Doctrine on transgender

  • Thread starter Thread starter FireFromHeaven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It is relevant to me. Welcome to forum posting. It is what we do. I am sure your** opinion** that this is actually scientifically definitive is relevant to you.
I never pictured you a relativist. Thanks for admitting to it 😉

More seriously, by all means feel free to reject medical science. It is your right. But still, my statements stays - it is general recognized as a valid, medical condition among people qualified to have an opinion, and you can’t just wish that away.
Well, that again is your opinion. The evidence remains. It is still listed as a mental disorder in the DSM.
The people responsible for including it in the DSM agree with me. They say the same thing about several other neurobiological disorders, like autism and ADHD - neither of them are psychological in the popular meaning of the word, but they’re in the DSM since they’re only diagnosable through psychiatric evaluation at the moment.

In general, when the medical community explains why something is (or is not) in the DSM or any other diagnostic manual, I prefer to believe them. I’m not a medical professional or a neurobiologist, and forming my own opinion in a field I have not studied professionally would simply be intellectually dishonest. Hence, I go with the consensus, as has proved to be a rather reliable criterion with solid scientific results.
Again your opinion. There are links above. They link teaching. The teaching is from Catholic sources. These are facts, as opposed to theories and opinions. What does not exist is any infallible or magisterial teaching on transgenderism per se.
Again, not simply my opinion. The fact that you read opinions about transgenderism into the texts, does not make them relevant. That is a fact. The scientific studies indicating a neurobiological cause are facts.
Again, your opinion that it is possible to have a brain with gender identification.
That is not simply an opinion, but well founded scientific fact, proved through autopsy of regular males and females, compared to autopsies of transgender males and females. There is at the moment no evidence to contradict that, but several studies that support it.

Would you say that evolution is just an “opinion”, too? In that case we can just as well end this exchange, since debating when one side rejects a vast portion of modern science simply isn’t fruitful.
Throughout history, many more have believed in reincarnation than have believed in brain gender.
Show me statistics, please. Most areas who ascribe to hinduism and/or buddhism, have also had “third genders”, which presupposes a difference between mental gender and biological sex.

By the way, “believing you’re Napoleon” is not representative of belief in reincarnation, but a caricature introduced to the West through New Age, and of course as a mockery of the Eastern religions. So throughout history, very few have believed in that possibility.
In fact, if one is prone to always disregard the possibility for self-delusion, then one can also find people that have undergone regression therapy and have reported on previous lives. I do not believe in that either, but that is why I used that particular analogy. It was not ridicule. If it seemed that way, it is only because this whole subject is prone to be seen that way.
Forgive me if I misunderstood you, but given your earlier tendency toward likening transgenderism to things like “believing you are a petunia”, the conclusion regarding ridicule wasn’t too far off. The fact that “believing you’re Napoleon” is a common way to describe “lunatics”, just adds to that picture.

That said, self-deception is absolutely something to be considered. However, studies of transgender brains seem to contradict that possibility. So unless science as such is a deception, there seems to be no self-deception involved in properly diagnosed transgenderism.
So I tried to answer the OP and post the best-existing Catholic sources I can find. No Catholic sources have been posted to the contrary, or that contradicted them. We have had opinions. I have read some science. I have read opinions about the science. In the end, I will use the simple logic of Occam’s Razor and stick with the simplest solution, which also coincides with Catholic teaching to date.
Creative use of Occam’s Razor, there. But the simplest solution has to take evidence into account. There’s massive evidence of the condition existing in all cultures and throughout time, with similar prevalence. There’s also an amounting evidence for a biological cause.

The way you use Occam’s Razor would inevitably result in the opinion that epistemological skepticism is the simplest solution to everything - if the material/external world simply doesn’t exist, everything is a deception and/or simulation, and that explains everything. No further research needed. Which is why the need to take evidence, without selection based on ideology, into account, is important.
That being said (my opinion), I do not want to even suggest that this is the Catholic opinion, or that others cannot totally believe that transgenderism is more legitimate than I do.
That’s good to hear. Yet, you keep referring to “Catholic teaching to date” when there is none. Isn’t that suggesting that this is the Catholic opinion?
 
I can respect this. I personally would never suggest to anyone that transgenderism is legitimate either. I accept the possibility that it is a biological abnormality caused by original sin that leads to the development of the incorrect reproductive system, and I accept the possibility that it is a psychological abnormality caused by original sin that causes one to be unable to accept their true sex.
The mind and the body are connected, so I see what you are saying. Perhaps what we are discussing is somewhat a matter of semantic. Terms like “gender”, psychological abnormality" and even “transgender” may change. If you change the meaning of the word “gender” then what is a delusion becomes an understanding (and visa versa). I use the terms in a traditional sense. I guess this is obvious, but I do not believe that a person looks at their physical genitalia and sees something that is not there. Of course everyone know what gender they physically are. I just use the term gender to refer to that undeniable absolute, the primary sexual characteristic.

In practice, I do not think this is much of an issue. We still deal with all people as people first. There are a few quirks that come up in society, but these should be easily handled by those involved.
 
I never pictured you a relativist. Thanks for admitting to it 😉
You do not use that word correctly, so lame name-calling is probably not a good idea. Having an opinion does not mean one is a relativist. I do not reject medical science. I did not reject science.
Again, not simply my opinion. The fact that you read opinions about transgenderism into the texts, does not make them relevant. That is a fact. The scientific studies indicating a neurobiological cause are facts.
No, it is evidence in support of a theory.
Would you say that evolution is just an “opinion”, too?
That would be a well supported theory.
The way you use Occam’s Razor would inevitably result in the opinion that epistemological skepticism is the simplest solution to everything -
I believe a valid tool and my use appropriate. Yes, I am skeptical about many things, including science. If a tobacco company performs research on the effects of tobacco, it is good to examine the results skeptically. Our society has seriously deteriorated morals. I do have some skepticism when it comes to research that is done to justify some agendas. True science is blind. It is also rare when it comes to political issues.
 
It seems evident (to me) that we humans are,** by design**, either male or female, and opposite sex attracted. It is evidently the case that for some folks, something goes “awry” and such folks may find themselves with one or more conditions, such as same sex attraction, gender dysphoria, intesex, etc.

Do we care, from the moral perspective, whether what went awry is of a biological origin, a psychological origin, or any other origin?

I would have thought that the key issue here is that there is no shame or sin in any of these conditions, and the origin of the condition has no implications for any issue of morality.
 
You do not use that word correctly, so lame name-calling is probably not a good idea. Having an opinion does not mean one is a relativist. I do not reject medical science. I did not reject science.
The sentence you quoted was meant as a friendly joke, as indicated by the winky. I am aware I stretched the term a bit.

That said, I’d say accusing someone of being delusional is far more serious than accusing someone of relativism, based on their random acceptance of data (and constant use of “opinion”, which triggered the joke).
No, it is evidence in support of a theory.
I’m sorry, but your hypothesis isn’t supported by what you provide as evidence.
That would be a well supported theory.
And “brain sex” is well supported by empirical studies so far. Of course it’s nowhere nearly as well supported as evolution, but there’s still no reason to reject it based on current data. That would constitute cherry picking based on preference, not evidence.
I believe a valid tool and my use appropriate. Yes, I am skeptical about many things, including science. If a tobacco company performs research on the effects of tobacco, it is good to examine the results skeptically. Our society has seriously deteriorated morals. I do have some skepticism when it comes to research that is done to justify some agendas. True science is blind. It is also rare when it comes to political issues.
I agree Occam’s razor is a valid tool, but you’re applying it incorrectly. It can never be used to discard data. It simply says that when you have differing theories satisfying the same set of data, the simplest should be selected.

I have yet to see traces of this “agenda” you’re speaking about in the medical research on transgenderism. There’s certainly an agenda in the “gender science” which is part of the humanities (to which I have nothing against, but some of the newer fields are indeed agenda-ridden) - but the data I’m referring to directly contradicts that agenda, since it indicates that mental gender (along with gender roles) is more or less fixed. Which is why radical feminists are often even more anti-trans than “conservatives” (I object to placing this in the liberal-conservative scale, since people’s opinions are unpredictable. The only person who hasn’t accepted me in real life is ultra-liberal, and on top of that gay, and the most accepting of my friends and family are conservative).
I use the terms in a traditional sense.
Still, terms change in meaning, and using them in a “traditional sense” is a strategy to get away with unacceptable language and/or refuse to acknowledge scientific progress more often than not.

I could insist on calling people with mental disabilities “morons” or “retards”, since that is the original meaning of those terms. Insisting on calling transgender individuals “delusional” is as rude as it is inaccurate and scientifically unfounded.
 
Do we care, from the moral perspective, whether what went awry is of a biological origin, a psychological origin, or any other origin?

I would have thought that the key issue here is that there is no shame or sin in any of these conditions, and the origin of the condition has no implications for any issue of morality.
I don’t think a single person here would disagree with you that there is no shame and sin as far as the conditions go. But it does matter the origin, because it could determine the morality of modern treatment for the condition. Obviously, in the case of homosexuality, the morality has already been doctrinally stated (that one afflicted by same-sex attractions, regardless of origin, must abstain). However, in the case of transsexuality, the origin is important in understanding whether their identity can be theologically correct, whether their identity can be treated through modern means (through so-called “sex change” surgery & hormones) or not morally, and/or whether they could, in the future, be eligible for marriage or Holy Orders in the future.

I will say that a post-operative “FtM” transgender person almost certainly will be barred from marriage for life; there is no way for them to establish full potency as a male, as it is defined as erection, penetration, and ejaculation, the latter of which they cannot achieve (at least currently). Virtually every other question is still up in the air though.
 
I would have thought that the key issue here is that there is no shame or sin in any of these conditions, and the origin of the condition has no implications for any issue of morality.
I think you have a point.
 
I came across an interesting connection between the stria terminalis and pedophilia. So, if we say variance in this part of the brain is indicative of “brain sex”, how do we not also define pedophilia as a gender? I see this as the problem with the current transgender rhetoric. Over the course of my life, I have observed a slippery slope that has not even slowed as to redefining something as simple as male and female. In the end, I do not even know if it matters. If a person want to call themselves something, what do I care. It doesn’t really change much. I will stick with male and female and ignore any novelty.
 
I came across an interesting connection between the stria terminalis and pedophilia. So, if we say variance in this part of the brain is indicative of “brain sex”, how do we not also define pedophilia as a gender?
The differences observed in relation to gender identity are far more extensive than the stria terminalis alone. But you are correct there is some neurological connection between gender and orientation - there is a working hypothesis (albeit not supported by evidence at this point) that homosexuality could be caused by a “light version” of the hormonal disturbance in utero believed to cause transgenderism. I’m not convinced, but it can’t reject it until there’s data that contradicts it.

However, there is absolutely no reason to define a sexual orientation, or in this case a paraphilia, as gender. There are male pedophiles, and female pedophiles. Just as there are male homosexuals and female homosexuals, and even male heterosexuals and female heterosexuals.

You’re grasping at straws here.
I see this as the problem with the current transgender rhetoric. Over the course of my life, I have observed a slippery slope that has not even slowed as to redefining something as simple as male and female.
The slippery slope argument is, and remains, a fallacy.

Also, no matter what you believe, male and female is in no way simple. And repeating that it is, won’t make it so. Biological sex can’t be identified from chromosomes alone - there are XY women and XX men (born that way, just to be clear). There are XXY, XXX, XXXY etc. individuals. There are people whose individual cells even have different chromosomes. Genitals aren’t sufficient, either; there are people with a penis and ovaries, and with a vagina and internal testes. In some cases, doctors can only make a qualified guess about their gender or sex, and in some cases, it’s simply indeterminable.

So no, male and female is not simple. No more simple (or perfectly ordered) than planetary movement turned out to be. It’s a mess, simply put.
In the end, I do not even know if it matters. If a person want to call themselves something, what do I care. It doesn’t really change much. I will stick with male and female and ignore any novelty.
By ignoring any “novelty” (which transsexualism most certainly isn’t, as pointed out numerous times in this and other threads), you’re effectively sticking your head in the ground. Facts don’t change because you ignore them.

But by all means, it is your right. I will however recommend that you follow common courtesy in real life encounters with transgender individuals, by calling them by the name, pronouns and titles they identify with, and showing general respect, so as not to hurt their relationship with the Church. You haven’t said anything to the contrary, so it could very well be you already do so. In that case, I commend you.
 
The slippery slope argument is, and remains, a fallacy.
No, it is** not **a fallacy. You are wrong about that. It *can *be a fallacy. Since the issue of sexuality is built on precedents, for one, this is not a fallacy. Unfortunately, I am old enough, have seen enough and know enough history first hand to accept your simple claim of, “Fallacy.” You might as well try and convince me the sun is going to start setting in the East.
 
No, it is** not **a fallacy. You are wrong about that. It *can *be a fallacy. Since the issue of sexuality is built on precedents, for one, this is not a fallacy. Unfortunately, I am old enough, have seen enough and know enough history first hand to accept your simple claim of, “Fallacy.” You might as well try and convince me the sun is going to start setting in the East.
Couldn’t help but interject here, especially with recently studying some debate tactics, specifically logical fallacies. You are correct in that it can be a fallacy, but considering you failed to explain the middle points of your slippery slope argument with information or citation and followed up your statement with only a red herring (sun setting changing) and your original argument was an appeal to personal experience, it is safe to say that your argument so far presented is a fallible slippery slope, instead of a plausible one. If you wish to make the connection between transgenderism and pedophilia, please provide information from a credible peer reviewed citation to give your slippery slope argument validity.

Anyway, by all means continue the debate, I’m finding plenty of interesting points/arguments/debating going on here and enjoy seeing most of the individuals here trying to sort things out and come to some kind of compromise (ideally)
 
I will not comment on ridiculous, impossible situations.
I’d be very careful with the word “impossible” with respect to capabilities of modern medicine.
If a man is a woman based on his own identity, i.e., he “feels” like a woman, then anyone who thinks he is the re-incarnation of Napoleon is the Emperor of France.
Do you think that brain has gender, i.e. do you think that a male and female brain differs phisiologically?
 
I don’t think a single person here would disagree with you that there is no shame and sin as far as the conditions go. But it does matter the origin, because it could determine the morality of modern treatment for the condition. Obviously, in the case of homosexuality, the morality has already been doctrinally stated (that one afflicted by same-sex attractions, regardless of origin, must abstain). However, in the case of transsexuality, the origin is important in understanding whether their identity can be theologically correct, whether their identity can be treated through modern means (through so-called “sex change” surgery & hormones) or not morally, and/or whether they could, in the future, be eligible for marriage or Holy Orders in the future.

I will say that a post-operative “FtM” transgender person almost certainly will be barred from marriage for life; there is no way for them to establish full potency as a male, as it is defined as erection, penetration, and ejaculation, the latter of which they cannot achieve (at least currently). Virtually every other question is still up in the air though.
Certainly the origin of these conditions is important to know as it will determine the potential or otherwise for treatment, the potential efficacy of treatments.

I don’t understand this idea of theological identity, if that is the correct expression. Can you explain? Can you also outline how the cause of a condition determines or limits what is moral treatment?

It seems likely to me that some (rare) individuals will defy classification as male or female - they simple won’t meet the tests we establish for either gender. I presume such cannot be priests and cannot marry?
 
Do you think that brain has gender, i.e. do you think that a male and female brain differs phisiologically?
I agree that considering the consequences of a “head transplant” is a valid thought experiment, though probably not a fertile reseach area:D

The brain and rest of body are intertwined. Just as a person who has a leg amputated continues to “feel” the leg for a while, so a woman’s brain adapts in various ways because the attached body is in fact a woman.

As to whether the brain takes on female characteristic when the body does not, I don’t know. But it does suggest care is needed in sorting out cause and effect.
 
You are correct in that it can be a fallacy, but considering you failed to explain the middle points of your slippery slope argument with information or citation and followed up your statement with only a red herring (sun setting changing) and your original argument was an appeal to personal experience, it is safe to say that your argument so far presented is a fallible slippery slope, instead of a plausible one.
I should of course have specified this - there are indeed observed slippery slopes, but they are a rhetorical fallacy unless the “steps” are proved to be logical necessities (effect guaranteed by the cause), or at least statistically very likely to occur.

The most common example of an observed slippery slope, is euthanasia in Holland and Belgium. The situation in those countries is horrible. But then there are jurisdictions where careful legalization of euthanasia in extreme examples has not developed slippery-slopily like in those countries. Which proves that the slippery slope is not a necessity following from euthanasia as such, but probably caused by some other variable.

That said, euthanasia is of course morally reprehensible regardless of whether it triggers a slippery slope, so this is not an argument for legalization. A society that gives up on its citizens who suffer like that, is no longer human. But it is an interesting example of why one should be very careful with using slippery slope rhetoric. Most often, there are more solid arguments.

Another false slippery slope argument I’ve seen used for decades now, is the “acceptance of homosexuality will eventually lead to acceptance of pedophilia” argument. Yet, since the first time I heard someone say that, pedophilia is even more hated, while homosexuality is even more accepted. Awareness regarding pedophilia has also increased, so it’s not only more hated, but more feared. Sometimes to the extent of people throwing away common principles of justice; I’ve even seen a politician say it is better if ten innocent people are convicted than if one child is is abused. That is obviously misguided (and dangerous), but it is also a clear sign that pedophilia is nowhere near being accepted. Yet, despite all evidence pointing to the contrary, I still see people claiming “pedophilia will be accepted next”. That goes against experience, and not least against logic and intellectual honesty.

That said, the people who claimed that acceptance of gay unions would lead to redefinition of marriage in secular society, proved correct. But that’s not really a slippery slope - it has been a pronounced goal for the LGB movement for decades.

To sum it up, while there are observed slippery slopes, they’re more often false than not, and very difficult to predict. It’s also very difficult to identify where they start. In the case of euthanasia in the above-mentioned countries, did it start with acceptance of euthanasia in rare cases, or with abortion (both of which are morally wrong regardless of the slope), or with some other, seemingly independent, change of “cultural mind”? And why haven’t those events started similar slopes in other countries?

In the case of the liturgical chaos that has ridden the Church for decades now (which seems to have been a valid slippery slope - and now I guess I should duck 😉 ), did it start with the liturgical reform of Pope Paul VI, with the “intermediate form” in the sixties, with the introduction of St. Joseph to the Canon, with the 1955 Triduum reform, Psalter reform, or something else? The best analysis I’ve ever seen, concludes that the slope started when people started poking looking holes in the carpet which separated the sanctuary from the people in the ancient Latin Rite, and that the current chaos simply is a result of an increasing “see, hear and understand” trend that has been going on since then.

So it’s not only difficult to identify a valid slippery slope before it occurs, but also to identify the starting point after it has occurred. Which is why they’re generally not very useful in debates.
 
Couldn’t help but interject here, especially with recently studying some debate tactics, specifically logical fallacies. Anyway, by all means continue the debate,)
I wasn’t commenting as a debater. I was speaking from the one thing that cannot be denied - my own life experience. On the internet, there is truth and falsehood. Firsthand knowledge is more reliable, at least for the individual. I am not debating because I am stating my opinions without a desire to persuade anyone.

However, if I were to add some substance to the slippery slope argument, I do not need medical evidence connecting the two. The connection is not medical. It is moral The problem is not medical. It is moral. The connection is that all sexual sin falls under the sin of Lust, one of the seven biggies. Do I have to convince others that it is human nature to justify our sins? Do I have to explain that vocabulary is a battlefield in the justification of sin on a societal scale? Like our legal system, language is based on precedent. For example, once “X- challenged” (substitute anything for the “X”) is used in the media, the courts or professional circles, we find it more accepted and “X” is popping up all over the place.

I came across this interesting video a while back. Almost all of these have arisen as a societal “right” and or definition within my life. What evidence do I have that sexual “age” won’t be the next right?

youtube.com/watch?v=xXAoG8vAyzI
 
What evidence do I have that sexual “age” won’t be the next right?
For starters, doomsayers have been claiming it will for decades now - and yet, the pedophile (or in most cases ephebophile, which is a different but still sick phenomenon) activist organizations of the sixties and seventies have disappeared. On the rare occasion a group tries to advocate the lowering of the age of consent, it’s immediately shut down, by politicians as well as the public.

Pedophiles are, as I mentioned, so hated that even some politicians have stated that it’s better to let innocent people be convicted than to let one predator go free. In some jurisdictions, sex offenders (including people who urinate in the vicinity of a school - at night when there are no kids around!) are “branded” for life through the public sex offenders lists. I fear a witch hunt with more innocent victims than guilty ones, rather than a legalization. And this development has been going on parallel to the liberalization of sexuality in general.

That said, it could well be the age of consent will be lowered somewhat some places, be it to the age of 16 (which is the legal age here, and perhaps the most common worldwide), 15 (which is the age a two hours drive from here), or 14 (which is the age a day’s drive from here). But while I think the last example is too low, it is still not pedophilia. A pedophile is attracted to pre-pubertal children, and would not even look at a 14-years old. That said, no adult should even seriously consider being with someone that age, so I would be against such a law change. But it still wouldn’t be even nowhere near legalization of pedophilia.
 
The connection is not medical. It is moral The problem is not medical. It is moral.
The issue is very much medical and boils down to two questions: (1) does the brain have gender, (2) is it possible that brain gender and genital gender are mismatched.

Your view is predicated on the assumption that both of these are false, while there is significant scientific evidence to the contrary.
The connection is that all sexual sin falls under the sin of Lust, one of the seven biggies.
That’s backwards. Sexual sin does not “fall under” Lust, it stems from lust. Sexual sin cannot be committed unless you have lust, so to free yourself of sexual sin, you should free yourself of lust. Lust is an atavism, an animal driving impulse; sin is what happens when you let the impulse control you. The same goes for other seven.

(Side note: It’s actually fascinating that the abovie view is quite in line from what we have learned from neuroscience about free will. A human brain is essentially an animal brain with higher-level functions glued on top. The animal part of your brain responds to stimuli automatically (hungry → will eat; enemy detected → will kill; a member of opposite sex detected → will mate), and all the conscious part can do is inhibit these impulses when they appear. This is also why people sometimes have the sensation of fighting with themselved over impulses – one part of your brain is literally trying to block the other from acting.)

That said, I fail to see how mismatched gender self-identification implies lust. Lust is all about what you do (and with whom), while gender self-identification is about what you are. Homosexuals do not sin by who they are, but by what they are doing.

If we take a very reductionist view, then lust is addiction to dopamine released during sex – you want to have sex so that your brain gets the sex-induced dopamine high. But mismatched self-identification does not involve dopamine.

Your attempt to identify GID with lust is incorrect.
 
That said, I fail to see how mismatched gender self-identification implies lust. Lust is all about what you do (and with whom), while gender self-identification is about what you are. (…)

Your attempt to identify GID with lust is incorrect.
Exactly. Hormone treatment and removal of the gonads carries a significant risk of lowered, or even diminished, sex drive (especially in the case of MtF), and yet, a transgender person would much rather risk becoming asexual than having to remain in a body that doesn’t match his or her gender identity.

So it has nothing to do with lust; it’s about identity, not sexuality.
 
As a result of the Fall humans have suffered greatly, witness the great variety of maladies afflicting humanity both genetic and non-genetic. It would not at all be surprising then if homosexuality and gender dysphoria (including the most severe form which is transgender) are at least partially, mostly or even (almost) entirely biological in origin. The brain and genitalia are sexed at different times in development, it would not be surprising if it were possible for them to be mismatch in levels of sexing. This would rather easily explain why XY transgender is more common than XX transgender which would be that the former was insufficiently masculinized whereas the latter was excessively masculinized.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top