Group may sue over cross

  • Thread starter Thread starter _Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Um … fair in this case might be the maker denying me the right to build a big sculpture on public land promoting my non-belief.
If you don’t believe, and there is nothing on the public land, then you already have a sculpture there depicting what you believe in. You look right up there, and you see…nothing.

So even if they had a sculpture up there for Christians, Buddhists, Hindus, and everybody else, if there’s nothing up there for atheists, they already have their monument, right alongside the other ones----they believe in nothing, and there’s nothing up there.

Right?

Thanks for coming out, and have a nice day. 😉
 
Of course not…Looking at a hamburger ad doesn’t mean you have to buy a hamburger. Just don’t buy it.
If the government is providing public space for McDonald’s to put up billboards it is a problem. It is a form of favoritism which naturally raises questions regarding undue influence.

The article in the first post has the mayor admitting that private land has been offered for the cross, and that the new position would make the cross more visible. There seems little reason not to move the cross, other than a desire to have the city provide a public endorsement of Christianity.

I think the lawsuit is petty. On the other hand, it seems pretty clear that the city wants to establish itself as having a Christian identity. And that does cross church-state lines.
 
It does if it is on public land, which is what we are discussing here.
Public land is OUR land. The government cannot own anything. Private property can only be owned by a defined individual or corporation of individuals with material standing. The federal government can never have material standing in property ownership because the “owners” are fungible.
 
It does if it is on public land, which is what we are discussing here.
On some toll roads in this country - Illinois comes to mind - their “oasis” stops do have various fast food establishments. No one is required to eat there. 🤷

Jon
 
On some toll roads in this country - Illinois comes to mind - their “oasis” stops do have various fast food establishments. No one is required to eat there. 🤷

Jon
I have no objection to the state leasing land for commercial or religious purposes. It is the appropriation of the commons for the good of an individual or the purposes of one group only that I object to.
 
How stupid. It would almost seem that Atheists and Agnostics are afraid of Christianity!
 
I have no objection to the state leasing land for commercial or religious purposes. It is the appropriation of the commons for the good of an individual or the purposes of one group only that I object to.
I hope you are not selective in your idealism.
 
How stupid. It would almost seem that Atheists and Agnostics are afraid of Christianity!
Religious fanatics afraid of religious moderates. That’s just it. Atheists and agnostics are often bigger religious fanatics than church going people.
 
A cross I understand it, as does the European Commission, is mainly a cultural symbol. A cross atop a water tower is hardly a forceful call for Christianity. Like it or not European culture had two drivers - Jesus Christ and Aristotle/Plato and you can’t get around that. America was founded by people who came from that culture.
 
It does if it is on public land, which is what we are discussing here.
No, it does not.
There was a local McDonald’s with their sign located on public property for years.
Apparently there was an error when the land was surveyed for the signage.

It did not force anyone to participate in McDonalds at all even though the sign was on public property.
 
I have no objection to the state leasing land for commercial or religious purposes. It is the appropriation of the commons for the good of an individual or the purposes of one group only that I object to.
With due respect, you’ve moved the goal post here. There is no appropriation going on, from what I understand. Now that said, if the town only allows a cross, and therefore denies equal access, I would have a problem. But simply having a cross erected on public property does not establish a state church, and therefore does not violate the 1st Amendment, anymore than Moses with the 10 Commandments on the Supreme Court building does.

Jon
 
With due respect, you’ve moved the goal post here. There is no appropriation going on, from what I understand. Now that said, if the town only allows a cross, and therefore denies equal access, I would have a problem. But simply having a cross erected on public property does not establish a state church, and therefore does not violate the 1st Amendment, anymore than Moses with the 10 Commandments on the Supreme Court building does.

Jon
I think we agree! if everyone has access to erect symbols indicating what they believe, or don’t believe, about religion, I am quite happy to have a cross there. But I imagine some posters in the thread will have a few issues when, say, a hammer and sickle goes up.
 
If the government is providing public space for McDonald’s to put up billboards it is a problem. It is a form of favoritism which naturally raises questions regarding undue influence.

The article in the first post has the mayor admitting that private land has been offered for the cross, and that the new position would make the cross more visible. There seems little reason not to move the cross, other than a desire to have the city provide a public endorsement of Christianity.

I think the lawsuit is petty. On the other hand, it seems pretty clear that the city wants to establish itself as having a Christian identity. And that does cross church-state lines.
That doesn’t work either…the establisment clause doesn’t say “The government shall not…” or “the Courts shall not…” or City councils/employees or anything like that. It only says “Congress shall pass no law”. All the rest is not about what it says but what atheists think it should say.
 
I think we agree! if everyone has access to erect symbols indicating what they believe, or don’t believe, about religion, I am quite happy to have a cross there. But I imagine some posters in the thread will have a few issues when, say, a hammer and sickle goes up.
A hammer and sickle is a political symbol and doesn’t relate to the subject of religion.
 
That doesn’t work either…the establisment clause doesn’t say “The government shall not…” or “the Courts shall not…” or City councils/employees or anything like that. It only says “Congress shall pass no law”. All the rest is not about what it says but what atheists think it should say.
This is a common misconception. For most of our first century states, and by extension cities, schools, etc were free to establish a state religion. This all changed with the 14th Amendment, when our freedoms with respect to the federal government were expanded, making them freedoms with respect to the states as well.
 
How stupid. It would almost seem that Atheists and Agnostics are afraid of Christianity!
Awfully dumb of them. Christianity, as watered down and as it is adhered to these days, is nothing anyone needs be afraid of. 🤷
 
That doesn’t work either…the establisment clause doesn’t say “The government shall not…” or “the Courts shall not…” or City councils/employees or anything like that. It only says “Congress shall pass no law”…
The US Supreme Court ruled in 1925 (Gitlow v. New York) that the due process clause of the 14th amendment applied the provisions of the first amendment to each state and to any local government.
 
A hammer and sickle is a political symbol and doesn’t relate to the subject of religion.
So we are going to have freedom to erect only religious symbols on public land, and not non-religious symbols? That’s the point. You don’t get to decide what other people will do in expressing their beliefs. If you say a cross is ok, so is a hammer and sickle. Or a swastika, or a pentangle, or a statue of Satan.
 
So we are going to have freedom to erect only religious symbols on public land, and not non-religious symbols? That’s the point. You don’t get to decide what other people will do in expressing their beliefs. If you say a cross is ok, so is a hammer and sickle. Or a swastika, or a pentangle, or a statue of Satan.
Political symbols are not covered under the establishment clause. And frankly, neither is a cross or Star of David, because they don’t establish a state Church, and that’s what the establishment clause is all about - establishing a state Church. If folks want to argue against a cross based on equal access, fine. But arguing that a cross on a water tower, or a student prayer at a football game, or a coach bowing his head during said prayer, or a teacher wearing a crucifix in his lapel at school is establishment is ludicrous.

Jon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top