First openly gay Eagle Scout

  • Thread starter Thread starter JTD_Eagle1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Your sources are biased.

The APA and every licensing body (Social Work, Psychology, Psychiatry, MFT, Psychotherapy) all acknowledge that being gay is not a mental health disorder and carries no inherent psycho-social risk.

And you pick your few little studies out of the mountains of evidence and the entire mental health community. . . . please. . .

Oh, but that’s all part of their agenda too- right? And that’s your invincible argument.
The APA reclassification had nothing to do with science, and everything to do with the agenda of a group of homosexual psychiatrists: thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/204/transcript
 
It’s not about them being able to tell everyone in the troop, it’s about them not getting kicked out if the leaders somehow find out.
But deary this is not what the article states. The boy in question has declared he is going to promote homosexual rights.
 
And there’s the invincible argument. All I can say is sorry you are dead wrong.
Did you even read the link? It’s an interview of the grandson of the man who led the charge in 1973. Science had absolutely nothing to do with it.
 
Your sources are biased.

The APA and every licensing body (Social Work, Psychology, Psychiatry, MFT, Psychotherapy) all acknowledge that being gay is not a mental health disorder and carries no inherent psycho-social risk.

And you pick your few little studies out of the mountains of evidence and the entire mental health community. . . . please. . .

Oh, but that’s all part of their agenda too- right? And that’s your invincible argument.
Believe what you want to believe. The APA decided it was not a disorder by a plurality of a vote at a convention-hardly science.

From a 2009 canadian report:
  • The life expectancy for gay and bisexual men is 20 years less than the average Canadian man;
  • GLB people commit suicide at rates ranging from twice as often to almost 14 times more than the general population;
  • GLBs have smoking rates ranging from 1.3 to three times higher than average;
  • GLBs become alcoholics at a rate 1.4 to seven times higher than the general population;
  • GLBs use illicit drugs at a rate from 1.6 to 19 times higher than other Canadians;
  • GLBs experience depression at rates ranging from 1.8 to three times higher than average;
  • Homosexual men comprise 76% of AIDS cases and 45% of all new HIV infections;
  • GLB populations are at a higher risk of lung and liver cancer;
  • Homosexual and bisexual men suffer a higher rate of anal cancer than heterosexual men;
  • Lesbians report a higher rate of breast cancer;
  • GLBs experience verbal and physical abuse at a greater rate than most Canadians.
 
But deary this is not what the article states. The boy in question has declared he is going to promote homosexual rights.
I’m not talking about the guy in the article, I’m talking about the BSA decision to disallow expelling members solely on the basis of sexual orientation.
 
It is assumed by party members he is to be honored with a FLOUSSA Moochelle Obama shout out on twitter and an exalted seat at next year’s party congress…. Er… State of the Union address by dear leader because nothing in the world is more important to the security of USSA than demonstrating the superior equity of oppressed homosexual peoples especially of the BLT variety. The revolution progresses FORWARD.
😃 I’ve got a feeling you spend a lot of time on a certain unnamed political satire site…
 
Believe what you want to believe. The APA decided it was not a disorder by a plurality of a vote at a convention-hardly science.

From a 2009 canadian report:
  • GLBs experience verbal and physical abuse at a greater rate than most Canadians.
Yep, which causes a much higher level of stress and torment in life.
  • The life expectancy for gay and bisexual men is 20 years less than the average Canadian man;
  • GLB people commit suicide at rates ranging from twice as often to almost 14 times more than the general population;
These two things are connected, and are the result of two major events: the spread of AIDS and the much higher level of stress from societal mistreatment.
  • GLBs have smoking rates ranging from 1.3 to three times higher than average;
  • GLBs become alcoholics at a rate 1.4 to seven times higher than the general population;
  • GLBs use illicit drugs at a rate from 1.6 to 19 times higher than other Canadians;
All due to much higher levels of stress. People who are stressed more smoke, drink, and do drugs more. There is a direct correlation there.
  • GLBs experience depression at rates ranging from 1.8 to three times higher than average;
Very attributable to the higher stress.
  • Homosexual men comprise 76% of AIDS cases and 45% of all new HIV infections;
  • Homosexual and bisexual men suffer a higher rate of anal cancer than heterosexual men;
Due to the unsafe nature of sex between men.
  • GLB populations are at a higher risk of lung and liver cancer;
  • Lesbians report a higher rate of breast cancer;
I would like sources on these. I agree with everything else you posted besides this. Not saying I disagree, I just want to see proof first.

But yes, your entire document comes down to two things:

a) People treat gay people badly, leading them into high levels of stress and behavior that high levels of stress cause, and:

b) Sex between men is the most dangerous sex of the three types (WSW, MSM, WSM/MSW).

However, nothing in your post shows that homosexuality is a mental disorder or has any form of psychological consequence not given to it by society. You have proven it’s physically risky for gay men, but not for lesbians. I don’t understand why we can’t just stick to Church doctrine and not delve into weird arguments about mental/physical health, or what have you, that have nothing to do with why the Church opposes it.
 
However, nothing in your post shows that homosexuality is a mental disorder or has any form of psychological consequence not given to it by society. You have proven it’s physically risky for gay men, but not for lesbians. I don’t understand why we can’t just stick to Church doctrine and not delve into weird arguments about mental/physical health, or what have you, that have nothing to do with why the Church opposes it.
👍👍👍

YES!

This same thing happens with contraception around here. Folks confabulate or use ridiculous claims about how dangerous ABC is when it is as safe- or unsafe- as many other prescription drugs.

There are folks here that claim that masturbation is psychologically and socially harmful as well.

It’s like folks aren’t comfortable presenting the truths of the faith to stand alone. The truth is that homosexual acts are gravely sinful matter.

Contraception is sinful as well.

There is no need to trump up half-truths or outright falsehoods to try and “build” a case. In fact these kinds of claims make some Catholics look ignorant and detract from the image of the Church.

It really gets my goat.
 
Yep, which causes a much higher level of stress and torment in life.

These two things are connected, and are the result of two major events: the spread of AIDS and the much higher level of stress from societal mistreatment.

All due to much higher levels of stress. People who are stressed more smoke, drink, and do drugs more. There is a direct correlation there.

Very attributable to the higher stress.

Due to the unsafe nature of sex between men.

I would like sources on these. I agree with everything else you posted besides this. Not saying I disagree, I just want to see proof first.

But yes, your entire document comes down to two things:

a) People treat gay people badly, leading them into high levels of stress and behavior that high levels of stress cause, and:

b) Sex between men is the most dangerous sex of the three types (WSW, MSM, WSM/MSW).

However, nothing in your post shows that homosexuality is a mental disorder or has any form of psychological consequence not given to it by society. You have proven it’s physically risky for gay men, but not for lesbians. I don’t understand why we can’t just stick to Church doctrine and not delve into weird arguments about mental/physical health, or what have you, that have nothing to do with why the Church opposes it.
Your posts affirms what I said.Homosexual behavior is morally, physically and spiritually destructive.
 
Scout Oath (or Promise)
On my honor I will do my best
To do my duty to **God **and my country
and to obey the Scout Law;
To help other people at all times;
To keep myself physically strong,
mentally awake, and morally straight.

Scout Law
A Scout is trustworthy, loyal, helpful, friendly,
courteous, kind, obedient, cheerful, thrifty,
brave, clean, and reverent.

I had to memorize this over and over and over. It turns out, it means different than I was taught.

But it isn’t wholly the scouts fault. They are a powerful organization but many powerful organizations are being brought down by the gay lobby. States, countries, religions, and militaries. The scouts never really stood a chance. An organization that forms young boys into men and touches on how to be a moral man? Probably the single biggest target you could have.
 
And the pope himself said:
“…who am I to judge? The Catechism of the Catholic Church explains this very well. It says they should not be marginalized because of this (orientation) but that they must be integrated into society.”.
Actually, the gay lobby has taken and twisted his words (by taking them out of their context) very, very effectively.

What was said, in context was:Ilze Scamparini:
I would like to ask permission to ask a somewhat delicate question: another image has also gone around the world, which is that of Monsignor Ricca and news about your privacy. I would like to know, Holiness, what do you intend to do about this question. How to address this question and how Your Holiness intends to address the whole question of the gay lobby?
Pope Francis:
In regard to Monsignor Ricca, I’ve done what Canon Law orders to do, which is the investigatio previa. And from this investigatio there is nothing of which they accuse him, we haven’t found anything of that. This is the answer. **But I would like to add something else on this: I see that so many times in the Church, outside of this case and also in this case, they go to look for the “sins of youth,” for instance, and this is published. **Not the crimes, alas. Crimes are something else: the abuse of minors is a crime. No, the sins. But if a person, lay or priest or Sister, has committed a sin and then has converted, the Lord forgives, and when the Lord forgives, the Lord forgets and this is important for our life. When we go to confession and truly say: “I have sinned in this,” the Lord forgets and we don’t have the right not to forget, because we run the risk that the Lord won’t forget our [sins]. That’s a danger. This is important: a theology of sin. I think so many times of Saint Peter: he committed one of the worst sins, which is to deny Christ, and with this sin he was made Pope. We must give it much thought. But, returning to your more concrete question: in this case, I’ve done the investigatio previa and we found nothing. This is the first question. Then you spoke of the gay lobby. Goodness knows! So much is written of the gay lobby. I still have not met one who will give me the identity card with “gay” . They say that they exist. I think that when one meets a person like this, one must distinguish the fact of being a gay person from the fact of doing a lobby, because not all lobbies are good. That’s bad. If a person is gay and seeks the Lord and has good will, who am I to judge him? The Catechism of the Catholic Church explains this in such a beautiful way, it says, Wait a bit, as is said and says: “these persons must not be marginalized because of this; they must be integrated in society.” The problem isn’t having this tendency, no. We must be brothers, because this is one, but there are others, others. The problem is the lobbying of this tendency: lobby of the avaricious, lobby of politicians, lobby of Masons, so many lobbies. This, for me, is the more serious problem. And I thank you.
Please note the bolded parts above.

FIrst, he is talking about a person who has sinned, has converted and then asked for and received forgiveness.

Secondly, it seems like members of the gay lobby always leave out the part “seeks the Lord and has good will”

Third, there is a distinct difference between one who has homosexual tendencies but is trying to live according to the will of God and one who attempts to mainstream perverted conduct.

Sadly, it is ***usually ***the latter group who merely presents the “who am I to judge” meme without its proper context.
 
Well here is that “eagle scout’s” plans in his own words according to the article.

"“On my 18th birthday, I’m planning on applying to be an adult leader for the Boy Scouts so that we push the issue,” he said.

Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/news/nat...t-eagle-scout-article-1.1610308#ixzz2t8ZytUlz"
At least this young man is honest. There are many gay adult leaders in the BSA and probably among paid scout executives who aren’t so honest.
 
And there’s the invincible argument. All I can say is sorry you are dead wrong.
No, sorry, but you are. Homosexual acts are, by their very and intrinsic nature, selfish and damaging to both the perpetrators and to society at large.
 
Your posts affirms what I said.Homosexual behavior is morally, physically and spiritually destructive.
Being homosexual can be stressful whether or not you are sexually active. Being a member of a discriminated minority is morally, physically and spiritually destructive. Prime example is the way legal system treats minorities–it is estimated that 1 In 3 black males will go to prison In their lifetime.
 
👍👍👍

YES!

This same thing happens with contraception around here. Folks confabulate or use ridiculous claims about how dangerous ABC is when it is as safe- or unsafe- as many other prescription drugs.

There are folks here that claim that masturbation is psychologically and socially harmful as well.

It’s like folks aren’t comfortable presenting the truths of the faith to stand alone. The truth is that homosexual acts are gravely sinful matter.

Contraception is sinful as well.

There is no need to trump up half-truths or outright falsehoods to try and “build” a case. In fact these kinds of claims make some Catholics look ignorant and detract from the image of the Church.

It really gets my goat.
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

I, personally, can attest to the long-lasting damage that masturbation wreaks on the psyche and general way of thinking. You are wrong, completely and utterly wrong.

Further, saying “we know it’s sinful, that ought to be enough!” is completely useless when dealing with those who do not believe in God, as well as telling people that the sinful acts themselves aren’t harmful is an outright and outrageous lie.
 
Being homosexual can be stressful whether or not you are sexually active. Being a member of a discriminated minority is morally, physically and spiritually destructive. Prime example is the way legal system treats minorities–it is estimated that 1 In 3 black males will go to prison In their lifetime.
There has never been in a time in the History of the western world that homosexual behavior has been more accepted. At some point homosexuals are going to have to realize that is the behavior that causes the problem-not others peoples opinion of their behavior
 
There has never been in a time in the History of the western world that homosexual behavior has been more accepted. At some point homosexuals are going to have to realize that is the behavior that causes the problem-not others peoples opinion of their behavior
We are in agreement, homosexuals need to take action and responsibility to diminish their stress due to discrimination.
 
nydailynews.com/news/national/openly-gay-boy-scout-eagle-scout-article-1.1610308

I am an Eagle Scout myself, and I wanted to know your thoughts about this. I was let down last May when the BSA voted to allow openly gays in scouts, and have not supported the BSA since then, and I am no longer a member. I have no problem with allowing boys with SSA in the program, but the fact that they can acknowledge their homosexuality openly within the organization, is somewhat disturbing. I wonder what he will think when the day he turns 18, they will tell him he can no longer be a member.
You don know there are gay people in all walks of life. Are you prepared to quit your job if you have a gay co-worker? Or leave your family if someone comes out as gay? Or not watch TV shows, movies, etc because a gay person was involved somehow?
 
We are in agreement, homosexuals need to take action and responsibility to diminish their stress due to discrimination.
What they need to do is the same thing all of us need to do. Repent, confess and strive to sin no more.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top