Does 2 Tim 3:16-17 support Sola Scriptura?

  • Thread starter Thread starter RussAuburn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Paul wrote to Timothy: “All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work.” (2 Tim 3:16-17).
No, it does not support Sola Scriptura! It is true that all scripture is profitable for teaching, for reproof, etc. But Sola Scriptura means bible alone, while scripture is not limited only to the bible. Scripture includes all inspired writings existing in the present and those writings that the Church may declare in the future as inspired.
 
40.png
Ginger2:
That I disagree with as far as anything we need to know goes. If I learned that Jesus healed five thousand more lepers that are not mentioned in the NT, would it make any difference? If a new Scripture was found and authenticated that said Jesus raised 100 more individuals from the dead, would that make Jesus any greater?
It could make a big difference if the passage mentioned names of the some of the people healed-- and the name of even one of these people were found to be historically verified (like Caiaphas the High Priest was).
 
It could make a big difference if the passage mentioned names of the some of the people healed-- and the name of even one of these people were found to be historically verified (like Caiaphas the High Priest was).
No it wouldn’t - not unless God specifically wanted to use that specific incident to speak to someone’s heart - or to a multitude.
If some people refused to believe even when they stood face to face with Jesus, we have to accept that some people will simply not believe just because we discover more evidence.

As for me… I don’t need more evidence - I already have proof.

I used to think, "If God performed a miracle today, they would see and believe.? But it doesn’t work that way. Some people simply choose not to believe and God leaves that in their hands. Some people say “OK, I’ll give God a chance to prove His existence.” But forgot He is God - He doesn’t have to prove anything to someone who will turn away when God doesn’t promptly perform for them.

Abraham said to the rich man, "They already have the prophets…

I know an ex-gay man who was reading the Scriptures. He read the words about being a new creation and decided God could make him heterosexual. He’s is in a heterosexual marriage today.

I think they will be celebrating their 6th anniversary this year.

God has already given us everything we need. We already have historical evidence to support the Bible - how dare we continually insist we need more.
 
But there is much more to understanding scripture than prayer. The exegesis and hermeneutics are just as critical. And we can see what doing these without an infallible guide produces in the Protestant Denominations.
No, they are not essential - Christ Jesus is essential. Aside from what God has given us, these things can be helpful - but to those who are perishing it is all useless.
So, are you saying that the council that proclaimed the canon was not a theopneustos infallible council? If the HS did not guide that decision, then how is it any more trustworthy than Marcion’s canon?
No. The Holy Spirit is always with those who are serving the Lord. What I am saying is that 3 separate yet harmonious accounts of the life of Jesus bare powerful testimony even if not place in one collection. Christians would still know of these 3 books written by three different men and that all 3 books support each other’s testimonies. We would still have access to inspired writings with out them being gathered together in a collection of works called the Bible. The canon was created to keep false writings from being passed around as Inspired…

Come to think of it, it didn’t work. But it did make it easier for Christians to own a personal set of Prophetic and Apostolic works! 🙂 .
God had a plan about how He wanted people to find Him. He entrusted this plan to men.
God entrusted His plan to Jesus!
It is not overlooked. It is just that Catholics believe that, if one finds God, then one finds His Body, the Church. We believe that we are not meant to exist as “just me and Jesus”, but to be members one of another.
Absolutely! One body, many parts.
 
We have four Gospel accounts to testify of Jesus. How many more do you think are necessary to understand who Jesus is? 12, 50, 100?
Not the point at all–and in which case, Jesus wouldn’t have needed to send His Apostles, since by your logic, all we need are the four Gospels. Yet, the Gospels were not written when the Apostles went out to preach.
Would adding more accounts make the truth any truer?
If this is your reasoning, as again mentioned above, then Jesus wouldn’t have commissioned His Apostles. As well, we don’t need any church or pastor, since Scripture is enough. Yet, don’t we have pastors and churches?
Peter refers to Paul’s letters as Scripture. "… even as our beloved brother Paul also according to the wisdom given unto him hath written unto you;
Peter did not consider Paul’s letter here as Scripture. Where did you get the idea that he considered Paul’s letter to be Scripture?
I do not know any protestant who defines Sola Scripture as the Catholics do. Since Protestants are the ones who believe in Sola Scripture, Protestants would be the ones to know what we believe? Therefore the Catholic definition is wrong.
Since you insist on that, what then for you is sola scriptura?
This idea stems from your misunderstanding of Sola Scripture.
As Luther himself defined it, sola scriptura means that the only authority one must have is the Bible, and nothing else. Is this a misunderstanding as well of sola scriptura?
 
Peter did not consider Paul’s letter here as Scripture. Where did you get the idea that he considered Paul’s letter to be Scripture?
Milliardo,

Ginger was probably thinking of…
2 Peter 3:16:
16 as also in all his letters, speaking in them of these things, in which are some things hard to understand, which the untaught and unstable distort, as they do also the rest of the Scriptures, to their own destruction.
It appears that Peter understood that Paul’s writings (at least some of them) were scripture.
 
As Luther himself defined it, sola scriptura means that the only authority one must have is the Bible, and nothing else. Is this a misunderstanding as well of sola scriptura?
Can you provide the text from Luther for our review?

I’ve never read anything from the reformation that defined sola scriptura as meaning “…that the only authority one must have is the Bible, and nothing else”.
 
No, they are not essential - Christ Jesus is essential. Aside from what God has given us, these things can be helpful - but to those who are perishing it is all useless.
Who defines the essentials, the Church or Matt Slick?
No. The Holy Spirit is always with those who are serving the Lord. What I am saying is that 3 separate yet harmonious accounts of the life of Jesus bare powerful testimony even if not place in one collection. Christians would still know of these 3 books written by three different men and that all 3 books support each other’s testimonies. We would still have access to inspired writings with out them being gathered together in a collection of works called the Bible. The canon was created to keep false writings from being passed around as Inspired…
So you accept that the Church alone could determine which books are inspired?
Come to think of it, it didn’t work. But it did make it easier for Christians to own a personal set of Prophetic and Apostolic works! 🙂 .
When after the invention of the printing press in the 16th century?
What about all the peasant folks before then?
God entrusted His plan to Jesus!
Gods plan for salvation for us comes in many ways. In the case of Scripture it came through the traditions of His Church:

Catholic Christians and non-Catholic Christians believe that the Bible is the inspired Word of God. This belief is based on their acceptance of the fact that the Catholic Church had the authority to declare which books were inspired and should be included in the list of sacred books or “Canon”, and which should not be included.

The Catholic Church knew it had this authority and guidance because:
  1. “And I will pray the Father, and He will give you another Helper, that He may abide with you forever - the Spirit of truth” (John 14:16-17)
  2. “However, when He, the Spirit of Truth, as come, He will guide you into all truth” (John 16:13)
  3. “… I am with you always, even to the end of the age” (Matthew 28:20)
  4. “Whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven” (Matthew 16:19)
  5. “… it has now been revealed by the Spirit to His holy apostles and prophets” (Ephesians 3:5)
  6. “… the church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth” (1 Timothy 3:15)
For more than 1500 years the Catholic Church has accepted and taught that these 73 books of the Bible are inspired and make up the list of sacred books.

Jesus gave His Apostles and Church the gift of the Holy Spirit when He said. “… ‘Receive the Holy Spirit.’” (John 20:22).

Jesus also said, “However, when He, the Spirit of truth, has come, He will guide you into all truth” (John 16:13).

It is impossible that the Holy Spirit, the Spirit of Truth, would lead the Church in an error for 1900 years. Such a promise was made to the Church alone.

So the Spirit of Truth guides the Church in all truth, not an individual person.
Absolutely! One body, many parts.
Undoubtedly. Glad to have as a member.

Peace.
 
Can you provide the text from Luther for our review?

I’ve never read anything from the reformation that defined sola scriptura as meaning “…that the only authority one must have is the Bible, and nothing else”.
Does this mean that protestants now accept other teachings outside of the bible?
 
Oh good, the obvious! How about the teaching that Mary is mother of the Lord? or that statues are not idols?
Mary is the mother of Jesus and I do believe that is found in the gospels so I’m not sure what you are getting at.

As to “…statues are not idols?”, I guess it would depend on what one is doing with the statue.
 
Mary is the mother of Jesus and I do believe that is found in the gospels so I’m not sure what you are getting at.

As to “…statues are not idols?”, I guess it would depend on what one is doing with the statue.
I am pursuing your declaration that you accept teachings that are outside of the bible. By teachings, we are talking of it in the context of CAF, that is, of Church teachings. So you believe in everything that the Catholic Church teaches, right?
 
Mary is the mother of Jesus and I do believe that is found in the gospels so I’m not sure what you are getting at.
Perhaps he meant to ask if you accept that Mary is the mother of God. A great many protestants don’t accept the Council doctrine that Mary is Theotokos, Mother of God.
 
I am pursuing your declaration that you accept teachings that are outside of the bible. By teachings, we are talking of it in the context of CAF, that is, of Church teachings. So you believe in everything that the Catholic Church teaches, right?
No, I am not catholic nor do I accept everything the catholic church teaches.

Sola scriptura, at least as defined during the reformation, does not exclude or eliminate the authority of the church, study guides, creeds, teachers, etc. I don’t believe any of the reformers taught anything akin to what I see some catholic apologists trying to sell as sola scriptura which could best be described as the “me and my bible alone under a tree” mentality.

In the passage that this thread is supposed to be dedicated to we find Paul giving Timothy advice. Paul did not say turn to the magesterium or the bishop of Rome. He told Timothy to turn to the scriptures. During a time of crisis we have Paul, under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, advising Timothy to turn to the scriptures, not the magesterium.

Let’s look at our choices. You can accept scripture as the sole infallible rule of faith or you can place your trust in the RCC (magesterium + scripture + tradition (supposedly apostolic)).

Scripture, not tradition, is described as “theopneustos” or God-breathed, i.e. inspired by God. This is the only time this term is used in the Bible. With the scriptures you have something that isn’t just breathed upon by God (such as the apostles) but breathed out by God, or inspired by God.

In general terms, tradition isn’t looked on to favorably throughout the NT. Of course we have 2Thess2:15 but your church with it’s rich history can’t tell anyone what exactly Paul meant by “traditions” in this text.

Your church claims infallibility but that dies the death of a 1,000 qualificiations. None of you are sure what has been defined infallibly and what hasn’t. Doctrine can’t “change” but it can “develop”. Well, your church develops it to such a degree so as to be unrecognizeable from one time period to another.

Your church currently seem to take a very liberal view of “outside the church there is no salvation” but that hasn’t always been the case.

Your church used to be pretty clear that the Mosaic covenant had ended but now it seems your church now teaches that the Jews have a covenant that is salvific.

The point being, your “tradition” seems to change so as to suit the times.

So, in the end, we have two views.

One that believes scripture (which is inspired by God) and scripture alone is the sole infallible rule of faith and the view that somehow the Roman church + scripture + tradition (much of which can’t be traced back to the apostles but is supposed to be apostolic in nature) is what the faith should be based on.

We obviously have come to different conclusions.
 
Sola scriptura, at least as defined during the reformation, does not exclude or eliminate the authority of the church, study guides, creeds, teachers, etc. I don’t believe any of the reformers taught anything akin to what I see some catholic apologists trying to sell as sola scriptura which could best be described as the “me and my bible alone under a tree” mentality.
“Sola scriptura is the teaching that the Bible is the only inspired and authoritative Word of God, is the only source for Christian doctrine, and is accessible to all — that is, it is perspicuous and self-interpreting. That the Bible requires no interpretation outside of itself is an idea directly opposed to the teaching of the Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, Coptic, Anglican, and Roman Catholic faiths , which teach that the Bible can be authentically interpreted only by Apostolic Tradition and the ecumenical church councils.” (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_solas)

In sum, 1Tim 3:15 would confirm that 2Tim 3:16-17 does not support Sola Scriptura.
 
That is incorrect. The Bible is a group of books. Each tells a part of the story. Stories are over-lapping and confirm one another.

Much of the Bible can be confirmed thru historic records and archeology - but most important…

The Bible is the living word of God. Thru the Scriptures God often speaks to His people. That in itself allows the Scriptures to be self-authenticating.
The “historic records” you are referring to is called “Tradition” which was passed down from the Apostles, you are borrowing from the Catholic Church, but you don’t want to admit it.
 
The problem is that the RC defines the Church differently than the Bible.

The church is the body of believers - wherever they exist. But Catholics define the “Church” as membership in the Catholic denomination.

As I look thru the posts, I see this is a stumbling block for our discourse.

Since you claim Tradition is the only way to correctly interpret Scripture, you make the Scriptures null.

God does not change. He remains the same God’s word does not change.

Mal 3:6 For I [am] the LORD, I change not; therefore ye sons of Jacob are not consumed.
Hbr 13:8 Jesus Christ the same yesterday, and to day, and for ever.

The Catholic Church claims that doctrines evolve. (That’s how you justify changing them)

The Word of God does not change.

I choose to believe that which is unchanging.
 
The problem is that the RC defines the Church differently than the Bible.

The church is the body of believers - wherever they exist. But Catholics define the “Church” as membership in the Catholic denomination.
You seem to ignore the parts of the bible which show that this church had authority over all the “body’s of believers”, in what they believed and practiced as shown in Acts 15, and the fact that Paul went to the church leadership to get his teachings approved.

The church indeed has an invisible aspect to it, but it also had and still has a physical aspect to it.

I think one of your main issues with the Catholic Church is that when it’s tradition’s contradict your own personal interpretation of scripture, you feel that the Catholic Church must be wrong, because you are right.

There is absolutely nothing the Catholic Church teaches which contradicts scripture, it only contradicts your incorrect interpretation of scripture.
Just as it contradicted the interpretation of scripture by Arius in the 4th Century.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top