Have you been born again?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mmmcounts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
How is it that the Bible can be inerrant in matters of faith and morals, if the Catholic men (including a Pope) who wrote it were not, themselves, infallible with regard to their teachings on faith and morals? 🤷

Or do you believe that the Bible fell down from Heaven already written, collected, and bound into its codex binding - or that God took hold of those men, possessed their bodies, and forced them to write His words by means of automatic writing? 😉
Excellent point… I think this is the key question sola scripturists have to answer.

R.C. Sproul, a prominent Calvinist theologian, has been quoted as saying something like the following: “the Bible is a fallible collection of infallible books.” I give him high marks for honesty, but not on theology. If your Bible is a fallible collection (since it was compiled by fallible men), who’s to say that the books contained therein are the right ones, and who’s to say that some books that should’ve been included were not?

For more on the Catholic case against sola scriptura, I recommend the following (especially for mmmcounts and allischalmers):

The Catholic Case Against Sola Scriptura
 
As an 8 day old baby, what did you repent of?
Nothing since the eight-day old has not committed any personal sins. However, baptism achieves the transition from being in a state of sin as a result of being in the line of Adam to a state of justification as a result of being “in Christ”.

Hope this helps. :tiphat:
 
3m,

Rather than spending so much time initiating pointless debates on another religion’s website or intensely studying your Bible looking for “gotcha” passages how about using that time doing charity like Jesus asked?
 
I was baptized about three years after God saved me and it was to be obedent to God,s command to do so. However my sins where not washed away when I was baptized. They were washed away by the blood of Jesus Christ the moment that I was saved.

And I was not saved by walking an aisle or saying the siiner prayer.
As you describe it, then I would say that you were saved as a result of baptism of desire…specifically, you were saved as a result of your implicit desire for baptism.

Perhaps I should explain. When someone goes to see a physician, he has an explicit desire to be healed of his illness. When the physician announces, “What you need is penicillin”, the patient would readily agree if that was, in fact, the cure. Therefore, all along, the paitent had an explicit desire to be cured and an implicit desire for the penicillin which would do the job.

You, had an explicit desire to be saved and an implicit desire for baptism which actually achieves the effect of making you “born again”.

Hope this helps. :tiphat:
 
The word “baptized” in Romans 6:3-5 has nothing to do with water. this is talking of a spiritual baptism, or our union and assocition with Christ in his death. “Baptism” here refers to the spiritual union with christ rather than the physical picture. We must remenber that water Baptism is a picture of something else. It is a picture of our dying to sin in Christ, being buried with Christ and resurrecting with Christ. The word "baptized " means to be submerged or immersed. At the same time we die, are buried and raised with Christ through our faith in Him, we are placed (baptized, immersed) by the Holy Spirit into the body of Christ. This is what water baptism pictures. Paul is not speaking of the picture (water baptism) here but of the spiritual act of union with the death, burial and resuuection of Christ.
By the way I have the truth and it has set me free---- thank you!
You have already been corrected about this many times, but I will do so again lest anyone following this thread be led astray by your erroneous interpretations.

Mark 16:16
Whoever believes and is baptized will be saved, but whoever does not believe will be condemned.

Whoever does A and B will be saved.

Put another way: the person who does A will also do B and will be saved. The person who does not do A will not do B and will be condemned.

In your case, you did A and finally did B three years later.
 
Why is baptism given such paramount importance in Jesus’ final instructions to the apostles if it is only symbolic? This just makes no sense to me. It didn’t make sense to me when I was baptized as a young man into the Southern Baptist church of my parents, and it still makes no sense 41 years later. Scripture simply does not support a symbolic view of baptism.
The same is true of Protestant “communion”. It’s purely symbolic, and Protestants have no real idea why they drink a tiny cup filled with grape juice and nibble a small piece of cracker since these things are mere symbols.

It’s the Law of New Testament exchanged for the Law of the Old. They are following the letter of the Law by complying with what scripture plainly records that Jesus commanded, but there is no Spirit of the Law because they have rejected the real meaning of the sacraments that He instituted.

The troubling thing is: Paul said that we are not saved by works of the Law, and if it weren’t for the fact that non-Catholic baptisms may be valid, I might ask if Paul’s words could not applied to these symbolic Protestant “works”, also.
 
3m,

Rather than spending so much time initiating pointless debates on another religion’s website or intensely studying your Bible looking for “gotcha” passages how about using that time doing charity like Jesus asked?
I do stuff. There’s just no reason to go on a Catholic forum and talk about it.
 
How is it that the Bible can be inerrant in matters of faith and morals, if the Catholic men (including a Pope) who wrote it were not, themselves, infallible with regard to their teachings on faith and morals? 🤷

Or do you believe that the Bible fell down from Heaven already written, collected, and bound into its codex binding - or that God took hold of those men, possessed their bodies, and forced them to write His words by means of automatic writing? 😉
I do believe that the OT canon, at any rate, was well established well before the Church of Rome existed. I’d say more, but it’s not at all on topic, you thread-jacker.
 
I do believe that the OT canon, at any rate, was well established well before the Church of Rome existed. I’d say more, but it’s not at all on topic, you thread-jacker.
jmcrae’s post isn’t off-topic. Your theology relies upon the fundamental errors of sola scriptura and individual interpretation of scripture, so it’s important to establish a baseline regarding what the scriptures are and how they came into being.

On what basis do you believe the scriptures to be infallible (inerrant was the word we used in my old Baptist church), especially since they were compiled by fallible men?

And what do you think of RC Sproul’s statement that the Bible is “a fallible collection of infallible books?”
 
What is the reason you come on a Catholic forum?
Ockham, I think that’s a fair question. In my experience, non-Catholics have a few reasons for coming here. 1) they think ours is a church that teaches false doctrines, full of people who’ve never heard the true gospel, and thus we’re seen as a mission field (fortunately, mmm has said that joining the Catholic Church doesn’t immediately call into question the validity of a person’s salvation); 2) they get a kick out of contentious debate and enjoy ticking off Catholics
; 3) they earnestly want to learn about our faith in a spirit of positive ecumenism; 4) they’re interested in converting to Catholicism.

The charitable side of me wants to believe that mmm is here for #3, but the title of the post suggests reason #1. I hope I’m wrong.
 
Quote me one Early Church Father that did not recognize John 3:5 as referring to water baptism. This was one of the only doctrines that was unanimously agreed upon by all of the fathers. Baptism is a regeneration (see Titus 3:5) whereby our sins are forgiven (see Acts 2:38) and we are made a new creation in Christ. As Christians we are born again in baptism and we believed this for 2000 years. There was no sinners prayer or altar calls in the early century Church. Sorry but there is only one faith and one baptism (see Ephesians 4) for all, not 30,000 different denominations of Christians all disputing the commands of Christ…teachccd
I don’t know about John 3:5 specifically, but Clement of Rome did not teach baptismal regeneration. It’s true that most did, but not all. There really wasn’t much of anything that was “unanimously agreed upon by all of the fathers,” so it’s probably a good idea to stop using that argument. The early church fathers disagreed on many things and were certainly fallible- Augustine and Jerome felt that the church was in a bit of a crisis during their generation. Some examples of their fallibility can be found in Origen- he said the Holy Spirit was a created being and that Satan and the demons would get back into heaven. We shouldn’t look to the early church leaders for the same infallible guidance we get from the Bible- we’ll get all sorts of teachings from that and some will be flawed. And one of those things is Tertullian’s “law of baptism” (or martyrdom, either one).

Oh, one more thing: There is only one Body of Christ, but within that body are way more than 30,000 sects and denominations. Just because a tree has a lot of branches doesn’t mean it’s fractured and in danger. If there are complaints from the Branch of Rome, it only means that branch needs an attitude adjustment.
 
yes I was baptized along with bolth my children and will soon baptize mu third:)
 
Ockham, I think that’s a fair question. In my experience, non-Catholics have a few reasons for coming here. 1) they think ours is a church that teaches false doctrines, full of people who’ve never heard the true gospel, and thus we’re seen as a mission field (fortunately, mmm has said that joining the Catholic Church doesn’t immediately call into question the validity of a person’s salvation); 2) they get a kick out of contentious debate and enjoy ticking off Catholics
; 3) they earnestly want to learn about our faith in a spirit of positive ecumenism; 4) they’re interested in converting to Catholicism.

The charitable side of me wants to believe that mmm is here for #3, but the title of the post suggests reason #1. I hope I’m wrong.
I pray for #3 & 4, but with 3M I suspect #1 & 2 are his motivations. Let’s keep the faith for him in this year of St. Paul.

I battled a few Sola Scripturists in a non-church related chatroom awhile back. These were seasoned foaming at the mouth Fundamentalists and vehemently anti-Catholic. Two things surprised me; how much disinformation they had on the Church and how easy it was to squash their attacks. I’m no trained apologist so if I could handle those guys I wonder what someone with real book learning could do.

At the end of the day, I feel sorry for our lost Protestant brothers and sisters. I believe their hostility towards God’s Church stems from a frustration of trying to find truth in the falsehood of Sola Scripture. Cognitive dissonance of faith must be a terrible thing to endure. They want to experience Christ but have layers of prejudice and bigotry towards His Church.
 
Oh, one more thing: There is only one Body of Christ, but within that body are way more than 30,000 sects and denominations. Just because a tree has a lot of branches doesn’t mean it’s fractured and in danger. If there are complaints from the Branch of Rome, it only means that branch needs an attitude adjustment.
Wait a second… you and your fellow non-Catholic Christians agree on little else, aside from the fact that you think the Catholic Church teaches false doctrines. And you’re the ones telling us that our church needs an attitude adjustment?

Thank goodness most of the non-Catholic Christians I meet don’t approach me and my fellow Catholics in the condescending and insulting manner you’ve taken in this thread. I wonder how many Catholics you expect to attract by mocking our Church as needing an “attitude adjustment.”
I pray for #3 & 4, but with 3M I suspect #1 & 2 are his motivations. Let’s keep the faith for him in this year of St. Paul.
I’ll join you in seeking St. Paul’s intercession for our non-Catholic brothers and sisters - great idea 👍
I battled a few Sola Scripturists in a non-church related chatroom awhile back. These were seasoned foaming at the mouth Fundamentalists and vehemently anti-Catholic. Two things surprised me; how much disinformation they had on the Church and how easy it was to squash their attacks. I’m no trained apologist so if I could handle those guys I wonder what someone with real book learning could do.
:rotfl: You should listen to Patrick Madrid or Jimmy Akin debate James White!
At the end of the day, I feel sorry for our lost Protestant brothers and sisters. I believe their hostility towards God’s Church stems from a frustration of trying to find truth in the falsehood of Sola Scripture. Cognitive dissonance of faith must be a terrible thing to endure. They want to experience Christ but have layers of prejudice and bigotry towards His Church.
Oh, I wouldn’t take it that far. I believe Our Lord has given them grace upon grace to accomplish the great things they’ve done for Him in this world. I wish they’d stop targeting my fellow Catholics for missionary activity, but they’ve done a lot of good apart from that.

I mean, of course I’d like them to have the fullness of the means of grace, but Our Lord has certainly been generous in what He has given them. They’ve done a lot with a little, and Our Lord should receive all glory, honor and praise for that.
 
I don’t know about John 3:5 specifically, but Clement of Rome did not teach baptismal regeneration.
He didn’t mention the subject at all, that I am aware of, other than when he rather obliquely refers to Noah’s regeneration (which seems like it could be a reference to St. Peter’s sermon on Baptism).

What if, instead, we say, “The Fathers who actually mentioned the subject of Baptism unanimously teach baptismal regeneration.” 😃
 
Thank goodness most of the non-Catholic Christians I meet don’t approach me and my fellow Catholics in the condescending and insulting manner you’ve taken in this thread. I wonder how many Catholics you expect to attract by mocking our Church as needing an “attitude adjustment.”
Do you or do you not assent to the common Roman Catholic belief that the Church of Rome is the One True Church of Christ at the exclusion of all other “Christians?”

First, if you do think that’s true, I’m a little curious about where those other Christians are if it’s not in the Body of Christ, the Church, of which Christ is the head. A fake church, perhaps? A different one?

Second, I’m a little curious about where these people are in the Kingdom of God. Did all of them fail to get in because they didn’t get let in by a Catholic priest? If they are in God’s kingdom, are they figuratively separated from the “True Church” members? What will this look like in God’s eternal kingdom? Should the rest of us tiptoe by all of you so you can continue believing you’re the only ones there? Or do you really think you’ll be the only ones there?

Third, if you think participation in the Roman Catholic Church (and only the Roman Catholic Church) is somehow necessary for someone to live with God eternally, how can you possibly defend this and what is wrong with your theology? If it means nothing concerning salvation to be “not a part of” Christ’s One True Church, what’s the point of exclusion? Seriously, What Is The Point? What are you trying to prove?

If you do, in fact, believe the Church of Rome is Christ’s One True Church at the exclusion of all non-Roman Catholic sects and denominations, you need to seriously examine what kind of message that sends. Perhaps you’d like to trade that sort of sentiment for one that’s more friendly to ecumenical dialogue, because identification of the Roman Catholic Church as the One and Only True Church has a way of doing just the opposite. It should go without saying that if you believe something along those lines, you should believe something that’s more ecumenically friendly. I’ve also stated this in terms of an “attitude adjustment,” but you thought that was mocking. :confused: 🤷 Whatevs, let’s hope “be more ecumenically friendly” comes across better.

I may have to start a new thread on this- something about Jesus’ One True Universal Worldwide Church. Where do you think it should go?
 
Do you or do you not assent to the common Roman Catholic belief that the Church of Rome is the One True Church of Christ at the exclusion of all other “Christians?”

First, if you do think that’s true, I’m a little curious about where those other Christians are if it’s not in the Body of Christ, the Church, of which Christ is the head. A fake church, perhaps? A different one?

Second, I’m a little curious about where these people are in the Kingdom of God. Did all of them fail to get in because they didn’t get let in by a Catholic priest? If they are in God’s kingdom, are they figuratively separated from the “True Church” members? What will this look like in God’s eternal kingdom? Should the rest of us tiptoe by all of you so you can continue believing you’re the only ones there? Or do you really think you’ll be the only ones there?

Third, if you think participation in the Roman Catholic Church (and only the Roman Catholic Church) is somehow necessary for someone to live with God eternally, how can you possibly defend this and what is wrong with your theology? If it means nothing concerning salvation to be “not a part of” Christ’s One True Church, what’s the point of exclusion? Seriously, What Is The Point? What are you trying to prove?

If you do, in fact, believe the Church of Rome is Christ’s One True Church at the exclusion of all non-Roman Catholic sects and denominations, you need to seriously examine what kind of message that sends. Perhaps you’d like to trade that sort of sentiment for one that’s more friendly to ecumenical dialogue, because identification of the Roman Catholic Church as the One and Only True Church has a way of doing just the opposite. It should go without saying that if you believe something along those lines, you should believe something that’s more ecumenically friendly. I’ve also stated this in terms of an “attitude adjustment,” but you thought that was mocking. :confused: 🤷 Whatevs, let’s hope “be more ecumenically friendly” comes across better.
Given the tone of your posts in this thread, I can only conclude that you’re not here for either ecumenical dialogue in the spirit of Christian friendship, and that you’re not trying to convert us (that would require a bit more charity than you’ve displayed in your most recent posts). It seems you’ve come here for contentious debate, and that’s a shame.

All of your questions are answered here and here. Read these and come back with some questions that reflect an understanding of what we mean when we call ourselves Christ’s one true church.

And it’s not ecumenically insensitive if it’s true.
I may have to start a new thread on this- something about Jesus’ One True Universal Worldwide Church. Where do you think it should go?
I’d recommend that you start the thread in Apologetics, though if you do a search, you’ll see that such threads have been started many times over.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top