Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Chuck, have you noticed how writing on a Catholic Answers forum is like educating a parade? After a few weeks of good serious discussion and clarification of presuppositions people begin finally to get on the same page, and then someone else comes waltzing in and we have to start at ground zero all over. But that’s what my organization is all about.[/quiote]

Getting people exposed to the science involved is the important thing. There are lurkers and those just interested in reading the debate.

The best thing is to expose the facts and let people think about it.
 
Being that this is a thread on science I would respectfully toss out this reflection on this the holiest of days on what science can suggest that leaves one in awe.

Letting Mel Gibson give the visual impressions of the passion of Jesus (He does do quite a job of it!)

For those who have not had a chemistry class, consider the mole. The mole is a quantity of atoms or molecules. The molar theory states that for any atom or molecule the atomic weight in grams will have 6.23X10-23 individual particles in it. 1 gram of Hydrogen will have 623 with 21zeros hydrogen atoms it. (so far so good?) To pound this concept home. my Chem 101 professor claimed that if one could tag a mole of sodium chloride so that it was recognizable and that mole of NaCl were dumped into the ocean and allowed to mix for a sufficient time one would not be able to take any sample from the ocean, any ocean of the world without having at least one tagged NaCl molecule in it. (for the purist one Na+ or Cl- ion)

Now consider: Before His crucifixion Jesus was flogged and His head pierced with thorns. His torn and bleeding body was forced to walk and drag the cross to Golgatha where His hands and feet were pierced by nails and He was crucified. When He gave up His spirit and passed into death the Romans made sure of it by piercing His side with a lance and the final blood and lymph poured out through that holy wound. His body was taken down and prepared for burial by Joseph and some of the women disciples. Of course in three days He was to rise and ultimately ascend into Heaven.

But it is reasonable to believe that during the passion Jesus separated Himself into two natural parts. His Body, which would rise again and ascend into heaven and His Blood which would (remember the molar theory above) quite literally and ultimately wash the entire world in the Blood of the Lamb. " This is my Blood, the Blood of the New Covenant"

Wow!
 
Hey, Chuck – after my lecture in Indianapolis next week I was planning on driving to see the AiG “museum” with a friend, although I have some moral qualims ginving money to those folks to suypport their evil and deceitful works.

I asked my executive director whether I should go openly or incognito, and she advised the latter. If Ken Ham finds out who I am, they may screen me from the more juicy bits, as they did when she went last year. I understand they’ve pulled the videos of Adam made by Eric Linden (they discovered he’s a porn star!).
I think you should be a little bit more careful how you describe those at the creation museum. They are serving the Lord and giving the gospel in great clarity. Even if you believe that they are misguided, you speak as though they are diabolical. Honestly, it is very offensive to someone like me who is a supporter of their work.
 
I think you should be a little bit more careful how you describe those at the creation museum. They are serving the Lord and giving the gospel in great clarity. Even if you believe that they are misguided, you speak as though they are diabolical. Honestly, it is very offensive to someone like me who is a supporter of their work.
In short then, my friend, you reject scripture and follow the speculations and “science” of godless men who assume away in light of their godless worldview. (bolded for emphasis) You are flat wrong and God is flat right.
It is very hard for me to consider Kenneth Miller as a godless man. I think you mistake those who search for natural truth as automatically being against God and that, unfortunately, serves nothing but error.
 
I think you should be a little bit more careful how you describe those at the creation museum. They are serving the Lord and giving the gospel in great clarity. Even if you believe that they are misguided, you speak as though they are diabolical. Honestly, it is very offensive to someone like me who is a supporter of their work.
I’m sure they mean well.
BUT
I’m not sure how they are serving the Lord by giving his followers a bad name and/or leading non-believers to an incorrect assumption about Christianity.
 
What is the incorrect assumption about Christianity you refer to?

God Bless,
Ed
 
It is involved more than can be typed here, but briefly. Homo sapiens was a biological reality but not yet ready for sharing the life of God through the soul or grace. Having the natural body was not sufficient until the brain could perceive what difference the soul could make. There is a computer modeling experiment that uses genes for brain size and collection of what are termed memes. Homo sapiens sapiens underwent a gradual increase in brain size to the point where the birth process could no longer accommodate the increase in infant skull size. During that time period of natural development homo sapiens was gaining brain capacity but was not yet capable of perceiving or acting on having a soul. The geological record shows a period of time where we had a larger brain but skeleton data was “strewn” across the landscape. Suddenly we see graves with personal effects and sometimes flowers and decorations placed in the graves with the body. Aha! now we see the effect of the soul. Not yet ready for the ten commandments yet but getting closer and close enough to perceive the afterlife. One can easily come to the conclusion that God would judge this people not by the commandments or by Paul’s epistles but exactly where they were at in that time frame and at stage of development.
Suddenly archeology begins to see graves that demonstrate a care for the infirm and arthritic elders. That is altruism beyond biological necessity and we see it both in homo sapiens sapiens and in homo sapiens neanderthalis. I can see the work of God here and evidence that in this period God considers us ready to give us a share of His life and grace however humble the beginnings
This is just bad fiction writing. There is zero evidence for this. God said, “I’ll just get the ball rolling and hang around waiting for random mutation and natural selection.”?

“altruism beyond biological necessity”? Gene worship? After all, you are what you are only because of your genes?

The science textbook sees zero “work of God” and that’s what kids are being taught. You have mutation and natural selection, period. End of story.

The science textbook is missing critical information.

God bless,
Ed
 
I think you should be a little bit more careful how you describe those at the creation museum. They are serving the Lord and giving the gospel in great clarity. Even if you believe that they are misguided, you speak as though they are diabolical. Honestly, it is very offensive to someone like me who is a supporter of their work.
I’m sorry – I thought deliberate lying to school children was still considered wrong by the Catholic Church. That’s why I referred to the propaganda work of the AiG “museum” as evil; I did not call it diabolical.

Spending 27 million dollars to fabricate a false history of life on earth, and then inviting busloads of children in to unlearn their basic science, thereby either depriving them of careers of science or necessitating years of remedial work when they become young adults – or, worse yet, setting the stage for their abandoning of their puerile faith when they mature – is to me the moral equivalent of purveying pornography. Both are a deliberate distortion of the truth about God, humanity, and the world, and both are evil.

Prayerfully yours this Good Friday,
Petrus
 
My thanks for the direction to “Is the Theory of evolution mandatory…” thread. Rather than the human mind being a simply biochemical process. Brain science indicates a major event which is synthetic. The synthesis of having chemical messengers and neuronal connections to such an extent that the combination literally creates a next step state beyond the sum of the parts. This synthesis can be seen in anthropoid apes but not to the extent it is seen in humans.
… Archeology shows a distinct change in early man. …Then suddenly graves appear where the people inside them show arthritis (osteo arthritis=old age) and wound damage that is old indicating the individual had to cope with infirmity for a long time. The graves often also show a sense of the afterlife with personal possessions and tokens of affection placed with the deceased. Both caring for weaker members and concern for deceased are altruistic behaviors beyond natural altruism suggesting the affect of having been given a share of God’s life that transcends the completely natural state. Just a hypothesis.
Excellent post, Chuck, and an interesting hypothesis. Do you know the book edited by Joseph Bulbulia on The Evolution of Religion? It might include some helpful material for your exploration of this idea.

Petrus
 
I sense great pride on this thread…Tremble.
Cling2Cross - you are exactly right. I apologize on behalf of the other Catholics here for the uncharitable comments made by some of the Catholic posters.

Pride seems to rear it’s head more on the science oriented threads than elsewhere. For the record, I’m an engineer (and believe in most of evolution), so I’m not anti-science. But it does seem that science has a corrosive effect on many people’s souls.

In terms of our salvation, which is the most important thing we should all be concerned with, I don’t think anybody will end up in Hell because they believed in 6 day creationism. But I can picture hell filled with Science groupies who will continue to beat their chests screaming “I won! I won!..”
 
Check the Library on this site. It states that Genesis records actual history.

Jesus Christ is the most important person and relationship a person should have.

Science (which, according to people here, actually means evolution) is not the most important criteria. It is not - but it is being presented as the most important thing you should believe.

Only a desire for the Church to be dictated to by “science” motivates certain posters.

God bless,
Ed
 
This is just bad fiction writing. There is zero evidence for this. God said, “I’ll just get the ball rolling and hang around waiting for random mutation and natural selection.”?

“altruism beyond biological necessity”? Gene worship? After all, you are what you are only because of your genes?

The science textbook sees zero “work of God” and that’s what kids are being taught. You have mutation and natural selection, period. End of story.

The science textbook is missing critical information.

God bless,
Ed
For heaven’s sake Ed. let me be clearer. If you read closely I am saying that suddenly man begins to behave supernaturally (altruism beyond biological necessity) A prairie dog squealing in warning of an approaching hawk is altruistic simply because it puts itself at risk to protect its gene investment in the community. Chimps ganging up on a predator is altruistic in that they put themselves at risk to protect the group and therefore a gene investment. In both cases there is biological necessity. If man takes care of an injured tribe member even though that member is too old or too injured to be of reproductive use there is a direct suggestion that God has been at work. The behavior has a basis in nature but transcends nature in its application. In addition, the burial and grave side respect of even early man is so far above altruism as a biological behavior that it smacks of an entirely new human aspect.
There is scripture that validates this idea. The first is the prime commandments. Love God above all else and love thy neighbor as thyself. Now I don’t know how committed cro-magnon was to the first since God is not a “nature” phenomenon. But it is probable that even the bare beginnings of man glimpsing the idea of God would put the second commandment into more practical use. The second is in the Gospel. Read the judgement. I was hungry and you fed me, I was thirsty and you gave me to drink, I was sick and you nursed me… This is God, sitting on a rock on a hillside declaring that these “beyond biological necessity” behaviors are what we are judged on. In this case I took those words, that wonderful declarative statement and used it to formulate an hypothesis… when would we begin to see those aspects valued by God expressed in man and if we suddenly see them in the archaeological record then it suggests a time period when God began to share His spirit with man.

I have seen many textbooks that have the archaeological findings in them and the astute Christian teacher can use them for evidence.
 
For heaven’s sake Ed. let me be clearer. If you read closely I am saying that suddenly man begins to behave supernaturally (altruism beyond biological necessity) …This is God, sitting on a rock on a hillside declaring that these “beyond biological necessity” behaviors are what we are judged on. In this case I took those words, that wonderful declarative statement and used it to formulate an hypothesis… when would we begin to see those aspects valued by God expressed in man and if we suddenly see them in the archaeological record then it suggests a time period when God began to share His spirit with man.
Brilliant post, Chuck! May I quote you in my new book? And can you post your sources for these ideas?
 
But it does seem that science has a corrosive effect on many people’s souls."
Creationism has a corrosive effect on faith. Children who are raised on a diet of anti-science creationism are forced to make the false choice between (1) atheistic science and (2) primitive, anti-science religion. It’s a tragedy that most people who abandon their faith are abandoning a very immature reading of that faith. I don’t believe in the God atheists don’t believe in either!
 
Cling2Cross - you are exactly right. I apologize on behalf of the other Catholics here for the uncharitable comments made by some of the Catholic posters.

Pride seems to rear it’s head more on the science oriented threads than elsewhere. For the record, I’m an engineer (and believe in most of evolution), so I’m not anti-science. But it does seem that science has a corrosive effect on many people’s souls.

In terms of our salvation, which is the most important thing we should all be concerned with, I don’t think anybody will end up in Hell because they believed in 6 day creationism. But I can picture hell filled with Science groupies who will continue to beat their chests screaming “I won! I won!..”
Let’s be clear. This thread is on what to teach kids about evolution. There are multiple theology threads that deal amply with salvation and belief and rightly so.
In science threads we discuss and argue and debate science and its effect on and interaction with theology. If one has a scientific point to debate that’s great. However, the blanket statement that a theological -biblical claim makes extant science knowledge into crud will be met with a determined and vocal defense. Absolutely no one here excludes God, His ultimate responsibility for the existence of the universe, or the need for His forgiveness and salvation. It is that spirit that this thread offers thoughts and arguments.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top