Harry's RCIA Progress

  • Thread starter Thread starter Andruschak
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am very excited for you! I knew you would get through it just fine. It sounds like you were dressed to the nines, I must admit, I don’t know much about half of what you were wearing myself, so cudos to you for knowing so much already, you’re well ahead of the crowd!

And I don’t doubt that your sponsor was very proud to be there for you. 😃

Happy Trails!
 
I am indeed in RCIA, and this Rite Of Acceptance was part of RCIA. It means we were presented to the congregation, who “accepted” us as Candidates and Catechumans of St. Philomena Church:)

This acceptance means we will now attend the 11 AM Mass, as a group. A special section of pews will be cordoned off for our exclusive use. It is at the front and to the left, so the congregation can see us. :o

After the Homily, but before the Eucherist, we will be “dismissed”, to attend another hour or so of RCIA class in our classroom.

This “Dismissal” will continue most Sundays from now on, the last one to be on Palm Sunday.
The Rite of Acceptance also means that the Inquirer Accepts Christianity and is now seeking to be Baptized. From that point forward they are a Catechumen.

"After the Homily, but before the Eucherist, we will be “dismissed”, to attend another hour or so of RCIA class in our classroom.

This “Dismissal” will continue most Sundays from now on, the last one to be on Palm Sunday."

Only Catechumens are dismissed from Mass.

I don’t understand this:

“Large ceremonial brown scapular, worn over the shirt, a visable mark of my being a Candidate rather then a Catechuman.”

If you are a Candidate then you are already Baptized and do not participate in the Rite of Acceptance.

Even as a Candidate, the Brown Sacpular has no part in the Rite of Welcome. Cermonial Scapulars are only for those who are members of certain Orders and Fraternities. Non-Catholic Christians should not wear a cermonial Scapular.

“My tri-colored cingulem around my waist, with the ends hanging down my right side. Gold, Silver, and White, braided togather. A mark of my vows of chastity and obediance.”

A Cincture is part of a liturgical vestment? Why would you be wearing one? It’s also not part of the Rite? Vows?

"Large wood bead Rosary, draped over the cingulem and hanging down my left side. Clickity-clacking when I walked. If you got it, flaunt it.😃 "

If you showed up at our Rite dressed like that I would begin to question your motivation in becoming Catholic.
 
The Rite of Acceptance also means that the Inquirer Accepts Christianity and is now seeking to be Baptized. From that point forward they are a Catechumen.

"After the Homily, but before the Eucherist, we will be “dismissed”, to attend another hour or so of RCIA class in our classroom.

This “Dismissal” will continue most Sundays from now on, the last one to be on Palm Sunday."

Only Catechumens are dismissed from Mass.
.
Well, that may be the case IN THEORY, assuming you can find a Church where Candidates are offered a different program from the Catechumans. That may be what the US Council Of Bishops wanted, but too bad. In practice, RCIA is quite a muddle in most Parishes. And most especially in my area. :rolleyes:

In practice, candidates and catechumans are lumped together. We attended the Rite Of Acceptance together. We are dismissed together. We are in RCIA class together. From now to the Easter Vigil we will be together. We will be together at The Rite Of Sending. And the Three Scrutinies. And The Triduum.:getholy:

The only substantial difference will be at The Vigil. Catechumans get their baptism. As the sole Candidate, I will go to confession instead. Then Confirmation and First Eucherist for all. 👍

Do you have a problem with this?
 
Even as a Candidate, the Brown Sacpular has no part in the Rite of Welcome. Cermonial Scapulars are only for those who are members of certain Orders and Fraternities. Non-Catholic Christians should not wear a cermonial Scapular…
Oddly enough, there do exist other opinions. From the FAQ at the website of The Rose Scapular Company…

@@@@@

I’m not Catholic but I want to wear the Scapular, what if I can’t get to a priest to enroll me? Our answer is put it on anyway and wear it faithfully, try to get to a priest to enroll you if you can. Otherwise we leave you in the hands of the Blessed Mother and Jesus, they often work miracles as we have seen so many times with the Scapular.

@@@@@

Pretty much the same thing is prrinted twice in the booklet GARMENT OF GRACE. If one cannot find a Priest willing to do the formal investure, put on the scapular anyway as a sign of devotion to Mother Mary. Observe chastity (I do). Do some sort of devotion to Mary daily (I recite the Rosary). It’s HER scapular, and nobody has the right to say you cannot wear it in her honor, asking for her grace and help.👍
 
Well, that may be the case IN THEORY, assuming you can find a Church where Candidates are offered a different program from the Catechumans. That may be what the US Council Of Bishops wanted, but too bad. In practice, RCIA is quite a muddle in most Parishes. And most especially in my area. :rolleyes:

In practice, candidates and catechumans are lumped together. We attended the Rite Of Acceptance together. We are dismissed together. We are in RCIA class together. From now to the Easter Vigil we will be together. We will be together at The Rite Of Sending. And the Three Scrutinies. And The Triduum.:getholy:

The only substantial difference will be at The Vigil. Catechumans get their baptism. As the sole Candidate, I will go to confession instead. Then Confirmation and First Eucherist for all. 👍

Do you have a problem with this?
Yes I have a great problem with this because it is a great disservice to you and would have ignored your valid Baptism. The prayers spoken during the Rite of Acceptance (assumming that they did not make up their own Rite or prayers, which would not supprise me since they seem to be making up their own RCIA process) did not speak of your Baptism or you already being a member of the Christian community because of your Baptism.

As a validly Baptized Christian, you should not be dismissed from Mass since you have a right by virtue of your Valid Baptism to remain. You as a Candidate would not go through the Rite of Sending, because by your Valid Baptism you are already a member of the Mystical Body of Christ. You would not experience the Scrutinies because they speak of you seeking Baptism and your readiness for Baptism, which you have already received.

Yes they are making up their own version of RCIA and Ignoring your valid Baptism and the rights and responsibilities that go along with it. Yes this bothers me when parishes do this out of ignorance of the Rite.
 
Oddly enough, there do exist other opinions. From the FAQ at the website of The Rose Scapular Company…

@@@@@

I’m not Catholic but I want to wear the Scapular, what if I can’t get to a priest to enroll me? Our answer is put it on anyway and wear it faithfully, try to get to a priest to enroll you if you can. Otherwise we leave you in the hands of the Blessed Mother and Jesus, they often work miracles as we have seen so many times with the Scapular.

@@@@@

Pretty much the same thing is prrinted twice in the booklet GARMENT OF GRACE. If one cannot find a Priest willing to do the formal investure, put on the scapular anyway as a sign of devotion to Mother Mary. Observe chastity (I do). Do some sort of devotion to Mary daily (I recite the Rosary). It’s HER scapular, and nobody has the right to say you cannot wear it in her honor, asking for her grace and help.👍
Do not believe everything you read on the internet! The Scapular is a Sacramental and as such it’s use is regulated by the Catholic Church. Yes, a CATHOLIC can put on the Scapular, not a Ceremonial Scapular, one worn under the clothing, even if they are not enrolled if they are seeking to be. A priest cannot enroll you in the Brown Scapular if you are not a practicing Catholic. I’m happy you have a desire to be enrolled, but after you are received into full union with the Catholic Church.

In Spiritual direction sometimes encouragment is needed and sometimes limitations are needed.
 
Yes they are making up their own version of RCIA and Ignoring your valid Baptism and the rights and responsibilities that go along with it. Yes this bothers me when parishes do this out of ignorance of the Rite.
I’m sure many Parishes do it out of ignorance, if the postings of other RCIA Candidates in this forum is any indication. In addition to ignorance, many RCIA programs lack trained Volunteers who know what to do anyhow.😦

As in…who would interview the Candidates to decide what they need? An over-worked Priest? Most likely that poor RCIA Volunteer. One candidate is a lapsed catholic whose last contact was shortly after Confirmation. This Candidate probably needs most of RCIA and especially the Catechism background.:o

But the other Candidate is 62 years old, validly baptized CoE, confirmed in the Lutheran Church, with a lifelong study of Spirituality behind him, knows more then 95% of the “Cafeteria Catholics” know, and can pick up most of the leftovers sooner or later without RCIA. Me, in other words.:eek:

The RCIA Volunteers had zilch experience or guidance on how to handle someone like me.:rolleyes:

So instead of individual evaluations and programs, which can be time intensive, ALL candidates are lumped together with ALL the catechumans, and instructed as ONE class

All other churches and parishes near to me run their RCIA programs more or less the same way as St. Philomena. I’ve accepted this as a sort of penance, to learn humility and obediance:D
 
Yes I have a great problem with this because it is a great disservice to you and would have ignored your valid Baptism. The prayers spoken during the Rite of Acceptance (assumming that they did not make up their own Rite or prayers, which would not supprise me since they seem to be making up their own RCIA process) did not speak of your Baptism or you already being a member of the Christian community because of your Baptism.
.
As a matter of fact, it was mentioned to the Congregation that some of us were validly baptized and there as candidates, not catechumans. I am not sure of the exact wording of the prayers as I am hard of hearing.

And since you seem to be quite knowledgable about this sort of thing…that part of the ceremony where our sponsers repeatedly made the SOTC over parts of our body…was that supposed to be for catechumans only? If so, we candidates got a free ride:D

O yes, we all got this big wooden cross to wear around our necks at every Dismissal. Plus a Bible. 👍
 
As a validly Baptized Christian, you should not be dismissed from Mass since you have a right by virtue of your Valid Baptism to remain. You as a Candidate would not go through the Rite of Sending, because by your Valid Baptism you are already a member of the Mystical Body of Christ. You would not experience the Scrutinies because they speak of you seeking Baptism and your readiness for Baptism, which you have already received.
.
So THAT’S what the scrutinies are about? I though it was something like questions and answers from the Catechism, which is what I went through in the Lutheran Church Confirmation. I darn near memorized the whole book for teenage confirmation. :rolleyes:

OK, so that means I’ll just sit politely on the sidelines whilst The Scrutiny is in progress. 👍

Next Question: What exactly is The Rite Of Sending anyhow? I know we will be bussed to Our Lady Of The Angeles Cathedral in Los Angeles on 25 February. We might even get to see the cardinal!
 
Do not believe everything you read on the internet! The Scapular is a Sacramental and as such it’s use is regulated by the Catholic Church. Yes, a CATHOLIC can put on the Scapular, not a Ceremonial Scapular, one worn under the clothing, even if they are not enrolled if they are seeking to be. A priest cannot enroll you in the Brown Scapular if you are not a practicing Catholic. I’m happy you have a desire to be enrolled, but after you are received into full union with the Catholic Church.

In Spiritual direction sometimes encouragment is needed and sometimes limitations are needed.
Good news…my sponser is active in some sort of rosary fraternity at the Church. (Exact name forgotten:o ) The group is having some sort of meeting next Sunday at 9 AM, and I have been invited. I’ll ask them about this particular devotion to Mother Mary

(My sponser was very pleased that I am already praying the Rosary daily)
 
So THAT’S what the scrutinies are about? I though it was something like questions and answers from the Catechism, which is what I went through in the Lutheran Church Confirmation. I darn near memorized the whole book for teenage confirmation. :rolleyes:

OK, so that means I’ll just sit politely on the sidelines whilst The Scrutiny is in progress. 👍

Next Question: What exactly is The Rite Of Sending anyhow? I know we will be bussed to Our Lady Of The Angeles Cathedral in Los Angeles on 25 February. We might even get to see the cardinal!
This sounds like the rite of elect. Many parishes together with a beautiful ceremony. The bishop or cardinal speaks about your journey.

If at all possible, attend the Chrism Mass, too. There, they bless the oils that are used in baptism, anointing, and, I believe, vocations.

They lumped us all together, as well. I was baptised, but could not prove it (the church being defunct and washed away by Hurricane Katrina), so I was considered a catecumen rather than a candidate. But there were candidates with us as well. We didn’t have dismissal until after Epiphany. Ours was rather loosely done, too, because of different schedules, I sometimes couldn’t make the mass (others had the same problem) where the dismissal was done. Our priest doesn’t even like doing dismissal.
 
As a matter of fact, it was mentioned to the Congregation that some of us were validly baptized and there as candidates, not catechumans. I am not sure of the exact wording of the prayers as I am hard of hearing.

And since you seem to be quite knowledgable about this sort of thing…that part of the ceremony where our sponsers repeatedly made the SOTC over parts of our body…was that supposed to be for catechumans only? If so, we candidates got a free ride:D

O yes, we all got this big wooden cross to wear around our necks at every Dismissal. Plus a Bible. 👍
The Rite of Acceptance is for Catechumens only.

The Rite of Welcome is for Candidates.

The Prayers are different, Without looking at the Rite I seem to think that the “Signing of the senses” is also done in the Rite of Welcome. (?) I’ll check on that.
 
So THAT’S what the scrutinies are about? I though it was something like questions and answers from the Catechism, which is what I went through in the Lutheran Church Confirmation. I darn near memorized the whole book for teenage confirmation. :rolleyes:

OK, so that means I’ll just sit politely on the sidelines whilst The Scrutiny is in progress. 👍

Next Question: What exactly is The Rite Of Sending anyhow? I know we will be bussed to Our Lady Of The Angeles Cathedral in Los Angeles on 25 February. We might even get to see the cardinal!
The Rite of Sending Catechumens is from the early Church. Catechumens were sent to the Bishop who was the ordinary minister of Adult Baptism at the Easter Vigil. As a Candidate you would not be in the Rite of Sending, the Rite of Election or the signing of the Book of the Elect. You would however be invited to attend the Rite of Continuing Conversion for Candidates and receive the Bishops encouragement and blessing. Here the Rite of Election and the Rite of Continuing Conversion. take place at the same location on the same day, but in separate and distinct ceremonies.

There would be nothing wrong for a parish to do the same with the Rite of Acceptance and the Rite of Welcome. They could be celebrated at the same Mass, just in two distinct and separate ceremonies each using the proper prayers for each…
 
This sounds like the rite of elect. Many parishes together with a beautiful ceremony. The bishop or cardinal speaks about your journey.

If at all possible, attend the Chrism Mass, too. There, they bless the oils that are used in baptism, anointing, and, I believe, vocations.

They lumped us all together, as well. I was baptised, but could not prove it (the church being defunct and washed away by Hurricane Katrina), so I was considered a catecumen rather than a candidate. But there were candidates with us as well. We didn’t have dismissal until after Epiphany. Ours was rather loosely done, too, because of different schedules, I sometimes couldn’t make the mass (others had the same problem) where the dismissal was done. Our priest doesn’t even like doing dismissal.
When is the Chrism Mass usually performed?

Our four Priests do like Dismissals. After all, we are exposed to the Sunday Readings and the Homilies. We are a captive audience, so to speak:rolleyes:

Our RCIA instructor informed us that, from now on, the main purpose of the RCIA classes after we get dismissed (before the actual Eucherist Sacrement) is to discuss and share about the Sunday Readings. 👍

Having gone through the Bible several times from several viewpoints, it is interesting to note the different translations and interpretations of the catholic Church as compared (say) to the Lutherans and Jehovah Witnesses

Of course I get all that plus MUCH more at catechismclass.com but I can see that this is useful for those with no previous background in Bible studies
 
The Rite of Acceptance is for Catechumens only.

The Rite of Welcome is for Candidates.

The Prayers are different, Without looking at the Rite I seem to think that the “Signing of the senses” is also done in the Rite of Welcome. (?) I’ll check on that.
THANK YOU! for informing me that the ceremony was called “Signing Of The Senses”. Another golden nugget of information. I love these forums. I am learning so much:thumbsup:

Well, I guess they lumped Welcome and Acceptence together, since candidates and catechumans got the signing of the senses together. We are on our way!😃
 
A Cincture is part of a liturgical vestment? Why would you be wearing one? It’s also not part of the Rite? Vows?

".
No. But I was under the impression that cingulems, like cinctures, could be worn by anyone. I wear the Cincture of Saint Philomena around my waist, out of sight under my clothing. It is there to remind me of my vow of chastity. (Vow made in private, at home, to BVM and Philomena.)

If it is the case that lay people CANNOT wear Cingulems (citation please), I shall PROMPTLY cease to do so. No problem:thumbsup:

But in many other spiritual and/or religious traditions, anyone can wear a cingulem for spiritual intentions. My large, very visable cingulem has 3 colors, which can stand for a variety of three attributes. Gold, Silver, and White. I currently regard it as my dedication to the three great archangels of the Church.

Michael, for integrity and courage
Raphael, for healing, especially my alcoholism
Gabriel, the messenger archangel, for my 12th step work
 
? Vows?

"Large wood bead Rosary, draped over the cingulem and hanging down my left side. Clickity-clacking when I walked. If you got it, flaunt it.😃 "

If you showed up at our Rite dressed like that I would begin to question your motivation in becoming Catholic.
My wearing the large Rosary (and also using it for Rosary prayers and the Chaplet Of The Divine Mercy) is non-negotiable.

You are welcomed to questioning my motivations. What is your first question?
 
No. But I was under the impression that cingulems, like cinctures, could be worn by anyone. I wear the Cincture of Saint Philomena around my waist, out of sight under my clothing. It is there to remind me of my vow of chastity. (Vow made in private, at home, to BVM and Philomena.)

If it is the case that lay people CANNOT wear Cingulems (citation please), I shall PROMPTLY cease to do so. No problem:thumbsup:

But in many other spiritual and/or religious traditions, anyone can wear a cingulem for spiritual intentions. My large, very visable cingulem has 3 colors, which can stand for a variety of three attributes. Gold, Silver, and White. I currently regard it as my dedication to the three great archangels of the Church.

Michael, for integrity and courage
Raphael, for healing, especially my alcoholism
Gabriel, the messenger archangel, for my 12th step work
I’m beginning to understand a bit more now after discussing this with you here.

Cords can be worn by laity but are usually worn out of sight as personal devotion. Wearing them externally is usually only for ceremonial purposes. I assume that they too are regulated by the church in some way. I have never seen any one wear a large rosary except clergy or religious.

We need to remember that the purpose of the cord, rosary, scapular is personal devotion and should not be used to draw attention to ourselves. What is important is that God knows what our intention is, what other people think is not revelant.
 
I’m beginning to understand a bit more now after discussing this with you here.

Cords can be worn by laity but are usually worn out of sight as personal devotion. Wearing them externally is usually only for ceremonial purposes. I assume that they too are regulated by the church in some way. I have never seen any one wear a large rosary except clergy or religious.

We need to remember that the purpose of the cord, rosary, scapular is personal devotion and should not be used to draw attention to ourselves. What is important is that God knows what our intention is, what other people think is not revelant.
Well, this WAS, after all, very much a ceremonial occasion. A once in a lifetime ceremonial occasion, after all. I felt it proper to display my dedication. I will, of course, run all this past my sponser next Sunday, and include your (name removed by moderator)ut. After all, she knows what would be considered proper at this particular church. Thank you for your help and (name removed by moderator)ut on all this. You are a credit to this Forum:thumbsup:

@@@@@

Attention Moderators. It would be OK to move this thread onto the end of the thread “Harry’s RCIA Progress” now. I think it has about run its course. I have certainly learned some new things from the replies
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top