Friend has "Eucharist Scrapbook"

[Zundrah]

There are dozens if not more videos on youtube of Eucharist desecration.
It’s really disgusting and youtube should remove them.

I just logged in there and I saw 3 videos on it… There are more. I flagged and reported them all.

But the disturbing thing is, one of the videos had been up there for 4 years… I don’t think youtube will ever remove them.

 

[TheRealJuliane]

I just logged in there and I saw 3 videos on it… There are more. I flagged and reported them all.

But the disturbing thing is, one of the videos had been up there for 4 years… I don’t think youtube will ever remove them.

Of course they will not remove the videos. More hits = more ads = more money. Controversy is good for business.

 

[runningdude]

I’m a little confused here too. The other 7 page (as of now) thread that you began but only posted one time after your first post, where you were accused of being a fake, made it clear that you are extremely vocal and very confident in your knowledge of the Catholic Church. But yet here, you are confused and not sure what to do? A family where your own daughter goes to their house for a play-date, has a scrapbook of hosts out on display next to the dog and you aren’t sure what to do? Your attitude in the other thread implies that you WOULD know what to do in this situation. I mean really, if you thought nothing of publicly humiliating a woman for complimenting you and then asking to pray over you, and you supposedly ripped her apart for not being a Catholic, then I would imagine you would have thought nothing of ripping this mother apart on the phone.

You do bring up interesting topics for discussion though!

Well, in the other thread, she was worried she handled the situation wrong. Now shes asking how to better approach this situation. Seems consistent enough.

 

[Zundrah]

Of course they will not remove the videos. More hits = more ads = more money. Controversy is good for business.

The Internet works in such weird ways. If this was a public display, something could have been done afterwards and I’m sure they’d be in court now.

 

[paperwight66]

Before getting upset, it’s as well to remember that we don’t know that the ‘host’ desecrated in these videos has, indeed, been consecrated.

It’s perfectly possible to buy altar-breads from church suppliers.

Certainly, the intention to desecrate and to shock believers is horrible. But we don’t know that anyone making these videos (or an accomplice) has obtained the Host through going to Holy Communion.

Or indeed that what they pass off as a host isn’t cardboard or white felt or any other look-alike.

Caution, and prayers for them, that’s best.