R
Rin
Guest
I never pictured you a relativist. Thanks for admitting to itIt is relevant to me. Welcome to forum posting. It is what we do. I am sure your** opinion** that this is actually scientifically definitive is relevant to you.
More seriously, by all means feel free to reject medical science. It is your right. But still, my statements stays - it is general recognized as a valid, medical condition among people qualified to have an opinion, and you canât just wish that away.
The people responsible for including it in the DSM agree with me. They say the same thing about several other neurobiological disorders, like autism and ADHD - neither of them are psychological in the popular meaning of the word, but theyâre in the DSM since theyâre only diagnosable through psychiatric evaluation at the moment.Well, that again is your opinion. The evidence remains. It is still listed as a mental disorder in the DSM.
In general, when the medical community explains why something is (or is not) in the DSM or any other diagnostic manual, I prefer to believe them. Iâm not a medical professional or a neurobiologist, and forming my own opinion in a field I have not studied professionally would simply be intellectually dishonest. Hence, I go with the consensus, as has proved to be a rather reliable criterion with solid scientific results.
Again, not simply my opinion. The fact that you read opinions about transgenderism into the texts, does not make them relevant. That is a fact. The scientific studies indicating a neurobiological cause are facts.Again your opinion. There are links above. They link teaching. The teaching is from Catholic sources. These are facts, as opposed to theories and opinions. What does not exist is any infallible or magisterial teaching on transgenderism per se.
That is not simply an opinion, but well founded scientific fact, proved through autopsy of regular males and females, compared to autopsies of transgender males and females. There is at the moment no evidence to contradict that, but several studies that support it.Again, your opinion that it is possible to have a brain with gender identification.
Would you say that evolution is just an âopinionâ, too? In that case we can just as well end this exchange, since debating when one side rejects a vast portion of modern science simply isnât fruitful.
Show me statistics, please. Most areas who ascribe to hinduism and/or buddhism, have also had âthird gendersâ, which presupposes a difference between mental gender and biological sex.Throughout history, many more have believed in reincarnation than have believed in brain gender.
By the way, âbelieving youâre Napoleonâ is not representative of belief in reincarnation, but a caricature introduced to the West through New Age, and of course as a mockery of the Eastern religions. So throughout history, very few have believed in that possibility.
Forgive me if I misunderstood you, but given your earlier tendency toward likening transgenderism to things like âbelieving you are a petuniaâ, the conclusion regarding ridicule wasnât too far off. The fact that âbelieving youâre Napoleonâ is a common way to describe âlunaticsâ, just adds to that picture.In fact, if one is prone to always disregard the possibility for self-delusion, then one can also find people that have undergone regression therapy and have reported on previous lives. I do not believe in that either, but that is why I used that particular analogy. It was not ridicule. If it seemed that way, it is only because this whole subject is prone to be seen that way.
That said, self-deception is absolutely something to be considered. However, studies of transgender brains seem to contradict that possibility. So unless science as such is a deception, there seems to be no self-deception involved in properly diagnosed transgenderism.
Creative use of Occamâs Razor, there. But the simplest solution has to take evidence into account. Thereâs massive evidence of the condition existing in all cultures and throughout time, with similar prevalence. Thereâs also an amounting evidence for a biological cause.So I tried to answer the OP and post the best-existing Catholic sources I can find. No Catholic sources have been posted to the contrary, or that contradicted them. We have had opinions. I have read some science. I have read opinions about the science. In the end, I will use the simple logic of Occamâs Razor and stick with the simplest solution, which also coincides with Catholic teaching to date.
The way you use Occamâs Razor would inevitably result in the opinion that epistemological skepticism is the simplest solution to everything - if the material/external world simply doesnât exist, everything is a deception and/or simulation, and that explains everything. No further research needed. Which is why the need to take evidence, without selection based on ideology, into account, is important.
Thatâs good to hear. Yet, you keep referring to âCatholic teaching to dateâ when there is none. Isnât that suggesting that this is the Catholic opinion?That being said (my opinion), I do not want to even suggest that this is the Catholic opinion, or that others cannot totally believe that transgenderism is more legitimate than I do.