I cannot see a possible way for a third sex to be theologically legitimate. God created people male or female, period. He also did this for complementary purposes with procreation as well as companionship, a goal that would be completely ignored if He were to create a third sex. In my mind, there is no possible argument for its existence.
The case I think could be made, is that the eunuchs in the New Testament and early Church can be seen as a sort of “third gender”. They were, however, celibate. As are actually many of the “androgynes” of today - it seems to me a large proportion of them are asexual.
That said, these individuals would probably theologically still be either male or female. I doubt there are genderless glorified bodies after the resurrection. So the case to be made is weak at best.
I will also add that, in my experience, those who call themselves a third sex often do so more for political reasons. How many “third sex” individuals do you see that have such a strong identity with it they’ll risk being kicked out of their homes (…) In my opinion, there seems to be no actual disturbance in a “third sex” individual; they just identify that way out of political or ideological motivation.
In the Western world, there are few such individuals. But looking to the East, there are several groups that act like a third gender, and who risk being kicked out of their homes for it; the hijras in India and Pakistan perhaps being the best known example. Some of them may of course simply be transsexual, which seems to be confirmed by the fact that several of them now seek HRT, SRS and integrate to society as women. Some of them may be somewhere in between.
In any case, there are hypotheses (with some support from studies) that androgyny could be caused by insufficient hormonal exposure in
either direction during pregnancy, causing an ungendered brain. Which is why I’m hesitant to write off their existence as a mere idea, until there’s more science to confirm (or deny) the underlying reasons. I also don’t see them doing much damage - if someone wants to dress male one day, and female the next, it’s okay by me. I have no idea how they (except the ones that are asexual) live their sexual lives, but of course sexual morals stay the same, whether the individual is trans, cis or neither.
One can argue the magisterial level of transgenderism and correctly point out that this has not been addressed by name. However, we still have John Paul II’s signature work (…) I do not doubt that if it becomes a more popular concept that it will be addressed by a pope some day, but I would hope that it never becomes that well accepted.
Given the horrible agony transgender individuals experience, and the fact that the popular opinion most orthodox Catholics seem to accept as fact makes this agony even worse, I most certainly
hope it becomes accepted enough for a pope (or at least Rome in some capacity) to clarify how a transgender individual can fit in the Church. Medically, it
is a valid and widely accepted condition, which means it will have to be addressed.
That said, the current state of transsexuals (as in, transgender individuals who have received medical treatment to adjust their bodies to their brains) in the Church is laid out by the much-debated document mentioned earlier in this thread. That document is outdated scientifically, doesn’t really say much theologically at all, but at least it makes clear that sex reassignment is permissible when therapeutically necessary. But since many seem to be unable to recognize even that, I really hope Rome would at least make something like that statement official, not just a sub secretum communication to the bishops we shouldn’t even be aware of. I refer to SMGS’s excellent analysis of that document and its implications, however, instead of laying out the details again.
I know this is a cross some bear. Perhaps all of us that show an inflexibility with traditional sense of masculinity or femininity have driven some into this state of confusion.
Too simple. As a child, I was shown significant flexibility. I was gently guided towards playing with boys instead of girls, and cars instead of dolls. But when I insisted on girls and dolls instead of boys and cars, there was no punishment or emotional abuse - at least not from my parents and most teachers. The boys in my class of course bullied me, and I was severely emotionally abused by one teacher in my fifth year, but in general, my pre-pubertal life wasn’t too bad, compared to what came next. My parents were
definitely not liberal, especially when it came to morals and media exposure, but they were understanding. As you probably understand, my childhood was in no way easy, but my parents, along with most adult role models, were exemplary.
Still, a transsexual person experiences body dysphoria no matter how they dress, act or play as a child (or adult). There’s a sense of disgust of one’s own body that can only be likened to a regular person being forced to have gender reassignment surgery. Imagine if you were kidnapped, put to sleep and woke up as the opposite sex; that is how a transsexual feels every day of his or her life. It generally becomes worse throughout puberty, when the body starts to produce different hormones than what the brain expects. There are of course differences between individuals, but there is one, close to invariable likeness: We fight it until we can’t. And at that point, some commit suicide, others transition. Some just give up and become empty shells. And we all would have had better lives if ideology was replaced with compassion, and preferably if we were discovered and treated early enough to prevent the first, disastrous puberty.