Because empirically, I would think determining gender based on sight would take about two seconds. Now this gender identity theory is so involved as to require MRI’s, blood work, hormone levels, and who knows what. Sure, it is empirical in and of itself, though the result is still theoretical. All of that versus two seconds.
“Empirical evidence (also empirical data, sense experience, empirical knowledge, or the a posteriori) is a source of knowledge acquired by means of observation or experimentation.”
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empirical_evidence - redirected from empirically.
“Sexual dimorphism is a phenotypic difference between males and females of the same species, meaning that there are obvious differences between the male and female of the species.”
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_dimorphism - for below points
Empirical evidence for Gender identity as it pertains to not conforming to simple male or female by sight in all cases:
- Dissection of brain of diseased non-GID individuals and comparison with GID for notes of Sexual Dimorphism. Scientists confirm key differences in brain of GID individuals to match characteristics of gender they identified with. “The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism”, May 2000, p. 2034-2041, Copyright 2000, The Endocrine Society Vol. 85, No. 5"
- Scans of brain with current technology also reflects the above point.
- Digit Ratio (2D:4D) is a sexually dimorphic trait which is viewed to be linked but still being researched for correlation, though patterns are being observed (numerous citations given on wikipedia).
- Intersex individuals defy traditional “by sight” analasys due to underdeveloped/overdeveloped biology.
- 3rd “genders” have been observed in other cultures (primarily in asia) and documented for about a millenia (if memory serves, trying to find citation now).
These are just a few points of trying to point out something “empirically.” I would think, considering there is more to gender than just genetalia empirically (doctors tend to point out the brain as the most important sex organ anyway) that we should be willing to look more than two seconds and realize that you are not defined by your genetalia. To try and pidgeonhole someone based on what you see, I can ask you whether you would think you were male if, by some accident driving or at a workplace, your biology were irreparably damaged and had to be removed, would you stop being male when that is removed? The answer I expect (and have heard every time save once) is no, you wouldn’t. If that is the case, as I presume it would be, why then would you define someone’s gender based on something that, when removed, doesn’t define them due to extraneous circumstances?
I will say I recognize that you probably don’t like that it’s being broken down in this way, and probably used empirical reference more to try and downplay it using oversimplification, but I still felt it important to help show that it isn’t nearly as simple as just “by sight” and hopefully the example above for a situation also helps show this. The result isn’t just for emphirical information, it’s for a very real impact on the people who suffer. If you’re willing to pass them over because your two second rule doesn’t want to see further, it isn’t helping the individuals going through it and is one of the reasons they tend to struggle with greater degrees of homelessness, violence (receiving), and suicide.
As a small note Joie, I was educated pretty quickly that what you’re referring to with “why XY transgender is more common than XX transgender” the more accurate term is transsexual. Transgender is the umbrella term that any gender deviant behavior falls under, from crossdressing to identity difference to a man carrying a pot of water on his head (borrowed that from the person Yeshua told his talmud to look for for a place to celebrate passover/the last supper.) I was told however that the transsexuals, like my friend, tend to prefer transgender because transsexual sounds overly focused on the sexuality of it, rather than the identity, as they do not want to be defined by what kind of sex they have (she tells me many of them choose not to have any at all.)
Anyway, if I were to continue I fear I will ramble and digress, so I will leave it at that. All I know is there’s plenty of experts out in the world who have established guidelines of care, and dismissing them based on conspiracy of undermining x or not liking the answer seems callous.