Either Catholics or Mormons have it right...

  • Thread starter Thread starter SalesianSDB
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
They talk of three separate beings all being God; therefore they believe in three Gods. They may only pray to one God but they believe there are three.
Essence make one one. Yes, Mormons don’t want to understand it.
Without wheels, would I really have a car? yet my car has wheels. Your statement is pointless.
Another pointless but very common Mormon statement. What a Catholic believes does not depend on what a Muslim believes, and neither changes what a Mormon believes.
Another common yet meaningless Mormon statement.
Another example of a complete a total dodge. First, I am not a Mormon; the only reason I am taking their side is because I feel forced to take their position because of the utter and complete dishonesty of the criticism. It is not representative of Catholicism, of Christianity, or anything that believes in honesty or Jesus Christ. I condemn it as the work of evil. Second, I stand against all organized Christian churches because they all seem to do the same thing…argue over the senseless and worthless while ignoring the most important doctrines taught by Jesus. It is disheartening to see, but it is the truth.

Stephen, when you want to be honest, answer the questions or just humbly admit you haven’t a clue about what you are talking about.
 
JeanMichael –

What you are seeing is the fruits when people reject the truth of Jesus Christ.

Jesus Christ Himself is the founder and definer of Christianity and HIs One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church…Not Islam and certainly not Mormonism.

The problem you are describing is when others such as Islam – from its slaughter and staking of the Holy Land by creating more myths – Mohammed had no interest in Jerusalem…and the time in which he was supposed to ascend into heaven – the farthest mosque was 10 miles away…and the spot the Umayyhids created as his ascension was actually approximate to St. Mary Major Catholic Church!!..and the slaughter of Constantinople, the home of the Orthodox Church … from this religion…

To Mormonism appointing itself as the interpreter of the Apostolic Church originating out of the early 1800’s Stone Campbell movement with some pretty shady characters…insinuating Christ made a mistake…the apostles were not allowed to appoint their successors but the Mormons were…

Yes you would have a problem with organized religion.

And if you were to accept the fact that there is such a thing as authentic, concrete, non-arbitrary truth, it would help you to see that theology has its place in insuring Truth.

Jesus said to Pilate, who later had Him crucified named Himself as Truth.

Certainly within all these divisions there are falsehoods but there is only one Truth and that is Jesus Christ. It is his own apostles with the Holy Spirit at Pentecost began His church, appointed their successors, developed liturgy from the Last Supper, the Bible assembled. It took many people many years. No new stories.

There is great consistency of faith and worship since the beginning of Christianity that brings us peace, oneness with God and with each other, holiness not of ourselves but from God alone, the universality of faith inspite of heresies and apostates–they are always present-- throughout the world at the beginning era of Christianity inspite of many hardships and persecutions – not killing, not slaughtering or overtaking holy lands, no creating a new story 1800 years later using glasses—implying blindness because of blindness to the truth of the light of Christ.

Christ’s major healings were regarding blindness…where people could see. Why put on the glasses, Joseph Smith??

There is another thread here started by Soren who has studied under the best scholars in the world on the book of Hebrew.

There is such a thing as scholarly research and then there is another who wants to believe in myths and serve the flesh.

It is Islam and Mormonism that invalidate Christianity for Christianity’s sake.

I pray you come to see that the Truth does exist.
Kathleen, I don’t know how your words applied to anything I stated previously. The points I was making is that criticism of one group (certain Catholics against Mormonism) and others (Islam against Catholicism). The main point was this: Jesus never, not a single time, demanded of his followers to believe in the doctrine of the Trinity! Yet, you demand that all individuals must believe in the Trinity or they cannot even be a Christian! This is a pure doctrine of man. It was not taught by Jesus. It was not taught by the original apostles.

The original apostles most definitely chose their successors. Please refer to Acts and find out how the first apostle not chosen directly by Jesus was chosen to fill the place vacated by Judas.

Second, there is no historical evidence to support that the church founded by Jesus Christ is the Catholic Church. That is a position of faith; not historical fact. Anyone that states the contrary is simply not aware that there is nothing that supports that position. They are confusing faith with historicity.

Third, one of the things that I am trying to engender is a respect for all people of faith; to reject this senseless attack of others who follow Jesus Christ; to understand the position of faith that all have and that no one has a complete lock on “historicity”.

Truth is absolute. If it is not absolute it is not truth, but belief. As a student of Truth, as a follower of Jesus, and a his very broken disciple I have yet to find an organized religion that is not filled with zealots who know not Christ, but who speak in his name; those who ignore love and teach hate, war, lies in order to further their own church, its wealth and its power. Where is that church that teaches and soley focuses on Jesus Christ crucified and resurrected, and that we teach by love, we proclaim truth in love, patience, and faith. Do any of you see your examples for what they are? Your logic is flawed and full of holes and yet you blindly repeat it in order to condemn another group that professes Christ as their Savior. The more I see this behavior the stronger I come in my resolve to reject you as those who draw nigh unto Christ with their lips, but as those who never knew him.

Seeing this in the church of my childhood continues to cause deep pain. I follow Christ and worship him with all those who follow him. Their religious affiliation is irrelevant to me because all organized religions are full of the same type of people; those who seek to aggrandize themselves and demean others. It disgusts me.

I don’t even like talking about this. I need to repent of this and focus on this wonderful time of year. He was born of the Virgin and all the angels did sing praises to the birth of the Lamb of God. Sheperds quaked at the sight of the Star of Bethlehem and yet they adored him who was born in a manger. Peace on Earth Good Will to Men. Good Will not just to Catholics, but Mormons, Muslims, Anglicans, Lutherans…everyone.
 
I never said that to be Christian one has to have correct ideas. I have stated in past posts that I do believe that the Mormons do draw on that of Jesus Christ, in what way and in what manner, it is their own personal relationship irregardless of their definitions and their practices-- and Christ Himself is the one Who accepts, not us.

Heresies and apostasies brought forth doctrines. Catholicism is Christocentric, our faith is based on the life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. It is not a reactionary faith…we are not going forward because we are better than the Jews or any other people, but the new life and liberty in Christ.

So I think you are projecting here. People come here to define beliefs. Some times people come to grow in understand, to bring forth differences, to seek clarify. Others come to refute and argue.

Jesus said He instituted His Church as Peter as His rock. He appointed His apostles, and they appointed their successors…yes, we do have documents, many writings, artifacts, history of saints…and there were those many followers of Christ who left Him, thinking He was speaking of cannibalism.

You do not acknowledge either the invalidation of our faith by Mormonism in their declaration of this apostasy, nor do you care to acknowledge its or origins and the dubious characters involved. That is the tragedy. I do pray for the Mormon people, for our unity as Christians. You have not read the thread the we all declare our affection for the Mormon people.

The issue is constructs, the beginnings and beliefs in Mormonism that have endured since its inception that are now being buried.

We are approaching a sacred time, and Yes, I do share with you my withdrawal from this thread. I have had my own trial in the Church, but what has kept me in it is our apostolic faith and forgiveness. It is so easy to be relative.

You give me the impression that you consider yourself above others because you are better than those in organized religion. You cannot see the issues. And personally for myself, if people can’t grasp the Holy Trinity…theological concepts…it is no loss for me…because Christ looks at the heart of the person…not intellectual theology.
 
Another example of a complete a total dodge.
A ‘dodge’ means someone addressed me and I did not give a direct answer. No one addressed me, so a ‘dodge’ would be impossible. I addressed you, so if you failed to address my argument then it would be you who ‘dodged.’ Let’s see how you did:
You mix up scriptures and context in your attempt to “prove” that Mormons believe in three Gods, but in talking to Mormons they say they are monotheists in that they pray to one God without any question or choice of praying to any other God.
Stephen168;7386469:
They talk of three separate beings all being God; therefore they believe in three Gods. They may only pray to one God but they believe there are three.
And your response:
First, I am not a Mormon; the only reason I am taking their side is because I feel forced to take their position because of the utter and complete dishonesty of the criticism. It is not representative of Catholicism, of Christianity, or anything that believes in honesty or Jesus Christ. I condemn it as the work of evil. Second, I stand against all organized Christian churches because they all seem to do the same thing…argue over the senseless and worthless while ignoring the most important doctrines taught by Jesus. It is disheartening to see, but it is the truth.
What a dodge. You didn’t address anything I said.
First, I am not a Mormon; the only reason I am taking their side is because I feel forced to take their position because of the utter and complete dishonesty of the criticism.
Most of the criticism against Mormonism is honest and your defense of their position is irrational. Your irrational claims are the same I’ve heard from other Mormons; mainly, an irrational attack on Catholic belief as I pointed out in my post. The definition of essence is not a mystery, but Mormons like to make fun of Catholic beliefs they don’t understand by calling them a mystery. Do you really think Catholic belief depends on what a Muslim believes about Catholics? Somehow is makes sense to a lot of Mormons because they use this claim a lot.
Stephen, when you want to be honest, answer the questions or just humbly admit you haven’t a clue about what you are talking about.
Name calling is also popular among Mormons. I will let my answer and your total lack of a response speak for itself.
 
It is like…God is whatever you make him to be…no matter the means you took to create Him…

The Catholic Faith originated and progressed very differently than Mormonism to say the least.
 
Kathleen, I don’t know how your words applied to anything I stated previously. The points I was making is that criticism of one group (certain Catholics against Mormonism) and others (Islam against Catholicism). The main point was this: Jesus never, not a single time, demanded of his followers to believe in the doctrine of the Trinity! Yet, you demand that all individuals must believe in the Trinity or they cannot even be a Christian! This is a pure doctrine of man. It was not taught by Jesus. It was not taught by the original apostles.

The original apostles most definitely chose their successors. Please refer to Acts and find out how the first apostle not chosen directly by Jesus was chosen to fill the place vacated by Judas.

Second, there is no historical evidence to support that the church founded by Jesus Christ is the Catholic Church. That is a position of faith; not historical fact. Anyone that states the contrary is simply not aware that there is nothing that supports that position. They are confusing faith with historicity.

Third, one of the things that I am trying to engender is a respect for all people of faith; to reject this senseless attack of others who follow Jesus Christ; to understand the position of faith that all have and that no one has a complete lock on “historicity”.

Truth is absolute. If it is not absolute it is not truth, but belief. As a student of Truth, as a follower of Jesus, and a his very broken disciple I have yet to find an organized religion that is not filled with zealots who know not Christ, but who speak in his name; those who ignore love and teach hate, war, lies in order to further their own church, its wealth and its power. Where is that church that teaches and soley focuses on Jesus Christ crucified and resurrected, and that we teach by love, we proclaim truth in love, patience, and faith. Do any of you see your examples for what they are? Your logic is flawed and full of holes and yet you blindly repeat it in order to condemn another group that professes Christ as their Savior. The more I see this behavior the stronger I come in my resolve to reject you as those who draw nigh unto Christ with their lips, but as those who never knew him.

Seeing this in the church of my childhood continues to cause deep pain. I follow Christ and worship him with all those who follow him. Their religious affiliation is irrelevant to me because all organized religions are full of the same type of people; those who seek to aggrandize themselves and demean others. It disgusts me.

I don’t even like talking about this. I need to repent of this and focus on this wonderful time of year. He was born of the Virgin and all the angels did sing praises to the birth of the Lamb of God. Sheperds quaked at the sight of the Star of Bethlehem and yet they adored him who was born in a manger. Peace on Earth Good Will to Men. Good Will not just to Catholics, but Mormons, Muslims, Anglicans, Lutherans…everyone.
People here seem quite content discussing the issues you feel are not important. As a matter of fact all participants appear quite passionate about them and more than willing to carry on these conversations. It strikes me as more than a little bit arrogant for you to try to set the limits of discussion based on what you find appropriate. Places like this and MAD and CARM are set up for these kind of discussions for people who like to participate in them. Each of these sites has their own bias and all those who participate are aware of them. If you find this troubling you should spend some time finding sites that suit you instead of sanctimoniously lecturing those who are using the sites for discussion, you know what they were set up for originally. There are many sites that are set up for what you are looking for, there is no need for you to conform this site to your expectations.

Oh and by the way
*Lecturing Catholics on behavior
*Neglecting to lecture non-Catholics on the same behavior
*Claiming you do the 2 above because you were raised Catholic and _as a result you are embarrassed by the behavior
*Disparaging “organized religion”
*Setting yourself up as the arbiter of “Christian” behavior

It’s been done before, and as with others your one sided lecturing shows not a disdain for “organized religion” in general but a clear disdain for Catholicism in particular. Disdain for Catholicism is fine, lots of people have negative views of Catholicism and they are quite upfront about it. You on the other hand present yourself as someone removed from the discussion, someone with objectivity, above all the “narrow mindedness” presumed in “organized religion” while at the same time focusing all of your criticism on the Catholic posters and their view. I find this quite disingenuous on your part.

In short, I’ll believe your “I dislike all organized religion” when I see you saying the same things to LDS on MAD and Evangelicals on CARM until then I see an anti-Catholic chip on your shoulder covered with a pretty shawl. 🤷
 
I myself have a great love and need for this religious organization we call the Catholic Church. It’s where I found Christ to be many years into my life. I love the mystical body of Christ , the fact that we are all joined together in Him, receiving Him is so many beautiful ways via the sanctifying Sacraments, the Mass. I see myself as a leaf among many connected to Him, the tree of life. I once had a special place away from any organized religion, it was two very large granite rocks that came together, with a waterfall running between them falling into a large mountain pool. I would get between the rocks with the water below my feet and fish the hole below. I always brought one bear with me for this special place . I was young; this is what we did when fishing.

Every year when I was there it was special, at this place I would give thanks to God, a God that I did not know as I know now, but I knew he was there. This was my religion then. All of this and so much more brought me to the Catholic faith, the last place I ever would have looked. Now my special place is at the Holy Mass. I am there with the body of Christ both in heaven and on earth. I see others as just as important as me, loved no less by my Father. You take away any part of the Catholic Church, you part a little of Christ Himself. Christ is the Catholic Church and yes we are the members of His body. I still have my special place in the mountains. But in my life now all places are special as all places contain Christ. I could not say I do not need my family, just as I could not say I do not need His Church. His Church reaches out to the whole world and says here I AM. Come to my table together and feed on me. I will bring you back. It is truly the best place to find Jesus as He is. All other forms of Christianity flow from the Mass whether known or not. All other forms of cults who whisper the name of Jesus can only whisper this name because of the Catholic Mass. They all live down stream so to speak. Like it or not.
 
You mix up scriptures and context in your attempt to “prove” that Mormons believe in three Gods, …
I have not seen anyone use scripture to ‘prove’ Mormons believe in three Gods. We have used scripture to ‘prove’ there is only one God and believing in more than one God is contrary to God’s Commandants.
Joseph Smith 1844:
In the beginning, the head of the Gods called a council of the Gods; and they came together and concocted a plan to create the world and people it.
 
I myself have a great love and need for this religious organization we call the Catholic Church. It’s where I found Christ to be many years into my life. I love the mystical body of Christ , the fact that we are all joined together in Him, receiving Him is so many beautiful ways via the sanctifying Sacraments, the Mass. I see myself as a leaf among many connected to Him, the tree of life. I once had a special place away from any organized religion, it was two very large granite rocks that came together, with a waterfall running between them falling into a large mountain pool. I would get between the rocks with the water below my feet and fish the hole below. I always brought one bear with me for this special place . I was young; this is what we did when fishing.

Every year when I was there it was special, at this place I would give thanks to God, a God that I did not know as I know now, but I knew he was there. This was my religion then. All of this and so much more brought me to the Catholic faith, the last place I ever would have looked. Now my special place is at the Holy Mass. I am there with the body of Christ both in heaven and on earth. I see others as just as important as me, loved no less by my Father. You take away any part of the Catholic Church, you part a little of Christ Himself. Christ is the Catholic Church and yes we are the members of His body. I still have my special place in the mountains. But in my life now all places are special as all places contain Christ. I could not say I do not need my family, just as I could not say I do not need His Church. His Church reaches out to the whole world and says here I AM. Come to my table together and feed on me. I will bring you back. It is truly the best place to find Jesus as He is. All other forms of Christianity flow from the Mass whether known or not. All other forms of cults who whisper the name of Jesus can only whisper this name because of the Catholic Mass. They all live down stream so to speak. Like it or not.
I have to make a note regarding the bear. Its name was Bud!
 
Zaffirobrant…

Good defense. I have been reflecting with all the sharings with Mormons since coming on to CAF, and there is very little meeting of the road. I was very leery of coming onto a Mormon thread after I visited that LDS bookstore and came across such bad sayings about Christianity, its construct to start a new belief system in Mormonism. When people come here, they are coming to a Catholic Forum to learn our beliefs. I do not know why the poster came here with his anti-Catholic bias.

There was a fellow named Why Me who would come on in the same way, who gave us the impression he was Catholic because he was even lectoring at Mass. Finally somebody came out with a link to his site…with Joseph Smith as his icon, and saying how bad Catholics were talking him. People were picking up this guy wasn’t honest, and he was denying the reality of Mormonism.

Being nice just doesn’t cut it when it comes to the Truth. Jesus wasn’t always nice.

For us, our Christian duty is to defend the truth and to oppose fraud and bigotry…which the LDS administrators are continuing to do. To deny or cover up is a form of lying. And they are covering up even to their own members, especially the young people.

Rebecca said here the more you argue with the Mormons the more they think they are winning.

To deny fraud, to deny cover-up, to deny switch and bait-- people are drawn into Mormonism thinking they are worshipping the same Christ…then after baptism, they are given new teachings…this is fraud. Or claiming an apostasy at the beginning of Christianity…this opposes Scripture for the apostasy comes in the Latter Times…as now.

You can’t call such behavior or practices as moral representing true religion.

And I am saying these things in reaction to the upcoming appearance of the Mormon Temple in Rome and I have life long ties to Italian Roman Catholics.

The image of the Holy Trinity is given us at the beginning of Christ’s Ministry – at the River Jordan with the voice of the Heavenly Father and the Holy Spirit in the shape of a dove above Christ.

Again, the construct of Roman Catholicism is Jesus Christ and HIs life, teachings, healings, HIs crucifixion on the Cross – not the Garden of Gethsemane --, His appointment of His apostles and the sacraments, His resurrection to give us a new life.

Why would we need a new religion? Who else is there but Christ?
 
Another example of a complete a total dodge. First, I am not a Mormon; the only reason I am taking their side is because I feel forced to take their position because of the utter and complete dishonesty of the criticism. It is not representative of Catholicism, of Christianity, or anything that believes in honesty or Jesus Christ. I condemn it as the work of evil. Second, I stand against all organized Christian churches because they all seem to do the same thing…argue over the senseless and worthless while ignoring the most important doctrines taught by Jesus. It is disheartening to see, but it is the truth.

Stephen, when you want to be honest, answer the questions or just humbly admit you haven’t a clue about what you are talking about.
I assume then, since you have such disdain for organized religion, that you have found the fullness of truth on your own. It is you who know what is important and what is not. How is this different from any organized religion?

JeanMichel, defending truth is a noble exercise. Each of us has a little different tact and varying degrees of patience and charity and, no doubt, it can get ugly at times. But tolerance of error is not charity. Pretending that we all believe the same thing is not a virtue, but an offense against truth.
 
He should check Soren’s thread regarding the ‘apostasy’…to see where people are coming from.

What people here are reacting to is the fraud and rejection of Christianity by this founding group of Mormonism, and the way and manner the leadership ‘does things’.
 
Rich,

I always enjoy your sharings of your conversion to Catholicism and how you experience faith…it is so spiritually rich and so much reflected of your deep place in the Word of God, Jesus Incarnate.

May you have a most holy Christmas, and also all who have come to this thread.
 
I myself have a great love and need for this religious organization we call the Catholic Church. It’s where I found Christ to be many years into my life. I love the mystical body of Christ , the fact that we are all joined together in Him, receiving Him is so many beautiful ways via the sanctifying Sacraments, the Mass. I see myself as a leaf among many connected to Him, the tree of life. I once had a special place away from any organized religion, it was two very large granite rocks that came together, with a waterfall running between them falling into a large mountain pool. I would get between the rocks with the water below my feet and fish the hole below. I always brought one bear with me for this special place . I was young; this is what we did when fishing.

Every year when I was there it was special, at this place I would give thanks to God, a God that I did not know as I know now, but I knew he was there. This was my religion then. All of this and so much more brought me to the Catholic faith, the last place I ever would have looked. Now my special place is at the Holy Mass. I am there with the body of Christ both in heaven and on earth. I see others as just as important as me, loved no less by my Father. You take away any part of the Catholic Church, you part a little of Christ Himself. Christ is the Catholic Church and yes we are the members of His body. I still have my special place in the mountains. But in my life now all places are special as all places contain Christ. I could not say I do not need my family, just as I could not say I do not need His Church. His Church reaches out to the whole world and says here I AM. Come to my table together and feed on me. I will bring you back. It is truly the best place to find Jesus as He is. All other forms of Christianity flow from the Mass whether known or not. All other forms of cults who whisper the name of Jesus can only whisper this name because of the Catholic Mass. They all live down stream so to speak. Like it or not.
Rich, thanks for this. I love to hear people’s conversion stories. It is incredible how God calls each of us to the same destiny in such unique ways. It is abundantly evident that you have fallen in love. I cannot imagine my life without the Church and its sacraments.

God bless you and your family and I wish you a blessed Christmas.

Steve
 
Thanks and all praise to God
I am so glad you guys are here!!!
The time you have to do what you do is precious
To the LDS and JeanMichel

We all really care about you guys in all sincerity

Have a merry Christmas
Go to the Christmas Mass if you get a chance, don’t miss Christ-mas


**To all Catholics …invite,invite and invite some more. **

**God Bless **
 
I stand by Rich…go to Mass, if you don’t like the pictures such as those at the Madeleine in SLC, then go to another church…

The Mass bears witness that Jesus Christ is the Living Word of God!
 
As per usual, Parker, you put your spin or the LDS spin on whatever is in scripture. Making it say what you want it to mean does not hold any water.

And believe me when I say that the Jews knew exactly what was meant by the term “prophet” and who was and was not a prophet. Since Christianity is a fulfillment and completion of Judaism, we also know about prophets and prophecy. I suggest that you make a concerted and deep effort to learn about Judaism. A good start is “The Writing of Flavius Josephus”. There is much literature available. Shalom.

PAX DOMINI :signofcross:

Shalom Aleichem
Javl,

You did not address ParkerD’s post that you were quoting. The verses given by ParkerD clearly show that Moses was considered to be a prophet. Also, you referenced Flavius Josephus to ParkerD. ParkerD then provided a quote by Josephus that showed that he considered Moses to be a prophet, and you didn’t address that point in your responding post either. In addition, the Jewish Encyclopedia has a section called “His Prophetic Powers” in its article on Moses. Also, the Jewish website “Judaism 101” refers to Moses as “the greatest of the prophets”. So I am unsure why you are claiming that Moses was not a “true prophet”.
 
The professional category of Moses is Patriarch. His work is more in providing the Jewish people freedom and leading them to the promised land.

The Mormons tend to contradict anything appearing Catholic or just Christian, words mean different, phrases, references all have different meanings…and we Catholics work in conjunction with aspects of mainline Judeo Salvation History.
 
Javl,

You did not address ParkerD’s post that you were quoting. The verses given by ParkerD clearly show that Moses was considered to be a prophet. Also, you referenced Flavius Josephus to ParkerD. ParkerD then provided a quote by Josephus that showed that he considered Moses to be a prophet, and you didn’t address that point in your responding post either. In addition, the Jewish Encyclopedia has a section called “His Prophetic Powers” in its article on Moses. Also, the Jewish website “Judaism 101” refers to Moses as “the greatest of the prophets”. So I am unsure why you are claiming that Moses was not a “true prophet”.
That is just a tangent to the claim by Mormons that polygamy is a Christian practice. But it was never taught or practiced by Christ and the Apostles. A Christian has not and would not practice polygamy. A person seeking the truth would question a religion invented in 19th century American which claims to be a restored Christian Church. Polygamy is an example of why that claim is false.
 
That is just a tangent to the claim by Mormons that polygamy is a Christian practice. But it was never taught or practiced by Christ and the Apostles. A Christian has not and would not practice polygamy. A person seeking the truth would question a religion invented in 19th century American which claims to be a restored Christian Church. Polygamy is an example of why that claim is false.
This does not address the issue that I was responding to, which was about whether Moses was a “true prophet” or not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top