Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A number of things. Now obviously, “mutation” means “change” so tautologically mutation must be responsible for all genetic diversity by definition. But it’s the “random” aspect that I want to discuss. While parsimony and Occam’s razor would lead me to dismiss the hypothesis of a directed or front-loaded evolution should the data be consistent with a “random” or completely contingent evolutionary process, there are still some questions about exactly what a completely “random” process could produce. What I mean by “directed” evolution is that God intervenes in the process, keeping it on track, while “front-loaded” evolution means that the initial conditions were set to bring about the intended result, with however no more interventions needed after that. With this in mind, however, almost all criticisms against “random” evolution simply aren’t applicable to directed or front-loaded evolution.

By analogy, we would reject the idea that if all the air in the room present while I am typing this moves to the other half, asphyxiating me, that this would be the result of a “natural” process - it’s too wildly improbable, even though technically speaking no laws at the micro level would be violated. We would also reject the idea from parsimony that God caused all the air in the room to disappear and then miraculously reappear on the other side. He must have either moved it directly to the other side, or arranged the initial conditions of the molecules so they would go there by a seemingly natural process.

First of all, I need to be specific on what is meant by “random”. The term “random” here technically means “random with respect to fitness”, not “random” in the ontological sense, like one might mean it with regard to quantum events. Yet this element of “randomness” is often implied, and an empirical randomness (based only on our lack of knowledge) is conflated with an ontological one. Thus, a “random” process in the technical sense is consistent with directed or front-loaded evolution, since all that would mean is that we can’t predict when the next beneficial mutation will occur. So I’m not arguing against the technical definition but against the implied one.

Now, the evidence. I’m not “dogmatic” on this either way, and could be convinced either way by more evidence.

There appear to be jumps in the fossil record followed by periods of stasis. Now it is possible that this is merely a result of not finding the appropriate fossils since the species didn’t fossilize. However it is also possible that they aren’t there and never were there. To be fair relatively small jumps in DNA space can result in large jumps in phenotype space; however, the “relatively small jumps” might still be larger than what a “random” process could produce.

There also appear to be “jumps” in the DNA evidence. If you look at the ape and monkey and human DNA, the chromosomal pattern between the various groups show big mutations at the chromosomal level (for instance the well-known fusion of chromosome 2 in humans). So there is evidence that “jumps” in the DNA space also occur. Are these random? Well, perhaps, but these appear to be one-off, and irreversible events.

And there is the question of the fitness landspace. With so many mutations being deleterious, even fatal, can you really get from point A to point B by a stochastic process? Perhaps Michael Behe was dead wrong about chloroquine resistance in his “Edge of Evolution” book but the question still remains. There may be an “Edge of Evolution” - a limit as to what a stochastic process can produce. True, the fitness landscape is not static, but changing (which is the response given to this critique) but there may still be too many valleys in the fitness landscape. And saying well it must be possible because here we are is begging the question.

Last, but certainly not least, is information theory. Information theory is IMHO one of the most sound and well-supported disciplines. Where does the information arise to build a given phenotype? Obviously you don’t get information from random noise anymore than you hear Beethoven’s Ninth by tuning the radio to static. Trial and error? Natural selection could form Beethoven’s Ninth if you waited for the right series of intensities from the noise. But is there enough time for this? You aren’t going to get a Shakespeare play by setting monkeys to randomly type on typewriters, to use a shop-worn example. The typical response is that how can you quantify the information in the genome. A good question, and one I don’t have an immediate answer ready for, but how can you quantify the information in this post. Doesn’t mean there isn’t information in it (well I hope so, anyway).

(Note BTW I didn’t include “irreducible complexity”. That one I haven’t found convincing at all.)
I just wanted to note that I found this to be an excellent post worth reading a few times. It really got me thinking. 👍
 
One thing that no one has considered.

We actually do not know for certain the mode and means of evolution.

We do know that variation exists and selection occurs. However, several factors have not been solidly researched like thermodynamic limitations, the absolute effect of codon wobble on what and what is not allowed in variation.
The DNA history of gene change and the theory of the allele is barely a half a century old and now we have reliable evidence that RNA is playing a role we had no idea about until a mere 10 years ago.
This arena of science is a baby and yet I have seen it argued back and forth about what is absolutely right and wrong. At this point I think it is premature to say that variation is due to totally random mutation. There may be physical restraints on both RNA and DNA that “push” both in positive directions rather than pointless meanderings with selection being the supreme judge. As a geneticist I can allow the possibility that the “deck is stacked” in favor of a certain complexity that exists but cannot be recognized by our current scientific sophistication. I allow it, but maintain it has to be proved to become a replacement theory.

At a minimum for science we must assume as Christians that God didn’t just throw the dice willy-nilly. If Evolution is a creative process then it has a plan and we just can’t see it now. Our tools are too unsophisticated, our science is too new.

ID is wrong because it depends on the “magic hat”. Current evolution theory [as preached by Richard Dawkins]is wrong in that it is semi-proved and developed an atheistic hubris that since we have a couple of the answers we can dump God.

It behooves ( Lord I love that word!) us all to consider that it is too early in the game to make any judgments as to the supreme facts of genetics and evolution and totally random chance of mutation. As Christians we should simply maintain that God chose this method of gene mutation and natural selection to get where we are today and devote ourselves as scientists to finding out how He did it. He allows that, encourages it and honors our efforts.
Fair enough?
 
My concern was with regards to the arguments given on this particular forum. The evidence is available for you to research. Do I see evidence of zealotry (religious zeal) as applied to the defense of Darwin and his theory? Yes, I do.
It’s just a last-ditch attempt to avoid discussing the evidence, by resorting to a personal attack. It is the counter-part of some atheists calling Christians “superstitious.” A mindless attack to cover the lack of a cogent argument.
 
It should be understood that “random” can be apparently random, like rolls of dice or the likelihood of encountering a predator, or it can be irreducibly random, like radioactive decay.

Evolutionary theory means that muations are not driven by necessity, but occur stochasticly, rather than deterministically.

So we often know what the mutation rate for a particular allele in a certain organism is, and even what the back-mutation rate is. Still, they appear randomly, in the same sense that rolling dice, the number 1 appears randomly. Since a quantum event can cause a mutation, it might even be true that most mutations are irreducibly random.

It really doesn’t matter. If God were secretly causing each mutation, making it appear to be random, the result would be no different than random mutations.
 
OK, me leave thread now. They is using the big smartypants wordz.

I mean, I always tho’t “stochastic” was “Thomas Aquinas on vodka.”

This thread has gotten completely beyond a layman like myself.

Let me know what y’all finally decide is the science of it, and I’ll say, “Great. Way to go, God!”👍

John
 
(parts removed for saving space)
And there is the question of the fitness landspace. With so many mutations being deleterious, even fatal, can you really get from point A to point B by a stochastic process? Perhaps Michael Behe was dead wrong about chloroquine resistance in his “Edge of Evolution” book but the question still remains. There may be an “Edge of Evolution” - a limit as to what a stochastic process can produce. True, the fitness landscape is not static, but changing (which is the response given to this critique) but there may still be too many valleys in the fitness landscape. And saying well it must be possible because here we are is begging the question.
Since every organism must conform to a set of basic rules that allow successful life the process successfully eliminates anything that is outside of those parameters without any selection at all from the environment. For our own group, primates, research has shown that we have a reproductive success rate of less than 10%. Studies using radioactive detection of hormones from fertilized ova show that 90% of all fertilizations don’t even implant. (Monty python-every sperm is sacred may be wrong:D )
Similar results have be seen in Macac and Papio. There is also the data from the genome mapping project that shows that many genes in the genome have duplicated though often silenced allele copies that can be “played with” by mutation without having any effect on the carrier organism. Such alleles if improved and reactivated by regaining promoters can then be added to the genetic make up.

Finally we have the marsupial radiations in Australia that show a geological flash in speciation due to an empty biome that allows almost any variation to find a niche and success. The Australian radiations would serve as a good example of organismic stricture that mutations pass through and the subsequent success of those organisms that do make it through the stricture and then are allowed to flourish due to lack of competition and availability of open niche targets.
 
Since every organism must conform to a set of basic rules that allow successful life the process successfully eliminates anything that is outside of those parameters without any selection at all from the environment. For our own group, primates, research has shown that we have a reproductive success rate of less than 10%. Studies using radioactive detection of hormones from fertilized ova show that 90% of all fertilizations don’t even implant. (Monty python-every sperm is sacred may be wrong:D ).
Chuck H, are you doubting the seminal text?

Every sperm is sacred.
Every sperm is great.
If a sperm is wasted,
God gets quite irate.

Let the heathen spill theirs
On the dusty ground.
God shall make them pay for
Each sperm that can’t be found.
 
Chuck H, are you doubting the seminal text?

Every sperm is sacred.
Every sperm is great.
If a sperm is wasted,
God gets quite irate.

Let the heathen spill theirs
On the dusty ground.
God shall make them pay for
Each sperm that can’t be found.
Yep which might explain why my Meaning of Life DVD won’t play anymore. John Clese has excommunicated me!:rotfl:
 
Since every organism must conform to a set of basic rules that allow successful life the process successfully eliminates anything that is outside of those parameters without any selection at all from the environment. For our own group, primates, research has shown that we have a reproductive success rate of less than 10%. Studies using radioactive detection of hormones from fertilized ova show that 90% of all fertilizations don’t even implant. (Monty python-every sperm is sacred may be wrong:D ).
Chuck H. now for something completely different. On a more scholarly note, prescinding from your comment above, what do you as a (Catholic?) geneticist make of the theological implication that if 90% of all fertilizations never even implant, then either

(1) “souls” are not infused at conception, and these spontaneous abortions preclude the development of persons, or

(2) the population of “heaven” will be more than 900% greater than the total number of humans who have ever lived, and

(3) these 90% of non-implanted conceptions “get into heaven” by doing an end-run around the moral gauntlet that has to be run by normally implanted conceptions that come to full term, are born, and during life have to prove themselves morally worthy of the Kingdom of God?

Prayerfully yours,
Petrus
 
Chuck H. now for something completely different. On a more scholarly note, prescinding from your comment above, what do you as a (Catholic?) geneticist make of the theological implication that if 90% of all fertilizations never even implant, then either

(1) “souls” are not infused at conception, and these spontaneous abortions preclude the development of persons, or

(2) the population of “heaven” will be more than 900% greater than the total number of humans who have ever lived, and

(3) these 90% of non-implanted conceptions “get into heaven” by doing an end-run around the moral gauntlet that has to be run by normally implanted conceptions that come to full term, are born, and during life have to prove themselves morally worthy of the Kingdom of God?

Prayerfully yours,
Petrus
It’s weak I know but using the selection of David as the new king of the Israelites (We see their bodies, God sees their hearts) and presupposing that God is logic as well as Love; I would imagine that wastage fertilizations are immediately known as failures by God and never get a soul. Recognized as “reproductive waste” from the instant of fertilization they would become little more than shed cells from the bodies of the parents. That still allows souls to be instilled at the moment of conception into any fertilization that “has a reasonable chance” and would include embryos that will survive well into pregnancy but are lost as fetuses due to genetic or chromosomal aneuploidy. I can look at a trisomy 18 or trisomy 13; two syndromes that are catastrophic to the physical human and are often lost in the third trimester, but still see where they have a soul and are cared for and made perfect by a loving God. I would suspect that theologians have a time with this subject as well as anencephalics that are born without any brain. While such children ( I wouldn’t automatically toss them out) have no possibility of a normal life and indeed rarely survive more than a few weeks at best, they do have human form and who knows?
The Church shows some ambivalence in this area since early spontaneous abortions do not qualify for burial and even in the staunchest catholic hospital are disposed of in the medical waste furnace. There is also the matter of hydatidiform moles which are triploid fertilizations that result in totally disorganized fetal tissues and must be removed by D&C to protect the mother from chorionic cancer.
It is so easy and elegant when a lively wriggling infant is in mom’s arms.
If I was a theologian I would exercise a principle of possible humanity and the soul is freely given whatever the outcome of fetal development or viability at birth. If there is no possible humanity then it is not given and the fertilization becomes biological waste.

That’s my opinion but not necessarily a claim to absolute truth.
 
Positively a “Hanging in there” RC.

I say hanging in there because I have seen some official teachings that make me really want to see the original arguments and data since at first glance I can’t believe anyone ever even went “there”:confused:
 
If I was a theologian I would exercise a principle of possible humanity and the soul is freely given whatever the outcome of fetal development or viability at birth. If there is no possible humanity then it is not given and the fertilization becomes biological waste. That’s my opinion but not necessarily a claim to absolute truth.
Chuck H., thanks for these careful reflections. And do hang in there; I consider myself a devoted Roman Catholic even though I’ve been reviled by conservatives on some threads of this forum as heretical, atheistic, pagan, an enemy of Rome, etc. For some, taking a position that they view as in any way as differing from “the Magisterium” sends you halfway to hell. And for some, a guy named Corapi (?) is a guru; his slogan apparently is “The devil’s favorite color is grey.” Someone who can’t see liminal cases would have a real problem with what you posted previously about “souls” and hydatidiform moles.

Petrus
 
Chuck H., thanks for these careful reflections. And do hang in there; I consider myself a devoted Roman Catholic even though I’ve been reviled by conservatives on some threads of this forum as heretical, atheistic, pagan, an enemy of Rome, etc. For some, taking a position that they view as in any way as differing from “the Magisterium” sends you halfway to hell. And for some, a guy named Corapi (?) is a guru; his slogan apparently is “The devil’s favorite color is grey.” Someone who can’t see liminal cases would have a real problem with what you posted previously about “souls” and hydatidiform moles.

Petrus
I often refer to myself as the “loyal opposition”. Those who leave the Church because they disagree with this or that haven’t read too much Church history. The Church has always been a lusty brawling group which I see as the Holy Spirit keeping us honest.
I fathered one of those “toe the liners” I am sure he will tell the priest at my funeral that I should be buried in cursed ground. He just missed being a SSPX and still drives 25 more miles to church than he needs to so he can attend a latin mass. He proves genes jump generations. His great grandmother was the same.
 
One thing that no one has considered.

We actually do not know for certain the mode and means of evolution.

We do know that variation exists and selection occurs. However, several factors have not been solidly researched like thermodynamic limitations, the absolute effect of codon wobble on what and what is not allowed in variation.
The DNA history of gene change and the theory of the allele is barely a half a century old and now we have reliable evidence that RNA is playing a role we had no idea about until a mere 10 years ago.
This arena of science is a baby and yet I have seen it argued back and forth about what is absolutely right and wrong. At this point I think it is premature to say that variation is due to totally random mutation. There may be physical restraints on both RNA and DNA that “push” both in positive directions rather than pointless meanderings with selection being the supreme judge. As a geneticist I can allow the possibility that the “deck is stacked” in favor of a certain complexity that exists but cannot be recognized by our current scientific sophistication. I allow it, but maintain it has to be proved to become a replacement theory.

At a minimum for science we must assume as Christians that God didn’t just throw the dice willy-nilly. If Evolution is a creative process then it has a plan and we just can’t see it now. Our tools are too unsophisticated, our science is too new.

ID is wrong because it depends on the “magic hat”. Current evolution theory [as preached by Richard Dawkins]is wrong in that it is semi-proved and developed an atheistic hubris that since we have a couple of the answers we can dump God.

It behooves ( Lord I love that word!) us all to consider that it is too early in the game to make any judgments as to the supreme facts of genetics and evolution and totally random chance of mutation. As Christians we should simply maintain that God chose this method of gene mutation and natural selection to get where we are today and devote ourselves as scientists to finding out how He did it. He allows that, encourages it and honors our efforts.
Fair enough?
Exactly. There’s still much more to be discovered in genetics. Which is why I am not “dogmatic” about what I said in the above post.
 
I often refer to myself as the “loyal opposition”. Those who leave the Church because they disagree with this or that haven’t read too much Church history. The Church has always been a lusty brawling group which I see as the Holy Spirit keeping us honest.
I fathered one of those “toe the liners” I am sure he will tell the priest at my funeral that I should be buried in cursed ground. He just missed being a SSPX and still drives 25 more miles to church than he needs to so he can attend a latin mass. He proves genes jump generations. His great grandmother was the same.
Chuck H., what’s a SSPX? And do you have to be one to enjoy Mass in Latin? I sing baritone in our Schola Cantorum, in a very progressive parish (open, inclusive, opposed to Bush’'s war, supportive of the homeless, etc.). The Eucharistic prayer and other prayers are in English, but the five sung bits are in Latin; Mozart this year for Easter.

And, in answer to #186

(1) Yes, John Haught and Archbishop Zycinski (see of Lublin) are very much in the prayerful mainstream of Catholicism, as well as being quite au courant with biology.

(2) I think “conservatives” might be surprised how “progressive” Augustine might be, were he alive today, at least on issues at the interface between religion and the sciences. On the other hand, those categories might not translate well across the centuries.

Petrus
 
Chuck H., what’s a SSPX? And do you have to be one to enjoy Mass in Latin? I sing baritone in our Schola Cantorum, in a very progressive parish (open, inclusive, opposed to Bush’'s war, supportive of the homeless, etc.). The Eucharistic prayer and other prayers are in English, but the five sung bits are in Latin; Mozart this year for Easter.

And, in answer to #186

(1) Yes, John Haught and Archbishop Zycinski (see of Lublin) are very much in the prayerful mainstream of Catholicism, as well as being quite au courant with biology.

(2) I think “conservatives” might be surprised how “progressive” Augustine might be, were he alive today, at least on issues at the interface between religion and the sciences. On the other hand, those categories might not translate well across the centuries.

Petrus
Society of Saint Pius X sspx.org/
I gather they are part of Lefebvre’s group . They are opposed to everything Vatican II.

When I say tridentine, I am talking about the entire mass in Latin. altar rail, communion only host and on the tongue. I ran into that here in Houston once at a Dominican parish, blew me away since I haven’t seen that for years. The parish was staffed by several older Dominicans (retired) which was good because there were no extraordinary ministers so only the priests could administer the Eucharist. That contrasted to our retired Franciscan parish in Galveston where mass is mainly in English and in conformity to the usual mass everyone goes to these days.
I would sit through a Mozart mass anytime or even a Beethoven mass and wouldn’t mind the Latin since it sounds strange when anyone tries to mix the music with English when it was a Latin work to begin with.
I just remember when I was a kid, the offering and sacrifice parts of the mass gave me chance to daydream since I never had any idea what they were saying. I don’t think I was the only one. To this day I think Vatican II happened because Pope John XXIII loved to don an old cassock and sneak out of the Vatican to walk the streets of Rome and probably heard the people talking about how they wished the mass was in their own language. I don’t know for certain but John was very concerned with pastoral things.
 
Exactly. There’s still much more to be discovered in genetics. Which is why I am not “dogmatic” about what I said in the above post.
I think a great moment of truth for me came when there were several scientists (physicists) talking about string theory on Universe (Nat Geo) and the fact that it could never be tested but was reasonably described mathematically using up to 10 dimensions above the ones we can observe. I could hear Jesus. You hypocrites! You can’t prove me so I don’t exist yet you create unobservable dimensions to prove a point that can never be experimented on. For that matter, string theory can never be more than string hypothesis. Now string theory sounds good to me and Timothy Radcliffe OP writes that the harmonics of the strings are probably the laughter of the Trinity (joy, not a cosmic joke). I just find it offensive to suggest you can’t prove God so He isn’t there but unprovable strings are. As Bugs might say, “what a bunch of maroons!”
 
For that matter, string theory can never be more than string hypothesis. Now string theory sounds good to me and Timothy Radcliffe OP writes that the harmonics of the strings are probably the laughter of the Trinity (joy, not a cosmic joke). I just find it offensive to suggest you can’t prove God so He isn’t there but unprovable strings are. As Bugs might say, “what a bunch of maroons!”
Wait – you’re not calling Timothy Radcliffe a maroon, are you? He’s a friend of mine, and was at out parish for a while last year!

I dined with George Coyne (retired director of the Vatican Observatory) and heard an excellent lecture by him. He spoke tonight on “The Dance of The Fertile Universe: Did God Do It?” He seriously believes Intelligent Design Creationism is the great heresy of our time.

Petrus
 
Wait – you’re not calling Timothy Radcliffe a maroon, are you? He’s a friend of mine, and was at out parish for a while last year!

I dined with George Coyne (retired director of the Vatican Observatory) and heard an excellent lecture by him. He spoke tonight on “The Dance of The Fertile Universe: Did God Do It?” He seriously believes Intelligent Design Creationism is the great heresy of our time.

Petrus
Not at all. The physicists who deny God because he can’t be proven are the maroons. I should have split Timothy Radcliffe away before saying that.
As for George Coyne, I have heard a few of his lectures and he is accurate. However, by definition if the universe is here, God did it so the worst that can be said of the ID people is they suffer from a literal translation of the Bible and believing it inerrant.
I think that, if approached by a scientific argument that God initiated a process in the beginning, they might be brought to the real science side. Their struggle is against the atheistic science that cannot see how creation is process and must have an author.
There is so much of religion that stands on Genesis that if it were proven to be a myth there would exist a requirement to undergo a radical realignment and understanding of theology. Our own Popes who have stated that evolution is accurate still pull back and reserve Adam and Eve to preserve the “fall” belief because it is so central to Judeo-Christian belief and thought. The fact that they include statements like this when discussing evolution infers they have thought about it and recognize theologically dangerous ground.
Hypothetically, if Adam and Eve were biblical constructs to explain man’s “state” then no original sin and the exodus was God bringing one group of man to the side to begin a relationship and Jesus’ mission was to take that relationship to the next level. The sacrifice of the cross would be required since man’s free will makes him able to refuse the truth and rightness of God but that conflicts directly with the Pauline dogma of salvation from Adam’s fall.
Given all of this I can see why some Christian scientists (no pun intended) would be almost desperate to find a direct intervention in creation that would support Genesis.
George Coyne is a good scientist and therefore views evolution as fascinating and exciting as a concept but my bet is it will eventually be problematic for rational theologians and fundamentalist theologians will forever regard it as a lie to maintain their beliefs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top