Free will in heaven?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Chicago_Bears
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You err by equivocating on the word “ability,” I think, diggerdomer. You assume that, because a man would (logically) never, ever, exercise a certain ability, he therefore must not have it. This is not the case. In heaven, man will retain the power to exercise his ability to do evil. Thus, his free will remains.

However, in heaven, man’s intellect will be perfected, and the virtue of prudence will be fully present in him. Prudence orders our desires according to the intellect, which is ordered according to truth, which is God, Who is good. It is not in the nature of the perfect intellect, then, to perceive any evil as a good. Perfect prudence in cooperation with a perfect intellect, therefore, cannot create an evil desire. Therefore, a fully perfected man will never desire to exercise his ability to do evil.

He will retain the power, but not the desire.

Another way of looking at it is this: free will is not the ability of some neutral observer to pick between good and evil. Free will is the freedom of the will to do what it is already naturally ordered towards: the good!

A priest told me that one. I quite like it.

Now, Adam and Eve is a much, much knottier problem that has never been answered to my satisfaction. Indeed, all human accountability for sin is something that (as digger heard in another thread) troubles me greatly. So I leave those aside and let wiser minds sort them out.
 
I’m following it with interest. I’m curious too of this distinction.

Pure free will equals the will to only do God’s will.

(Human) free will equals the will to do both good and evil…I think…

So there is a difference.

I think that the answer to this question is that God did not originally give Adam and Eve a (human) free will. I think He gave them a pure free will. Later, by failing to trust God, Adam and Eve gave themselves their own (human) free will.

Now as to why God did not stop Adam and Eve from giving themselves their own (human) free will, I don’t know the answer to this…but I would like to hear some ideas as to why this happened the way it did.
Free-will is free-will, the freedom to choose good. But it becomes pure in Heaven. Certainly we can abuse our freedom by choosing evil, but this isn’t why God gave us free-will. He gave it to us we would choose Him. For He created us for Himself, He created us so we can share in His happiness and life, and this out of mercy for us. In the beginning, Adam and Eve had free-will, untained by any inclination to evil. They did not enjoy the Beatific Vision, so they could have sinned. And they did sin, by disobeying God.

The reason God did not stop Adam and Eve fom sinning is because He dose not steal His graces away from us, and, because He foreknew the Redemption of man. In a sense, He permitted the fall of man so man would be redeemed; by the Redemption, man has obtained greater graces from God - such as the sacraments and the Grace of Jesus Christ - than had man not sinned. No one can fully understand God’s Ways, but at times He lifts the veils for us, so that we have greater trust in Him, pray more, love more, and become holier, our glory in Heaven increasing by such a progression from lower to higher holiness. Everything God dose, He dose for us - nothing He dose is selfish or self-centered. Even when He demands us to worship Him, He only demands it so He can give us graces in return, returning Love for our return of love for His Love for us. And He wants us to love Him for He Himself, not for what He gives us, so we can have a greater share in His life and happiness in Heaven. This is why it is said that God is All-Generous.
 
This is only my speculation but I think if Adam and Eve had not listened to the devil and sinned and if they eventually had eaten of the Tree of Life that was in the Garden of Eden THEN they would have received the perfect free will to always do God’s will that we will have when we get to heaven.

I think Jesus was the Tree of Life in the garden!

God in His infinite wisdom knew how Adam and Eve would choose–but that’s not the same as saying that there wasn’t a Perfectly good choice available to them–they COULD have eaten of the Tree of Life instead!

Adam and Eve had sanctifying grace yet fell to sin.

I believe if they had eaten of the Tree of Life that they would have had Fullness of Grace like Mary had and never would have sinned.

All of this is just my speculation–what do you think?
 
What is the Catholic position on free will in Heaven? If there is free will in Heaven, is there also sin and death in Heaven? Is there a difference between the type of free will in Heaven and the type on Earth? Do those in Heaven ever choose to sin and commit evil? Do they choose to hurt others?
You should look up Saint katherine of Genoa’s treatise on pergatory, she has some incredible insights as the state of a soul at death.
 
Why did God not give Adam and Eve pure free will? Then they wouldn’t have sinned, and not because they weren’t free, but because they were more free.
Do you have children?

If so, you surely love them more than you love you own life, right?

In order to love them completely, you would have to let them live their own lives, even if that meant allowing them to make mistakes and to suffer the consequences.

God loves us infinitely more than we could ever imagine.

There’s your answer! Pure love, agape love is totally giving, expecting absolutely nothing in return. Surprisingly, that is when we receive the most.

You are not “more free” without free will, it’s just the opposite.

Sancta Maria, Mater Dei, Ora Pro Nobis Peccatoribus!

Mark
 
No. That’s not true. We still have a pure free-will, the free-will to do all things good.
What does that mean?

In Heaven there is no death, no suffering , no sin, no evil so what is there to choose?
In Heaven we can do nothing except love God eternally. We cannot choose not to love him.
 
Do you have children?

If so, you surely love them more than you love you own life, right?

In order to love them completely, you would have to let them live their own lives, even if that meant allowing them to make mistakes and to suffer the consequences.

God loves us infinitely more than we could ever imagine.

There’s your answer! Pure love, agape love is totally giving, expecting absolutely nothing in return. Surprisingly, that is when we receive the most.

You are not “more free” without free will, it’s just the opposite.

Sancta Maria, Mater Dei, Ora Pro Nobis Peccatoribus!

Mark
So why does God take that form of free will away when people go to Heaven and give the so called “pure free-will”? Or can people choose to do evil in Heaven?

If the freedom to choose evil shows God’s love, why does He take it away?

I think a lot of the people here are contradicting each other. I am looking for the Catholic position. What does the Catholic Church teach on the issue of free will, evil, and suffering in Heaven?
 
So why does God take that form of free will away when people go to Heaven and give the so called “pure free-will”? Or can people choose to do evil in Heaven?

If the freedom to choose evil shows God’s love, why does He take it away?

I think a lot of the people here are contradicting each other. I am looking for the Catholic position. What does the Catholic Church teach on the issue of free will, evil, and suffering in Heaven?
To answer two of your points there is no evil or suffering in Heaven.
As to freewill I don’t know to what extent free will exists there.
 
. I am looking for the Catholic position. What does the Catholic Church teach on the issue of free will, evil, and suffering in Heaven?
CCC 1023-1029 should help vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P2M.HTM

The first line in 1023 (“Those who die in God’s grace and friendship and are perfectly purified live for ever with Christ. They are like God for ever, for they “see him as he is,” face to face:”) leads me to believe that there is no possibility of sinning or suffering in heaven.

“for ever with Christ” to me means just that–forever. No possibility of falling away, no sin, because we see him “face to face.”
 
CCC 1023-1029 should help vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P2M.HTM

The first line in 1023 (“Those who die in God’s grace and friendship and are perfectly purified live for ever with Christ. They are like God for ever, for they “see him as he is,” face to face:”) leads me to believe that there is no possibility of sinning or suffering in heaven.

“for ever with Christ” to me means just that–forever. No possibility of falling away, no sin, because we see him “face to face.”
So why did an all loving God deny this to Adam and Eve?
 
God didn’t deny it. Adam and Eve chose to sin.

Or did I misunderstand your question?
 
But they would not have chosen to sin if they “’[saw] him as he is,’ face to face.” Why did an all loving God deny Adam and Eve seeing him as he is?

Is God all loving in the Catholic view? Maybe that is a Protestant or Evangelical view.
 
But they would not have chosen to sin if they “’[saw] him as he is,’ face to face.” Why did an all loving God deny Adam and Eve seeing him as he is?

Is God all loving in the Catholic view? Maybe that is a Protestant or Evangelical view.
Yes God is all-loving in the Catholic view.

God gave Adam and Eve free will, that was God’s decision. I tend to think that if they saw God “face to face” as I believe we will in heaven then that would have precluded any real possibility of their acting to choose anything that is not God.
 
Yes God is all-loving in the Catholic view.

God gave Adam and Eve free will, that was God’s decision. I tend to think that if they saw God “face to face” as I believe we will in heaven then that would have precluded any real possibility of their acting to choose anything that is not God.
So do those in Heaven still have free will?
 
So why does God take that form of free will away when people go to Heaven and give the so called “pure free-will”? Or can people choose to do evil in Heaven?

If the freedom to choose evil shows God’s love, why does He take it away?
I heard Father Corapi speak a little about this. He said those who are in Heaven can no longer sin because they are affirmed in their free will. Their will is forever set towards God. The inclination to sin no longer exists in Heaven. God will not permit anything unclean in heaven. The soul entering heaven is in such a state of purity we can’t possibly comprehend it. To be in God’s presence we have to be completely purified. No one could tolerate being in God’s presence with even the slightest bit of impurity, It would be unbearable.

Sin enslaves our will, and the more we give into sin the more enslaved we become. We actually lose our freedom to sin. For example look at addiction… alcoholism, drugs, pornography, and gambling to name a few, leaves people desperate to stop but they can’t. Not without the help of God. The closer we draw to God the more free we become. In Heaven we are finally and totally free. Free to love and serve God completely.

Imagine what it would be like to stand in the presence and gaze at the face of an infinite being… A being who is infinite beauty, light, love, purity, holiness, and power. This being created us to be free, not enslaved. God in His infinite wisdom decided to test His creation. He did it first with the angels. They had the freedom to choose for or against God. Since they saw God face to face, and their wills are much higher than ours. The consequences of their decision was final with no chance of redemption for those who chose against God. They knew completely what using their wills to defy God meant, and chose to do it anyway. Our flesh and wills are far lower, and weaker than the angels. We don’t understand completely so God in His infinite mercy decided to give us a second chance through the crucifixion of Jesus. So to make a short story long… :cool: at the moment of death our wills are set, whether for God or against God. We will be utterly transformed and our wills be strong as God intended them to be if we die in a state of grace. Our wills are completely free in goodness and love. This eyeblink of a life is the only time we will get to choose between Good and evil. Once the choice is made and we die, then we live in whatever state we chose. The most horrific thing anyone in Heaven could imagine is doing anything to offend God. Being completely pure the thought does not enter the mind. It only enters the mind in this lowly sinful state with our very weak wills. This is the time of choosing, not after death.
 
For example look at addiction… alcoholism, drugs, pornography, and gambling to name a few, leaves people desperate to stop but they can’t. Not without the help of God.
There is no evidence that people can only break away from addiction through the help of God.
Their will is forever set towards God.
We will be utterly transformed and our wills be strong as God intended them to be if we die in a state of grace. Our wills are completely free in goodness and love.
How the will be free if it is set?
God in His infinite wisdom decided to test His creation.
Why would an all loving God chose to test human and deny them basic information about the choice they are making? Why not allow a truly free choice?
 
So do those in Heaven still have free will?
This is all speculation, on one hand. We have no definitive way of knowing one way or another exactly what heaven is like. Thank God.

my personal opinion is that whether we have free will or not in heaven is irrelevant. We are in the presence of God, completely and eternally. What else matters?
 
This is all speculation, on one hand. We have no definitive way of knowing one way or another exactly what heaven is like. Thank God.
Why are you thankful you do not know what Heaven is like?
my personal opinion is that whether we have free will or not in heaven is irrelevant. We are in the presence of God, completely and eternally. What else matters?
Why would an all loving God make humans live outside his presence at all?
 
There is no evidence that people can only break away from addiction through the help of God.
I have struggled with drug addiction all my life, and know that God is the only way out for me. The point is that these addictions are addictions to sin and they enslave our wills to the point where we can no longer choose not engage in those particular sins.
How the will be free if it is set?
I think you would gain invaluable insight if you read this
Why would an all loving God chose to test human and deny them basic information about the choice they are making? Why not allow a truly free choice?
We were not created angels so we don’t have the perspective they do, but our choice is free… here! There we will be completely free, and no longer desire things that are less than perfect. Evil is less than perfection.
We do have the basic information, The knowledge of good and evil is written in every persons heart. It is common knowledge that choosing to murder someone is evil, and choosing to help someone in need is good. This IS the free will God gave us to choose for or against Him here… In the next life the consequences of how we use our wills now will bear out eternally.
 
We do have the basic information, The knowledge of good and evil is written in every persons heart. It is common knowledge that choosing to murder someone is evil, and choosing to help someone in need is good. This IS the free will God gave us to choose for or against Him here… In the next life the consequences of how we use our wills now will bear out eternally.
Even leaving aside deny seeing “him as he is,” is not eating shellfish (for Jews) written on the heart? Or working on the Sabbath? What about homosexuals who feel love for their partners written on their heart? What the prohibition against idolatry? Historically many people have practiced idolatry, and was hardly common knowledge to these people that it was wrong?

Can a person choose to never commit any sins?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top