Ex-Catholics and salvation

  • Thread starter Thread starter TotallyConfused
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Bible IS a Catholic book
I don’t know that we should get into this on here….it is a Catholic board after all. But did Catholics write it? I’m sorry I thought the HOLY SPIRIT wrote it. 🤷
and they do NOT contradict. What makes you think they do ???
As far as the contradicting goes. Let’s look:

CCC Says:

982 There is no offense, however serious, that the Church cannot forgive. "

Bible says:

Hebrew 6:4-6
"For it is impossible in the case of those who have once been enlightened and tasted the heavenly gift and shared in the holy Spirit and tasted the good word of God and the powers of the age to come, and then have fallen away, to bring them to repentance again, since they are re-crucifying the Son of God for themselves and holding him up to contempt. "
 
TThe concept of Hell comes directly from Jesus. He often mentions the idea of eternal punishment, unquenchable fire, gnashing of teeth. etc, etc…
Ah, that’s true, sorry I was all caught up in the Jewish way of thinking. Yeah, Jesus did mention that.

How come, do you guys think, it is that Hell only origionated with Jesus and not before then?

I thought it should be something that was a constant from the beginning of the fall of Lucifer?
 
Ah, that’s true, sorry I was all caught up in the Jewish way of thinking. Yeah, Jesus did mention that.

How come, do you guys think, it is that Hell only origionated with Jesus and not before then?

I thought it should be something that was a constant from the beginning of the fall of Lucifer?
We believe that, when the time was ripe in human history, God revealed Himself and his will more completely through Jesus than at any time in the past, bringing to fulfillment promises of the Old Covenant. Much was explained that was previously less clear. One such issue involved the afterlife. As another poster explained, there was controversy at the time of Jesus over whether or not there even was an afterlife, let alone its’ nature. Christianity provides a bridge between this world and the next, not forsaking this world or running from it but rather acknowledging its’ temporary nature as well as the ultimate end for evil (hell) and the ultimate end for those who choose love (heaven).
 
I don’t know that we should get into this on here….it is a Catholic board after all. But did Catholics write it? I’m sorry I thought the HOLY SPIRIT wrote it. 🤷
Yes, but everybody knows that the Holy Spirit is Catholic! 😉

Actually that was only half a joke. The Holy Spirit inspired the writing of the Bible, the Holy Spirit leads us into all truth, and the Holy Spirit inspired the Church to both canonize the inspired Writings into the Bible, AND to interpret those inspired writings. The Holy Spirit also is the Source of the Teaching Authority of the Church (Magisterium) and Holy Tradition (which includes the Bible). So, yes the Bible is a Catholic Book.

It is using the Teaching Authority of the Church that any seeming contradictions are made plain.

Marsha
 
Yes, but everybody knows that the Holy Spirit is Catholic! 😉

Actually that was only half a joke. The Holy Spirit inspired the writing of the Bible, the Holy Spirit leads us into all truth, and the Holy Spirit inspired the Church to both canonize the inspired Writings into the Bible, AND to interpret those inspired writings. The Holy Spirit also is the Source of the Teaching Authority of the Church (Magisterium) and Holy Tradition (which includes the Bible). So, yes the Bible is a Catholic Book.

It is using the Teaching Authority of the Church that any seeming contradictions are made plain.

Marsha
And yet that same Holy Spirit provides comfort to an aged protestant woman whose husband just died.
That same Holy Spirit hears prayers and even performs miracles because of prayers.
Are all these things just false? Is the Spirit not actually there?

The Holy Spirit is above everything and hears everyone who calls on Him. Saying the Bible is a Catholic Book means that the Holy Spirit is Catholic (as you did) and that is just not so. He is above a label. By labeling Him as such you remove Him (theoretically) from the accessibility of any other God-fearing individual.

“Tradition” is word of mouth.
What needed to be written down, is.

How can the Holy Spirit contradict the Holy Spirit? See CCC # 982 vs. Hebrews 6 :4-6 (Just one thing that came to light during this thread)

Here’s what Catholics teach:

You have the Holy Spirit writing a book (Bible).
Then you have the same Holy Spirit helping people keep traditions going that’s not written in the Bible, but is contradicting the Bible
Then that same Holy Spirit gives only certain people the knowledge to correctly interpret the Traditional writings so that they finally align again with Scripture, inspired by the Holy Spirit?

You can believe that if you wanna….
 
Contrary to non catholic beliefs, each and every Catholic doctrine is validated against all scriptures to make sure that it does NOT contradict scriptures. SO no official tradition is ever adopted that contradicts scriptures.

This is not to say that all traditions are documented in scriptures. Scriptures simply does not cover all traditions. BUT there is never a tradition or doctrine that contradicts scriptures. The Church has a whole army of scriptural scholars doing reseach on any issue before it becomes doctrine.
 
Did Peter really turn his back totally on Christ and the Church?
I say no. He was afraid of persecution…but to make a conscious decision to turn from Christ is much different than what Peter did.
Peter acted out of fear and it was not a conscious decision to not follow Christ anymore.
You’re either for Christ or you’re not. There are no fence-sitters in the kingdom of God.

There is no turning your back from God halfway. I believe these are what you call cafeteria catholics.

If anyone thinks he/she can deny Christ because of fear of persecution and that will be ok with God…I think he may in for a rude awakening.
 
I think it’s more like that actual scripture verses conflict with the Catechism.
It doesn’t conflict with the Catechism. God cannot condemn his own teachings.

But it maybe the secular world’s philosophy that there are things greater than God’s mercy.
 
Contrary to non catholic beliefs, each and every Catholic doctrine is validated against all scriptures to make sure that it does NOT contradict scriptures. SO no official tradition is ever adopted that contradicts scriptures.

This is not to say that all traditions are documented in scriptures. Scriptures simply does not cover all traditions. BUT there is never a tradition or doctrine that contradicts scriptures. The Church has a whole army of scriptural scholars doing reseach on any issue before it becomes doctrine.
Any yet we just uncovered one…

Why would you even have oral traditions? It seems redundant and excessive. Scripture is inspired by the Holy Spirit. To say that there are Traditions, with a uppercase “T” implies that Scripture is not complete….as if all that is necessary for salvation is not contained in Scripture. We need additional information that’s ALSO from God?

And what’s more incredible is that Tradition holds teachings that can ruin a man’s soul, like contraceptives and masturbation and missing mass, etc.
 
The bible is not a “Catholic Book” per se, it’s a Book that’s divinely inspired. The Cahtolic Church just decided which books to include in it.

And I think it’s pretty clear that they can, and do, contradict.
Nope.

The bible is a catholic book written by catholic authors to be interpreted within the bounds that the Catholic Church establishes.
 
I think we kinda strayed a bit.

I think that the original question has been answered to a relative degree. Let me see if I can understand it:

The catholic church, the church that my friend has fallen away from teaches that, without a valid confession it is likely that the chances of salvation is slim.
However the thought processes of forgiveness and salvation is totally unknown to man and so there may still be a chance of salvation even if he does not return to the church or make a valid confession.

So, he should keep hoping and try his best…right?
You almost have it now, we can have an agreement. Just remember Salvation is God’s prerogative. God established the Sacraments as means of salvation but God is not bound by his own sacraments. Let’s leave the “salvation” decision to God.

However, there is one thing I don’t agree with your statement… the process and the depth of salvation is not totally unknown to man. God through his Church has revealed to the world the depth and limit of his mercy…is endless. The process that God established for forgiveness…is confession.

Can others who does not go to confession be forgiven too if they are truly sincere in repenting? Yes… as I said, God is not bound by His own sacraments. But the sacrament of confession is a sure way to find out.
 
Nope.

The bible is a catholic book written by catholic authors to be interpreted within the bounds that the Catholic Church establishes.
You forgot…”According to Catholics”
 
Thank you for that info.

So, would you, or anyone, know where the Catholics come up with “Hell” then?
You can start asking Jesus why he mentioned hell so many times, as I know he mentioned it 90 times and mentioned heaven only 27 times.

I mean…if Jesus says so…I believe it.
 
Now I beseech you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you all say the same thing; and that there be no dissension among you, but that you be perfectly united in one mind and in one judgment." (1 Cor. 1:10.)
 
You forgot…”According to Catholics”
Nope I didn’t forget that.

You must remember it was a synod of catholic bishops that put these books together and it was the same synod of Catholic Bishops which defined these books to be inspired. And not a synod of protestant pastors.

Have you ever wondered why the Holy Spirit chooses to work through these catholic bishops in the first place?

The reason being… there were no protestants before, only the catholic church…and that is how God established it…one, holy, roman, catholic church. And that’s how God uses his mystical body to bring more souls to heaven, through His Church.

“There should be no dissentions among you…” Isn’t that what St. Paul said?
 
Contrary to non catholic beliefs, each and every Catholic doctrine is validated against all scriptures to make sure that it does NOT contradict scriptures. SO no official tradition is ever adopted that contradicts scriptures.

This is not to say that all traditions are documented in scriptures. Scriptures simply does not cover all traditions. BUT there is never a tradition or doctrine that contradicts scriptures. The Church has a whole army of scriptural scholars doing reseach on any issue before it becomes doctrine.
Amen.

…and besides I wouldn’t believe the bible if the church didn’t tell me it was inspired.

Sound familiar?

So you see… for our protestants brothers and sisters, by taking the bible as the inspired word of God, they are accepting the teaching authority of the Catholic Church whether they like it or not.

Denying this defeats one of their tenets of faith. The bible.
 
Nope I didn’t forget that.

You must remember it was a synod of catholic bishops that put these books together and it was the same synod of Catholic Bishops which defined these books to be inspired. And not a synod of protestant pastors.

Have you ever wondered why the Holy Spirit chooses to work through these catholic bishops in the first place?

The reason being… there were no protestants before, only the catholic church…and that is how God established it…one, holy, roman, catholic church. And that’s how God uses his mystical body to bring more souls to heaven, through His Church.

“There should be no dissentions among you…” Isn’t that what St. Paul said?
Once again, this is according to a Catholic. Just because it was compiled by Catholics you can’t call this a “Catholic book”. It’s a book from God Himself. It’s for all men, written by God. It’s not Catholic, only for Catholics. According to Catholics maybe.

Of course I’ll get the Catholic answers, the standard Catholic lines, the quoted from the Catechism of the Catholic Church since this is a Catholic forum.
 
Amen.

…and besides I wouldn’t believe the bible if the church didn’t tell me it was inspired.

Sound familiar?

So you see… for our protestants brothers and sisters, by taking the bible as the inspired word of God, they are accepting the teaching authority of the Catholic Church whether they like it or not.

Denying this defeats one of their tenets of faith. The bible.
“Because the Church tells you so”….Yup, another standard line.

The bible is inspired from God, it was written by the Apostles and followers of Jesus. I don’t need the Church to tell me that, just read it.

Even if they were not compiled into a single bound book, they would still be available in individual letters as inspired letters, authored by the Holy Spirit.

We are going way off topic here…
 
Any yet we just uncovered one…
You just uncovered the very reason we need the CC. Without her, people get totally confused about the meaning of scripture.
Why would you even have oral traditions? It seems redundant and excessive. Scripture is inspired by the Holy Spirit. To say that there are Traditions, with a uppercase “T” implies that Scripture is not complete….as if all that is necessary for salvation is not contained in Scripture. We need additional information that’s ALSO from God?
Therefore, brothers, stand firm and hold fast to the traditions that you were taught, either by an oral statement or by a letter of ours. 2 Thess 2:15

It would seem that all Christians should be concerned about those oral traditions. How or why would anyone assume that Scripture alone is sufficient, especially after witnessing the multitude of different opinions as to its meaning?
 
Once again, this is according to a Catholic. Just because it was compiled by Catholics you can’t call this a “Catholic book”. It’s a book from God Himself. It’s for all men, written by God. It’s not Catholic, only for Catholics. According to Catholics maybe.

Of course I’ll get the Catholic answers, the standard Catholic lines, the quoted from the Catechism of the Catholic Church since this is a Catholic forum.
You might be missing one point here…

“Katolikos” means universal.

God intends for you to be catholic. What you will do for eternity is the mass. If you don’t agree…then you don’t seem to be getting what the book of Revelation really reveals.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top