Doctrine on transgender

  • Thread starter Thread starter FireFromHeaven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, as far as rarity goes, the rate of intersex dilter’s or00IS/CAIS (the Y receptor disorder you were thinking of) or de la Chapelle’s syndrome is actually about 5-10 times that of the rate of transgender disorders (estimated at only about 150,000 people out of 300 million in the United States). If it was a matter of simple self-hatred, don’t you think the rate wouldsex significantly higher? After all, what percentage of people are happy with their bodies?

Secondly, if someone’s neurological structure was definitively shown to biologically model that of their identified sex, would you consider them to be transgender or intersex? That is an important question for any discussion to occur.
Intersex is the physical condition in which the physical characteristics of both genitals are presents with one being dominant. Is very rare too. A person who only has physical charateristics of one sex is not intersex. As to neurological characteristics I am very skeptical of those studies because they are pushing an agenda. I don’t think that anyone has any kind of sex in the brain, and the hormone story is just an excuse to justify bad behavior (and quite an old one) when it comes to our brain everything is about choices we made and our process of thinking. Some people are different in that they don’t fit the traditional strict mold of the sexes but I don’t think is because they have a second sex in their head is because as the results of individualism they are different and simply just don’t fit the mold and that is been used as a mean to push trangenderism to people.

Again the rates and statistics are heavily exaggerated because that is the war horse of the gay movement. Thirty fourth years ago they were extremely rare and when the gay movement started pushing the scientific world all of a sudden changes everything to accommodate the agenda. Again all that area is biased and following an agenda. And yes I in is it, by far the vast majority of trangenderism is just self hatred against your own sex. That argument of the different gender in the brain (which as i emotion that is a word used by radical feminism to push am agenda) is a mean toanipulate people’s feelings on the subject so they can view a morally unnaceptable conduct as something accepted in society.
 
Well, maybe so, but we’re talking about whether a transgender person’s identity can truly be their gender theologically in this forum. So the theological definition of gender is what’s important here. And every single person, no matter what their condition, is either male or female, period, for all eternity, and they will never be the other gender.
I don’t think the theological or theoretical definition of gender matters a whit to those so afflicted. It’s such an ingrained part of personality. One doesn’t live theologically, one lives a perceived reality. Defining a person’s personality theologically won’t change their psychological circumstances and will do nothing to heal them.

I know a transsexual. She has said that she was on the verge of suicide before transitioning. We have to feel a great deal of compassion for these problems. It’s an enormous cross to bear and for many there’s just two ways out, suicide or a sex change. The latter may not be ideal and it may be mutilating, but until medically we have something better to offer it may be all we can offer, and theologically all we can do is offer this up to God’s mercy as imperfect man’s response to an artifact of our fallen nature.
 
If you are born biological a male then nothing changes that.
Provide rigorous definition of a “male”.
Your state of mind makes no difference, how you feel, how you think, how you dress, how you act, no matter what drugs you take or whatever surgery you have.
Born a male always a male. Wishful thinking and surgery do not change that.
And you are giving the best example of what I said earlier.

Orthodox Catholic worldview is unable to accept that mismatch between mind gender and body gender can objectively exist, and writes it off as delusion.
 
Intersex is the physical condition in which the physical characteristics of both genitals are presents with one being dominant. Is very rare too.
This is actually the definition of a hermaphrodite. An intersex individual is a broader term meaning an individual who has gendered organs present of both sexes. This can be anywhere form hermaphrodism to mixed internal reproductive organs (with uniform external genitalia) or what have you. For example, CAIS women have fully external female genitalia, but internal testes (where their ovaries should be) and usually congenitally missing organs such as the uterus.
As to neurological characteristics I am very skeptical of those studies because they are pushing an agenda. I don’t think that anyone has any kind of sex in the brain, and the hormone story is just an excuse to justify bad behavior (and quite an old one) when it comes to our brain everything is about choices we made and our process of thinking.
Actually, it has been a long-known fact that brains are gendered. Women’s brains have higher connectivity between the lobes, and individual structures within the brain are shaped based on the gender of the individual. Also, I would not deny science just because you think it has an agenda. These studies were posted in academic journals, not popular journals, and they were very open about their methodology. As someone who was in Biochemistry, I can tell you that the only real concerns are those studies posted in popular journals. Remember that, at one point, a huge portion of the Catholic community felt that heliocentric data was biased by an anti-Christian agenda, and they utilized lines from Scripture describing the Sun rotating around the Earth (in the sky) to argue so.
Again the rates and statistics are heavily exaggerated because that is the war horse of the gay movement. Thirty fourth years ago they were extremely rare and when the gay movement started pushing the scientific world all of a sudden changes everything to accommodate the agenda.
Well, firstly, transgenderism and homosexuality have nothing to do with each other. But even if the so-called “gay agenda” was in science, they’d be failing rather hard wouldn’t they? If they were trying to bias science to prove they were biologically born gay, where are the studies “proving” this?
I don’t think the theological or theoretical definition of gender matters a whit to those so afflicted. It’s such an ingrained part of personality. One doesn’t live theologically, one lives a perceived reality. Defining a person’s personality theologically won’t change their psychological circumstances and will do nothing to heal them.

I know a transsexual. She has said that she was on the verge of suicide before transitioning. We have to feel a great deal of compassion for these problems. It’s an enormous cross to bear and for many there’s just two ways out, suicide or a sex change. The latter may not be ideal and it may be mutilating, but until medically we have something better to offer it may be all we can offer, and theologically all we can do is offer this up to God’s mercy as imperfect man’s response to an artifact of our fallen nature.
No; theological understandings matter more than ANY experiential understanding ever could. Do we tell gay people that their experiences of being attracted to members of their same sex outweighs a theological understanding of their attractions? Do we tell people that their experiential understanding of life outweighs Church teaching in any area? Of course not.

It is extraordinarily important to know, from a theological standpoint, what gender someone is. Their theological gender is the only one we can support, as we do not wish them to lead themselves into sin, no matter what they do. Now, I am open to the idea of transgenderism being legitimate, but to argue that we should only care about how it affects their day-to-day life and not their spiritual life is ridiculous!
 
This is actually the definition of a hermaphrodite. An intersex individual is a broader term meaning an individual who has gendered organs present of both sexes. This can be anywhere form hermaphrodism to mixed internal reproductive organs (with uniform external genitalia) or what have you. For example, CAIS women have fully external female genitalia, but internal testes (where their ovaries should be) and usually congenitally missing organs such as the uterus.

Actually, it has been a long-known fact that brains are gendered. Women’s brains have higher connectivity between the lobes, and individual structures within the brain are shaped based on the gender of the individual. Also, I would not deny science just because you think it has an agenda. These istudies were posted in academic journals, not popular journals, and they were very open about their methodology. As someone who was in Biochemistry, I can tell you that the only real concerns are those studies posted in popular journals. Remember that, at one point, a huge portion of the Catholic community felt that heliocentric data was biased by an anti-Christian agenda, and they utilized lines from Scripture describing the Sun rotating around the Earth (in the sky) to argue so.

Well, firstly, transgenderism and homosexuality have nothing to do with each other. But even if the so-called “gay agenda” was in science, they’d be failing rather hard wouldn’t they? If they were trying to bias science to prove they were biologically born gay, where are the studies “proving” this?

It is extraordinarily important to know, from a theological standpoint, what gender someone is. Their theological gender is the only one we can support, as we do not wish them to lead themselves into sin, no matter what they do. Now, I am open to the idea of transgenderism being legitimate, but to argue that we should only care about how it affects their day-to-day life and not their spiritual life is ridiculous!
You are still using the word gender and that word is incorrect. Theologically speaking you can’t use the word gender because is a term coined by the anti life movement to go against the church’s teaching that men and women are different.

As to gay agenda in science they have been very successful since they removed homosexuality from the DMS in the 70’s. That only shoes how good they are doing. And if you want to add all the studies that says that lesbians parents are better, that homosexuality is genetical, the studies in Papua nueva guinea etc. Are all part of the studies tryimg to influence people into seeing homosexuality as normal but I think thatay be topic for discussion on another thread so I don’t want to dwell too much into it.

I guess that what you mean on your second paragraph is that the brain has sez? No there is no such thing as gendered brain – wrong term, even from the anti loge point gender means a societal construct so there wouldn’t be a thing like gendered brain. I do agree and know that there is acientifical proof that the “majority” of women’s’ brain are different to the majority" of men’s brain and that “generally” speaking the brain is structured according to the person’s sex. And note I highlight majority and generally because that is the general rule. The general rule is that humans have two arms, right? But still you have cases of people born with no arms at all. All humans are different and truth is the general rule doesn’t apply coolie cutter style to everyone. There is no such thing as a sexed brain, simply there is people who are different and don’t fit the general rule. That is all it is. Individualism. You can’t expect the structure of the brain of every single woman in the world to be the same because is not and it won’t.

Moreover, if you ask me this rigid cookie cutter expectation of all women’s brains are xyz and all men’s brains are ABC and women have to be like this and all men have to be like that is precisely what is causing most transgenserism because when you have a person who is different that doesn’t fit the mold you are telling them they don’t fit neither here nor there. Then that person starts developing hatred against their own self because they don’t fit and that evolves into satistifying the necessity to fit in the cookie cutter by having a sex change operation. If we wouldn’t subject people to such strict cookie cutter roles then we wouldn’t have so many cases of transgenderism.
 
Orthodox Catholic worldview is unable to accept that mismatch between mind gender and body gender can objectively exist, and writes it off as delusion.
Precisely this is because humans have free will and second, because the idea of gender is unacceptable for the church.
 
Sorry to hear this, I will pray that you find peace.
Actually I found peace a long time ago and while I am still far away from being a feminine woman, I am very happy as a woman now And wouldn’t change it for anything. But I did spend my childhood and early teen going by a male name, dressing like a boy, arguing that Iwas not a girl that iI was a boy, I always played with cars and robots and always disliked everything girl related so I am quite familiar with the feelings that ho with the situation and that is why I am convinced the problem with transgenders is that their issues are wrongly addressed.
 
This is actually the definition of a hermaphrodite. An intersex individual is a broader term meaning an individual who has gendered organs present of both sexes. This can be anywhere form hermaphrodism to mixed internal reproductive organs (with uniform external genitalia) or what have you. For example, CAIS women have fully external female genitalia, but internal testes (where their ovaries should be) and usually congenitally missing organs such as the uterus.

s!
As to this I refer back to #48 from ora labora as he is right on point with this. Also as he mentions these conditions are extremely rare. People with CAIS are male as they are XY, they are sterile and don’t have a female reproductive system. Is a very sad condition but rare and you cannot base your argument for 90% of the population on an extremely rare condition.
 
As to this I refer back to #48 from ora labora as he is right on point with this. Also as he mentions these conditions are extremely rare. People with CAIS are male as they are XY, they are sterile and don’t have a female reproductive system. Is a very sad condition but rare and you cannot base your argument for 90% of the population on an extremely rare condition.
People with CAIS aren’t male. That’s ridiculous. Almost all of them identify as female, look completely female, have completely female external genitalia, and are unaware of their condition until puberty, when most fail to have periods. Without modern medical testing, most would remain unaware of their condition their entire lives. Basing sex entirely on chromosomes is silly, and I’ve not seen any evidence that it’s official Church teaching.

I definitely agree that it’s a rare condition, but so is transgenderism. This discussion isn’t about the majority, but about a very small subset of people.
 
No; theological understandings matter more than ANY experiential understanding ever could. Do we tell gay people that their experiences of being attracted to members of their same sex outweighs a theological understanding of their attractions? Do we tell people that their experiential understanding of life outweighs Church teaching in any area? Of course not.

It is extraordinarily important to know, from a theological standpoint, what gender someone is. Their theological gender is the only one we can support, as we do not wish them to lead themselves into sin, no matter what they do. Now, I am open to the idea of transgenderism being legitimate, but to argue that we should only care about how it affects their day-to-day life and not their spiritual life is ridiculous!
We as laity have no business interfering with people’s experiences of their sexuality, unless we’re health professionals trying to help a patient. There is absolutely nothing theological that you or I could say to a gay or transgendered person to change how they experience their sexuality.

Even if they do manage to resist the temptation to have their bodies mutilated or manage to live a chaste life, how they sense their sexuality will remain the same.

The theological understanding of sexuality is an ideal. We are a fallen species entirely dependent on God’s mercy and grace to fill in the deep chasm left by the wounds of our fallen nature.
Their theological gender is the only one we can support,
I profoundly disagree with this. We must support the entire person as-is, where is. We cannot say that their perceived gender is “in error”. It just is. They live it, and they must learn to accept it and accept that God loves them unconditionally in spite of it. We cannot “only” support their theological gender, without rejecting the person, because their perceived gender is hardwired into their brains and is completely intertwined with who they are. Most would rather not be what they are and may even have trouble accepting themselves. Rejecting their perceived experiences will just throw oil on the fire. Most importantly these persons have the image of Christ imprinted on their souls. They are not just “transgendered” but whole people who have an inbred dignity afforded to them by this image of Christ on their soul.
as we do not wish them to lead themselves into sin, no matter what they do. Now, I am open to the idea of transgenderism being legitimate, but to argue that we should only care about how it affects their day-to-day life and not their spiritual life is ridiculous!
I don’t think I said anywhere that we shouldn’t be concerned how it affects their spiritual life. My argument is that the path in leading them to a healthy spiritual life does not lie in pointing out that they’re somehow in “error” for believing that they are, say, a woman trapped in a man’s body. It will not change how they feel one bit. A health professional may be able to determine the degree of transgenderism involved and whether the person can be helped without transitioning to their perceived gender. But if we as laity or even clergy dismiss their condition as an error on their part, we’re really pushing that person away from God and not doing their spiritual well-being any kind of good. We’re in fact trying to impose on God our own set of limitations on how He should relate to that person and who He should and accept and reject. It’s a subtle form of judging the person and often comes from our own deep-seated discomfort with these issues.

We need to make these folks feel loved and accepted unconditionally (on our part) to lead them into a relationship with Christ who does love them unconditionally. It is only through a close relationship with Christ can these people truly be helped spiritually. If that relationship shows them a better way to deal with their condition that is great. If it doesn’t because they can’t overcome it, they still need to feel hope in God’s mercy and unconditional love for them. God doesn’t reject His ailing children. Despair is a terrible thing. And this means we ourselves need to become more Christ-like in our interactions with transgendered and gay people. The Rule of St. Benedict says to greet any visitor to the monastery as if it was Christ himself visiting. It doesn’t place conditions on this. It doesn’t say “only people who accept Church teaching on sexuality”. It says everyone and that’s because everyone has the image of Christ on his soul. It’s part of our dignity, and we must become more Christ-like just as Christ ate with sinners who were the rejects of the society of His day.

All of this theological debating on how to approach, as people leading ordinary lives and having to occasionally interact with gays and the transgendered, is in fact worthless for those interactions. This stuff is wayyyy above our pay grade (unless as I said you’re a health professional engaged with the patient). Our faith is supposed to be transformational and dependent on a deepening of a relationship with Christ. A gay or transgendered person can have a relationship with Christ, and it is absolutely not dependent on their accepting the “theological” understanding of their gender. The starting point is not telling them that theirs is a sinful or wrong condition or that what they feel in their hearts is wrong. The starting point is telling them that they’re loved unconditionally, and to ask them to “come and see” how God made literally present in front of us can be transformational.

Alas I’m afraid though, with the way some of us in the Church have spoken on sexual disorders I’m not surprised at all that many gays and transgendered reject the Church.
 
We as laity have no business interfering with people’s experiences of their sexuality, unless we’re health professionals trying to help a patient. There is absolutely nothing theological that you or I could say to a gay or transgendered person to change how they experience their sexuality.

Even if they do manage to resist the temptation to have their bodies mutilated or manage to live a chaste life, how they sense their sexuality will remain the same.

The theological understanding of sexuality is an ideal. We are a fallen species entirely dependent on God’s mercy and grace to fill in the deep chasm left by the wounds of our fallen nature.

I profoundly disagree with this. We must support the entire person as-is, where is. We cannot say that their perceived gender is “in error”. It just is. They live it, and they must learn to accept it and accept that God loves them unconditionally in spite of it. We cannot “only” support their theological gender, without rejecting the person, because their perceived gender is hardwired into their brains and is completely intertwined with who they are. Most would rather not be what they are and may even have trouble accepting themselves. Rejecting their perceived experiences will just throw oil on the fire. Most importantly these persons have the image of Christ imprinted on their souls. They are not just “transgendered” but whole people who have an inbred dignity afforded to them by this image of Christ on their soul.

I don’t think I said anywhere that we shouldn’t be concerned how it affects their spiritual life. My argument is that the path in leading them to a healthy spiritual life does not lie in pointing out that they’re somehow in “error” for believing that they are, say, a woman trapped in a man’s body. It will not change how they feel one bit. A health professional may be able to determine the degree of transgenderism involved and whether the person can be helped without transitioning to their perceived gender. But if we as laity or even clergy dismiss their condition as an error on their part, we’re really pushing that person away from God and not doing their spiritual well-being any kind of good. We’re in fact trying to impose on God our own set of limitations on how He should relate to that person and who He should and accept and reject. It’s a subtle form of judging the person and often comes from our own deep-seated discomfort with these issues.

We need to make these folks feel loved and accepted unconditionally (on our part) to lead them into a relationship with Christ who does love them unconditionally. It is only through a close relationship with Christ can these people truly be helped spiritually. If that relationship shows them a better way to deal with their condition that is great. If it doesn’t because they can’t overcome it, they still need to feel hope in God’s mercy and unconditional love for them. God doesn’t reject His ailing children. Despair is a terrible thing. And this means we ourselves need to become more Christ-like in our interactions with transgendered and gay people. The Rule of St. Benedict says to greet any visitor to the monastery as if it was Christ himself visiting. It doesn’t place conditions on this. It doesn’t say “only people who accept Church teaching on sexuality”. It says everyone and that’s because everyone has the image of Christ on his soul. It’s part of our dignity, and we must become more Christ-like just as Christ ate with sinners who were the rejects of the society of His day.

All of this theological debating on how to approach, as people leading ordinary lives and having to occasionally interact with gays and the transgendered, is in fact worthless for those interactions. This stuff is wayyyy above our pay grade (unless as I said you’re a health professional engaged with the patient). Our faith is supposed to be transformational and dependent on a deepening of a relationship with Christ. A gay or transgendered person can have a relationship with Christ, and it is absolutely not dependent on their accepting the “theological” understanding of their gender. The starting point is not telling them that theirs is a sinful or wrong condition or that what they feel in their hearts is wrong. The starting point is telling them that they’re loved unconditionally, and to ask them to “come and see” how God made literally present in front of us can be transformational.

Alas I’m afraid though, with the way some of us in the Church have spoken on sexual disorders I’m not surprised at all that many gays and transgendered reject the Church.
Thanks for a wonderful post Ora.
God bless.
 
Actually I found peace a long time ago and while I am still far away from being a feminine woman, **I am very happy as a woman **now And wouldn’t change it for anything.
Sorry I do not understand this statement. If you are not a feminine woman, what kind of woman are you referring to?
But I did spend my childhood and early teen going by a male name, dressing like a boy, arguing that Iwas not a girl that iI was a boy, I always played with cars and robots and always disliked everything girl related so I am quite familiar with the feelings that ho with the situation and that is why I am convinced the problem with transgenders is that their issues are wrongly addressed.
If you have found your peace, good for you, I do hope it continues. I have come across many who have fought this, thinking they could keep it buried only to transition later in life.
I disagree however that the root cause is related to being unhappy with their bodies to start with.
 
Sorry I do not understand this statement. If you are not a feminine woman, what kind of woman are you referring to?

If you have found your peace, good for you, I do hope it continues. I have come across many who have fought this, thinking they could keep it burieto, but stillI hnly to transition later in life.
I disagree however that the root cause is related to being unhappy with their bodies to start with.
What I mean by not feminine specifically is I don’t like make up, I don’t like jewelry, I don’t like purses, I don’t like dresses and barely can stand skirts (the only way I would wear make up or a dress is if there is a specific occasion requires me to do it, or if for work reasons I have to but still heavily dislike it) I don’t like high heels or earrings and don’t like fashion or anbehaviorike that. My likes I have been told are totally the opposite of most women and forost of my life the majority of women have told me that they find me difficult because my conversations don’t fit with them and they think I am don’t have a female personality (this is what I constantly been told by other women, I personally don’t think there is a “female” personality but that is what I have been told). So that is why I say that I far from being a feminine woman because I don’t fit the society standard of feminine behavior. That used to really bug me in the past but now I don’t care.
 
The National Catholic Bioethics Center has FAQs on various issues.
Here is their FAQ on transgenderism.
What is immoral about a sex-change operation?
Properly understood, a person cannot change his or her sexual identity. For persons not suffering the disorders mentioned above (e.g., hermaphroditism) a person is either male or female. A person is the unity of soul and body, and ‘soul’ should be understood not as an immaterial self, but as that which makes the body be what it is, namely, a human person. We are either male or female persons, and nothing can change that. A person can mutilate his or her genitals, but cannot change his or her sex. Changing one’s sex is fundamentally impossible; these procedures are fundamentally acts of mutilation.
Mutilation results in a person being rendered impotent or sterile and dependent for the rest of one’s life on a hormonal regimen which makes one appear to be other than what he or she is. There is nothing wrong with the genitalia of persons seeking such operations. But they are removed in order to conform to the person’s subjective belief about who he or she wants to be. Doing violence to one’s body when there is nothing wrong with it is an unjustifiable mutilation. Furthermore, seeking such a mutilation manifests a self-hatred inconsistent with the charity we owe to ourselves. Persons seeking such operations are clearly uncomfortable with who they really are. Loving such persons properly demands addressing the beliefs and self-understanding that give rise to this fundamental rejection of self.
 
I have to complement you on your honesty.
What I mean by not feminine specifically is I don’t like make up, I don’t like jewelry, I don’t like purses, I don’t like dresses and barely can stand skirts (the only way I would wear make up or a dress is if there is a specific occasion requires me to do it, or if for work reasons I have to but still heavily dislike it) I don’t like high heels or earrings and don’t like fashion or and behavior like that.
Seems like you do not conform with society’s image of a woman, you are fortunate that society is much more accepting of a women adopting non-female clothing. If man had said that he does not like wearing pants, but prefers wearing dresses, loves makeup, loves jewelry etc the reaction would be quite different.
My likes I have been told are totally the opposite of most women and forost of my life the majority of women have told me that they find me difficult because my conversations don’t fit with them and they think I am don’t have a female personality (this is what I constantly been told by other women, I personally don’t think there is a “female” personality but that is what I have been told). So that is why I say that I far from being a feminine woman because I don’t fit the society standard of feminine behavior. That used to really bug me in the past but now I don’t care.
From what you have said so far (I am not a professional psychologist) it appears that you are a trans man but have come to terms about being called a woman and have ignored labels. I find it unusual that you say you don’t like most things related to being a woman, don’t behave like one, don’t fit in with them and yet love being one. You have not mentioned one thing you like about being a woman!
In essence you have not changed either your behavior nor clothing and are living an androgynous lifestyle, for most trans women this would be an acceptable solution, most do not go on to transition anyway.
I wish you the very best.
Have a very Merry Christmas.
 
I hcomplent you on your honesty.

Seems like you do not conform with society’s image of a woman, you are fortunate that society is much more acceptingopting non-female clothing. If man had said that he does not like wearing pants, but prefers wearing dresses, loves etc the reaction would be quite different.

I am not a professional psychologist) it appears that you are a trans man but have come to terms about being called a woman and have ignored labels. I find it unusual that you say you don’t like most things related to being a woman, don’t behave like one, don’t fit in with them and yet love being one. You have not mentioned one thing you like about being a woman!
In essence you have not changed either your behavior nor clothing and are living an androgynous lifestyle, for most trans women this would be an acceptablpersonality most do not go on to trawoman is on anyway.
I wish you the very best.
Have a very Merry Christmas.
Now just for clarification purposes I don’t wear men’s clothes. All my clothes are from the female aisle. For work I usually wear dressy pants and low heels, and outside work I tend to wear jeans and sneackers but is all from the female section of the store. I dont think i live an androgenus lifestyle because i dont cross dress. I just do not like what most women like and i care very little about fashion.

Again my personal opinion is that people have different personalities. I dont think the sex is on the brain. Yes Most men tend to behave in certain way and most women tend to behave in certain way because obviously hormones have an influence but not all humans , due to individualism, are or can be the same. The fact that someone’s hormones don’t affect them in the same way as the majority that doesn’t mean that said person has one sex on the brain and a different one on the body. That person belongs to the sex that his body is (and i am not talking about hermaphrodites) and just has a different personality. That person certainly needs to adapt a little and of course there have to be limits, but telling them that his or her being different makes them have the soul of a different sex is incorrect and creates confusion.

Trying to force every human being into a strict cookie cutter role of male or female is what causes most cases of transgenderism. Liking dresses, wearing make up and high heels is not what makes a woman a woman. What makes me a woman is my two xx chromosomes and my body. I don’t have to behave like one because I am one. The fact that I am different just means I have a different personality not that i am trans. Drag queens wear ten times more make up than most women and they are not women and will never be. Is not that I have come to terms with being called a woman is that I accepted reality, that I am woman and I learned to accept my own self and started loving my body as it is. I do have changed some behavior back from my teens as from having short hair to long, and I have changed dressing style in the sense that as a teen I was let’s say more radical, now for work obviously I try to dress accordingly but still you would never find me in high heels or skirts.

Most trangenders instead of realizing what I just said, start rejecting their reality because they want to fit and can’t fit. Hence eventually start developing self hatred against their sex. That is why I say the root of the problem is self hatred and non acceptance. If instead of pushing those transgender into a lie and telling them that a sex change operation will solve the problem we would address their internal problem and help them to accept that they are the sex they are but still be different probably we would have many many less transgendered people.

You don’t need to like everything that others like to be happy with your own self and you don’t need to be like most women to be happy as a woman. Yes I love being a woman since I realized I can be a woman and not wear make up and jewelry. I just have a different personality.
 
The National Catholic Bioethics Center has FAQs on various issues.
Here is their FAQ on transgenderism.
How would you reconcile all this with a person who has attempted (seriously) suicide because of a disorder of gender identity?

I would agree that mutilation is a bad thing. However mutilation is often used to save a life. Amputations, colostomies, hysterectomies, etc., have often licitly been used to treat various disorders ranging from cancer to gangrene or severe injury. Would it be better to say to someone with flesh-eating disease that it’s better to let them die than amputate their arm or leg?

What’s different about a mental disorder compared to a physical disorder? It’s time in this informed era, to stop stigmatizing psychological disorders as somehow being a defect of character. The brain is an organ and can suffer disorders as much as one’s hand or internal organs.

At one time, mastectomies, which are highly mutilating, were routine for all breast cancer cases. Now lumpectomies combined with chemo and radiation therapy, which are far less mutilating are as effective in the majority of cases.

However for transgenderism, we have not made that much progress in treatment. I would agree that surgery should be a very last resort, when it is clear that the patient will successfully commit suicide without it or will not be able to function in the world. Until we figure this out, surgery is perhaps the best treatment on offer, just as mastectomies once were the best treatment on offer.

Rather than stigmatizing those who feel they have no choice but to go this route we should instead invest in looking for better treatments. The sin may very well be ours for not treating this disorder seriously enough to spend on research to find better treatments, not on the person feeling that they’re about to step over a precipice without treatment. The sin could very well be not taking it seriously, and stigmatizing what is perhaps a very real disorder by confusing it with a defect of character.

Until we’ve walked a mile in their shoes…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top