I would argue that the vast, vast majority of gay people use it to describe their orientation (their attractions), NOT their behavior.
Perhaps. But my experience, as limited as it is, has only one person with SSA that has recognized that attraction as disordered and has committed himself to a life of chastity says otherwise. It is only those that do not consider their attractions other than a natural condition that openly–and proudly–declare themselves gay.
Why? How many gay people do you know who stopped identifying as gay when they were single? A single gay person is no less likely to identify as gay than that same person is when in a same-sex relationship.
It isn’t a matter of being single. Note the words I used: “When someone says they are gay, the common understanding is that they mean they have SSA and
given the opportunity would act upon those desires.” Whether that is sexual activity or the typical affectionate behavior between couples such as holding hands, kissing, snuggling, etc. That is his point–and I agree.
I think the only thing that DEFINES me is that I am a child of God and a member of the Church. I have permanent qualities (my gender, for example) and temporary qualities (my eye/skin/hair color, my sexual orientation, my height to a large degree, for examples), but I don’t consider anything to define me, not even my behavior.
I had a lengthy discussion with him some years ago, so I might have the details wrong. But as I recall there were two things he said that defined him: his behavior and his conscience. They are inextricably intertwined, but distinct. I haven’t explored this idea in depth from a philosophical or theological standpoint, but I found his position compelling. We are what we think and what we do. If I murder someone, I am a murderer. If I steal from someone, I am a thief. If I have sexual relations outside of marriage, I’m a fornicator (or if already married, an adulterer). But, if I
think of murdering someone, I’m not a murderer. And so on. Conscience acts as restraint. A well-formed conscience (along with a strong will) restrains one from transitioning from thinking about murder to becoming a murderer. And it is the same with SSA. A well-formed conscience restrains one from transitions from SSA to becoming gay.
Now, of course, one can “return” (so to speak) from being a murderer, thief, etc, through repentance. And one can “return” from being gay to having SSA in the same way. But the point he makes is that there is a distinction. A distinction that is not made clear by using the term “gay” or “lesbian” as a blanket term.
If someone is a genius at math, does that attribute stop existing if they aren’t actively doing math problems? Think about it that way.
See above. His distinction is between SSA and being gay. He thinks this distinction is much more clear. And since it is impossible to prevent actively involved homosexuals from using the term “gay” or “lesbian” to refer to themselves, he feels it is important for those committed to a life of chastity to make the distinction.
I think that a 14-yo girl who comes out to her parents as a lesbian is just being honest about who she’s attracted to. She’s not making any claim about “Oh I must make out with this girl right now and you can’t stop me!”
I didn’t say otherwise. First off, a 14-yo girl needs to be told that ANY activity should be reserved for marriage. Second, I never suggested that she would “make out” with anyone “
right now”. I never suggested that such attraction was compelling nor immediate. But I too was once 14, and I wasn’t always honest nor upfront with my parents about my behavior (and not just on who I was attracted to).
We do a disservice to her to tell her “no your feelings aren’t validated, you aren’t really a lesbian, you can’t identify that way,” instead of “okay, well here’s the Church’s position on homosexuality, and there’s nothing wrong with you. I hope you know we’ll always love you, even though we must follow moral law, and we hope you will choose to do the same thing too. We can’t approve of your behavior if you date girls, but we accept you, regardless of who you’re attracted to.”
That’s fine. In this case you are talking to a 14-yo, and likely are not having an in-depth, technical discussion about the nuances of SSA, behavior, conscience, etc.
Consider the tones of those two common responses.
It depends on the audience. I agree that when discussing moral issues with a teenager, one should use language they understand and can identify with. But this discussion here, I hope, is a much more sophisticated audience.
Accept them for who they are, simple as that. Don’t deny their feelings. Don’t deny who they fall for.
Validation is important I get that. Certainly one can preface any discussion with statement of validation. But you have to go beyond that, as you mention below.
Just be clear on moral law and how it applies to their behavior; don’t try to force them to change their inner qualities. Get them to see a higher goal, so that those inner qualities don’t distract them from it.
How is this any different than what I said, other than a change in the use of terms? Validation is not acceptance. This wasn’t really an answer. If “accept them for who they are” means nothing more than validate their feelings, then this isn’t any different than dealing with alcoholics, thieves, cheaters, adulterers, etc. But, as you say, this isn’t enough.
Catchphrases, like “accept them for who they are,” are meaningless without the appropriate followup conversation.