No; theological understandings matter more than ANY experiential understanding ever could. Do we tell gay people that their experiences of being attracted to members of their same sex outweighs a theological understanding of their attractions? Do we tell people that their experiential understanding of life outweighs Church teaching in any area? Of course not.
It is extraordinarily important to know, from a theological standpoint, what gender someone is. Their theological gender is the only one we can support, as we do not wish them to lead themselves into sin, no matter what they do. Now, I am open to the idea of transgenderism being legitimate, but to argue that we should only care about how it affects their day-to-day life and not their spiritual life is ridiculous!
We as laity have no business interfering with people’s experiences of their sexuality, unless we’re health professionals trying to help a patient. There is absolutely nothing theological that you or I could say to a gay or transgendered person to change how they experience their sexuality.
Even if they do manage to resist the temptation to have their bodies mutilated or manage to live a chaste life, how they sense their sexuality will remain the same.
The theological understanding of sexuality is an
ideal. We are a fallen species entirely dependent on God’s mercy and grace to fill in the deep chasm left by the wounds of our fallen nature.
Their theological gender is the only one we can support,
I profoundly disagree with this. We must support the
entire person as-is, where is. We cannot say that their perceived gender is “in error”. It just is. They live it, and they must learn to accept it and accept that God loves them unconditionally in spite of it. We cannot “only” support their theological gender, without rejecting the person, because their perceived gender is hardwired into their brains and is completely intertwined with who they are. Most would rather not be what they are and may even have trouble accepting themselves. Rejecting their perceived experiences will just throw oil on the fire. Most importantly these persons
have the image of Christ imprinted on their souls. They are not just “transgendered” but whole people who have an inbred dignity afforded to them by this image of Christ on their soul.
as we do not wish them to lead themselves into sin, no matter what they do. Now, I am open to the idea of transgenderism being legitimate, but to argue that we should only care about how it affects their day-to-day life and not their spiritual life is ridiculous!
I don’t think I said anywhere that we shouldn’t be concerned how it affects their spiritual life. My argument is that the path in leading them to a healthy spiritual life does not lie in pointing out that they’re somehow in “error” for believing that they are, say, a woman trapped in a man’s body. It will not change how they feel one bit. A health professional may be able to determine the degree of transgenderism involved and whether the person can be helped without transitioning to their perceived gender. But if we as laity or even clergy dismiss their condition as an error on their part, we’re really pushing that person away from God and not doing their spiritual well-being any kind of good. We’re in fact trying to impose on God our own set of limitations on how He should relate to that person and who He should and accept and reject. It’s a subtle form of judging the person and often comes from our own deep-seated discomfort with these issues.
We need to make these folks feel loved and accepted unconditionally (on our part) to lead them into a relationship with Christ who does love them unconditionally. It is only through a close relationship with Christ can these people truly be helped spiritually. If that relationship shows them a better way to deal with their condition that is great. If it doesn’t because they can’t overcome it, they still need to feel hope in God’s mercy and unconditional love for them. God doesn’t reject His ailing children. Despair is a terrible thing. And this means
we ourselves need to become more Christ-like in our interactions with transgendered and gay people. The Rule of St. Benedict says to greet any visitor to the monastery
as if it was Christ himself visiting. It doesn’t place conditions on this. It doesn’t say “only people who accept Church teaching on sexuality”. It says everyone and that’s because
everyone has the image of Christ on his soul. It’s part of our dignity, and we must become more Christ-like just as Christ ate with sinners who were the rejects of the society of His day.
All of this theological debating on how to approach, as people leading ordinary lives and having to occasionally interact with gays and the transgendered, is in fact worthless for those interactions. This stuff is wayyyy above our pay grade (unless as I said you’re a health professional engaged with the patient). Our faith is supposed to be transformational and dependent on a deepening of a relationship with Christ. A gay or transgendered person can have a relationship with Christ, and it is absolutely
not dependent on their accepting the “theological” understanding of their gender. The starting point is not telling them that theirs is a sinful or wrong condition or that what they feel in their hearts is wrong. The starting point is telling them that they’re loved unconditionally, and to ask them to “come and see” how God made literally present in front of us can be transformational.
Alas I’m afraid though, with the way some of us in the Church have spoken on sexual disorders I’m not surprised at all that many gays and transgendered reject the Church.