Doctrine on transgender

  • Thread starter Thread starter FireFromHeaven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
One can argue the magisterial level of transgenderism and correctly point out that this has not been addressed by name. However, we still have John Paul II’s signature work, The Theology of the Body, into which every novel twist that comes along needs to fit. I do not see how the concept of transgender can fit, at least as a type of gender. I do not doubt that if it becomes a more popular concept that it will be addressed by a pope some day, but I would hope that it never becomes that well accepted. I know this is a cross some bear. Perhaps all of us that show an inflexibility with traditional sense of masculinity or femininity have driven some into this state of confusion.
 
From and essay on JPII’s theology of the body
Functional man is deeply wed to a “mind over matter” mentality, in which the human will exercised as power can bend all things to its own purposes, including the human body. Only this mentality can explain, for example, that bizarre belief that one’s sexuality is solely a function of one’s mind, one’s will, such that a sex change operation can actually bring about a genuine change in one’s gender.
No one here is arguing that a surgical operation changes anything. The question is whether a person’s genitalia post-birth can be influenced by any in-utero factors. Since the answer to that question is an obvious yes, I don’t see how the possibility doesn’t exist that so-called “transgenderism” could be legitimate.

Here’s a hypothetical; say the technology exists (and it will very soon, believe me) that allows the parents to “change” the gender of their baby in-utero, even if the chromosomes of the unborn child are not their desired gender, whether by blocking anti-Mullerian hormones and the SRT gene or instituting anti-Mullerian hormones and adding testosterone. Would you say that, although the child was originally meant to be X gender, the child’s genitalia post-birth means that they “changed” to Y gender? Obviously not; parents will never have the power to choose their child’s gender. That right belongs to God alone.

Likewise, if there is an accidental error in-utero now, there is the possibility that it can cause developmental errors where a person may develop into an earthly body consistent with the sex opposite to their actual gender. Those developmental errors would constitute a birth defect in this scenario, a consequence of original sin that God allows to happen. This neither suggests that He created the person wrong nor suggests that their obtaining a surgery later in life “changes” their gender.

I would be very interested in your response to that argument. I also would add that neither an opinion of a Bishop nor an interpretative essay on The Theology of the Body are doctrine, which the OP specifically asked for.
 
I would be very interested in your response to that argument. I also would add that neither an opinion of a Bishop nor an interpretative essay on The Theology of the Body are doctrine, which the OP specifically asked for.
My answer is simple. I do not believe that possibility. Transitional utero phases are not relevant, anymore than any transitional phase that all humans go through makes them not a human person. We call an embryo a human even though biological it does not seem to resemble a human. If a person is born male, then they are male.

I mentioned that nothing authoritative has been said that uses the term transgender. However, Theology of the Body is definitive. Since transgenderism is the novelty, the burden of proof is upon the Catholic to show how it can be legitimate within this Catholic theology, not upon the priests and bishops to prove the impossible negative. If I came up with the theory that aliens were inbreeding (or half human, half goats where being cloned)and some humans were now not human, I would have to show how that humans could not be human, not ask everyone else to prove it is impossible.

Okay, in lack of something more definitive, what say we all just listen to our own bishop and if someone has an issue, then consult your own priest. In absence of iron-clad dogma, let God lead through the authority he has established.

What we will not find is the Church acknowledging the plethora of new genders and sexual possibilities that this generation has produced.
 
I cannot see a possible way for a third sex to be theologically legitimate. God created people male or female, period. He also did this for complementary purposes with procreation as well as companionship, a goal that would be completely ignored if He were to create a third sex. In my mind, there is no possible argument for its existence.
The case I think could be made, is that the eunuchs in the New Testament and early Church can be seen as a sort of “third gender”. They were, however, celibate. As are actually many of the “androgynes” of today - it seems to me a large proportion of them are asexual.

That said, these individuals would probably theologically still be either male or female. I doubt there are genderless glorified bodies after the resurrection. So the case to be made is weak at best.
I will also add that, in my experience, those who call themselves a third sex often do so more for political reasons. How many “third sex” individuals do you see that have such a strong identity with it they’ll risk being kicked out of their homes (…) In my opinion, there seems to be no actual disturbance in a “third sex” individual; they just identify that way out of political or ideological motivation.
In the Western world, there are few such individuals. But looking to the East, there are several groups that act like a third gender, and who risk being kicked out of their homes for it; the hijras in India and Pakistan perhaps being the best known example. Some of them may of course simply be transsexual, which seems to be confirmed by the fact that several of them now seek HRT, SRS and integrate to society as women. Some of them may be somewhere in between.

In any case, there are hypotheses (with some support from studies) that androgyny could be caused by insufficient hormonal exposure in either direction during pregnancy, causing an ungendered brain. Which is why I’m hesitant to write off their existence as a mere idea, until there’s more science to confirm (or deny) the underlying reasons. I also don’t see them doing much damage - if someone wants to dress male one day, and female the next, it’s okay by me. I have no idea how they (except the ones that are asexual) live their sexual lives, but of course sexual morals stay the same, whether the individual is trans, cis or neither.
One can argue the magisterial level of transgenderism and correctly point out that this has not been addressed by name. However, we still have John Paul II’s signature work (…) I do not doubt that if it becomes a more popular concept that it will be addressed by a pope some day, but I would hope that it never becomes that well accepted.
Given the horrible agony transgender individuals experience, and the fact that the popular opinion most orthodox Catholics seem to accept as fact makes this agony even worse, I most certainly hope it becomes accepted enough for a pope (or at least Rome in some capacity) to clarify how a transgender individual can fit in the Church. Medically, it is a valid and widely accepted condition, which means it will have to be addressed.

That said, the current state of transsexuals (as in, transgender individuals who have received medical treatment to adjust their bodies to their brains) in the Church is laid out by the much-debated document mentioned earlier in this thread. That document is outdated scientifically, doesn’t really say much theologically at all, but at least it makes clear that sex reassignment is permissible when therapeutically necessary. But since many seem to be unable to recognize even that, I really hope Rome would at least make something like that statement official, not just a sub secretum communication to the bishops we shouldn’t even be aware of. I refer to SMGS’s excellent analysis of that document and its implications, however, instead of laying out the details again.
I know this is a cross some bear. Perhaps all of us that show an inflexibility with traditional sense of masculinity or femininity have driven some into this state of confusion.
Too simple. As a child, I was shown significant flexibility. I was gently guided towards playing with boys instead of girls, and cars instead of dolls. But when I insisted on girls and dolls instead of boys and cars, there was no punishment or emotional abuse - at least not from my parents and most teachers. The boys in my class of course bullied me, and I was severely emotionally abused by one teacher in my fifth year, but in general, my pre-pubertal life wasn’t too bad, compared to what came next. My parents were definitely not liberal, especially when it came to morals and media exposure, but they were understanding. As you probably understand, my childhood was in no way easy, but my parents, along with most adult role models, were exemplary.

Still, a transsexual person experiences body dysphoria no matter how they dress, act or play as a child (or adult). There’s a sense of disgust of one’s own body that can only be likened to a regular person being forced to have gender reassignment surgery. Imagine if you were kidnapped, put to sleep and woke up as the opposite sex; that is how a transsexual feels every day of his or her life. It generally becomes worse throughout puberty, when the body starts to produce different hormones than what the brain expects. There are of course differences between individuals, but there is one, close to invariable likeness: We fight it until we can’t. And at that point, some commit suicide, others transition. Some just give up and become empty shells. And we all would have had better lives if ideology was replaced with compassion, and preferably if we were discovered and treated early enough to prevent the first, disastrous puberty.
 
My answer is simple. I do not believe that possibility. Transitional utero phases are not relevant, anymore than any transitional phase that all humans go through makes them not a human person. We call an embryo a human even though biological it does not seem to resemble a human. If a person is born male, then they are male.
So are you suggesting that an embryo has no sex, that parents have the theological capability of changing a child’s sex as long as they do it before the child’s birth, or a third option that I’m not understanding from you?
I mentioned that nothing authoritative has been said that uses the term transgender. However, Theology of the Body is definitive. Since transgenderism is the novelty, the burden of proof is upon the Catholic to show how it can be legitimate within this Catholic theology, not upon the priests and bishops to prove the impossible negative. If I came up with the theory that aliens were inbreeding (or half human, half goats where being cloned)and some humans were now not human, I would have to show how that humans could not be human, not ask everyone else to prove it is impossible.

Okay, in lack of something more definitive, what say we all just listen to our own bishop and if someone has an issue, then consult your own priest. In absence of iron-clad dogma, let God lead through the authority he has established.

What we will not find is the Church acknowledging the plethora of new genders and sexual possibilities that this generation has produced.
The experience of transgenderism isn’t really a novelty; the only real novelty has been the physical ability to “correct” a body in line with one’s identity. Transgender individuals have existed in many, many cultures throughout time (albeit oftentimes through mistaken theological understanding of those individuals, such as “third gender” concepts in certain ancient and current tribes). I also would posit that the burden of proof to submit that the possibility of transgenderism is theologically legitimate has already been met, but that the burden of proof to submit that transgenderism is definitely theologically legitimate has not even been close to being met. I highly doubt you could meet a burden of proof for the theological possibility of us being half-goat.

But I do agree with you at the end of your post. Since there is nothing definitive on transgenderism (as it is not mentioned in The Theology of the Body or anywhere else definitive), transgender individuals should follow the advice of their individual priest.

However, since the OP asked for doctrinal information, and there is none, I will not substitute theological opinion for doctrine, no matter if it is consensus or not. A consensus of theologians once believed geocentrism and birth control were both legitimate, as well 🤷. I see no harm in keeping an open mind about it; staying neutral on a matter of theological debate until more evidence comes out is not the same as endorsing the issue.
 
My answer is simple. I do not believe that possibility. Transitional utero phases are not relevant, anymore than any transitional phase that all humans go through makes them not a human person. We call an embryo a human even though biological it does not seem to resemble a human. If a person is born male, then they are male.
The problem with this, is that deciding whether someone was “born male” has proved to be far more complicated than we originally thought. There are hundreds of intersex conditions, where people are born biologically neither male nor female. Some of these intersex conditions are recently discovered, and individuals that are now known to be intersex, were seen as (and condemned as, by ideologues) transsexual less than a generation ago. Yet, we now know them to be of ambiguous sex. And these aren’t “one in a million” cases - they’re many times more common than transgenderism.

There is also a mounting pile of evidence indicating that transgender individuals are born with a central nervous system of the opposite sex of their reproductive system. This is most probably caused by transitional utero phases. Yet you say those phases are irrelevant? When they cause a life of agony and dysphoria? How is that irrelevant?

Reality is, this is in no way simple, and this is exactly why there is no definitive statement from the Church as of today. We did that mistake during the heliocentrism conflict, and the statements from the Galileo trial are rather embarrassing. The gender situation is very comparable - evidence seems to confirm that the world isn’t as simple as we thought it to be. Biological gender isn’t always either/or, it can conflict with neurological gender, and it’s sometimes not even possible to determine.

This resembles facts like planetary movement not being perfectly circular, the Earth not being the center of the universe, and so on. Those discoveries were as shocking as the ones we’re witnessing now. They challenged the very foundations of our world view. I think this is why the Church hasn’t said a lot yet, and why it will probably still take a while - very strong statements at this time could be an embarrassment centuries from now. So I think this is prudent, even though I wish it would happen sooner, since people actually are suffering this time. GD affects people, which is more than can be said about heliocentrism…

Edit: Typo.
 
My answer is simple. I do not believe that possibility. Transitional utero phases are not relevant, anymore than any transitional phase that all humans go through makes them not a human person. We call an embryo a human even though biological it does not seem to resemble a human. If a person is born male, then they are male.
Assume that we transplant a woman’s brain onto man’s body. Or we can transplant the whole head – it would be technically easier. What gender is the person produced in such operation?

Ignore whether such transplantation itself would be legit.
I mentioned that nothing authoritative has been said that uses the term transgender. However, Theology of the Body is definitive. Since transgenderism is the novelty, the burden of proof is upon the Catholic to show how it can be legitimate within this Catholic theology, not upon the priests and bishops to prove the impossible negative.
You are committing the gallilean error. Let me rephrase:

*Since heliocentrism is the novelty, the burden of proof is upon the Catholic to show how it can it be legitimate within this Catholic theology, not upon the priests and bishops to prove the impossible negative. *

As we know from history, acceptance of heliocentrism did not happen because someone figured out how to make it legitimate within Catholic theology – strictly speaking, pontifical decrees declaring heliocentrism to be a heresy were never revoked, and are still in force. What happened is that heliocentrism has been found to be a real phenomenon through scientific means, and Catholic theology had to adapt – although some sources maintain that geocentrism was still an official doctrine as late as 1800s.

Likewise, objective existence (or not) of intersex disorders is not contingent on whether the Catholic theology can accommodate that. Like heliocentrism, existence of such disorders is a purely emprirical question. And just like heliocentrism, intersex disorders have been emprically shown to exist, and be biological (not psychological) in nature.
 
There is also a mounting pile of evidence indicating that transgender individuals are born with a central nervous system of the opposite sex of their reproductive system. This is most probably caused by transitional utero phases. Yet you say those phases are irrelevant? When they cause a life of agony and dysphoria? How is that irrelevant?
The underlying problem here is that a lot of anti-abortion arguments are based on a proposition that there is no ontological difference between an adult and a fertilized ovum. In abortion debates, this is usually expressed along the lines of “The embryo is human, because it will develop into a human, not into a duck”. However, this proposition necessarily implies that the developmental path is hardcoded in the DNA and cannot be changed.

Existence of developmental disorders caused by hormonal imbalances in utero is a severe blow to this line of thinking. If a man can turn into a woman in utero, then a resulting adult is something noticably different than the ovum she came from.
 
The underlying problem here is that a lot of anti-abortion arguments are based on a proposition that there is no ontological difference between an adult and a fertilized ovum. In abortion debates, this is usually expressed along the lines of “The embryo is human, because it will develop into a human, not into a duck”. However, this proposition necessarily implies that the developmental path is hardcoded in the DNA and cannot be changed.

Existence of developmental disorders caused by hormonal imbalances in utero is a severe blow to this line of thinking. If a man can turn into a woman in utero, then a resulting adult is something noticably different than the ovum she came from.
Whether sex and/or gender is developed later in pregnancy and not set from the beginning (sometimes even biological sex is different from genetic sex, in the case of XY women or XX men) does not change the nature of abortion, since human dignity and value does not originate from gender or sex, but from being human. And a human embryo most definitely will develop into a human adult if not disturbed (of course including natural miscarriages).

I agree that some Catholics seem to make the mistake of equating “biological” with “genetic”, however, and it could very well be because of what you say. But if it is, the conclusion does not follow from the argument - the Church’s view on abortion has been consistent throughout time. Even back when theologians believed fetuses weren’t given a soul until later in pregnancy, and hence believed in an ontological difference, we taught that abortion was wrong from the moment of conception. The fact that we are now proved to be human in essence already at that moment, does not require our gender, personality, height, weight or any trait at all to be defined; it is enough to know that the embryo is, in essence, human.
 
I agree that some Catholics seem to make the mistake of equating “biological” with “genetic”, however, and it could very well be because of what you say. But if it is, the conclusion does not follow from the argument - the Church’s view on abortion has been consistent throughout time. Even back when theologians believed fetuses weren’t given a soul until later in pregnancy, and hence believed in an ontological difference, we taught that abortion was wrong from the moment of conception.
Precisely! The Catholic Church judged abortion to be wrong before anyone discovered DNA.

My point is that Catholic theology (at least in a popular form) has been compromised at the moment when the “argument from DNA” became accepted. It is a very strong argument, so it’s popular, but it dangerously subverts the whole philosophical system. Once you accept that the essence of humanity is in DNA, then it’s logical to assume that traits such as gender are defined exclusively by DNA. This line of thinking effectively reduces a human being to a set of codons: You’re XY so you’re male, and if you think otherwise, you must be deluded.
 
Medically, it is a valid and widely accepted condition, which means it will have to be addressed…
In case, I was not clear, that is an opinion that I do not agree with. My opinion is not your opinion. I do not accept changing psychological definitions to be a “medical” condition.
 
Assume that we transplant a woman’s brain onto man’s body. Or we can transplant the whole head – it would be technically easier. What gender is the person produced in such operation?

Ignore whether such transplantation itself would be legit.
I will not comment on ridiculous, impossible situations.
*Since heliocentrism is the novelty, the burden of proof is upon the Catholic to show how it can it be legitimate within this Catholic theology, not upon the priests and bishops to prove the impossible negative. *

Likewise, objective existence (or not) of intersex disorders is not contingent on whether the Catholic theology can accommodate that. Like heliocentrism, existence of such disorders is a purely emprirical question. And just like heliocentrism, intersex disorders have been emprically shown to exist, and be biological (not psychological) in nature.
I have said nothing about intersex conditions, as that is not the topic and a whole different issue. This is also not heliocentric, which can be proven mathematical, and the evidence is physical. The two are not the same. Show me where soul is and tell me what it weighs and I will acknowledge the validity of the comparison.

I would hope those who are reading this will not be so quick to dismiss all Catholic thought on the subject, be it a bishop or priest, or the Great John Paul’s Theology of the Body. If you note, those who are pushing this new type of gender have an absolute dearth of Catholic teaching, dismissing what there is as out dated. If a man is a woman based on his own identity, i.e., he “feels” like a woman, then anyone who thinks he is the re-incarnation of Napoleon is the Emperor of France.
 
In case, I was not clear, that is an opinion that I do not agree with. My opinion is not your opinion. I do not accept changing psychological definitions to be a “medical” condition.
Do you consider a stria terminalis incongruent with external genitalia to be a medical condition?
 
Do you consider a stria terminalis incongruent with external genitalia to be a medical condition?
“Incongruent” is a sliding term. I do not believe the stria terminalis to be genitalia, or indicative of gender. Something does not determine gender because it is related statistically to gender, like hip size, for example.

Again, I will note that this does not relate to Catholic doctrine. If the bishops and priests who have commented above does not relate to the OP, as you suggested, then how much more do these type of studies drift us further and further from the topic of doctrine.

I sometimes like to bring up a reminder that this is a Catholic website. I am pretty sure that any priest or bishop commenting on doctrine will hold more weight that any new medical theory.
 
“Incongruent” is a sliding term. I do not believe the stria terminalis to be genitalia, or indicative of gender. Something does not determine gender because it is related statistically to gender, like hip size, for example.
It is not a sliding term in all cases. In this instance, if you read the medical autopsies, every single cisgender woman had a significantly smaller basal nucleus than every single cisgender man. The one transgender FtM they studied had a male-sized basal nucleus, and all six MtF transgender individuals had female-sized basal nuclei. There was no spectrum; the numbers were exceptionally distinct.
Again, I will note that this does not relate to Catholic doctrine. If the bishops and priests who have commented above does not relate to the OP, as you suggested, then how much more do these type of studies drift us further and further from the topic of doctrine.

I sometimes like to bring up a reminder that this is a Catholic website. I am pretty sure that any priest or bishop commenting on doctrine will hold more weight that any new medical theory.
Except that the doctrine does not deal with transgender issues. There is no doctrine whatsoever that discusses transgender issues. Absent of that, they are merely speaking as theologians giving opinions on a current medical issue, much like scientists are scientists giving opinions on a current medical issue. Both are equally valid in this case, since science and faith cannot disagree (which IS doctrine, by the way). Everyone here, including both individuals you cited, are merely giving their opinion as to how transgender individuals fit in with Catholic theology. None of it is authoritative in any way.

While this may be a Catholic website, Catholicism is not incompatible with science. We do not blatantly deny scientific discovery, just because we are uncomfortable with the results. If you believe that transgenderism is a psychological disorder with no biological or theological component, that is your prerogative as a Catholic. But you should not be attempting to suggest to others that they must believe it as Catholics, because Catholics are free to form their own opinions on the matter provided they do not encourage their transgender friends to marry or seek Holy Orders until further notice.
 
. But you should not be attempting to suggest to others that they must believe it as Catholics, because Catholics are free to form their own opinions on the matter provided they do not encourage their transgender friends to marry or seek Holy Orders until further notice.
I do not think I suggested that. People are free to believe any and every medical, scientific or psychological theory that comes along. It matters nothing. In any case, no feelings are immoral.

However, in all this talk, there is a profound silence on the other possibility, that of self-deception. That possibility is as old as the science of psychology and something we all engage in from time to time. It is something everyone should consider when thought and physical reality seem to contradict each other.
 
In case, I was not clear, that is an opinion that I do not agree with. My opinion is not your opinion. I do not accept changing psychological definitions to be a “medical” condition.
I’m sorry, but your opinion is irrelevant. When I say “widely accepted as a medical condition”, I obviously mean “widely accepted by medical professionals and scientists with relevant qualifications”. There is consensus that transgenderism most probably has a neurobiological cause, and that it is not psychological in nature - even the first version of the diagnosis “transsexualism” had something along the lines of “not suffering from mental delusion” as one of its criteria.

The reason it’s still in the DSM, is simply that the only way to diagnose it is through psychiatric evaluation. Brain imaging is not yet advanced enough to make a 100% certain diagnosis, and the underlying cause isn’t completely identified (though there are significant clues).

The same goes for ADHD, autism and plenty of other neurobiological conditions. Yet, any medical professional (I’m sure there are exceptions, but they’re rare and misinformed) would inform you that you’re ignorant if you wrote them off as “psychological”.
I will not comment on ridiculous, impossible situations.
Weller proposed a valid, plausible thought experiment. Brain transplants have been discussed by medical researchers, and while impossible by today’s technology, they are neither ridiculous nor inconceivable. His argument was very relevant. Must be convenient to refuse to comment on any thought experiment you don’t like, though.
I have said nothing about intersex conditions, as that is not the topic and a whole different issue.
Intersex conditions are not a “whole different issue”, since intersex and transsexualism has proved to be intertwined. Many of the individuals who were seen as transsexual a few decades ago, are today proved to be intersex. It is more than conceivable that “transsexualism” as such simply turns out to be an array of intersex conditions a few decades from now. Hence it is very much the issue.
This is also not heliocentric, which can be proven mathematical, and the evidence is physical. The two are not the same. Show me where soul is and tell me what it weighs and I will acknowledge the validity of the comparison.
The evidence for a neurobiological cause of transgenderism is also physical. They are the same - both are well founded, scientific hypotheses, and heliocentrism was as “immature” then as the gender breakthroughs are now. Remember that at the time, geocentrism with epicycles actually fit better with observations than early heliocentrism did - in some ways, you could accuse the heliocentrists of even ignoring evidence. This is probably also what prompted the Church’s rash condemnation; in the view of the Magisterium at the time, the geocentrists acted against reason. Yet, they were right. The Church pronounced too early, and Rome is still too embarrassed to even cancel the decrees; geocentrism is still formally a heresy, just one we like to ignore. Evidence for a neurobiological cause of transgenderism is better founded now than heliocentrism was in its early beginnings.

As for the soul, as an orthodox Catholic, I am sure you would know the soul has no gender or sex, since those are physical quantities, and contingent on the body. Without bodies, we have no gender or sex. Therefore, where the soul is, is completely irrelevant - our minds, and as such personalities, are however generally thought to reside in our brains, unless you subscribe to some New Age notion of our bodies simply being “avatars”.
I would hope those who are reading this will not be so quick to dismiss all Catholic thought on the subject, be it a bishop or priest, or the Great John Paul’s Theology of the Body. If you note, those who are pushing this new type of gender have an absolute dearth of Catholic teaching, dismissing what there is as out dated.
There is absolutely no Catholic teaching on the subject whatsoever. I’m not dismissing what there is as outdated, since there is none.

I did however point out that the current policy document, which is not teaching but guidance to bishops regarding practical situations, is scientifically outdated. Which should be obvious; it’s more than ten years old, and science has progressed a lot since then.
If a man is a woman based on his own identity, i.e., he “feels” like a woman, then anyone who thinks he is the re-incarnation of Napoleon is the Emperor of France.
And again you resort to ridicule. I could say something about charity, but instead I’ll thank you for having upgraded me from “a petunia” to “Napoleon”. It means a lot.

Just a small hint, though: It is inconceivable for a human to be a petunia. It is also inconceivable for a 21st century human to be Napoleon. It is not inconceivable for a brain to be masculinized while the rest of the body gets feminized, or the other way around, since those processes happen independently during pregnancy. You commit the fallacy of equating inconceivable events with conceivable events, effectively resulting in ridicule.
 
Precisely! The Catholic Church judged abortion to be wrong before anyone discovered DNA.

My point is that Catholic theology (at least in a popular form) has been compromised at the moment when the “argument from DNA” became accepted. It is a very strong argument, so it’s popular, but it dangerously subverts the whole philosophical system. Once you accept that the essence of humanity is in DNA, then it’s logical to assume that traits such as gender are defined exclusively by DNA. This line of thinking effectively reduces a human being to a set of codons: You’re XY so you’re male, and if you think otherwise, you must be deluded.
While I see that it would be logical to assume that such traits are defined exclusively by DNA, it is not a logical necessity. So I think the “argument from DNA” still stands when it comes to abortion, since the DNA after all is what makes one human - it’s just not what (exclusively) makes one male or female.

I agree though, the line of thinking you present indeed reduces a human being to a set of codons. And it seems to be a common line of thinking, indeed. That saddens me, since it effectively is an even worse kind of materialism than what we see among atheists in general.

There’s also an inconsistency here - if gender and sex were exclusively governed by DNA, and that made any treatment of gender identity disorder morally illicit, it would also be morally illicit to treat the treatable parts of Down’s syndrome, cystic fibrosis and several other genetically caused conditions. Yet, no one seems to have an issue with treating those conditions.
 
I’m sorry, but your opinion is irrelevant.
It is relevant to me. Welcome to forum posting. It is what we do. I am sure your** opinion** that this is actually scientifically definitive is relevant to you.
The reason it’s still in the DSM, is simply that the only way to diagnose it is through psychiatric evaluation
. Well, that again is your opinion. The evidence remains. It is still listed as a mental disorder in the DSM.
There is absolutely no Catholic teaching on the subject whatsoever. I’m not dismissing what there is as outdated, since there is none.
Again your opinion. There are links above. They link teaching. The teaching is from Catholic sources. These are facts, as opposed to theories and opinions. What does not exist is any infallible or magisterial teaching on transgenderism per se.
And again you resort to ridicule. I could say something about charity, but instead I’ll thank you for having upgraded me from “a petunia” to “Napoleon”. It means a lot.

Just a small hint, though: It is inconceivable for a human to be a petunia. It is also inconceivable for a 21st century human to be Napoleon. It is not inconceivable for a brain to be masculinized while the rest of the body gets feminized, or the other way around, since those processes happen independently during pregnancy. You commit the fallacy of equating inconceivable events with conceivable events, effectively resulting in ridicule.
Again, your opinion that it is possible to have a brain with gender identification. Throughout history, many more have believed in reincarnation than have believed in brain gender. In fact, if one is prone to always disregard the possibility for self-delusion, then one can also find people that have undergone regression therapy and have reported on previous lives. I do not believe in that either, but that is why I used that particular analogy. It was not ridicule. If it seemed that way, it is only because this whole subject is prone to be seen that way.

So I tried to answer the OP and post the best-existing Catholic sources I can find. No Catholic sources have been posted to the contrary, or that contradicted them. We have had opinions. I have read some science. I have read opinions about the science. In the end, I will use the simple logic of Occam’s Razor and stick with the simplest solution, which also coincides with Catholic teaching to date.

That being said (my opinion), I do not want to even suggest that this is the Catholic opinion, or that others cannot totally believe that transgenderism is more legitimate than I do.
 
So I tried to answer the OP and post the best-existing Catholic sources I can find. No Catholic sources have been posted to the contrary, or that contradicted them. We have had opinions. I have read some science. I have read opinions about the science. In the end, I will use the simple logic of Occam’s Razor and stick with the simplest solution, which also coincides with Catholic teaching to date.

That being said (my opinion), I do not want to even suggest that this is the Catholic opinion, or that others cannot totally believe that transgenderism is more legitimate than I do.
I can respect this. I personally would never suggest to anyone that transgenderism is legitimate either. I accept the possibility that it is a biological abnormality caused by original sin that leads to the development of the incorrect reproductive system, and I accept the possibility that it is a psychological abnormality caused by original sin that causes one to be unable to accept their true sex. Either way, I consider it likely to be a neurological condition, though I have no way of knowing whether gender should truly be determined by genitalia, a wholesale look at reproductive organs, the gendered brain structure, or a combination of all 3. That is something I’d imagine the Magisterium will eventually have to rule on.

As I said, I would tell a transgender person that while the possibility certainly exists that their glorified body is of the sex they identify with, it is just as possible theologically they will be resurrected in a glorified body of the sex they don’t identify with, but that if so, they would be cured of all discontent with it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top