Doctrine on transgender

  • Thread starter Thread starter FireFromHeaven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That’s backwards. Sexual sin does not “fall under” Lust, it stems from lust.
I am fine with your terminology, it that is what you prefer. “Fall under” (interesting use of quotes, btw) was meant to denote category, not causality. Specifically, all of this is in the same section of the Catechism.
A human brain is essentially an animal brain with higher-level functions glued on top.
But humans are not just higher level animals, which means, we are much more than our brains and our Chemistry, at least if one accepts Catholic theology. We are not just a different kind of apple and lust/attraction is more than dopamine.
Your attempt to identify GID with lust is incorrect.
Point taken. I did not mean to imply the two are related causatively. I was side-tracked.

I do find it ironic that empiricism is used to argue the existence of gender identity. That’s fine. I just find it ironic.
 
I am fine with your terminology, it that is what you prefer. “Fall under” (interesting use of quotes, btw) was meant to denote category, not causality. Specifically, all of this is in the same section of the Catechism. But humans are not just higher level animals, which means, we are much more than our brains and our Chemistry, at least if one accepts Catholic theology. We are not just a different kind of apple and lust/attraction is more than dopamine.
Point taken. I did not mean to imply the two are related causatively. I was side-tracked.

I do find it ironic that empiricism is used to argue the existence of gender identity. That’s fine. I just find it ironic.
Why is it ironic?
 
Why is it ironic?
Because empirically, I would think determining gender based on sight would take about two seconds. Now this gender identity theory is so involved as to require MRI’s, blood work, hormone levels, and who knows what. Sure, it is empirical in and of itself, though the result is still theoretical. All of that versus two seconds.
 
Because empirically, I would think determining gender based on sight would take about two seconds. Now this gender identity theory is so involved as to require MRI’s, blood work, hormone levels, and who knows what. Sure, it is empirical in and of itself, though the result is still theoretical. All of that versus two seconds.
That’s a rather modern definition of gender.
 
Because empirically, I would think determining gender based on sight would take about two seconds. Now this gender identity theory is so involved as to require MRI’s, blood work, hormone levels, and who knows what. Sure, it is empirical in and of itself, though the result is still theoretical. All of that versus two seconds.
“Empirical evidence (also empirical data, sense experience, empirical knowledge, or the a posteriori) is a source of knowledge acquired by means of observation or experimentation.” en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empirical_evidence - redirected from empirically.
“Sexual dimorphism is a phenotypic difference between males and females of the same species, meaning that there are obvious differences between the male and female of the species.” en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_dimorphism - for below points

Empirical evidence for Gender identity as it pertains to not conforming to simple male or female by sight in all cases:
  • Dissection of brain of diseased non-GID individuals and comparison with GID for notes of Sexual Dimorphism. Scientists confirm key differences in brain of GID individuals to match characteristics of gender they identified with. “The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism”, May 2000, p. 2034-2041, Copyright 2000, The Endocrine Society Vol. 85, No. 5"
  • Scans of brain with current technology also reflects the above point.
  • Digit Ratio (2D:4D) is a sexually dimorphic trait which is viewed to be linked but still being researched for correlation, though patterns are being observed (numerous citations given on wikipedia).
  • Intersex individuals defy traditional “by sight” analasys due to underdeveloped/overdeveloped biology.
  • 3rd “genders” have been observed in other cultures (primarily in asia) and documented for about a millenia (if memory serves, trying to find citation now).
These are just a few points of trying to point out something “empirically.” I would think, considering there is more to gender than just genetalia empirically (doctors tend to point out the brain as the most important sex organ anyway) that we should be willing to look more than two seconds and realize that you are not defined by your genetalia. To try and pidgeonhole someone based on what you see, I can ask you whether you would think you were male if, by some accident driving or at a workplace, your biology were irreparably damaged and had to be removed, would you stop being male when that is removed? The answer I expect (and have heard every time save once) is no, you wouldn’t. If that is the case, as I presume it would be, why then would you define someone’s gender based on something that, when removed, doesn’t define them due to extraneous circumstances?

I will say I recognize that you probably don’t like that it’s being broken down in this way, and probably used empirical reference more to try and downplay it using oversimplification, but I still felt it important to help show that it isn’t nearly as simple as just “by sight” and hopefully the example above for a situation also helps show this. The result isn’t just for emphirical information, it’s for a very real impact on the people who suffer. If you’re willing to pass them over because your two second rule doesn’t want to see further, it isn’t helping the individuals going through it and is one of the reasons they tend to struggle with greater degrees of homelessness, violence (receiving), and suicide.

As a small note Joie, I was educated pretty quickly that what you’re referring to with “why XY transgender is more common than XX transgender” the more accurate term is transsexual. Transgender is the umbrella term that any gender deviant behavior falls under, from crossdressing to identity difference to a man carrying a pot of water on his head (borrowed that from the person Yeshua told his talmud to look for for a place to celebrate passover/the last supper.) I was told however that the transsexuals, like my friend, tend to prefer transgender because transsexual sounds overly focused on the sexuality of it, rather than the identity, as they do not want to be defined by what kind of sex they have (she tells me many of them choose not to have any at all.)
Anyway, if I were to continue I fear I will ramble and digress, so I will leave it at that. All I know is there’s plenty of experts out in the world who have established guidelines of care, and dismissing them based on conspiracy of undermining x or not liking the answer seems callous.
 
I’d be very careful with the word “impossible” with respect to capabilities of modern medicine.

Do you think that brain has gender, i.e. do you think that a male and female brain differs phisiologically?
This might give some insight.

hawaii.edu/PCSS/biblio/articles/1961to1999/1997-sex-reassignment.html
Mother recalls: “As soon as he had the surgery, the doctor said I should now start treating him as a girl, doing girl things and putting him in girl’s clothes. But that was a disaster. I put this beautiful little dress on him, … and he [immediately tried] to rip it off… I think he knew it was a dress and that it was for girls and he wasn’t a girl.”
On the other hand, Joan could act quite feminine when she wanted to, and was reported as doing so, e.g. mother was quoted to have said: "One thing that really amazes me is that she is so feminine. I’ve never seen a little girl so neat and tidy as she can be when she wants to be… (pp. 119)."11 However, she most often, would prefer to reject such behavior. It was also more common that she, much more than the twin brother, would mimic Father. One incident Mother related was typical: When the twins were about 4 or 5 they were watching their parents. Father was shaving and Mother applying makeup. Joan applied shaving cream and pretended to shave. When Joan was corrected and told to put on lipstick and makeup like Mother, Joan said: “No, I don’t want no makeup, I want to shave.”
Girl’s toys, clothes and activities were repeatedly proffered to Joan and most often rejected. Throughout childhood Joan preferred boy’s activities and games to those of girl’s; she had little interest in dolls, sewing or girl’s activities. Ignoring the toys she was given, she would play with her brother’s toys. She preferred to tinker with gadgets and tools and dress up in men’s clothing; take things apart to see what makes them tick. She was regarded as a tomboy with an interest in playing soldier. Joan did not shun rough and tumble sports nor avoid fights.
spiegel.de/international/germany/intersex-activists-call-for-ban-on-surgical-operations-on-children-a-931213.html
Many intersex adults experienced painful and traumatic treatments in their childhood, and controversial medical interventions are still common. After a vaginoplasty, or the surgical construction of a vagina, for example, dilators have to be inserted on a regular basis for the rest of the person’s life to prevent the vaginal walls from collapsing. “I’ve heard from many who experienced that as a kind of routine sexual invasion,” Veith says.
The decision to live as a man or woman, or to live outside the gender binary, should rest with the individual, Veith says, once they’ve reached sexual maturity. Her organization calls for a legal ban on any medically unnecessary interventions before the child’s 16th birthday.
 
Yes, that concerns the well-known case of David Reimer. As an adult he appeared on the Oprah show to discuss what happened, and a somewhat popular book was written about his experiences. It was titled: As Nature Made Him.

His life has become a textbook example that gender identity is innate, and can not be imposed by parents or doctors. Only the individual knows whether s/he is male or female.
 
Yes, that concerns the well-known case of David Reimer. As an adult he appeared on the Oprah show to discuss what happened, and a somewhat popular book was written about his experiences. It was titled: As Nature Made Him.

His life has become a textbook example that gender identity is innate, and can not be imposed by parents or doctors. Only the individual knows whether s/he is male or female.
Thanks for the info. There are youtube videos online regarding David Reimer just a click away for anybody interested.

The more one digs into this the more bizarre it gets. One has to really use their imagination to visualize the consequences of this surgery.

‘‘Oh my artificial vagina just collapsed and i am running out of hormone pills and i gotta get some Depends undergarments because i am now incontinent!’’ :eek:

C’mon is it really worth it? Is it really helping these people out in the long run? 🤷
 
The more one digs into this the more bizarre it gets. One has to really use their imagination to visualize the consequences of this surgery.
It was horrible what was done to him, and sadly, he wasn’t the only such case. From what I understand, it was fairly routine to do this to intersex infants 30 or 40 years ago. It was considered in the best interest of the child to be shaped, physically and socially, as the doctor and parents thought best.

Nowadays, physicians are extremely reluctant to perform surgery on an intersex infants, if the only purpose is to make ambiguous genitals appear more "normal. Medical experts no longer believe that social conditioning can determine gender identity. Only the individual knows whether s/he is male or female. Gender identity can not be imposed on by others.
 
Thanks for the info. There are youtube videos online regarding David Reimer just a click away for anybody interested.

The more one digs into this the more bizarre it gets. One has to really use their imagination to visualize the consequences of this surgery.

‘‘Oh my artificial vagina just collapsed and i am running out of hormone pills and i gotta get some Depends undergarments because i am now incontinent!’’ :eek:

C’mon is it really worth it? Is it really helping these people out in the long run? 🤷
Maybe you should ask yourself why people go to such lengths, spend so much money, and expend so much effort, when the risks are so high, if you don’t believe it to be an actual medical condition.

Oh, and by the way, medications for heart disease typically carry a fatality risk. Are you suggesting we shouldn’t treat heart disease because the treatment can end up having a terrible side effect? Lumbar punctures can potentially paralyze a person from the waist down; should we never use them if meningitis is suspected?

But either way, you’re free to believe whatever you want on the issue, as long as it’s in line with other, vaguer doctrine. If you wish to believe that there is no legitimacy to the condition, that is your right, just as Rin has the right to believe very firmly in the legitimacy of the condition. Neither position is heterodox, and until and unless the Vatican issues a public statement on the issue, neither position will be heterodox.
 
Maybe you should ask yourself why people go to such lengths, spend so much money, and expend so much effort, when the risks are so high, if you don’t believe it to be an actual medical condition.
You assume i haven’t? I do try to be emphatic but this is so bizarre it is difficult to fathom.
Oh, and by the way, medications for heart disease typically carry a fatality risk. Are you suggesting we shouldn’t treat heart disease because the treatment can end up having a terrible side effect?
Sure heart disease has risks. Maybe i’m just a cold blood SOB but there is a world of difference between heart disease and sex reassignment surgery. They are not even on the same level in my book. Lets not legitimize SRS with heart disease surgery.
Lumbar punctures can potentially paralyze a person from the waist down; should we never use them if meningitis is suspected?
Yeah and with SRS you have the risk of fecal matter coming through the constructed vagina into the pink lace undies.
But either way, you’re free to believe whatever you want on the issue, as long as it’s in line with other, vaguer doctrine. If you wish to believe that there is no legitimacy to the condition, that is your right, just as Rin has the right to believe very firmly in the legitimacy of the condition. Neither position is heterodox, and until and unless the Vatican issues a public statement on the issue, neither position will be heterodox.
Just keep waiting on the Vatican. That is your right.
 
You assume i haven’t? I do try to be emphatic but this is so bizarre it is difficult to fathom.

Just keep waiting on the Vatican. That is your right.
  1. You don’t have to put your brain on hold to be Catholic.
  2. You don’t have to be so open minded your brains fall out.
Think about it this way. Let’s say that two parents, 40 years from now, reallllly want a girl no matter what. They’re going to have a boy (though they don’t know that at this early a stage of pregnancy), but they use newly developed technology to inject aMH (anti-Mullerian hormone) blockers and SRT silencers into the fetus so that, no matter what the child would normally be, they end up with female genitalia and female reproductive organs.

What gender is this child, in your opinion, from a well-formed Catholic mindset? And what treatment should there be for the child after they are born, if any, in your opinion?
 
Think about it this way. Let’s say that two parents, 40 years from now, reallllly want a girl no matter what. They’re going to have a boy (though they don’t know that at this early a stage of pregnancy), but they use newly developed technology to inject aMH (anti-Mullerian hormone) blockers and SRT silencers into the fetus so that, no matter what the child would normally be, they end up with female genitalia and female reproductive organs.

What gender is this child, in your opinion, from a well-formed Catholic mindset? And what treatment should there be for the child after they are born, if any, in your opinion?
Let nature take its course. Settle for the boy. Trust in God.
 
Let nature take its course. Settle for the boy. Trust in God.
That’s not my point. I’m saying that if a Protestant couple, who have no caring for what Catholics think, ALREADY DOES THIS, what should we do with the resulting child? Should we treat “her” as a girl even though the child will most likely identify with their true gender? Should we treat “him” as a boy even though all of the child’s reproductive organs and genitalia would be female?

The point people are making now is that accidental errors already happen in utero that do these things. Look at hermaphrodism, intersexism, etc. Why is it so hard to believe that a child could be unnaturally affected by aMH (or produce too few aMH) and have their biological sex altered from their true gender as a result of original sin? Unborn children are still people and still have gender; just because their genitalia is not defined yet does not mean they don’t.
 
That’s not my point. I’m saying that if a Protestant couple, who have no caring for what Catholics think, ALREADY DOES THIS, what should we do with the resulting child? Should we treat “her” as a girl even though the child will most likely identify with their true gender? Should we treat “him” as a boy even though all of the child’s reproductive organs and genitalia would be female?

The point people are making now is that accidental errors already happen in utero that do these things. Look at hermaphrodism, intersexism, etc. Why is it so hard to believe that a child could be unnaturally affected by aMH (or produce too few aMH) and have their biological sex altered from their true gender as a result of original sin? Unborn children are still people and still have gender; just because their genitalia is not defined yet does not mean they don’t.
Does rape and incest justify legal abortion?
 
Does rape and incest justify legal abortion?
Absolutely not. The life of a child always takes precedence over the reason the life came to be. The only way the life of a child can be “terminated” is if a mother requires a necessary medical procedure that has the side effect of the loss of the child (such as removal of her uterus to save her life).

How does this have any relevance whatsoever?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top