First openly gay Eagle Scout

  • Thread starter Thread starter JTD_Eagle1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m a lesbian. Why is that wrong to acknowledge? My SSAs are a part of me, and aren’t something I “do.” But guess what? There’s a place for gays and lesbians in the Church, just as there’s a place for straight men and straight women (and bisexual men and bisexual women). Trying to force people to stop agreeing that fundamental qualities about themselves (their hair color, their eye color, their skin color, who they’re attracted to) just makes them feel more trapped. Why do that when you could just accept them for who they are and how they feel and show them moral behavior?
…and don’t forget those attracted to children!
 
Trying to force people to stop agreeing that fundamental qualities about themselves (their hair color, their eye color, their skin color, who they’re attracted to) just makes them feel more trapped.
I suspected as much, you believe SSA is innate.

With all due respect homosexual desires are disordered and not natural according to the Bible and Catechism and thus reveal a problem that should be addressed.

What you need to know is that SSA is temporary for the majority of people. I expect that for the minority that SSA persists it is because of attitudes similar to yours, ie that God created them as homosexuals and as such there is no problem

My advice for you from someone who has had SSA is to realize it is not ordained by God and thus the only way to be relieved of this cross is to recognize it is something He does not want. Not to worry, we all have desires that God does not want, whether inherent or otherwise and the first step is being healed is recognition of said.
 
I’m a lesbian. Why is that wrong to acknowledge?
The issue here, it seems, it the ambiguity in the use of words. When someone says “I am gay” or “I’m a lesbian” what do they mean? Do they mean just that they have SSA? Does it mean they have SSA and act upon it, choosing to date and engage in sexual activity with those of the same sex? Does it mean they have SSA and that SSA is a essential, critical aspect of their very being, whether they remain chaste or not?
My SSAs are a part of me, and aren’t something I “do.”
I never said otherwise. Indeed, look at my example of the one chaste, strongly Catholic person I know that has SSA. I paraphrased him, but from my earlier message he said that “his innate desires do not define him, but that his actions and his conscience do”. I suspect that is the same with you.
But guess what? There’s a place for gays and lesbians in the Church, just as there’s a place for straight men and straight women (and bisexual men and bisexual women). Trying to force people to stop agreeing that fundamental qualities about themselves (their hair color, their eye color, their skin color, who they’re attracted to) just makes them feel more trapped.
Of course they do. I’m just seeking clarity of terms. When someone says they are gay, the common understanding is that they mean they have SSA and given the opportunity would act upon those desires. And, I think, that is what the media means when they talk about “gay rights.” And I think many of the gay activist organizations mean when they make statements, protest, or otherwise make their opinion known.

There IS a place for gays and lesbians in the Church. In fact, there is a place for everyone in the Church. However, like everyone else, including fornicators, drunkards, thieves, murders–indeed, sinners–we are called to repentance and to sin no more. This applies to gays and lesbians as well.
Why do that when you could just accept them for who they are and how they feel and show them moral behavior?
What do you mean when you say “accept them for who they are”? That they have SSA? That’s not an issue. That they are think being involved in a romantic, perhaps even sexual, relationship with a person of the same sex is acceptable? That is an issue.
 
From a Christian standpoint, your SSA should mean nothing to me. In fact, it’s too much information. Do alcoholics announce over coffee and donuts after Sunday Mass that they are alcoholics? I am to treat you as I do everyone else with love and dignity because you are a child of God. Why do I need to know you are a lesbian?
I only mention it for one of two reasons:

a) it is relevant to explaining where my knowledge of the LGBT community comes from, or:

b) people discuss identifying as gay as identifying with the behavior, in order to show them an example where that is not true.

Believe it or not, I don’t go around shouting that I’m lesbian to the rooftops :p. In fact, almost no one I currently know where I live knows about my SSAs, because it’s not relevant to conversation.
The issue here, it seems, it the ambiguity in the use of words. When someone says “I am gay” or “I’m a lesbian” what do they mean? Do they mean just that they have SSA? Does it mean they have SSA and act upon it, choosing to date and engage in sexual activity with those of the same sex? Does it mean they have SSA and that SSA is a essential, critical aspect of their very being, whether they remain chaste or not?
I would argue that the vast, vast majority of gay people use it to describe their orientation (their attractions), NOT their behavior. Why? How many gay people do you know who stopped identifying as gay when they were single? A single gay person is no less likely to identify as gay than that same person is when in a same-sex relationship. So being gay or lesbian (much like being straight) is not defined by your relationships, but rather your attractions, which are not sinful.
I never said otherwise. Indeed, look at my example of the one chaste, strongly Catholic person I know that has SSA. I paraphrased him, but from my earlier message he said that “his innate desires do not define him, but that his actions and his conscience do”. I suspect that is the same with you.
I think the only thing that DEFINES me is that I am a child of God and a member of the Church. I have permanent qualities (my gender, for example) and temporary qualities (my eye/skin/hair color, my sexual orientation, my height to a large degree, for examples), but I don’t consider anything to define me, not even my behavior. My behavior certainly helps others (including God, though He knows anyway) to know my heart and where my will is directed, but I would argue that it does not define me either. I see no problem using temporary identifiers I absolutely 100% will not have after death if, by the grace of God, I get to Heaven, since they are not sinful. Of course I wouldn’t identify with a behavior. If someone is a genius at math, does that attribute stop existing if they aren’t actively doing math problems? Think about it that way.
Of course they do. I’m just seeking clarity of terms. When someone says they are gay, the common understanding is that they mean they have SSA and given the opportunity would act upon those desires. And, I think, that is what the media means when they talk about “gay rights.” And I think many of the gay activist organizations mean when they make statements, protest, or otherwise make their opinion known.
I highly disagree with you. I think that a 14-yo girl who comes out to her parents as a lesbian is just being honest about who she’s attracted to. She’s not making any claim about “Oh I must make out with this girl right now and you can’t stop me!” We do a disservice to her to tell her “no your feelings aren’t validated, you aren’t really a lesbian, you can’t identify that way,” instead of “okay, well here’s the Church’s position on homosexuality, and there’s nothing wrong with you. I hope you know we’ll always love you, even though we must follow moral law, and we hope you will choose to do the same thing too. We can’t approve of your behavior if you date girls, but we accept you, regardless of who you’re attracted to.”

Consider the tones of those two common responses.
There IS a place for gays and lesbians in the Church. In fact, there is a place for everyone in the Church. However, like everyone else, including fornicators, drunkards, thieves, murders–indeed, sinners–we are called to repentance and to sin no more. This applies to gays and lesbians as well.
No argument here.
What do you mean when you say “accept them for who they are”? That they have SSA? That’s not an issue. That they are think being involved in a romantic, perhaps even sexual, relationship with a person of the same sex is acceptable? That is an issue.
Accept them for who they are, simple as that. Don’t deny their feelings. Don’t deny who they fall for. Just be clear on moral law and how it applies to their behavior; don’t try to force them to change their inner qualities. Get them to see a higher goal, so that those inner qualities don’t distract them from it.
 
I suspected as much, you believe SSA is innate.
Gee, I’ve only been saying it in every thread on the topic on this forum for the last 6 months. I wasn’t exactly hiding it.
What you need to know is that SSA is temporary for the majority of people. I expect that for the minority that SSA persists it is because of attitudes similar to yours, ie that God created them as homosexuals and as such there is no problem.
There is no problem with having SSAs. There is no problem with having SSAs.

To every gay person reading this forum, there is absolutely no problem with you, and you are more than welcome in this Church, same-sex attractions or no, as long as you follow moral behavior, which includes abstinence from same-sex behavior.

To you, Catolico, I highly, highly suggest you do more reading on the issue, because the Church has clearly stated that even if gay people have absolutely no way to ever change their sexual orientation, they are not sinning by being attracted to members of the same sex. Please, for the good of evangelization, stop saying that SSAs are sinful! You are going against your own Church by saying so.
 
There is no problem with having SSAs. There is no problem with having SSAs.
Pointing out the fact that SSA temptations are not sin and then assuming that SSA is normal and not a problem does not agree with Scripture nor the Catechism.

Furthermore, when you tell people that SSA is normal and is not a problem you are standing in the way of the Holy Spirit from healing them, and I can only caution you of the grave consequences of doing that.

Also, it is disingenuous to promote that people need to feel that their troubling thoughts are somehow normal and should not be addressed. The correct approach is to share troubling thought with Christ so that He can heal us, not claim they are normal or good.
 
Pointing out the fact that SSA temptations are not sin and then assuming that SSA is normal and not a problem does not agree with Scripture nor the Catechism.

Furthermore, when you tell people that SSA is normal and is not a problem you are standing in the way of the Holy Spirit from healing them, and I can only caution you of the grave consequences of doing that.

Also, it is disingenuous to promote that people need to feel that their troubling thoughts are somehow normal and should not be addressed. The correct approach is to share troubling thought with Christ so that He can heal us, not claim they are normal or good.
I have never, ever claimed that SSAs are good. But they are, in fact, neutral. If you don’t encourage them, they are absolutely, 100%, neutral. They have no bearing on your spiritual life unless you let them. No one needs to change their SSAs that has them; they just need to choose Christ over them. I firmly believe I am doing what’s best for these kids.
 
Gee, I’ve only been saying it in every thread on the topic on this forum for the last 6 months. I wasn’t exactly hiding it.

There is no problem with having SSAs. There is no problem with having SSAs.

To every gay person reading this forum, there is absolutely no problem with you, and you are more than welcome in this Church, same-sex attractions or no, as long as you follow moral behavior, which includes abstinence from same-sex behavior.

To you, Catolico, I highly, highly suggest you do more reading on the issue, because the Church has clearly stated that even if gay people have absolutely no way to ever change their sexual orientation, they are not sinning by being attracted to members of the same sex. Please, for the good of evangelization, stop saying that SSAs are sinful! You are going against your own Church by saying so.
Who said “There Are None So Blind As Those Who Will Not See” and “There Are None So Deaf As Those Who Won’t Hear?”

Whoever it was had a point.
 
Gee, I’ve only been saying it in every thread on the topic on this forum for the last 6 months. I wasn’t exactly hiding it.

There is no problem with having SSAs. There is no problem with having SSAs.

To every gay person reading this forum, there is absolutely no problem with you, and you are more than welcome in this Church, same-sex attractions or no, as long as you follow moral behavior, which includes abstinence from same-sex behavior.

To you, Catolico, I highly, highly suggest you do more reading on the issue, because the Church has clearly stated that even if gay people have absolutely no way to ever change their sexual orientation, they are not sinning by being attracted to members of the same sex. Please, for the good of evangelization, stop saying that SSAs are sinful! You are going against your own Church by saying so.
How does a Boy Scout know that he is gay? Is it because he may have some effeminate mannerisms? There are normal heterosexual married men with children who will tell you that they have been teased all their lives and people have jokingly questioned their sexuality and telling them that they are “so gay” when they are not. How many young people have let themselves be persuaded that they are gay because of the teasing and it seems like they would be better loved by some if they would only admit to it. Perhaps there were events in their lives such as broken families that effected their confusion. Maybe they have even had lustful thoughts regarding their own sex. The problem that some sponsoring organizations have with the Boy Scouts new policy is that it could be damaging to allow a confused young person to define himself by his temptations and at such a young age. And what we are seeing with this is not just admitting that one has a SSA but they are declaring an acceptance of the gay lifestyle when they declare that they will do everything that they can do to change the Boy Scout policy into accepting openly gay leaders. It is the assumption that openly gay leaders are people who are embracing the lifestyle.
You are correct in saying that there is nothing wrong with someone who has a SSA, that is, as long as he or she does not dwell on or entertain those thoughts. The same is true for anyone who has had lustful temptations.
 
How does a Boy Scout know that he is gay? Is it because he may have some effeminate mannerisms? There are normal heterosexual married men with children who will tell you that they have been teased all their lives and people have jokingly questioned their sexuality and telling them that they are “so gay” when they are not. How many young people have let themselves be persuaded that they are gay because of the teasing and it seems like they would be better loved by some if they would only admit to it. Perhaps there were events in their lives such as broken families that effected their confusion. Maybe they have even had lustful thoughts regarding their own sex. The problem that some sponsoring organizations have with the Boy Scouts new policy is that it could be damaging to allow a confused young person to define himself by his temptations and at such a young age.
I highly doubt that their confusion was caused by teasing or broken families. I knew I was physically attracted to other girls when I was 15, and I’ve known straight guy friends of mine who knew they were attracted to girls even earlier than that. I don’t understand why you think a 14 or 15-year-old guy wouldn’t know what gender physically arouses him. I don’t think it has anything to do with “teasing.” I’ve had plenty of friends who were teased for being shy or effeminate in middle/high school, and who later still ended up dating women in college. It’s pretty obvious that attractions are an innate part of us; everyone has them growing up.
And what we are seeing with this is not just admitting that one has a SSA but they are declaring an acceptance of the gay lifestyle when they declare that they will do everything that they can do to change the Boy Scout policy into accepting openly gay leaders. It is the assumption that openly gay leaders are people who are embracing the lifestyle.
Well I don’t agree with there being actively gay Scout leaders, but that isn’t the case at the moment. I believe the young man should be commanded for earning his Eagle Scout badge, but I don’t agree with his decision to push for gay Scout leaders. Certainly, with the celibacy requirement to be a Boy Scout, there is nothing immoral about the current policy.
You are correct in saying that there is nothing wrong with someone who has a SSA, that is, as long as he or she does not dwell on or entertain those thoughts. The same is true for anyone who has had lustful temptations.
👍
 
I have never, ever claimed that SSAs are good. But they are, in fact, neutral. If you don’t encourage them, they are absolutely, 100%, neutral. They have no bearing on your spiritual life unless you let them. No one needs to change their SSAs that has them; they just need to choose Christ over them. I firmly believe I am doing what’s best for these kids.
SSA temptations are not a sin but they are not normal and in fact are disordered. Furthermore, nothing the devil has created is neutral.
 
SSA temptations are not a sin but they are not normal and in fact are disordered. Furthermore, nothing the devil has created is neutral.
…so, in the case of a man who’s tempted to sleep with a woman outside of wedlock, you’d call that man’s heterosexual impulses “of the devil” as well?

I think you do a horrendous disservice to all of those with SSA who courageously and willingly bear their crosses in Christian life for love of Christ. You are implicitly stating that the devil had some sort of hand in the creation of these people.

That is perhaps the most vile, hateful, archaic and disgusting thing I’ve ever read here.
 
I highly doubt that their confusion was caused by teasing or broken families. I knew I was physically attracted to other girls when I was 15, and I’ve known straight guy friends of mine who knew they were attracted to girls even earlier than that. I don’t understand why you think a 14 or 15-year-old guy wouldn’t know what gender physically arouses him. I don’t think it has anything to do with “teasing.” I’ve had plenty of friends who were teased for being shy or effeminate in middle/high school, and who later still ended up dating women in college. It’s pretty obvious that attractions are an innate part of us; everyone has them growing up.

Well I don’t agree with there being actively gay Scout leaders, but that isn’t the case at the moment. I believe the young man should be commanded for earning his Eagle Scout badge, but I don’t agree with his decision to push for gay Scout leaders. Certainly, with the celibacy requirement to be a Boy Scout, there is nothing immoral about the current policy.

👍
Personally I’d like it if gay people could be Scout leaders if they were chaste.
SSA temptations are not a sin but they are not normal and in fact are disordered. Furthermore, nothing the devil has created is neutral.
Why couldn’t it just be concupiscence?
 
I would argue that the vast, vast majority of gay people use it to describe their orientation (their attractions), NOT their behavior.
Perhaps. But my experience, as limited as it is, has only one person with SSA that has recognized that attraction as disordered and has committed himself to a life of chastity says otherwise. It is only those that do not consider their attractions other than a natural condition that openly–and proudly–declare themselves gay.
Why? How many gay people do you know who stopped identifying as gay when they were single? A single gay person is no less likely to identify as gay than that same person is when in a same-sex relationship.
It isn’t a matter of being single. Note the words I used: “When someone says they are gay, the common understanding is that they mean they have SSA and given the opportunity would act upon those desires.” Whether that is sexual activity or the typical affectionate behavior between couples such as holding hands, kissing, snuggling, etc. That is his point–and I agree.
I think the only thing that DEFINES me is that I am a child of God and a member of the Church. I have permanent qualities (my gender, for example) and temporary qualities (my eye/skin/hair color, my sexual orientation, my height to a large degree, for examples), but I don’t consider anything to define me, not even my behavior.
I had a lengthy discussion with him some years ago, so I might have the details wrong. But as I recall there were two things he said that defined him: his behavior and his conscience. They are inextricably intertwined, but distinct. I haven’t explored this idea in depth from a philosophical or theological standpoint, but I found his position compelling. We are what we think and what we do. If I murder someone, I am a murderer. If I steal from someone, I am a thief. If I have sexual relations outside of marriage, I’m a fornicator (or if already married, an adulterer). But, if I think of murdering someone, I’m not a murderer. And so on. Conscience acts as restraint. A well-formed conscience (along with a strong will) restrains one from transitioning from thinking about murder to becoming a murderer. And it is the same with SSA. A well-formed conscience restrains one from transitions from SSA to becoming gay.

Now, of course, one can “return” (so to speak) from being a murderer, thief, etc, through repentance. And one can “return” from being gay to having SSA in the same way. But the point he makes is that there is a distinction. A distinction that is not made clear by using the term “gay” or “lesbian” as a blanket term.
If someone is a genius at math, does that attribute stop existing if they aren’t actively doing math problems? Think about it that way.
See above. His distinction is between SSA and being gay. He thinks this distinction is much more clear. And since it is impossible to prevent actively involved homosexuals from using the term “gay” or “lesbian” to refer to themselves, he feels it is important for those committed to a life of chastity to make the distinction.
I think that a 14-yo girl who comes out to her parents as a lesbian is just being honest about who she’s attracted to. She’s not making any claim about “Oh I must make out with this girl right now and you can’t stop me!”
I didn’t say otherwise. First off, a 14-yo girl needs to be told that ANY activity should be reserved for marriage. Second, I never suggested that she would “make out” with anyone “right now”. I never suggested that such attraction was compelling nor immediate. But I too was once 14, and I wasn’t always honest nor upfront with my parents about my behavior (and not just on who I was attracted to).
We do a disservice to her to tell her “no your feelings aren’t validated, you aren’t really a lesbian, you can’t identify that way,” instead of “okay, well here’s the Church’s position on homosexuality, and there’s nothing wrong with you. I hope you know we’ll always love you, even though we must follow moral law, and we hope you will choose to do the same thing too. We can’t approve of your behavior if you date girls, but we accept you, regardless of who you’re attracted to.”
That’s fine. In this case you are talking to a 14-yo, and likely are not having an in-depth, technical discussion about the nuances of SSA, behavior, conscience, etc.
Consider the tones of those two common responses.
It depends on the audience. I agree that when discussing moral issues with a teenager, one should use language they understand and can identify with. But this discussion here, I hope, is a much more sophisticated audience.
Accept them for who they are, simple as that. Don’t deny their feelings. Don’t deny who they fall for.
Validation is important I get that. Certainly one can preface any discussion with statement of validation. But you have to go beyond that, as you mention below.
Just be clear on moral law and how it applies to their behavior; don’t try to force them to change their inner qualities. Get them to see a higher goal, so that those inner qualities don’t distract them from it.
How is this any different than what I said, other than a change in the use of terms? Validation is not acceptance. This wasn’t really an answer. If “accept them for who they are” means nothing more than validate their feelings, then this isn’t any different than dealing with alcoholics, thieves, cheaters, adulterers, etc. But, as you say, this isn’t enough.

Catchphrases, like “accept them for who they are,” are meaningless without the appropriate followup conversation.
 
Perhaps. But my experience, as limited as it is, has only one person with SSA that has recognized that attraction as disordered and has committed himself to a life of chastity says otherwise. It is only those that do not consider their attractions other than a natural condition that openly–and proudly–declare themselves gay.
First, may I say that I found your post one of the best I’ve read on CAF in a long time, and I wanted to thank you for that. It was very thoughtful.

To respond, I still disagree with you. You should watch Ellen Page’s coming out speech at Time to Thrive, the Human Rights Campaign’s war against violence on LGBT Americans. She was nearly in tears during the whole thing, and none of her speech made any reference to someone needing to act on their attractions. It was about the fear one holds as a gay American, not knowing if your house (whether a youth or adult), career, your wellbeing, even your life can be at danger at any given moment if people only but find out that you’re gay (e.g. have SSAs). She came out to inspire gay youth not to feel afraid anymore, to try to have productive conversations on the issue to help educate people that being gay does not equal being a freak. Again, none of this implies behavior, at least not current behavior. If someone finds out about a past relationship of yours, you can instantly find yourself ostracized and ignored by former friends. You can lose your job and place of living. You can be beaten. It’s very scary to be LGBT in this country. And again, this is a feeling that is shared by any person who is gay (e.g. has SSAs). She was given a standing ovation by the crowd not for being gay, but for not being afraid enough to admit it, considering she might sacrifice her career doing so.

Now, obviously Ellen Page has a different view on gay “marriage” than you & I, but her speech never referenced anything about that, or even about the legitimacy of gay relationships. It was about protecting gay (e.g. same-sex-attracted) kids and adults from abuse. Gay in the LGBT community means attractions, period. You can say you’re a celibate gay person in the LGBT community and they instantly know what you mean. By your definition, that would be an oxymoron.
It isn’t a matter of being single. Note the words I used: “When someone says they are gay, the common understanding is that they mean they have SSA and given the opportunity would act upon those desires.” Whether that is sexual activity or the typical affectionate behavior between couples such as holding hands, kissing, snuggling, etc. That is his point–and I agree.
While that is certainly something he is free to identify with, it does not do much good for the purposes of evangelization. Telling people that they aren’t gay unless they act on them makes them feel like you’re denying their attractions and they’ll shut down. Talk to them using their own language. Gay is not a dirty word. You can be gay and be Catholic, as long as you aren’t actively gay (or encouraging it).
I had a lengthy discussion with him some years ago, so I might have the details wrong. But as I recall there were two things he said that defined him: his behavior and his conscience. They are inextricably intertwined, but distinct. I haven’t explored this idea in depth from a philosophical or theological standpoint, but I found his position compelling. We are what we think and what we do. If I murder someone, I am a murderer. If I steal from someone, I am a thief. If I have sexual relations outside of marriage, I’m a fornicator (or if already married, an adulterer). But, if I think of murdering someone, I’m not a murderer. And so on. Conscience acts as restraint. A well-formed conscience (along with a strong will) restrains one from transitioning from thinking about murder to becoming a murderer. And it is the same with SSA. A well-formed conscience restrains one from transitions from SSA to becoming gay.
But SSA isn’t just “thinking about sex.” It’s your innate attractions to someone, which involves a much deeper level of your person than a simple thought (I wonder if I could rob a bank), or even a complex thought (e.g. planning out a bank heist). The more accurate comparison would be suggesting that I am only a brunette when my hair is uncovered, because that is the only time it is observable to others. It really doesn’t make sense to say that, even though identifying as a brunette is identifying with something that isn’t a behavior. Making the distinction between SSAs and being gay would be an entirely unique one, as being gay MEANS having SSAs in popular culture. It makes gay people feel like you consider “gay” to be that dirty word, and, again, they’ll shut down. There’s no hope of evangelization. I have no problem using SSAs around orthodox Catholics and theologians who use it fairly often, but there’s no concern using the word gay or lesbian to describe myself to the gay community. They don’t see a contradiction between being lesbian and being celibate.
 
Now, of course, one can “return” (so to speak) from being a murderer, thief, etc, through repentance. And one can “return” from being gay to having SSA in the same way. But the point he makes is that there is a distinction. A distinction that is not made clear by using the term “gay” or “lesbian” as a blanket term.
Sure it is. The distinction is between “actively gay” and merely “gay.” That is the current distinction in popular culture. Again, if you want to change terms, you’re only going to come across as denying someone’s personal identity, which is going to get you nowhere in evangelization. Catholics should not shy from using the terms “gay” or “lesbian” in public media.
See above. His distinction is between SSA and being gay. He thinks this distinction is much more clear. And since it is impossible to prevent actively involved homosexuals from using the term “gay” or “lesbian” to refer to themselves, he feels it is important for those committed to a life of chastity to make the distinction.
Quite the opposite! I think it’s the duty of any chaste gay or lesbian Catholic to identify in the way that would resonate most with the audience they understand. What better way to evangelize than to share the same attractions as they do, and to use their language to describe it?
I didn’t say otherwise. First off, a 14-yo girl needs to be told that ANY activity should be reserved for marriage. Second, I never suggested that she would “make out” with anyone “right now”. I never suggested that such attraction was compelling nor immediate. But I too was once 14, and I wasn’t always honest nor upfront with my parents about my behavior (and not just on who I was attracted to).
Sure, but the level of fear a 14-yo feels coming out is unlike almost anything else you could possibly imagine. No matter how nice your parents are, there’s still a deep fear you’ll be hit, sent to abusive therapy, or, worst of all, thrown out of the house for coming out. And once you tell them, you can’t put it back in the bag; if they treat you terribly at first, you’ll have to deal with that for the rest of your childhood.
That’s fine. In this case you are talking to a 14-yo, and likely are not having an in-depth, technical discussion about the nuances of SSA, behavior, conscience, etc.
You’re not likely to have that discussion with your average actively gay person either! It’s highly unlikely they know the inner details of Catholic teaching if they are actively gay. Heck, my gay friends who grew up Catholic couldn’t even tell you the details of conscience or concupiscence (and many couldn’t even name the difference between venial and mortal sin!) The best thing you can do is represent a chaste Catholic and explain why the Church is completely supportive of you, lesbian and all.
It depends on the audience. I agree that when discussing moral issues with a teenager, one should use language they understand and can identify with. But this discussion here, I hope, is a much more sophisticated audience.
The only audience I would ever use SSAs to would be an audience of Church officials, religious, and/or theologians. Anyone else I’d use gay or lesbian.
Validation is important I get that. Certainly one can preface any discussion with statement of validation. But you have to go beyond that, as you mention below.

How is this any different than what I said, other than a change in the use of terms? Validation is not acceptance. This wasn’t really an answer. If “accept them for who they are” means nothing more than validate their feelings, then this isn’t any different than dealing with alcoholics, thieves, cheaters, adulterers, etc. But, as you say, this isn’t enough.

Catchphrases, like “accept them for who they are,” are meaningless without the appropriate followup conversation.
Maybe so, but validation also means validation of their identity. You can accept their identity without accepting their behavior. Trying to force a change in vocabulary will absolutely, 100% feel like a denial of validation of their identity, and you will get nowhere in the LGBT community doing so.

Again, if a person wants to identify with SSAs and say they aren’t gay, I’m fine with that. But we should be careful to deny the language of our target audience in public, because it comes across as a tone of superiority and a denial of their identity, as previously stated.
 
First, may I say that I found your post one of the best I’ve read on CAF in a long time, and I wanted to thank you for that. It was very thoughtful.
Thanks. You are one of those CAF posters I find very easy and very enjoyable with which to dialog. With some posters, it feels like a recitation of talking points. But with you, it is a discussion.

I think we are on the same page with regards to our ends (persuading those actively involved in homosexual activity and homosexual relationships to a life of chastity), but have a difference of opinion on the means. And I admit, my perspective is shaped by my experiences with gay and actively gay people. And you are only the second gay person that with which I’ve had an in-depth discussion on this issue.

So, rather than respond point by point, I’m going to concede your points. It seems that in my informal poll of chaste, Catholic gay people, the results are 50-50 on how best to persuade others.
Sure it is. The distinction is between “actively gay” and merely “gay.” That is the current distinction in popular culture. Again, if you want to change terms, you’re only going to come across as denying someone’s personal identity, which is going to get you nowhere in evangelization. Catholics should not shy from using the terms “gay” or “lesbian” in public media.
He disagreed. He thought the terms “gay” and “lesbian” were already too strongly tied with “actively gay” that without the qualifier “chaste” things would be unclear. And he thought “chaste” too “Catholic” a term, and thought SSA was much clearer and less “religious.”
Quite the opposite! I think it’s the duty of any chaste gay or lesbian Catholic to identify in the way that would resonate most with the audience they understand. What better way to evangelize than to share the same attractions as they do, and to use their language to describe it?
This, however, is a good point. But I would think this is only effective in writing or in a delivered speech. In a discussion, saying “I am gay” isn’t quite enough to differentiate. But, as I said, my point of view is colored by my other discussions. But I guess if one is evangelizing, then one would by necessity get to that point.

But as frequently attributed to St. Francis, “Always preach the gospel, and when necessary use words.” I’m not sure how one does this with the issue of active homosexuality. As has been said here, being “gay” does not mean having sexual relations. What differentiates a chaste gay person from a single gay person other than a public statement?
 
Thanks. You are one of those CAF posters I find very easy and very enjoyable with which to dialog. With some posters, it feels like a recitation of talking points. But with you, it is a discussion.
🙂
I think we are on the same page with regards to our ends (persuading those actively involved in homosexual activity and homosexual relationships to a life of chastity), but have a difference of opinion on the means. And I admit, my perspective is shaped by my experiences with gay and actively gay people. And you are only the second gay person that with which I’ve had an in-depth discussion on this issue.

So, rather than respond point by point, I’m going to concede your points. It seems that in my informal poll of chaste, Catholic gay people, the results are 50-50 on how best to persuade others.
Fair enough. And I would never tell your friend how he could or could not identify. I simply think it is more prudent in evangelization to identify with how the audience does.
He disagreed. He thought the terms “gay” and “lesbian” were already too strongly tied with “actively gay” that without the qualifier “chaste” things would be unclear. And he thought “chaste” too “Catholic” a term, and thought SSA was much clearer and less “religious.”
I never ever use chaste. I use celibate, which is technically theologically incorrect (as being gay does not imply one must be entirely celibate, which implies lifelong abstinence, as a gay person could still get married to a person of the opposite sex if they found themselves in a loving relationship, even if the physical attraction wasn’t there.) But again, you don’t really care in technical language what’s correct or not, as long as you deliver your desired message. A gay person hearing “celibacy” hears “abstain from gay sex.” They almost universally have no interest whatsoever at that point in being in an OS relationship anyway in the first place, so there’s no point in going with the more technical “chaste.” If they become faithful Catholics, then you can start having deeper discussions on their vocational options.

The problem with using SSAs in evangelization is it feels to your average gay person like you’re trying to put distance between yourself and the “bad” gay people. An us vs. them mentality. And considering there is absolutely a real war between conservative Protestants/Mormons and gays right now, culminating in high homelessness, suicide, and violence/murder victim rates of gays, and retributing in many gays not giving two c**ps about Christian businesses being forced to do X, Y, or Z, using language that implies you’re at war with the gay identity, or even that you see it as an “other” or a “bad,” will start you off on a terrible foot with the gay community.

Now, granted, “SSAs” is a decidedly Catholic term which does not carry the same vulgarity to it as Protestant terms such as “the gay lifestyle” (on par with f****t in the gay community). And I will fight up and down the street all day trying to force Catholics to stop using the latter phrase, as it is one of the worst possible things you could ever say to a gay person, whereas I use “SSAs” myself when discussing the issue to a Catholic audience. But it still puts in a separation between you and the community that is very harmful to evangelization, as you emphasize them changing their identity too much, as opposed to you emphasizing they change their behavior, which is ultimately the important goal.
This, however, is a good point. But I would think this is only effective in writing or in a delivered speech. In a discussion, saying “I am gay” isn’t quite enough to differentiate. But, as I said, my point of view is colored by my other discussions. But I guess if one is evangelizing, then one would by necessity get to that point.

But as frequently attributed to St. Francis, “Always preach the gospel, and when necessary use words.” I’m not sure how one does this with the issue of active homosexuality. As has been said here, being “gay” does not mean having sexual relations. What differentiates a chaste gay person from a single gay person other than a public statement?
I suppose it’s just about being a good example. My friends that know I’m gay know I’m chaste. I was asked in a parking lot by a random woman once whether I was gay (maybe the rainbow keychain, maybe something else?), and I took a second to think up an answer, and said “yeah I’m gay, but I’m Catholic, so I’m celibate.” She sparked up a quick theological debate with me [she believed in God], to which I responded in kind, and finally we had to agree to disagree. But I can guarantee you she will never look back on that experience and be like “oh man that religious person was trying so hard to convert me” so much as “oh wow some religious people do actually abstain,” which is where the seed gets planted :).
 
Thanks. You are one of those CAF posters I find very easy and very enjoyable with which to dialog. With some posters, it feels like a recitation of talking points. But with you, it is a discussion.

I think we are on the same page with regards to our ends (persuading those actively involved in homosexual activity and homosexual relationships to a life of chastity), but have a difference of opinion on the means. And I admit, my perspective is shaped by my experiences with gay and actively gay people. And you are only the second gay person that with which I’ve had an in-depth discussion on this issue.

So, rather than respond point by point, I’m going to concede your points. It seems that in my informal poll of chaste, Catholic gay people, the results are 50-50 on how best to persuade others.

He disagreed. He thought the terms “gay” and “lesbian” were already too strongly tied with “actively gay” that without the qualifier “chaste” things would be unclear. And he thought “chaste” too “Catholic” a term, and thought SSA was much clearer and less “religious.”

This, however, is a good point. But I would think this is only effective in writing or in a delivered speech. In a discussion, saying “I am gay” isn’t quite enough to differentiate. But, as I said, my point of view is colored by my other discussions. But I guess if one is evangelizing, then one would by necessity get to that point.

But as frequently attributed to St. Francis, “Always preach the gospel, and when necessary use words.” I’m not sure how one does this with the issue of active homosexuality. As has been said here, being “gay” does not mean having sexual relations. What differentiates a chaste gay person from a single gay person other than a public statement?
I think you might find this site interesting.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top