Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh…you mean THIS Fr. Coyne:

Pope sacks astronomer over evolution debate

dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/worldnews.html?in_article_id=401950&in_page_id=1811
Ricmat, The Daily Mail has as much credibility as The National Enquirer, and repeating its slanders should probably be avoided in this forum. George himself told me over supper on Saturday that he’d been wanting for some time to retire from Rome, particularly after his colon cancer operation. I know of no credible person who believes Coyne was fired over his views on Intelligent Design.
 
You seem to be under the delusion I am against evolution!? … maybe? I’m not sure. However, my point was and still is: It is a theory with weaknesses and strengths like ANY other theory.
Do you understand the difference between theory and fact?
 
Chuck H., thanks for these careful reflections. And do hang in there; I consider myself a devoted Roman Catholic even though I’ve been reviled by conservatives on some threads of this forum as heretical, atheistic, pagan, an enemy of Rome, etc. For some, taking a position that they view as in any way as differing from “the Magisterium” sends you halfway to hell. And for some, a guy named Corapi (?) is a guru; his slogan apparently is “The devil’s favorite color is grey.” Someone who can’t see liminal cases would have a real problem with what you posted previously about “souls” and hydatidiform moles.

Petrus
I don’t recall anyone calling you pagan or an enemy of Rome, although I haven’t read all the posts.

Differing with “The Magesterium” ---- from this link:

catholic.com/thisrock/2005/0511fea1sb1.asp
The *mandatum *is fundamentally an acknowledgment by Church authority that a Catholic professor of a theological discipline is a teacher within the full communion of the Catholic Church. The mandatum, therefore, recognizes the professor’s commitment and responsibility to teach authentic Catholic doctrine and refrain from putting forth as Catholic teaching anything contrary to the Church’s magisterium.
“All Catholics who teach theological disciplines in a Catholic university are required to have a mandatum”
It looks to me like conformance to the magesterium is very important, especially for one who teaches theology. And who has a mandatum.

The “guy named Corapi(?)” is a Catholic priest and popular lecturer both in person and frequently on EWTN (that’s Eternal Word Television Network - a Catholic channel that many of us watch.) You state in a later post that you have not brought anyone into the Church (RCIA). Fr. Corapi has a better record in this regard. He is not a guru, he is a Catholic priest. Based on your previous interaction with Raida, you seem to be interested in this sort of thing, so here is Corapi’s story:

**Academic Credentials **
Doctor of Sacred Theology (S.T.D.) awarded Magna cum Laude, Ecclesiastical Faculty Of Theology, University of Navarre, Pamplona, Spain. Thesis: The Cross of Christ in the Magisterium of John Paul II
.
Licentiate in Sacred Theology (S.T.L.) awarded Summa cum Laude, Ecclesiastical Faculty of Theology, University of Navarre, Pamplona, Spain, concentration in Dogmatic Theology.
Code:
      *Master's Degree* (M.A.) with highest honors in Sacred Scripture, Holy             Apostles College And Seminary, Cromwell, Connecticut.

      *Bachelor of Sacred Theology* (S.T.B.) awarded *Summa cum Laude*,             Ecclesiastical Faculty Of Theology, University of Navarre, Pamplona,             Spain, concentration in Dogmatic Theology.
I don’t think that you and he would get along very well. But maybe I’m wrong.
 
George himself told me over supper on Saturday that he’d been wanting for some time to retire from Rome, particularly after his colon cancer operation.
And you expected him to say what? I disobeyed the Pope and scandalized the Church even though I made vows of obedience?
 
Of course, I do run into many atheists in my work; part of my personal apostolate is witnessing my authentic Catholicism to them in our common work of defending sound science.
How is your “authentic Catholicism” as you use it above different than say…“Catholicism?”
 
Dude… chill.😊

I feel like I’m under fire for stating how I see this whole argument. Yay science!.. yay faith! Yay us!

God created… Science tries to find out how. Im not sure how this offends you so much that it prompts the above response. LOL
You are not under fire. Just offering constructive criticism. Teaching science isn’t just the rote memorization of facts. My first responsibility when teaching has always been to make sure students know the definition of science so they know how to interpret articles about science.
We used to have an article from National enquirer about this creature that could kill man and eat him and the picture of the creature looked horrible and quite capable of doing so until we showed the students a specimen bucket with the creature in it (a sea louse, a roly-poly like creature that crawls along the sea bottom eating detritus(big but entirely innocuous). In this light I am always critical of throwing around the word theory like it was nothing special. Theory, science wise, is pretty close to doctrine, theology wise; a term not to be used lightly if students are to ever grasp its importance in science.

I am a good gentile therefore wordy. (“Be not like the gentiles who by say much hope to say anything at all”)😃
 
IAmEdmund, as a science teacher, you need to learn about the relationship between facts and theories.

I hope this might help you and your students.

Petrus
I know the difference between fact and theory.

My students and I are doing quite well, thank you. ;]

Have a happy day!!!
 
I know the difference between fact and theory.

My students and I are doing quite well, thank you. ;]

Have a happy day!!!
This is in no way a criticism of anyone here.

I took high school science and 56 hours of bachelor level science courses. Amazingly, I first learned about science method and levels of science in graduate school. I guess all my teachers assumed that someone else had taught the methodology and so this critical bit of science somehow always got left out. I tend to be a little critical because if science and evolution come up it is so common that either people toss the theory word around like it is a Time magazine term. It makes me suspicious that most science is still taught in facts rather then a complete concept of science to begin with. Orrrrr most people were like me in high school and their total concern was… “will this be on the test???” :rolleyes:
 
You seem to be under the delusion I am against evolution!? …
Inference from evidence:
  1. You repeated the standard creationist line about a “lack of transitionals” (BTW, you forgot to answer my request for the major groups lacking them)
  2. You repeated the standard creationist line about the geologic column, and you declined to explain how every location on earth could be accumulating sediment at the same time, or how erosion of layers doesn’t explain why some are not found in various places.
  3. You displayed some confusion about the meaning of “theory” and “inference.”
Pretty hard to ignore all that.
However, my point was and still is: It is a theory with weaknesses and strengths like ANY other theory.
I notice you mentioned a lack of transitionals, but you seem kinda shy about telling which major groups lack them. More evidence.
The geologic column doesnt annoy me.
See above. Denial isn’t as convincing as your behavior.
I can name alot of these missing `transitionals’.
But you won’t do it, um?
I do take umbrage at your `trolling’ to get me to do so, as though I am bereft of any evidences.
One sure way to shut me up would be to show me some. As I said, there still are a few. You spoke as though you knew of some. Now, it’s kinda puzzling why you won’t tell us about them.
 
Ricmat

I don’t know that I would want to be within arms reach of Corapi.

After the Spanish Inquisition, I tend to stay away from anyone educated primarily in Spain. I do have this aversion to a hot foot.👍
 
And you expected him to say what? I disobeyed the Pope and scandalized the Church even though I made vows of obedience?
Since the whole “episode” of George Coyne being fired for his views on evolution was fiction, I expected him to say nothing about it, which he didn’t.
 
Ricmat

I don’t know that I would want to be within arms reach of Corapi.

After the Spanish Inquisition, I tend to stay away from anyone educated primarily in Spain. I do have this aversion to a hot foot.👍
Have you ever heard him speak (he’s American BTW)? His life story is VERY interesting.

And the Spanish Inquisition has been highly exaggerated. This is a good series about the facts:

marianland.com/stjosephcom4/fireandswordcrusadeinqui.html
 
Since the whole “episode” of George Coyne being fired for his views on evolution was fiction, I expected him to say nothing about it, which he didn’t.
But if the pope had said “George, you’re doing such a wonderful job, PLEASE STAY!” do you think George would have said “Heck no, your Holiness, I’ve got better things to do?” Maybe “fire” is too strong a word.

Just google “coyne vatican” and you’ll get dozens of hits about how he very publically and vehemently disagreed with the pope despite his vows. My understanding is that to some degree, it’s OK to disagree in private, but to do so in public is a no-no.
 
Yes.And you?
:cool:
Theories do not ever become facts, because facts lie at a lower epistemological level than theories.

Fact: things fall down. The most cogent theory that has been developed to explain this is that the force of gravity attracts objects.
Fact: everything is genetically related. The best theory that has been developed to explain it is descent from common ancestors with modification and differential survival.

Thus, people who refer to evolution as “theory, not fact” have no idea what “theory” means in science. See talkorigins.org/indexcc/CA/CA201.html.

Petrus
 
I don’t know that I would want to be within arms reach of Corapi.
After the Spanish Inquisition, I tend to stay away from anyone educated primarily in Spain. I do have this aversion to a hot foot.👍
Chuck, I didn’t expect the Spanish Inquisition!
 
Just google “coyne vatican” and you’ll get dozens of hits about how he very publically and vehemently disagreed with the pope despite his vows. My understanding is that to some degree, it’s OK to disagree in private, but to do so in public is a no-no.
I didn’t get any such hits, including on Catholic News Service. In any case, George Coyne had a great career and continues to do so in this country. And Rome will never go over to ID and more than it will regress to geocentrism.
 
I didn’t get any such hits, including on Catholic News Service. In any case, George Coyne had a great career and continues to do so in this country. And Rome will never go over to ID and more than it will regress to geocentrism.
Sorry, it was Schoenborn that Coyne was arguing with (not the pope directly).

If you define ID as 6 day creationism in disguise, then I agree with you. If you define ID as “God designed the universe, possibly using a non-random form of evolution as one tool…” then those who have advanced beyond this actually need to regress to it.

Geocentrism has nothing to do with this.

Hmm… there must be something for the whole Galileo / geocentrism thing similar to Godwin’s law that I can invoke here and “declare victory.” If I can’t find anything, I’ll have to invent it. Or perhaps it will randomly appear out of the ether 🙂

[note: preceeding paragraph has nothing to do with drpmjhess, but rather another poster with whom he shares many views.]
 
Chuck, I didn’t expect the Spanish Inquisition!
My bet is that neither did many Spaniards. :eek:

I was referring to Corapi’s CV. A walk through the Prado in Madrid shows so many bonfires in the paintings. I had no idea that so many Spanish Bishops liked going to “cook outs”! :whistle:

oh hush! jess havin some fun with history.
 
Chuck H, I’d love to come talk in Texas. I believe your governor has just appointed a Young Earth Creationist to head up the department of education in the year that biology textbooks are being reviewed.

By the way, what do you make of the Chris Comer affair? She was fired from her job as Texas Director of Science for forwarding an email to her staff about an upcoming talk on evolution. The stated reason for her termination was that she was expected to remain neutral on the question of Creationism.

Petrus
I am not surprised about the Comer firing.

It is important to realize that Lubbock Texas is the “vatican” of the Church of Christ and fundamentalists make up a sizable part of the Texas population.
I went to school in Lubbock and after getting my masters moved to San Antonio. It was with enormous joy that I walked into our neighborhood store in SA and realized I was back in “papist” country by the beer cooler in the central aisle. 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top