D
drpmjhess
Guest
Chuck H, thanks for your response.Not at all. The physicists who deny God because he can’t be proven are the maroons.
There is so much of religion that stands on Genesis that if it were proven to be a myth there would exist a requirement to undergo a radical realignment and understanding of theology.
George Coyne is a good scientist and therefore views evolution as fascinating and exciting as a concept but my bet is it will eventually be problematic for rational theologians and fundamentalist theologians will forever regard it as a lie to maintain their beliefs.
(1) I agree with you about the physicists, although in my experience biologists are the scientists most likely to tend to atheism. They are even more reductionist than physicists, who are often drawn to mysticism through their study of liminal questions in cosmology.
(2) I’m not clear on your statement that “There is so much of religion that stands on Genesis.” I don’t know any theologians who begin with Genesis; the core of the Hebrew scriptures (what we call the “Old Testament”) is not creation, flood, etc., but the calling of Abraham through the Exodus and Sinai experience and entry into the promised land. Genesis seems to have been composed later, although various units transmitted orally may have an ancient history. Creation, Fall, Flood – these are good stories borrowed from Ancient Near Eastern neighboring cultures, and crafted to fit in theologically with the Exodus core narrative. Religion doesn’t stand or fall on the historicity of the early Genesis stories.
(3) What do you mean by “my bet is it [evolution] will eventually be problematic for rational theologians”? How will it be problematic? Theologians are already finding it fruitful for understanding suffering, theodicy, redemption, etc.
Thanks for your provocative comments!
Petrus