Falcon Heights Shooting

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lea101
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Based on his family’s statements, and how calm they were. And the fact the police have not disputed that and the cop’s completely unreasonable demeanor… I’m taking their word for it until proven otherwise.
The question is not was he reaching for his ID. The question is whether the policeman knew was reaching for his ID. Put yourself in the policeman spot. A man says "I have a gun"And then reaches for his pocket. If he pulls out an ID all is if he pulles out a gun your dead. So what do you do?
 
The question is not was he reaching for his ID. The question is whether the policeman knew was reaching for his ID. Put yourself in the policeman spot. A man says "I have a gun"And then reaches for his pocket. If he pulls out an ID all is if he pulles out a gun your dead. So what do you do?
I wouldn’t have stopped him in the first place given the specious rationale the officer used to pull him over in the first place.
 
I wouldn’t have stopped him in the first place given the specious rationale the officer used to pull him over in the first place.
Doesn’t matter. If you are a policeman and a person tells you they have a gun and reaches for their pocket what do you do? can you Entertain even for a minute that this is perhaps a tragic accident bought about by miscommunication? Do you really think this policeman set out to kill a black man in cold blood?
 
I wouldn’t have stopped him in the first place given the specious rationale the officer used to pull him over in the first place.
The taillight is a valid reason and a traffic stop with an ulterior motive is perfectly Constitutional.
 
Based on his family’s statements, and how calm they were. And the fact the police have not disputed that and the cop’s completely unreasonable demeanor… I’m taking their word for it until proven otherwise.
If I were I in the police position I likewise would not comment in the ongoing investigation.
 
Doesn’t matter. If you are a policeman and a person tells you they have a gun and reaches for their pocket what do you do? can you Entertain even for a minute that this is perhaps a tragic accident bought about by miscommunication? Do you really think this policeman set out to kill a black man in cold blood?
Interesting question. There has to be a better way, especially in a country in which (in many, if not most, states) the right to bear arms is sacrosanct, and many people may be carrying a gun perfectly legally.

A man with a gun still has to reach for his pocket during a traffic stop to get his license and registration, right?
 
Doesn’t matter. If you are a policeman and a person tells you they have a gun and reaches for their pocket what do you do? can you Entertain even for a minute that this is perhaps a tragic accident bought about by miscommunication? Do you really think this policeman set out to kill a black man in cold blood?
The cop’s lawyer gave a partial explanation that is plausible. Whether or not it is true requires more evidence. According to the lawyer, Officer Jeronimo Yanez thought Castile might be the robber, saw the gun, and ordered him to freeze. Instead Yanez reached into a pocket. That situation requires a split second decision which proved fatal. It is tragic, but highly unlikely to be found criminal if other evidence backs him up.

We don’t know yet what Yanez said to his partner or how they reported the stop when they first called it in. It certainly does not justify violence against other officers that had nothing to do with this incident, or accusations of murder based on such preliminary evidence.

Didn’t we learn from Ferguson how wrong initial reports can be?

10news.com/news/national/philando-castile-shooting-cop-thought-victim-was-involved-in-robbery-lawyer-says
 
Interesting question. There has to be a better way, especially in a country in which (in many, if not most, states) the right to bear arms is sacrosanct, and many people may be carrying a gun perfectly legally.

A man with a gun still has to reach for his pocket during a traffic stop to get his license and registration, right?
Actually no. The proper procedure for person with a concealed carry permit is to leave his hands on the steering wheel and tell the officer that he is armed and ask the officer how he wants you to proceed. It appears in this case the deceased told the officer he had a gun and then reached for his pocket. I believe there is also speculation that perhaps the officer saw he was armed and told him to freeze. Since the video does not start until after the deceased is shot it is impossible to tell exactly what happened- however the girlfriend does acknowledge that he was reaching for pocket when shot.

Personally I find it very hard to believe that the officer just decided to gun down the man in cold blood. Why do you believe he shot him?
 
Based on his family’s statements, and how calm they were. And the fact the police have not disputed that and the cop’s completely unreasonable demeanor… I’m taking their word for it until proven otherwise.
The police have not disputed their testimony or commented on what happened because it is premature. Absence of evidence in this instance is to be expected for the time being. Using this absence** as **evidence is contrary to reason.

The officer could be found justified. He could be found criminally responsible. He could be found neither. In the latter case, he may still be found to have used poor judgment and lose his job and lose a civil judgment. In a civil case, the video made by his girlfriend after the shooting may be damning enough, unless there is strong evidence she lied on the spur of the moment at a time of intense stressful shock. In a criminal case, a jury may still weigh the truth of her words, though that alone should not convict him.
 
Based on his family’s statements, and how calm they were. And the fact the police have not disputed that and the cop’s completely unreasonable demeanor… I’m taking their word for it until proven otherwise.
What kind of demeanor do you expect someone to have after they just shot someone (whether justified or unjustified). Think about everything that is going through that officers head. His adrenaline is spiking, he is probably got tunnel vision and his heart is most likely beating out of his chest. He is trying to remain calm and figure out what to do next while already analyzing his own actions and hoping he did everything right. He is trying to get backup and a million other things. I am not defending or condemning him for his demeanor but merely trying to articulate that the levels of stress on him at the time are extreme and a little leeway is probably deserved.

As always, we should wait for the investigation to be concluded. This shooting, like every shooting, must be investigated and if necessary be tried in court. Just relax and let the investigators do their job for a bit before jumping to conclusions.

EDIT:

Having just gone back and watched the video I have to ask what exactly about his demeanor do you take issue with? He continues to cover the suspect while waiting for backup. This is standard training as you never know if the person will continue to attack. I have seen people take 10 bullets and keep trying to shoot you, so you cover the person until help arrives. The only other thing he does is respond to the woman when she asks why he shot him, he says because he wouldn’t stop moving like he ordered him to and keep reaching around his gun (presumably for his wallet but there is no way to know that).
 
Personally I find it very hard to believe that the officer just decided to gun down the man in cold blood. Why do you believe he shot him?
I have no idea. You haven’t seen me take a side here, or even speculate. I just worry about nervous police officers and lots of guns, legal and otherwise, out there. A lot of potential for disaster.
 
Nope, he wasn’t fatherless, wasn’t a deadbeat, wasn’t a legitimate suspect of any crime, wasn’t guilty of committing any crime (unless you believe the police line about the broken taillight), was a lawful holder of a concealed carry permit, etc…

This man’s only mistake was complying with police directives by all account. Had he not reached for his ID as requested, he might still be alive.
  1. The officer pulled him over because he looked like an armed robbery suspect (and after seeing the surveilance photo of the robber, he looks a LOT like him)
  2. He was not a concealed carry holder. He had never applied for such a permit.
  3. If he told the cop he had a concealed carry license and was reaching for it, that was obviously a lie. So he wasn’t reaching for his CCW ID. What was he reaching for then?
 
  1. The officer pulled him over because he looked like an armed robbery suspect (and after seeing the surveilance photo of the robber, he looks a LOT like him)
  2. He was not a concealed carry holder. He had never applied for such a permit.
  3. If he told the cop he had a concealed carry license and was reaching for it, that was obviously a lie. So he wasn’t reaching for his CCW ID. What was he reaching for then?
Your statement about his CCW status is directly contradictory to reporting by the star Tribune. Can you cite your source?

m.startribune.com/philando-castile-had-permit-to-carry-gun/386054481/
 
  1. The officer pulled him over because he looked like an armed robbery suspect (and after seeing the surveilance photo of the robber, he looks a LOT like him)
  2. He was not a concealed carry holder. He had never applied for such a permit.
  3. If he told the cop he had a concealed carry license and was reaching for it, that was obviously a lie. So he wasn’t reaching for his CCW ID. What was he reaching for then?
Where did you get this information that he was not licensed to carry the gun? That must be new. And the girlfriend said he was reaching for his ID, which could be either the permit or his driver’s license, which the girlfriend said the officer had asked for.
 
  1. The officer pulled him over because he looked like an armed robbery suspect (and after seeing the surveilance photo of the robber, he looks a LOT like him)
  2. He was not a concealed carry holder. He had never applied for such a permit.
  3. If he told the cop he had a concealed carry license and was reaching for it, that was obviously a lie. So he wasn’t reaching for his CCW ID. What was he reaching for then?
Considering every other source I’ve read disputes your number 2, as other posters have also pointed out, would you care to provide evidence for your statement?
 
Your statement about his CCW status is directly contradictory to reporting by the star Tribune. Can you cite your source?

m.startribune.com/philando-castile-had-permit-to-carry-gun/386054481/
Where did you get this information that he was not licensed to carry the gun? That must be new. And the girlfriend said he was reaching for his ID, which could be either the permit or his driver’s license, which the girlfriend said the officer had asked for.
Considering every other source I’ve read disputes your number 2, as other posters have also pointed out, would you care to provide evidence for your statement?
The sheriff’s office issued a tweet in which is verified that he had never applied for a concealed carry with their office and they had never issued one to him.

And the sheriff’s office also stated that the officer reacted to the gun which was recovered at the scene and I believe was in his lap or in the pocket he was reaching for.
 
The sheriff’s office issued a tweet in which is verified that he had never applied for a concealed carry with their office and they had never issued one to him.

And the sheriff’s office also stated that the officer reacted to the gun which was recovered at the scene and I believe was in his lap or in the pocket he was reaching for.
Care to provide a link to this tweet? Also just because their office didn’t issue it doesn’t mean he didn’t have a CCW permit.
 
We have seven counties in this metro area. Citing that one of the seven did not issue him a permit proves little, as the Ramsey County Sheriff’s Office even notes in a reply tweet to the one you cited.

In MN, permit holder info is not public, so agencies are hesitant to confirm. But the newspaper is reporting that he had one: Philando Castile had permit to carry gun.

“Although the names of gun permit holders are not public under state law, a source confirmed Castile was issued the permit when he lived in Robbinsdale.”

Robbinsdale is in Hennepin County.
 
Interesting question. There has to be a better way, especially in a country in which (in many, if not most, states) the right to bear arms is sacrosanct, and many people may be carrying a gun perfectly legally.

A man with a gun still has to reach for his pocket during a traffic stop to get his license and registration, right?
I have been in this situation on several occasions. Each time, I prepared my license, ccw permit, registration, and proof of insurance before the officer came up to my vehicle. I then told him exactly where my gun was. Surprisingly, I was never shot because the officer thought I was going for my gun.

Having a gun is a responsibility that requires some careful thought.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top