You’re very welcome. I know that much of this language is very foreign to the person in the pew:
religious - secular
order - congregation - society
rule - constitution - statutes
simple vows - solemn vows - solemn promise - promise
diocesan right - pontifical right - exempt religious
Silly.

It’s allegory. My father, wife and one of my sons were killed in a car accident many many years ago. If he were alive and if he were Bill Gates . . .
I’m finding that many things that are being stated as having said by this one or that one are being misquoted or quoted out of context. This could be one of those.
Most communities keep their constitutions confidential. They may put portions of it on their site.
The rule is a different document. There are only five religious rules in the Catholic Church:
- Benedictine
- Basilian
- Augustinian
- Carmelite
- Franciscan
They’re the public domain, because they were all sealed by the popes at the time they were promulgated and were made available to founders of religious institutes to use as their guides. For example, the Dominicans follow the Augustinian Rule. Dominic never wrote a rule. He wrote a constitution for them that filled in the blanks on points that Augustine never mentions. Francis of Assisi wrote four rules. He founded three orders and a fraternity of hermits.
The SOLT don’t follow any of the above rules. Many communities do not have a rule. They write constitutions that they can change through a general chapter. You can never change a rule. The five rules are set in stone. They were promulgated by popes to be believed by all, iincluding the faithful, to be followed by those who vow to obey them, and to be accepted as they are by everyone who comes into contact with those who follow said rule.
While we are are not bound to live according to the Rule of St. Augustine, we may not question what it says. Once it was decreed as official teaching of the Church, we must give our assent.
That’s because the rules are public documents. The constitutions are not. It’s up to the community how much they want to share.
Sharing the constitution was discouraged to keep the laity out of the internal affairs of the religious. With the explosion of mass communication, this no longer works. In the past, something like this would have only been known to those lay faithful who were in direct contact with Fr. Corapi and the SOLT. The rest of the world would not know about it. You can’t have an opinion on something you don’t know.
There is still a policy that we must be very careful to observe. In our American culture, transparency has become an obsession. The Church does not subscribe to that idea. Then, the Church is not American. Americans make up a very small percentage of Catholics.
We tend to believe that the public has a right to know. The Church does not subscribe to that. Bl. John Paul once described it as America’s heresy. He explained that we have raised democracy from a means to an end. Democracy and all of its elements, including transparency, serve a purpose in civil society. The purpose is the end, not the process. That purpose is to do the will of God.
We don’t have to know all the facts related to Father Corapi or to the SOLT. However, we must all do the will of God. Knowledge of the facts usually satisfies our curiosity, but it’s not going to make us saints. I find this to be very true. I think of people like Carthusians, Cistercians, Trappists, diocesan hermits and others who live with little or no contact with the world. They are not less holy because they don’t know every detail. They are holy, because they are faithful to what they promised to live. If they are unfaithful, they jeopardize their sanctity.
In my own community, we have a brother who has no idea who Fr. Corapi is or what’s going on. He has no reason to read the newspaper, watch TV, listen to the radio or use the internet. His ministry does not require any of that. When he heard one of the Secular Franciscans and I talking about this, he asked, “Who’s Father Crabcake?”
I, on the other hand, do a great deal of writing, online ministry and I used to teach graduate school theology. I have more contact with the world of the internet. It’s cheaper than buyiing a lot of books. Brother is probably a much holier man than I.
We have to keep in mind that holiness is acheived not by what we know, but by how we love.
Fraternally,
Br. JR, OSF