W
Wowbagger
Guest
You err by equivocating on the word “ability,” I think, diggerdomer. You assume that, because a man would (logically) never, ever, exercise a certain ability, he therefore must not have it. This is not the case. In heaven, man will retain the power to exercise his ability to do evil. Thus, his free will remains.
However, in heaven, man’s intellect will be perfected, and the virtue of prudence will be fully present in him. Prudence orders our desires according to the intellect, which is ordered according to truth, which is God, Who is good. It is not in the nature of the perfect intellect, then, to perceive any evil as a good. Perfect prudence in cooperation with a perfect intellect, therefore, cannot create an evil desire. Therefore, a fully perfected man will never desire to exercise his ability to do evil.
He will retain the power, but not the desire.
Another way of looking at it is this: free will is not the ability of some neutral observer to pick between good and evil. Free will is the freedom of the will to do what it is already naturally ordered towards: the good!
A priest told me that one. I quite like it.
Now, Adam and Eve is a much, much knottier problem that has never been answered to my satisfaction. Indeed, all human accountability for sin is something that (as digger heard in another thread) troubles me greatly. So I leave those aside and let wiser minds sort them out.
However, in heaven, man’s intellect will be perfected, and the virtue of prudence will be fully present in him. Prudence orders our desires according to the intellect, which is ordered according to truth, which is God, Who is good. It is not in the nature of the perfect intellect, then, to perceive any evil as a good. Perfect prudence in cooperation with a perfect intellect, therefore, cannot create an evil desire. Therefore, a fully perfected man will never desire to exercise his ability to do evil.
He will retain the power, but not the desire.
Another way of looking at it is this: free will is not the ability of some neutral observer to pick between good and evil. Free will is the freedom of the will to do what it is already naturally ordered towards: the good!
A priest told me that one. I quite like it.
Now, Adam and Eve is a much, much knottier problem that has never been answered to my satisfaction. Indeed, all human accountability for sin is something that (as digger heard in another thread) troubles me greatly. So I leave those aside and let wiser minds sort them out.