Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Not at all. The physicists who deny God because he can’t be proven are the maroons.

There is so much of religion that stands on Genesis that if it were proven to be a myth there would exist a requirement to undergo a radical realignment and understanding of theology.

George Coyne is a good scientist and therefore views evolution as fascinating and exciting as a concept but my bet is it will eventually be problematic for rational theologians and fundamentalist theologians will forever regard it as a lie to maintain their beliefs.
Chuck H, thanks for your response.

(1) I agree with you about the physicists, although in my experience biologists are the scientists most likely to tend to atheism. They are even more reductionist than physicists, who are often drawn to mysticism through their study of liminal questions in cosmology.

(2) I’m not clear on your statement that “There is so much of religion that stands on Genesis.” I don’t know any theologians who begin with Genesis; the core of the Hebrew scriptures (what we call the “Old Testament”) is not creation, flood, etc., but the calling of Abraham through the Exodus and Sinai experience and entry into the promised land. Genesis seems to have been composed later, although various units transmitted orally may have an ancient history. Creation, Fall, Flood – these are good stories borrowed from Ancient Near Eastern neighboring cultures, and crafted to fit in theologically with the Exodus core narrative. Religion doesn’t stand or fall on the historicity of the early Genesis stories.

(3) What do you mean by “my bet is it [evolution] will eventually be problematic for rational theologians”? How will it be problematic? Theologians are already finding it fruitful for understanding suffering, theodicy, redemption, etc.

Thanks for your provocative comments!
Petrus
 
Chuck H, thanks for your response.

(2) I’m not clear on your statement that “There is so much of religion that stands on Genesis.” I don’t know any theologians who begin with Genesis; the core of the Hebrew scriptures (what we call the “Old Testament”) is not creation, flood, etc., but the calling of Abraham through the Exodus and Sinai experience and entry into the promised land. Genesis seems to have been composed later, although various units transmitted orally may have an ancient history. Creation, Fall, Flood – these are good stories borrowed from Ancient Near Eastern neighboring cultures, and crafted to fit in theologically with the Exodus core narrative. Religion doesn’t stand or fall on the historicity of the early Genesis stories.

(3) What do you mean by “my bet is it [evolution] will eventually be problematic for rational theologians”? How will it be problematic? Theologians are already finding it fruitful for understanding suffering, theodicy, redemption, etc.

Thanks for your provocative comments!
Petrus
Being a simple biologist I often shoot my mouth off about theologians this and that when in reality I have never even taken a comparative religion class, much less a real theology class so keep that in mind when I make these bold statements. 😊

I make the comments since, so many times, I run into people that absolutely require a physical Adam, a single act of disobedience, that brings death into the world and a stain on all humans through that act. I am struggling with the difference between redemption and salvation. The former requires a fall while the latter only requires a state of incompleteness or natural fault. To give an example of the impact of Adam and original sin. There was a question asked by a pregnant woman on whether or not her unborn child shared in her taking of the Eucharist. The apologist stated that while the child derived benefits from her receiving the sacrament it could not share in the sacrament since it was still in a state of original sin. To me that statement demonstrates the impact of Genesis on modern thought and teachings. Paul, Augustine, Aquinas all the way up.

Your approach beginning with Abraham and the exodus suggests more that God called a group of extant humans aside to begin the salvation of mankind. That is to say that He began our spiritual evolution through Abraham’s faith and the tribes of Israel. The question is am I wrong in thinking that emphasizes the salvation over the redemption?

This would be soooooooooooo much easier if I were arguing deem size and gene fixation.

Is this clearer? I hope so.
 
I make the comments since, so many times, I run into people that absolutely require a physical Adam, a single act of disobedience, that brings death into the world and a stain on all humans through that act. I am struggling with the difference between redemption and salvation. The former requires a fall while the latter only requires a state of incompleteness or natural fault. … Your approach beginning with Abraham and the exodus suggests more that God called a group of extant humans aside to begin the salvation of mankind. That is to say that He began our spiritual evolution through Abraham’s faith and the tribes of Israel. The question is am I wrong in thinking that emphasizes the salvation over the redemption?

Is this clearer? I hope so.
Chuck, you ask a huge question, and I will have to spend the next week thinking about it. Immediately after the Triduum I leave for a conference in Indianapolis, and a possible visit to the AiG “museum.”

The theologies of creation, sin, salvation, and redemption are being reworked as we speak, as all theologies must be reworked from time to time as worldviews change. Humans are tribal and parochial, and there will always be Catholics who say there is no salvation outside the church and that original sin must be interpreted in a literal way; Fundamentalists who insist the Bible is literally true and that Jesus is personal lord and savior, and Muslims who say that acceptance of the Shahadah is absolutely requisite for salvation.

Petrus
 
The theologies of creation, sin, salvation, and redemption are being reworked as we speak, as all theologies must be reworked from time to time as worldviews change. Humans are tribal and parochial, and there will always be Catholics who say there is no salvation outside the church and that original sin must be interpreted in a literal way;

Fundamentalists who insist the Bible is literally true and that Jesus is personal lord and savior, and Muslims who say that acceptance of the Shahadah is absolutely requisite for salvation.

Petrus
With regard to the first paragraph above…HUH? This seems like dangerous ground for a Catholic to be treading.

And why you would lump in the second paragraph with the first? *

PS I’ve been away for a couple of days, so maybe I missed something…*
 
The theologies of creation, sin, salvation, and redemption are being reworked as we speak, as all theologies must be reworked from time to time as worldviews change. Humans are tribal and parochial, and there will always be Catholics who say there is no salvation outside the church and that original sin must be interpreted in a literal way;
To which I replied:

With regard to the first paragraph above…HUH? This seems like dangerous ground for a Catholic to be treading.

and you replied:
What does?
Your phrase “as all theologies must be reworked from time to time as worldviews change” caught my eye. As I said, HUH?

Maybe you could explain further.
 
Your phrase “as all theologies must be reworked from time to time as worldviews change” caught my eye. As I said, HUH? Maybe you could explain further.
Theology is not static; it is a dynamic, hermeneutical enterprise of translation of meaning from one generation to the next. For example, the doctrine of “the Fall” must be reinterpreted for an age in which the world is understood as 4.5 billion years old – the Genesis myth can no longer be interpreted in the literal way it has been. Of course, we could insist on interpreting it that way, but at the price of a huge disconnect: science would continue enriching us with new knowledge about the world and its history, while literalist Catholics would exist (with their Protestant brethren) in a parallel world, hermetically sealed off from science while interpreting the Bible literally.

The same goes for the theology of atonement, which has seen numerous different models over the years, some more cogent and others less so.

Petrus
 
With regard to the first paragraph above…HUH? This seems like dangerous ground for a Catholic to be treading…
“You are called to learn from one another, to renew the context in which science is done and to nourish the inculturation which vital theology demands. Each of you has everything to gain from such an interaction, and the human community which we both serve has a right to demand it from us.”

Pope John Paul II, CTNS-Vatican Observatory Conference to commemorate the 300th anniversary of the publication of Isaac Newton’s Principia (September 1987)
 
Theology is not static; it is a dynamic, hermeneutical enterprise of translation of meaning from one generation to the next. For example, the doctrine of “the Fall” must be reinterpreted for an age in which the world is understood as 4.5 billion years old – the Genesis myth can no longer be interpreted in the literal way it has been. Of course, we could insist on interpreting it that way, but at the price of a huge disconnect: science would continue enriching us with new knowledge about the world and its history, while literalist Catholics would exist (with their Protestant brethren) in a parallel world, hermetically sealed off from science while interpreting the Bible literally.

The same goes for the theology of atonement, which has seen numerous different models over the years, some more cogent and others less so.

Petrus
Thanks for that clarification.

When I hear the word “worldview” used in conjunction with “reworking” anything, it brings to mind radical feminists, radical atheists, radical environmentalists, and others who want to do what they want to do, and don’t want anyone else (like the Church) disagreeing with them (because that upsets them, apparently). You see, we are all supposed to accept the world view that it’s not a child, it’s a choice. etc. I realize that you don’t believe this.

“Literalist Catholics” - I actually don’t know any of those, although it’s my understanding that Catholics are allowed to believe in a literal interpretation of Genesis, should they so desire. And I know of no one, Catholic or otherwise who are sealed off from science in the totality of their lives.

I thought that you were one of the “Science can’t tell us anything about God” guys that I’m always arguing with. I apologize if I have you confused with someone else 😦

I agree that science can be a good thing. So long as we all keep ethics in the picture. And don’t let it become more important than God. And remember that there are some things for which we can find good “models”, but never actually “know.”
 
I sing … in a very progressive parish (open, inclusive, opposed to Bush’'s war,
I wonder how you arrived at that conclusion (that “your parish is opposed to Bush’s war”). Through some scientific method, I would suppose. Perhaps everyone in the parish opposes Bush’s war. I’m not sure why you’d then define the parish as “open” and “inclusive”. It’s certainly not very diverse if everyone adopts the same political stance.

In your later comments you seemed to dismiss the Church’s teaching on contraception. Do you dissent against that moral teaching of the Church?

… what this has to do with teaching students evolution in schools is that one should expect Catholic teachers to communicate and embrace the Catholic faith in its fullness. I’d take it a step farther and link dismissive comments against the Magisterium with an uncritical embrace of Darwinism. I see a connection there.
 
The reason most scientists believe in evolution is that it is the best scientific theory that they have been able to come up with. They refuse to accept the idea that our origins are not subject to scientific analysis. The idea that there are areas that are outside the realm of science is rejected by these people.

Just as a bunch of witch doctors trying to explain how an internal combustion engine works would speak about spirits within the engine who were causing it to run. They would be speaking from their experiences. They would not recognize their ignorance of mechanics, just as many scientists are unwilling, or unable to recognize the limitations of their discipline.

Catholics who believe in evolution don’t seem to recognize the limitations of science, nor do they see the blatant contradictions between Genesis and evolution, or they dismiss them by calling Genesis a myth.

Science can no better explain our origins than it can tell us what happens to our conciousness when we die. There was no one there to witness the event.

The Bible does not claim to be a book of science. But it is supposed to be the word of God. Why would God make up a story like that found in Genesis if we had indeed evolved from lower life forms? What would be the point in having Jews, Christians and Muslims believeing this for thousands of years, only to learn the truth from Charles Darwin in the Nineteenth Century?
 
(taken out for brevity)

The Bible does not claim to be a book of science. But it is supposed to be the word of God. Why would God make up a story like that found in Genesis if we had indeed evolved from lower life forms? What would be the point in having Jews, Christians and Muslims believeing this for thousands of years, only to learn the truth from Charles Darwin in the Nineteenth Century?
Abu, I don’t know what your profession is but I would love to hear you explain it to a five year old. After you got through, I would use it as an example for the Genesis explanation of creation. One of our good members used the analogy of the kernel and the husk. The kernel of Genesis is that God created us plain and simple. If you read my previous post on ID proponents you would see that science, particular theistic science proposes a God creation process so lets clear out any question of who did it. The husk is explaining it to basically a very ignorant people. If you have taken an airplane trip you have engaged in activity that, to a Semite of 3000 BC, was pure and simple magic and there is no way you could explain it other than indulging in fairy tale logic and explanation. To say Darwin explained all of evolution is to compare Thomas Edison’s horse hair lightbulb to fluorescents and LEDs of today. The world has changed knowledge wise. We no longer believe that dead meat causes flies thanks to a great Catholic Scientist Louie Pasteur. We no longer believe that the sun circles the earth or the ocean pours over an eternal waterfall at the end of the world. While the process of evolution does diminish the husk of Genesis, it increases the complexity and grandeur of God by revealing a wonderful process of continuing and awe inspiring creation. For God, it is a win-win situation and it can be for us as well.
 
Yes, worship the mind of man. For only there can the truth be found.

I think anyone currently in the thrall of science and the new rationalism reconsider. The “Bible Explanation Industry” is not run by Catholics. I heard a priest on the radio remark about how someone explained the miracle of the multiplied loaves and fish as the “miracle” of sharing. He laughed.

Today. Right now. Anyone being considered for sainthood must have two miracles attributed to them. Only the Catholic Church takes the limited information provided by science and combines it with divine revelation.

Divine revelation is the starting point, not science. I also suggest everyone read the previous posts and notice the emphasis on science. The emphasis should be on God.

Science will not save you on the day of judgement.

God bless,
Ed
 
I wonder how you arrived at that conclusion (that “your parish is opposed to Bush’s war”). Through some scientific method, I would suppose. Perhaps everyone in the parish opposes Bush’s war. I’m not sure why you’d then define the parish as “open” and “inclusive”. It’s certainly not very diverse if everyone adopts the same political stance.

In your later comments you seemed to dismiss the Church’s teaching on contraception. Do you dissent against that moral teaching of the Church?

… what this has to do with teaching students evolution in schools is that one should expect Catholic teachers to communicate and embrace the Catholic faith in its fullness. I’d take it a step farther and link dismissive comments against the Magisterium with an uncritical embrace of Darwinism. I see a connection there.
Tell me reggieM; do you have a subscription to Conspiracy Magazine? Please don’t parse and quibble and condemn. It is quite contrary to the whole premise of this web site. After carefully reading back through all of our posts I can’t find a single word said about contraception.
We should all be aware that the Vatican has, for scores of years, supported and listened to its scientists at the Vatican Observatory and Church run Universities. That is not to say they determine doctrine but their knowledge and insight has helped several good popes and councils to clarify and update their teachings.
I don’t need to defend Darwin. For a man of his time period and state of knowledge he remains a great scientist. His observations have enhanced enormously our understanding of nature and his work, coupled with the Catholic Abbot Mendel created the new science of genetics and genetic change-evolution. All of the bible thumping and calling anathema in the world will not change the situation. He is not to blame for Richard Dawkins, only Richard is to blame for himself.
 
Yes, worship the mind of man. For only there can the truth be found.

I think anyone currently in the thrall of science and the new rationalism reconsider. The “Bible Explanation Industry” is not run by Catholics. I heard a priest on the radio remark about how someone explained the miracle of the multiplied loaves and fish as the “miracle” of sharing. He laughed.

Today. Right now. Anyone being considered for sainthood must have two miracles attributed to them. Only the Catholic Church takes the limited information provided by science and combines it with divine revelation.

Divine revelation is the starting point, not science. I also suggest everyone read the previous posts and notice the emphasis on science. The emphasis should be on God.

Science will not save you on the day of judgement.

God bless,
Ed
At the risk of sounding downright heretical; I would venture to say that if you or your child or your grandchild were found to have Phenylketonuria (PKU disease) and you prayed and prayed but still the child grew worse and finally ended up mentally retarded. You might ask God “why did you not cause a miracle?” His reply would be, “Ed I gave you a scientist that determined the biochemical and genetic nature of the disease and he came up with a nice treatment that would have avoided the retardation and the child would have been fine. Why didn’t you trust the mind that my creation gave that man?”
 
Tell me reggieM; do you have a subscription to Conspiracy Magazine? Please don’t parse and quibble and condemn. It is quite contrary to the whole premise of this web site. After carefully reading back through all of our posts I can’t find a single word said about contraception.
Conspiracy Magazine, is it, Chuck H? Even my accent gives me away, but I tell you, I do not know the man! I have never climbed the Grassy Knoll, and I was not even in Dealey Plaza that dismal day. They told me they found my body in Area 51, with Dawkins’ contracepting fingerprints on my glasses and documents from the Magisterium spilling from my broken briefcase. Unreal city, the liberal parish under the brown fog of a winter dawn, I had not thought evolution had undone so many!
 
What should a Catholic biology teach in a Catholic high school about creation and evolution?
My answer: Yes!

As an Earth Science teacher, I tell my students that what I teach is the `best theories’, that they will find precious few facts in my entire year long course.

I teach evolution for what it is… a theory' with strong points and weknesses. I also teach creationism, its strong points and weaknesses. I teach BOTH theories from a purely scientific standpoint! Invariably, I am asked What do you believe?’ I tell them that as a Catholic AND a scientist, I find confidence that a Creator was more than able to accomplish the creation of the Universe. As interested sceintists, we can only try to peak behind the curtain, so to speak.

I teach at a public school, and have never been `called to the matt’ on this mode of instruction, though I’m sure I will be someday by some depressed atheist. ;].
 
My answer: Yes!

As an Earth Science teacher, I tell my students that what I teach is the `best theories’, that they will find precious few facts in my entire year long course.].
It’s important to teach students to analyze theories. We’re lucky that the theory of evolution is better substantiated than the atomic theory in physics or the plate tectonic theory in geology. As for alternative theories of creation, I like the “Earth Diver” theory, in which it was a muskrat that dived down to the bottom of the sea and brought up mud out of which the First Being created the world.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top