Free will in heaven?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Chicago_Bears
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Please don’t read into what I typed. If you are not sure what I am trying to say, just ask. I never said I was not thankful to not know what heaven is like.
I never wrote you said you were not thankful to not know what heaven is like–more like the opposite. I asked why you were thankful you do not know what Heaven is like based on you writing:
We have no definitive way of knowing one way or another exactly what heaven is like. Thank God.
This seems to be a pretty clear thanks to God for there not being a way to know what Heaven is like. First, there is a statement and then a thanks.

If it is not thanks for there be no way of knowing what Heaven is like, what does it mean?
 
No one knows for sure.
If you (or anyone else) do not know, then how can you know that God is all loving? Since you do not know why God did this, how do you know that his motivation was not something other than love?
 
If you (or anyone else) do not know, then how can you know that God is all loving? Since you do not know why God did this, how do you know that his motivation was not something other than love?
Faith.

Experience.

The witness and example of holy men and women throughout history.

Given your responses to my posts, could you please re-state exactly what your question is? I’m getting the impression that no amount of (name removed by moderator)ut or responses from others is going to satisfy, so I’m just wondering again if you could share what, exactly, you’re looking for in this particular thread. thanks.
 
Given your responses to my posts, could you please re-state exactly what your question is? I’m getting the impression that no amount of (name removed by moderator)ut or responses from others is going to satisfy, so I’m just wondering again if you could share what, exactly, you’re looking for in this particular thread. thanks.
I am trying to understand the nature of free will on heaven and Earth and the relation to an all loving God.
Experience.
The witness and example of holy men and women throughout history
So, would it be fair to say that you do not know if God is all loving, but that you hope he is?
 
I am trying to understand the nature of free will on heaven and Earth and the relation to an all loving God.
So, would it be fair to say that you do not know if God is all loving, but that you hope he is?

No.

It is true to say I hope God is.

But, in faith, it’s also true to say I know God is.

And perhaps most importantly, in love I “know” God is.
 
I am trying to understand the nature of free will on heaven and Earth and the relation to an all loving God.
As I understand, the Catholic tradition teaches us that God is all loving and has created humans with free will.

If you can accept these “natures” fine, if not, fine. They are part of the Catholic faith tradition.

I don’t see a conflict between the two. This does not mean I can fully understand or explain the two, because they do not reduce themselves, as principles, to simply rational/scientific explanation. They are not irrational, but rather supra-rational. You can find evidence to support or refute them.

On earth, we have free will.

In heaven, I think the Church teaching on free will is less clear and not as important imho

Either way, the Church teaches God is all loving.

So…again…can you clarify more what you’re looking for here? I enjoy the dialogue but I’d like to know if there are boundaries or more specific ends you’re looking for that will allow us to sense we’re making some progress as opposed to being involved in unending speculation about matters that we’ll never be able to full explicate.

Thanks.
 
So, would it be fair to say that you do not know if God is all loving, but that you hope he is?
No.

It is true to say I hope God is.

But, in faith, it’s also true to say I know God is.

And perhaps most importantly, in love I “know” God is.

I do not understand your answers. I thought that faith was for things that cannot be known. For instance, I do not have faith that I am typing on a computer.

What is the difference between knowing something through sufficient evidence and knowing it through faith? If a Muslim knows something faith is it just as valid?

How can hope for something that you know? I do not hope I am typing. I know I am typing.
 
As I understand, the Catholic tradition teaches us that God is all loving and has created humans with free will.

If you can accept these “natures” fine, if not, fine. They are part of the Catholic faith tradition.
But what is the evidence for the tradition? Surely the Catholic Church based their views on rational review of evidence.
 
But what is the evidence for the tradition? Surely the Catholic Church based their views on rational review of evidence.
The evidence is the lives of holy men and women throughout the ages.

This evidence has also been partially and truthfully preserved in the witness of Scripture.
 
This response inaccurately presents things I’ve typed with things others have. Please clarify.
 
Chicago Bears: So, would it be fair to say that you do not know if God is all loving, but that you hope he is?

diggerdomer: No.

It is true to say I hope God is.

But, in faith, it’s also true to say I know God is.

And perhaps most importantly, in love I “know” God is.
I do not understand your answers. I thought that faith was for things that cannot be known. For instance, I do not have faith that I am typing on a computer.

What is the difference between knowing something through sufficient evidence and knowing it through faith? If a Muslim knows something faith is it just as valid?

How can hope for something that you know? I do not hope I am typing. I know I am typing.

(I think it got messed up because of the quote within a quote.)
 
The evidence is the lives of holy men and women throughout the ages.

This evidence has also been partially and truthfully preserved in the witness of Scripture.
Why are the lives of holy men and women evidence that God is all loving instead of evidence that the holy men and women believed that God was all loving?

Are not the claims in scripture what needs to backed up by evidence? It cannot be its own evidence. It would beg the question to say that the scripture (and tradition) says that God is all loving so that proves that God is all loving when there is an with whether scripture (and tradition) accurately reflects God (if he exists).
 
What is the Catholic position on free will in Heaven? If there is free will in Heaven, is there also sin and death in Heaven? Is there a difference between the type of free will in Heaven and the type on Earth? Do those in Heaven ever choose to sin and commit evil? Do they choose to hurt others?
I think if there was free will in heaven, the devil would have a chance to repent (as we have a chance to repent for our sins on earth). Once your earthly life ends, and you are no longer under the restraints of time/space, our ability to choose good vs. evil ends. Our decision at the moment of death (whether for or against God) stands for all eternity. Our choice is made and finalized at death. That’s why there is no evil or sin in Heaven. You’ve chosen God, your ability to choose further ceases and you remain in Heaven without evil and sin for all eternity. It’s a soothing thought.
 
You cant. Do you hope the sun will rise tomorrow or hope that it will or neither?
Can you re-phrase this? What exactly are you saying that I can’t? And what you asking in that question? It seems that both things between the first “or” are the same.

Edit - Are you making a reference to the problem of induction?
 
What is the Catholic position on free will in Heaven? If there is free will in Heaven, is there also sin and death in Heaven? Is there a difference between the type of free will in Heaven and the type on Earth? Do those in Heaven ever choose to sin and commit evil? Do they choose to hurt others?
This is part of the necessity of Purgatory. The process of purgatory cleanses the propensity toward sin that exists in even the redeemed - which is why we continue to sin on earth.

Without the refining and purification of purgatory, there might still bne a propensity to sin in heaven.
 
Do you have children?

If so, you surely love them more than you love you own life, right?

In order to love them completely, you would have to let them live their own lives, even if that meant allowing them to make mistakes and to suffer the consequences.
But how far does this analogy go?

Certainly we would be considered negligent parents if we simply allowed our children to wander dangerously into the street for example. We wouldn’t just sit back and say I love you so much I’m going to stand back while you get hit by a vehicle.

It’s true that children and even adults need room to explore and grow. I agree.

But at what point does God step in and prevent the negative actions we are trying to take?

This is where the question of free-will becomes a much more thorny issue in my opinion.
Sancta Maria, Mater Dei, Ora Pro Nobis Peccatoribus!
What is the translation for this? I recognize a couple words.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top