Does God call people to be separate from Catholic Eucharist

  • Thread starter Thread starter rcwitness
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Im kinda busy to read all that, but correct me if im wrong. That has to do with Catholics marrying outside the Church.

But a non Cat Christian couple would be able to confer the Sacrament
 
It’s not a matter of sacraments, it’s a matter of a marriage performed outside the Church. A non-Catholic marriage, sacramental though it may be, was not performed in the Catholic church. That’s what the convalidation is for.
 
I don’t want to say you are wrong, because you may be right.

I have just been under the impression that convalidation is only for Catholics who married outside the Catholic Church.

As far as I know, Christian converts to Catholicism do not need to convalidate their marriage, so long as they were Baptized prior.

www.catholic.com

Do these converts need to have their marriage convalidated?

I’m not surprised your friends are getting conflicting opinions on this question, because even many pastors, let alone other parish staffers, don’t understand C...
www.catholic.com www.catholic.com
 
Last edited:
And you asking me to give you the whole essence is like giving money to a homeless person when he can get off his butt and look for a job and earn his money or giving a cheater answers to a test without doing the work.
 
If I offer blue sky?

Then tell you to ponder over that.

Does it make any sense?

Is that the blue sky “motto” of some airliner?
Is that that it never rains in California?
Is that that in the Dominican Republic it would rain for several hours straight then we would get such blue sky that it belied the period of rain that preceded it?
Is it that I live so far up in the hills/mountains/tall building that I’m surrounded by blue sky?

So your proposal just simply states that you will let me think about it… think what about what?

Maran atha!

Angel
 
mcq72 said:
Plenty of Scripture was penned way before Jesus to verify His preaching.
Click to expand...
Jesu didn’t come to be confirmed by the written Word as Truth . Jesus confirmed the the written Word as Truth. Jesus being greater than?
 
Last edited:
mcq72 said:
40.png
rcwitness:
The faith was preached before Scripture was penned… so Scripture is not the only source of the revelation of Jesus.
Click to expand...
And is preaching a source of the faith and revelations of Jesus today?

Plenty of Scripture was penned way before Jesus to verify His preaching.
Click to expand...
The source of revelation is Jesus. He commissioned His disciples to preach, and His Holy Spirit inspired some to write Scripture.

The Old Testament contained oral teaching and written Scripture, which promised the Messiah would come.

The New Testament was established by His body and blood, which suffered for the forgiveness of sins, once and for all! This body and blood is a means by which we come together and share in His grace.
 
On the Catholic Answers regarding baptism it says “Yet Christians have also realized that the necessity of water baptism is a normative rather than an absolute necessity.”

And either way; I was baptised. So will you apologise for your insults?
 
I am sorry you felt insulted.

I honestly don’t know why.

I said you are Christian by your Baptism. Thanks to the Church 😉
 
Largely because, and I have explained this, you keep insinuating that I’m a liar.

So, will you apologise?
 
Alex337 said:
Largely because, and I have explained this, you keep insinuating that I’m a liar.

So, will you apologise?
Click to expand...
I didn’t say you are a lier. I believe you are being deceived.

Why would I believe it was God that told you to leave the Catholic Church? He has Confirmed me in Spirit and the history of the Church, in harmony with Scripture and the Church Fathers the opposite.
 
Last edited:
You kept saying I wasn’t Christian after I told you multiple times I was. You were mistaken and should simply say “I made a mistake, I’m sorry”.
 
It is not Christian to say some things you say.

Namely that Scripture is fallible. All of Christianity, even the children of the reformation know that is false.

Your religion does not Baptize or participate in His Supper.

It’s possible to be a Christian and deny the faith, you know?
 
You have said earlier that you accept I am Christian, or are you retracting that?

And again; you admitted that translations can be false. Which is what I said. Oh dear, are you not Christian?
 
Last edited:
Why are you in a thread about Communion, when your religion does not practice Communion?
 
Because the thread asks if God ever leads someone away from the Catholic Eucharist.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top