are right, the document doesn’t bind the faithful, since it is theoretically not known to us. But it does bind the bishops, who received it. And your personal interpretation of the Catechism certainly does not bind me. As others have pointed out, CCC 2297 condemns forced mutilations and torture, and clearly says that amputations etc. are morally licit when done for therapeutic medical reasons. Hormone treatment and SRS are always done for therapeutic medical reasons, so it’s not condemned by the Catechism. You can of course disagree with this, but your personal opinion doesn’t bind the faithful.

That said, I’m glad to read (earlier in the tread) that you’re at peace with yourself. I just wish people like you could realize that people are different - there are different degrees of gender dysphoria, and no cookie cutter solution, be it hormonal, surgical, therapeutical or religious.

Edit: Just one more thing - NCBC is by no means at the same level as a sub secretum document sent to bishops. Such a document binds the bishops. NCBC binds no one, neither bishop nor faithful.
 
The document says that transition can be morally licit when it will lessen the patients internal turmoil, in “extreme cases”. Every summary I’ve seen notes that. Links have been posted, look it up.

It seems you’re not familiar with the so-called Pontifical Secret, which is similar to “classified documents” in secular government. Issuing documents “under secrecy”, or “sub secretum” is completely normal; one instance is the appointment of a new Ordinary in a diocese, where all communication between the Nuncio and Rome is secret. It has nothing to do with being “underground” - in this specific case, it was probably because they expect things to change in the future. Also, this is definitely not something Cardinal Ratzinger “would never have sent” - on the contrary, he almost certainly did, and even more certainly so as Pope.

But you are right, the document doesn’t bind the faithful, since it is theoretically not known to us. But it does bind the bishops, who received it. And your personal interpretation of the Catechism certainly does not bind me. As others have pointed out, CCC 2297 condemns forced mutilations and torture, and clearly says that amputations etc. are morally licit when done for therapeutic medical reasons. Hormone treatment and SRS are always done for therapeutic medical reasons, so it’s not condemned by the Catechism. You can of course disagree with this, but your personal opinion doesn’t bind the faithful.

That said, I’m glad to read (earlier in the tread) that you’re at peace with yourself. I just wish people like you could realize that people are different - there are different degrees of gender dysphoria, and no cookie cutter solution, be it hormonal, surgical, therapeutical or religious.

Edit: Just one more thing - NCBC is by no means at the same level as a sub secretum document sent to bishops. Such a document binds the bishops. NCBC binds no one, neither bishop nor faithful.
I did look at the links and did quite research on the internet. There is nothing that indicates that is an official document. The links are all blogs from individuals and news and they don’t even seem to agree about the actual origin of the document. There is no actual proof that the document came from cardinal ratzinger…quite the opposite. Nothing shows it as a binding document and the fact that only individuals and secular people are the ones stating that is a binding document for bishops raises a big question mark as to the document being truly an official document.

Also, remember the actual official position of the church that is binding for the faithful and promulgated by cardinal ratzinger in 2000 is “sex change operations do NOT change the sex of the person”
 
Also, remember the actual official position of the church that is binding for the faithful and promulgated by cardinal ratzinger in 2000 is “sex change operations do NOT change the sex of the person”
And who said that it does? The very reason for SRS is that brain sex cannot be changed (*) but we can change appearance of the body to match what the brain expects. That’s all.

That being said, while I agree that a post-op MTF transsexual is a post-op MTF transsexual and not a female, I fail to see any reason why I should go against such person’s wishes and refuse to treat her as a female.

(*) Even if brain sex could be changed, I would have doubts about ethics of such procedures – this would amount to chaging someone’s personality.
 
And who said that it does? The very reason for SRS is that brain sex cannot be changed (*) but we can change appearance of the body to match what the brain expects. That’s all.

That being said, while I agree that a post-op MTF transsexual is a post-op MTF transsexual and not a female, I fail to see any reason why I should go against such person’s wishes and refuse to treat her as a female.

(*) Even if brain sex could be changed, I would have doubts about ethics of such procedures – this would amount to chaging someone’s personality.
Well I actually found fray Serpa’s answer to the issue we are discussing in the apologetics forum:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=566074&highlight=transgender

Fray Serpa indicates that sex change operations do constitute the sin of mutilation of the body which means that changing your sex is not morally licit.
 
Fray Serpa indicates that sex change operations do constitute the sin of mutilation of the body which means that changing your sex is not morally licit.
At which point we run into a larger and well-known problem with Catholic morality, which
is that taking an illicit action (SRS) to prevent a much worse alternative outcome (suicide) does not make that action justified.

In this context, it is difficult for me to understand how the “SRS is illicit” view can be reconciled with Matthew 5:29-30.
 
I did look at the links and did quite research on the internet. There is nothing that indicates that is an official document. The links are all blogs from individuals and news and they don’t even seem to agree about the actual origin of the document. There is no actual proof that the document came from cardinal ratzinger…quite the opposite. Nothing shows it as a binding document and the fact that only individuals and secular people are the ones stating that is a binding document for bishops raises a big question mark as to the document being truly an official document.
I’m afraid I did quite extensive research on this, too. Everything indicates that this is an official document.

The document was reported on by trustworthy, Catholic news outlets at the time of the leak. Why those articles were removed, I do not know; the normal thing for the Vatican to do would just be to announce that the rumors were unfounded. Perhaps it’s simply because of upgrades to new server systems - this is a long time ago, and news outlets don’t always preserve old articles when they upgrade their systems. Additionally, whether or not the document came directly from Cardinal Ratzinger or not is irrelevant. Not everything out of the CDF comes directly from the Prefect, but it sure goes by him if it’s important enough. And unless the Prefect denounces it, it is the position of the CDF until changed. The reason for it being binding for the bishops, is simply that every document sent from the CDF to the bishops regarding interpretation and practice of canon law (which this really boils down to - should baptismal records be changed? No, according to this document. Is the action morally licit in extreme cases of body dysphoria? Yes, according to this document. Can the person marry or receive Holy Orders, or join a religious order after this treatment? No, according to this document), sub secretum or not, is binding unless stated to be simply advisory.
Also, remember the actual official position of the church that is binding for the faithful and promulgated by cardinal ratzinger in 2000 is “sex change operations do NOT change the sex of the person”
First off, you seem to quote the exact same document I’m referring to, which has not been promulgated by anyone, since it’s sub secretum. Please point me to the document you’re referring to, if you’re speaking about a different one - it’s not mentioned anywhere, neither on the Web or in any news article I’ve ever read.

Second, if you’re speaking about the same document, you’re elegantly jumping past the fact that the very same document explicitly says that SRS can be morally licit as a last resort in “extreme cases” (which are the only cases in which the patient receives SRS, just for the record), if it will lessen the patient’s internal turmoil.

Third, the sentence you quote is obvious - SRS does not change the chromosomal composition of the person (which will probably never be possible, and quite dangerous if it were to become so), it does not provide the opposite internal reproduction organs (this will probably become possible, through growing them from one’s own body’s stem cells), etc. But that says nothing about the moral licitness of the treatment at all. It’s simply a fact, which most transsexuals are painfully aware of. Even though I’m not sure reproductive organs is a better indicator of theological gender than the central nervous system, which defines everything about who we are as a person, the conclusions of the document about marriage, ordination etc. are valid, given this as a premise. This choice of premises could change, or it could not, since it’s certainly not proclaimed as dogma. We’ll see.
Well I actually found fray Serpa’s answer to the issue we are discussing in the apologetics forum:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=566074&highlight=transgender

Fray Serpa indicates that sex change operations do constitute the sin of mutilation of the body which means that changing your sex is not morally licit.
While I’m convinced Fr. Serpa is a holy and orthodox priest from his other writings (which I do appreciate when I see them), he is neither infallible nor part of the Magisterium. In this specific case, my opinion and interpretation of the teaching of the Church differs from his. Until such happens that the Church decides to pronounce authoritatively on the matter, I think the referred document, intermediate as it may be, is the best source we have on Church policy on the treatment of transsexualism.
 
And who said that it does? The very reason for SRS is that brain sex cannot be changed (*) but we can change appearance of the body to match what the brain expects. That’s all.
Exactly.
That being said, while I agree that a post-op MTF transsexual is a post-op MTF transsexual and not a female, I fail to see any reason why I should go against such person’s wishes and refuse to treat her as a female.
I’m not sure a post-op MTF transsexual isn’t female - at least, she is most definitely not male. But as I mentioned above, I guess it depends on whether you define male/female by reproductive organs or brain. I think the latter should be more significant, since we don’t think with our reproductive organs. Their hormone production sure tries to control our brains, though - which is what causes body dysphoria. The brain expects one hormone, and gets the other.

That said, I’m glad you treat transsexuals as their perceived gender. This should be common courtesy, but sadly, it’s not.
(*) Even if brain sex could be changed, I would have doubts about ethics of such procedures – this would amount to chaging someone’s personality.
Exactly. I think it’s funny how some people are staunchly against lobotomy, but still probably wouldn’t hesitate giving their transsexual child a treatment that “cured” the condition. “Brain sex” has to do with some of the most fundamental structures in the brain - internal connectivity, volume, etc. The effects could possibly be more drastic than any form of lobotomy; I suspect the person could even be close to unrecognizable after the treatment.
At which point we run into a larger and well-known problem with Catholic morality, which
is that taking an illicit action (SRS) to prevent a much worse alternative outcome (suicide) does not make that action justified.
Not true. Catholic morality says that taking an inherently evil action to prevent a certain outcome (as in, direct abortion because of danger to the mother), is never licit. However, plenty of actions that are generally illicit are licit under certain circumstances - amputations when therapeutically necessary (cancer, gangrene, in my opinion transsexualism), the taking of a life when fighting a just war or in the case of the death penalty when there is no other option (which the Church has stated, and rightly so, is rarely the case in our time), stealing if you’re in danger of death from starvation because of poverty, and so on. The list is long.
In this context, it is difficult for me to understand how the “SRS is illicit” view can be reconciled with Matthew 5:29-30.
True.
 
I’m not sure a post-op MTF transsexual isn’t female - at least, she is most definitely not male.
Well, she isn’t female in a sense that she still has XY genotype and lacks uterus etc.

But really, I cannot understand what the fuss us all about. If someone looks like a female, dresses like a female and acts like a female, to me it’s a female. Why should I even care about someone’s genitals or their genotype, if I’m not going to have sex and/or children with them?
Not true. Catholic morality says that taking an inherently evil action to prevent a certain outcome (as in, direct abortion because of danger to the mother), is never licit.
However, plenty of actions that are generally illicit are licit under certain circumstances -
There was some oversimplification on my part, but never mind.

I just realized that if we say that amputations per se are morally neutral, then we could probably justify SRS under double effect.
 
Well, she isn’t female in a sense that she still has XY genotype and lacks uterus etc.

But really, I cannot understand what the fuss us all about. If someone looks like a female, dresses like a female and acts like a female, to me it’s a female. Why should I even care about someone’s genitals or their genotype, if I’m not going to have sex and/or children with them?
Maybe it’s not integral to your everyday life what gender someone is, but from a theological perspective, it’s EXTRAORDINARILY integral. We’re discussing the difference between supporting or protecting someone in/from their sins on the one hand if transgenderism is not legitimate, and the difference between unnecessarily harming someone and allowing them to do something licit and potentially lifesaving if transgenderism is legitimate.

Though may I add that CAIS women are XY genotype, lack a uterus (and even have internal testes!), etc. Are you suggesting they are not female? Male & female has a clear theological meaning but not as clear of a physical meaning.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top