Have you been born again?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mmmcounts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
As an 8 day old baby, what did you repent of?
Why come to a Catholic forum if all you are going do is contradict the Catholic faith and attempt to learn a bit of Catholicism??? Would it be fair if I went to a forum of your denomination (whatever it may be) and contradict it and never attempt to learn what you believe??
 
Prove it.

Show me that you “know” you were “born-again” at that point. Please show me exactly in the scriptures that you know you were saved at that moment.
Romans 8 : 16 Tells us that when God saves us the Spirit (God’s Spirit) bears witness to our spirit that we are the childern of God. Unsaved people do not have that witness and if you do not have that witness you are not born again. You can be baptized a hundred times and never have that witness because baptism does not save.

You see God does not save us and then not let us know about it.
 
Romans 8 : 16 Tells us that when God saves us the Spirit (God’s Spirit) bears witness to our spirit that we are the childern of God. Unsaved people do not have that witness and if you do not have that witness you are not born again. You can be baptized a hundred times and never have that witness because baptism does not save.

You see God does not save us and then not let us know about it.
Allis, don’t forget that St. Paul had already covered the importance of Baptism in romans 6: 3-5:
Or are you unaware that we who were baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death? We were indeed buried with him through baptism into death, so that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might live in newness of life. For if we have grown into union with him through a death like his, we shall also be united with him in the resurrection
Notice the newness of life is associated with Baptism. He clearly is saying that Baptism is required to be saved.

The problem with personal interpretations of the Bible, is that you don’t have the full context of the issues. That fullness of the Deposit of Faith resides within the Catholic Church. If you have the humility to accept the teachings of the Church over your own “inspiration” than you can be saved, because you will then have the truth (rather than your own opinions) and the truth will set you free.
 
Yes, I was “born again” at my baptism at the Easter Vigil Mass of 1995. I have known that there is a God since as far back as I can remember. I really felt His presence when I was 10 years old. I wasn’t “born again” until I was 25 and became Catholic. I had been to many Protestant churches growing up, but never baptized. I knew I needed it, but it never happened. I remember well the joyous feeling of the Holy Spirit descending upon me at my baptism and then through confirmation.

As a Catholic, I have had all 4 of my children baptized as babies. Do I wish they could experience that 1st rush of the Holy Spirit as I did? Yes, I wish that they could remember it, but I know that in their way, they did experience it. They are just blessed to have it with them as part of their lives from an early age. I know that they will get a taste of what it was like for me when they get to their confirmation. I am grateful to the RCIA people who answered my questions about infant baptism. It was the 1st question that I had for them, but not the last! They directed me to the Catechism of the Catholic Church. It is a wonderful resource of what the church believes and why. It answered my question of why with biblical quotes and verses. It made so much sense. Jesus wants all to come to Him especially the children. Why would you want to hold them back? He healed through the faith of others, ie the soldier who wanted his servant healed, and Jesus did it because of the soldiers faith, not the servants.
 
Allis, don’t forget that St. Paul had already covered the importance of Baptism in romans 6: 3-5:

Notice the newness of life is associated with Baptism. He clearly is saying that Baptism is required to be saved.

The problem with personal interpretations of the Bible, is that you don’t have the full context of the issues. That fullness of the Deposit of Faith resides within the Catholic Church. If you have the humility to accept the teachings of the Church over your own “inspiration” than you can be saved, because you will then have the truth (rather than your own opinions) and the truth will set you free.
The word “baptized” in Romans 6:3-5 has nothing to do with water. this is talking of a spiritual baptism, or our union and assocition with Christ in his death. “Baptism” here refers to the spiritual union with christ rather than the physical picture. We must remenber that water Baptism is a picture of something else. It is a picture of our dying to sin in Christ, being buried with Christ and resurrecting with Christ. The word "baptized " means to be submerged or immersed. At the same time we die, are buried and raised with Christ through our faith in Him, we are placed (baptized, immersed) by the Holy Spirit into the body of Christ. This is what water baptism pictures. Paul is not speaking of the picture (water baptism) here but of the spiritual act of union with the death, burial and resuuection of Christ.
By the way I have the truth and it has set me free---- thank you!
 
Romans 8 : 16 Tells us that when God saves us the Spirit (God’s Spirit) bears witness to our spirit that we are the childern of God. Unsaved people do not have that witness and if you do not have that witness you are not born again. You can be baptized a hundred times and never have that witness because baptism does not save.
I’ll ask it again… why, if baptism doesn’t save, did St. Peter say “baptism, which now saves you?” What did he mean?
 
The word “baptized” in Romans 6:3-5 has nothing to do with water. this is talking of a spiritual baptism, or our union and assocition with Christ in his death. “Baptism” here refers to the spiritual union with christ rather than the physical picture. We must remenber that water Baptism is a picture of something else. It is a picture of our dying to sin in Christ, being buried with Christ and resurrecting with Christ. The word "baptized " means to be submerged or immersed. At the same time we die, are buried and raised with Christ through our faith in Him, we are placed (baptized, immersed) by the Holy Spirit into the body of Christ. This is what water baptism pictures. Paul is not speaking of the picture (water baptism) here but of the spiritual act of union with the death, burial and resuuection of Christ.
By the way I have the truth and it has set me free---- thank you!
On what basis are you interpreting what Paul says to not mean water baptism? Tradition says that baptism is always of water. Why do you think that Paul would diverge from that definition. Why would he use the word baptism if he meant a spiritual union. Why wouldn’t he have just said it that way?

This is just another example of bending the scriptures to say what you want it to say rather than to reflect the truth. This is a very, very weak argument on your part. Allow yourself to see the truth as it is, rather than how you prefer it to be.
 
The word “baptized” in Romans 6:3-5 has nothing to do with water. this is talking of a spiritual baptism, or our union and assocition with Christ in his death. “Baptism” here refers to the spiritual union with christ rather than the physical picture. We must remenber that water Baptism is a picture of something else. It is a picture of our dying to sin in Christ, being buried with Christ and resurrecting with Christ. The word "baptized " means to be submerged or immersed. At the same time we die, are buried and raised with Christ through our faith in Him, we are placed (baptized, immersed) by the Holy Spirit into the body of Christ. This is what water baptism pictures. Paul is not speaking of the picture (water baptism) here but of the spiritual act of union with the death, burial and resuuection of Christ.
By the way I have the truth and it has set me free---- thank you!
This is the prevalent protestant view that water Baptism is a symbolic act and not salvific. Sadly, it’s not a biblical position.

Acts 2:38 38Then Peter said unto them, Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost.

Acts 22:16 16And now why tarriest thou? Arise, and be baptized, and wash away thy sins, calling on the name of the Lord.

Scripture plainly tells us that Baptism washes away sin; and through Baptism, we receive the Holy Spirit. So, is it through baptism that we become Christians and members of the Body of Christ, or do we become Christians by accepting Jesus Christ as our personal Lord and Savior? There is no passage in the Bible that says we become Christians by accepting Jesus Christ as our personal Lord and Savior. While it is extremely important to have a personal relationship with Jesus, that in itself does not save.

1 Corinthians 12:13 13 For by one Spirit are we all baptized into one body [the body of Christ], whether we be Jews or Gentiles, whether we be bond or free; and have been all made to drink into one Spirit.

Galatians 3:27 27 For as many of you as have been baptized into Christ have put on Christ.

Clearly, baptism makes us members of the Body of Christ and thus is the entrance into the new covenant with God, just a circumcision was the entrance into the old covenant with God. Scripture makes this connection for us in the following:

Colossians 2:11-12 11 In whom also ye are circumcised with the circumcision made without hands, in putting off the body of the sins of the flesh by the circumcision of Christ:

12 Buried with him in baptism, wherein also ye are risen with him through the faith of the operation of God, who hath raised him from the dead.

Baptism is the entrance into the new covenant as explicitly stated in the scripture above. So, is baptism salvific as the Catholic Church teaches? Once again, let’s go to scripture.

1 Peter 3: 20-21 20Which sometime were disobedient, when once the longsuffering of God waited in the days of Noah, while the ark was a preparing, wherein few, that is, eight souls were saved by water.

21 The like figure whereunto even baptism doth **also now save us **(not the putting away of the filth of the flesh, but the answer of a good conscience toward God,) by the resurrection of Jesus Christ:

Just as Noah and his family were saved by water, water baptism now saves us. There it is; explicitly stated in the Bible. Further, let’s look at Jesus’ own words in John’s gospel…

John 3:5 5Jesus answered, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God.

I have heard the position claiming that the water spoken of here is the placental fluid inside the womb; but, scripture never says that. This position is an interpretation (I would call it tortured logic) that is not supported by the context of scripture. Further, let’s read on in context as follows a few verses later, after he finished his talk with Nicodemus…

John 3:22 22After these things came Jesus and his disciples into the land of Judaea; and there he tarried with them, and baptized.

What did Jesus do immediately after telling Nicodemus how he can be saved? He went out baptizing with water. See the context? Baptism is the context in which one must be born of water and the spirit. Further, look at all of the accounts in the synoptic gospels about Jesus’ own baptism. Jesus is baptized with water and look what happens to him when he comes up out of the water (or is sprinkled)… the spirit descends upon him – water and the spirit.

In Matthew 28:19 what did Jesus say in his final instructions to the apostles? Go therefore and make disciples of all nations getting them to accept me into their hearts as their personal lord and savior? No. It says:

19Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost:

Why is baptism given such paramount importance in Jesus’ final instructions to the apostles if it is only symbolic? This just makes no sense to me. It didn’t make sense to me when I was baptized as a young man into the Southern Baptist church of my parents, and it still makes no sense 41 years later. Scripture simply does not support a symbolic view of baptism.
 
The word “baptized” in Romans 6:3-5 has nothing to do with water.
Of course it is talking about water - that is the essential meaning of the word itself. In John 3:5, Jesus tells us that we need water AND the Holy Spirit. Not, “no water, but instead, the Holy Spirit.” No. Jesus requires BOTH.
“Baptism” here refers to the spiritual union with christ rather than the physical picture.
Yet, Jesus insisted on both the physical and the spiritual. Jesus’ death on the Cross was not only spiritual - it was also physical. We enter into His death both physically and spiritually.
We must remenber that water Baptism is a picture of something else. It is a picture of our dying to sin in Christ, being buried with Christ and resurrecting with Christ.
Yes, it is, and that’s why there is water.
The word "baptized " means to be submerged or immersed.
In water, yes. A Sacrament is a sign that actually does the thing that it signifies. The Sacrament of Baptism signifies dying to self and rising again into the life of Christ, and while the physical action is occurring, the spiritual reality is being made present, at the same time.
 
Sorry this reply was a little slow in coming. I feel like I should answer this one, though, since it’s nicely laid out and you are, after all, asking for a reply.
I’d like to pose a few questions to mmmcounts:
  1. I was baptized into the Catholic Church as an infant. Is this when I was born again?
Nope. Some of the things I will refer to in this reply will be covered more in-depth along with a link to a pretty good analysis of the Greek (gevvnthn ex udatos kai pneumatos is examined at great length), some comparison to other uses of udatos elsewhere in the Bible, and a synopsis of various views taken by various theologians.

Anyway, regarding this question, let me start by addressing what “born again” means lexically. The best translation for “anwthen” as it is used in verse 3 (and 31, in a different context) is “from above” (I have also seen it translated even more woodenly as “up-place”). The only other places you’ll see “anwthen” in John are in chapter 19 verses 11 and 23.

The phrase pertaining to being born of “water and the spirit” (gevvnthn ex udatos kai pneumatos) is something I’ll go into more in-depth in the follow-up post, but in summary, the water refers to purification (as does fire in Matthew 3:11), and the meaning of being “born of the spirit” (Jesus mentions “water and the spirit” once, and thereafter drops the water) is explained by Jesus because Nicodemus asks about it.
9"How can this be?" Nicodemus asked.
And you know something? Jesus answers that question. (There’s plenty more to be said about this part of John 3, but I will do that in the follow-up). Here are the highlights.
14Just as Moses lifted up the snake in the desert, so the Son of Man must be lifted up, 15that everyone who believes in him may have eternal life.
Jesus refers to His coming crucifixion. All who believe in Him may have eternal life. That is how a person is “born of the spirit.” Did you do this when you were an infant? Doubtful.
16"For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life."
I’m sure you’ve seen this one before.
  1. In 1997, I had a powerful conversion experience through the ministry of an evangelical Protestant men’s ministry. Is this when I was born again?
It’s possible. I don’t know for sure. Was there evidence of the Holy Spirit indwelling you and sanctifying you following this? Did the Spirit testify to you that you were cleansed? That’s the primary reason for Jesus mentioning water in this passage, you know- it represents cleansing. If it was nothing but an emotional prayer, though, you were not “born again” or “born from above.” You just prayed an emotional prayer.
  1. Somewhere in the middle of 1998, I was re-baptized in a Baptist church that regarded my infant baptism as invalid. Is this when I was born again?
No, that was when you were re-baptized in a Baptist church.
  1. In 2006, I was received into the Catholic Church. Is this when I was born again, or is it when I provided evidence that I wasn’t truly born again in the first place
I don’t think anyone here will tell you membership in the Catholic Church causes you to be born from above, saved, or anything else along those lines. When you were received into the Catholic Church, you were received into the Catholic Church. That’s it. The part I’m confused about is the evidence that you weren’t truly born again in the first place. I don’t understand what that evidence is, where it comes from, or what the point of mentioning it was.
What does the Bible say about how one becomes born again? The verse you quoted (with which Catholics agree wholeheartedly) speaks of the need to be born again, but not the method by which this takes place.
Actually, it does. (Well, born “from above”…also described here as “born of the spirit”). But I already covered that. Nicodemus asks the save question you did (How can this be?). Jesus answers. I gave you highlights. Take a look at the passage more carefully if you’re truly interested in the answer.
I know I shouldn’t be contributing to this thread, since it has nothing to do with “This Rock” magazine, but I couldn’t let this one slide.
It’s true, it doesn’t have anything to do with “This Rock” magazine. I just got a pm from the mod saying he moved it though, so I hope that takes care of it. I also hope you can find your way back to this easily enough. Thanks for contributing. I’m glad we’re getting a lot of chit-chat here.

Here’s that link with lots of good info that I will flesh out a little after lunch.
dbts.edu/journals/1999/McCabe.pdf

I don’t consider this person infallible, and I don’t give full assent to every single thing he says. I may even disagree with him here and there. However, it provides a large amount of very useful and relevant information. (The comparison of different views doesn’t go deeper than surface-level and is a little disappointing, but I will pick out the parts that I found most useful to this topic).

Also, one more question for you, djrakowski (kind of a repeat). I still don’t know if you’re born again. Do you? I can’t tell you one way or the other. You tell me.
 
Also, one more question for you, djrakowski (kind of a repeat). I still don’t know if you’re born again. Do you? I can’t tell you one way or the other. You tell me.
Is being born again an emotional feeling? Or is it something that we can verify objectively, by saying, “Okay, this happened, and then this happened, so we know that you are born again. You can be assured, no matter how you may feel at any given moment, that you have been born again. There is no way that you could have deceived yourself into thinking you were, and there is no way you can doubt that you are, because we have all verified that these events did, indeed, take place.”
 
Sorry this reply was a little slow in coming. I feel like I should answer this one, though, since it’s nicely laid out and you are, after all, asking for a reply.

Nope. Some of the things I will refer to in this reply will be covered more in-depth along with a link to a pretty good analysis of the Greek (gevvnthn ex udatos kai pneumatos is examined at great length), some comparison to other uses of udatos elsewhere in the Bible, and a synopsis of various views taken by various theologians.
That’s interesting… I thought the Bible was supposed to be easily understood by anyone with the ability to read. Why should you need to explain this passage by making recourse to Greek? Did the translators of every single English-language version of the Bible mess up the translation here?
It’s possible. I don’t know for sure. Was there evidence of the Holy Spirit indwelling you and sanctifying you following this? Did the Spirit testify to you that you were cleansed? That’s the primary reason for Jesus mentioning water in this passage, you know- it represents cleansing. If it was nothing but an emotional prayer, though, you were not “born again” or “born from above.” You just prayed an emotional prayer.
Well, I sincerely believe that I had evidence of the fruits of the spirit. But my Baptist friends, all sincere Bible-only Christians just as yourself, believe that my conversion to Catholicism means that I really didn’t. And with such a subjective standard as “Did the Spirit testify to you that you were cleansed?” who can blame them for being doubtful, since it’s really my word against theirs? Why should they accept what I say about my conversion experience when it’s all about whether I suspect the Holy Spirit testified that I was cleansed?

At any rate, yes, I believe I did receive those gifts as enumerated by the scriptures. But that’s me speaking - could I have easily been fooling myself? And could you and everyone else using the same standard be fooling yourselves? You haven’t yet reached the end of your life, and thus you can’t tell whether you’re going to persevere to the end. Is it possible that you, me, or anyone else who’s shared a similar experience could fall away, thus proving that their personal opinions about having received the fruits, gifts and testimony of the Spirit were not authentic at all?
I don’t think anyone here will tell you membership in the Catholic Church causes you to be born from above, saved, or anything else along those lines. When you were received into the Catholic Church, you were received into the Catholic Church. That’s it. The part I’m confused about is the evidence that you weren’t truly born again in the first place. I don’t understand what that evidence is, where it comes from, or what the point of mentioning it was.
According to my Baptist friends (actually, I should say former friends, as they no longer speak to me), the Catholic Church teaches false, man-made doctrines and is thus a perversion of true Christianity (naturally, as a Catholic, I couldn’t disagree with them more strongly). They claim that nobody who’s truly born again would voluntarily convert to the Catholic Church, and by having done so, I’ve proven that I was never saved to begin with (regardless of my personal testimony about what happened during and after that event at which I received Jesus as my personal Lord and Savior). Would you agree with them?

(continued)
 
Here’s that link with lots of good info that I will flesh out a little after lunch.
dbts.edu/journals/1999/McCabe.pdf

I don’t consider this person infallible, and I don’t give full assent to every single thing he says. I may even disagree with him here and there. However, it provides a large amount of very useful and relevant information. (The comparison of different views doesn’t go deeper than surface-level and is a little disappointing, but I will pick out the parts that I found most useful to this topic).
How am I to know which of the information included in this document is reliable? You said you didn’t agree with everything therein, which raises three obvious questions: 1) why did you recommend something with which you disagree even in part, and 2) which parts are unreliable, and 3) can you back up your opinions about what’s wrong with what he’s written with something other than a personal interpretation of scripture?

You see, this is what puts the lie to the doctrine of sola scriptura (actually, this is only one of the things, apart from scripture itself, which doesn’t affirm this doctrine of men). You’ve referred me to a document with which you partially disagree, but you have no way of assuring me whether the author is correct, or whether your differing interpretations are correct. Whom should I trust - you, the author of this document, myself, the pastor of the Assemblies of God congregation across the street from my parish, the pastor of the independent charismatic church that’s less than a mile north of that AofG congregation, Martin Luther, Ulrich Zwingl, John Calvin, Jan Hus, Jonathan Edwards, Charles Spurgeon, D.L. Moody, Josh McDowell, Joel Osteen, Paula White, Joyce Meyer, Brian Houston, Melissa Scott, Robert Schuller? There are serious differences about hwo the scriptures are to be interpreted, how one becomes saved, the place of the sacraments, etc. amongst these teachers. How do I know which is the right one? Which of these individuals can tell me the right way to be saved?

I sure hope it isn’t on the basis of only my own personal testimony that I can witness to having been saved. My life, even since that salvation experience in 1997, has had its share of ups and downs. I’ve been far from Christ, near to Christ, hungry for his word, passive about it, deeply immersed in prayer and service, and lazy about prayer and service - even since the time I was saved in 1997. There were times, because of my behavior, that I doubted my salvation. And there were other times I had those proverbial mountaintop experiences.

And yet, I say with assurance that I was saved (and am being saved, and Lord willing, will be saved). Why should anyone doubt that?
Also, one more question for you, djrakowski (kind of a repeat). I still don’t know if you’re born again. Do you? I can’t tell you one way or the other. You tell me.
I was born again at my baptism, though my family failed to nurture the graces of that sacrament by instructing me in the faith. I had a powerful conversion experience in 1997, fter which the graces granted me in the sacrament of baptism were brought to life as I began to cooperate with the gift Our Lord had given me (as we have free will and are fully capable of deciding whether to accept or reject His love). Then I was brought into the fullness of the Christian faith when Our Lord called me home to his One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. And now I have assurance of the forgiveness of sins committed since baptism through the sacrament of reconciliation, through which I received the graces necessary to overcome sins that had plagued me my entire adult life.

So, am I born again? Can anyone, anywhere, ever challenge the personal assertion of one who claims to have been born again? By your subjective standard, I don’t think that’s possible.
 
Baptism In The Early Church

The Book of Acts records several incidents when the Apostles found people who had not received a full baptism. These people had been washed clean from sin, but they had not received the Holy Spirit. The Apostles laid hands on them, and they received the Holy Spirit - completing Christian baptism.

In the 1st. Century, baptism was given by immersing a person three times under the water,“in the name of the Father, and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.” (This is recorded in a document called “The Teaching Of The Lord”.)

By the 2nd. Century, a person was washed three times, in the name of the Trinity. Then he was anointed with oil which had been blessed. The name “Christ” means “The Anointed One”. Each new convert was anointed to become a Christian. (We know this from the writings of Justin Martyr, 165 A.D., and Theophilus of Antioch.)

From about 200 A.D. we have several detailed descriptions of baptism. It was normal to baptize children as well as adults. First, the convert renounced Satan, then he was anointed with ordinary oil. He made a statement of his Christian faith - a “Creed”. Next, prayers were said over the water, and the convert was immersed three times in the name of the Trinity. His body was spiritually cleansed and his soul was physically washed. As soon as he came up out of the water, he was anointed with blessed oil. Then the presbyter (or bishop) laid his hands on the person to call down the Holy Spirit. The new Christian could now go into the Eucharist service and receive Communion. (The writings of Tertullian, 200 A.D., and Hippolytus of Rome, 215 A.D., describe these things.)

Many early Christian writings still survive. You can read them in translation as the “Early Christian Fathers”. They show you what the Church really believed and did in those early centuries
orthodoxchurch.co.uk/occwi.htm
 
How am I to know which of the information included in this document is reliable? You said you didn’t agree with everything therein, which raises three obvious questions: 1) why did you recommend something with which you disagree even in part, and 2) which parts are unreliable, and 3) can you back up your opinions about what’s wrong with what he’s written with something other than a personal interpretation of scripture?

You see, this is what puts the lie to the doctrine of sola scriptura (actually, this is only one of the things, apart from scripture itself, which doesn’t affirm this doctrine of men). You’ve referred me to a document with which you partially disagree, but you have no way of assuring me whether the author is correct, or whether your differing interpretations are correct. Whom should I trust - you, the author of this document, myself, the pastor of the Assemblies of God congregation across the street from my parish, the pastor of the independent charismatic church that’s less than a mile north of that AofG congregation, Martin Luther, Ulrich Zwingl, John Calvin, Jan Hus, Jonathan Edwards, Charles Spurgeon, D.L. Moody, Josh McDowell, Joel Osteen, Paula White, Joyce Meyer, Brian Houston, Melissa Scott, Robert Schuller? There are serious differences about hwo the scriptures are to be interpreted, how one becomes saved, the place of the sacraments, etc. amongst these teachers. How do I know which is the right one? Which of these individuals can tell me the right way to be saved?

I sure hope it isn’t on the basis of only my own personal testimony that I can witness to having been saved. My life, even since that salvation experience in 1997, has had its share of ups and downs. I’ve been far from Christ, near to Christ, hungry for his word, passive about it, deeply immersed in prayer and service, and lazy about prayer and service - even since the time I was saved in 1997. There were times, because of my behavior, that I doubted my salvation. And there were other times I had those proverbial mountaintop experiences.

And yet, I say with assurance that I was saved (and am being saved, and Lord willing, will be saved). Why should anyone doubt that?
I was born again at my baptism, though my family failed to nurture the graces of that sacrament by instructing me in the faith. I had a powerful conversion experience in 1997, fter which the graces granted me in the sacrament of baptism were brought to life as I began to cooperate with the gift Our Lord had given me (as we have free will and are fully capable of deciding whether to accept or reject His love). Then I was brought into the fullness of the Christian faith when Our Lord called me home to his One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. And now I have assurance of the forgiveness of sins committed since baptism through the sacrament of reconciliation, through which I received the graces necessary to overcome sins that had plagued me my entire adult life.

So, am I born again? Can anyone, anywhere, ever challenge the personal assertion of one who claims to have been born again? By your subjective standard, I don’t think that’s possible.
:amen:

God Bless,
Michael
 
I do not have time to answer your first question now,

What took place in my life that give me confidence in my salvation, it was a number of things. A search for God that ended in a deep inter peace, a growing love for Jesus Christ, A love so great for his Word that the day is not complete if I do not study if every day, and much more.
Beautiful, really. I’ve felt that way so many times. I just wonder which time was the time I was ‘saved’? Or am I ‘saved’ everytime my faith grows stronger?
 
I would just like to commend the contributors on this thread. The posts that I have read have been “God Honoring” even though it is a difficult and passionate issue.
I think that salvation is non-denominational, ( Paul asks, Was Christ divided? ) and personal. In my opinion, this is the best way to know about one’s salvation.

*** Originally Posted by allischalmers View Post

What took place in my life that give me confidence in my salvation, it was a number of things. A search for God that ended in a deep inter peace, a growing love for Jesus Christ, A love so great for his Word that the day is not complete if I do not study if every day, and much more.***

God Bless.
 
  1. I was baptized into the Catholic Church as an infant.
  2. In 1997, I had a powerful conversion experience through the ministry of an evangelical Protestant men’s ministry. Is this when I was born again?
    .
It would seem yes … you had a Confirmation of sorts, as a Baptized adult.

If the Church really believed infant baptism was the endall of grace for Catholics … they wouldn’t teach what they do re: Confirmation
 
The word “baptized” in Romans 6:3-5 has nothing to do with water. this is talking of a spiritual baptism, or our union and assocition with Christ in his death. “Baptism” here refers to the spiritual union with christ rather than the physical picture. We must remenber that water Baptism is a picture of something else. It is a picture of our dying to sin in Christ, being buried with Christ and resurrecting with Christ. The word "baptized " means to be submerged or immersed. At the same time we die, are buried and raised with Christ through our faith in Him, we are placed (baptized, immersed) by the Holy Spirit into the body of Christ. This is what water baptism pictures. Paul is not speaking of the picture (water baptism) here but of the spiritual act of union with the death, burial and resuuection of Christ.
By the way I have the truth and it has set me free---- thank you!
A.C. …

Believe what you want, but Christ clearly taught BOTH water and spiritual Baptism.

I don’t think the order is essential … so long as both are accomplished. Paul first received H.S. … and shortly thereafter received water baptism. Christ believed water baptism so important that he had JTB baptize him.

At any rate, you did finally undergo water Baptism. Confirmed, before you were Baptized.

Still, you would benefit greatly from RCIA … and entry into the orginal Church started by Christ. You would also receive a Catholic Confirmation, and be allowed to receive the Eucharist … as Christ intended it to be received.

Many rebirthed Protestants have later entered Catholic Church … and most will tell you its the best move they ever made.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top