In modern times a professioning Roman Catholic among the Masons would certainly be an oddity. Yes, in the 19th century it was still happening. Generally nowadays, practicing Catholic men are eligible for membership in the Knights of Columbus. The Masonic Order is now considered an organization for Protestant men although some (but not all) Protestant fellowships reject or discourage Masonic participation.
Actually, I have known many Catholics in the Lodge. And Jews. A couple of Muslims, and a scattering of protestants. Atheists are not permitted.
As we are not a religion nor a political group, these two subjects are completely forbidden from being discussed.
Albert Pike was born in the 1800s, 400 years after of the Regius Poem was written and was therefore too late to be considered a Founder. He was influential in the Scottish Rite and his books and writings are quite popular in that body. I didn’t join it and can’t lend much light to that discussion.
I did join the Shrine and can offer insights into a Blue (regular) lodge and the Shriners.
What you have to remember about Masons is that our most unique and ancient characteristics and traditions are generally taken out of context and used to paint us as boogeymen that we are not.
As a fraternity, we grew out of the Renaissance and thrived during the Enlightenment in Europe. This movement gave us modern science, democracy, the concept of civil liberties, limited governments, and embraced the concept that people were not sheep to be led about by the nose. If you transport yourself back to the 14, 15, 16, and 1700s you can understand that these ideas weren’t real popular. It must be remembered that possession of a Bible written in vernacular was considered witch craft and punished as such. Just like drinking a tea made from willow bark was (ie aspirin) to relieve a fever as opposed to the medically approved practice of blood letting and leaches at the time.
Like any society unpopular with the local powers that be (again, remember the Inquisition was not known for judicial restraint or review and local nobility didn’t like radical discussion of human rights and democracy), it was necessary to stay hidden in the shadows. This was kind of fun and the tradition has persisted. The degrees we teach are moral lessons encouraging a person to study, learn, and think for themselves and embrace morality. These lessons are taught many ways and have been found most effective to keep them ‘hidden’ so as not to cheapen them.
Think about something…are we REALLY dispensing some mystical hidden agenda or telling folks to be good people? Before you answer - one of the charges against Catholicism was that of cannibalism due to communion. Out of context, the blood and body of Christ may seem a little barbaric. Just like a degree.
Now comes the issue. Anything that stays quiet or hidden or not well understood is subject to speculation - often unfair speculation (think of Boo Radley from To Kill a Mockingbird). When combined with the fact that we do not take sides in religious discussions (we aren’t a religion or church and how you find God is between you and God…it’s not my business but I have my hopes on how you do so) - you have speculations that such as the one that lead to this thread.
We have no secret code that dictates our taking over the banking system or gives us insight into the secret KFC 11 herbs and spices (Col. Sanders was a Mason along with Dave Thomas … but they didn’t share their recipe with the Brothers, sorry). Here is the code to Grand Lodge of NC (there is no GREAT Grand Lodge, they are all autonomous and “recognize” each other - except France. Long story.)
grandlodge-nc.org/themasonicCode I must warn you before reading it…it’s boring.
We have been persecuted in politics as well as from the pulpit. Given our trust in the common man and encouragement to set aside differences to work ( as in how we built the Shriner’s endowment to be the largest in the world supporting 20+ children’s hospitals at no cost to the family), several politicians don’t like us. Since we will not openly support any party or candidate, we are often the enemy by default.
I hope this clears up some of the questions and why folks see as not being compatible.
On a side note, if someone would like a fraternity that is based on ours and does great work AND they wish to stay within the good graces of the Church, check out your local KofC. We have worked around them on various occasions and I am impressed. And they ALL carry swords so I am jealous (I know it’s a sin so I pray for forgiveness).
If you want to learn more about Masonry or even have an interest in joining, look up the Grand Lodge for your state and find a local lodge. No burnt offerings or blood oaths required.
Have a blessed day!