A
auderyja
Guest
Haha, that’s a good one!Prof. Scott Hahn told this to his confessor soon after his conversion to Catholicism. The wise priest asked him: “What do you want, new sins?”
Haha, that’s a good one!Prof. Scott Hahn told this to his confessor soon after his conversion to Catholicism. The wise priest asked him: “What do you want, new sins?”
Yes. sometimes. I remember one very holy, young priest, as I stumbled to reveal my sin, he said, please don’t be embarrassed, Jesus wants to free you of this sin and He loves you so much…Yes, I admit it. Some of my sins are really embarassing to confess. Does anyone else feel like I do?
I’m too embarrassed to say ‘masturbation’
Does anybody go in and explicitly say that? Or is there a more polite way to say it??
You need to split up the porn as its own sin - it is coveting. The masturbation is assumed to include orgasm, I think, since that is the norm. If you don’t take it all the way, you could say “I stopped myself from continuing 3 x, but did the whole act 7 times,” for example.Oh, and is looking at pornography, masturbating then ejaculating all 3 different sins??
Cause the masturbating involves the action and thoughts while ejaculating is the spilling of your seed.
…and if someone said, no just masturbating, does that mean that once i touch myself i may as well finish off…because the sin is already committed?
Sorry if thats a bit gross for you - it IS what happens…and perhaps my age/hormones/dirty mind have made me curious and insensitive.
- not that i’m planning to (without a struggle against sin anyway), but just saying…
hmm…I was taught that Confession should be more specific in terms of saying what kinds of sin… I was told, to just say what you did, rather than only what Commandment it breaks. Because there are various ways to break a Commandment and we should include anything that affects the gravity of the sin. For example - if a person says they sinned against chastity… do they mean that they had an impure thought, or they had premarital sex, or something else? if they dishonoured their parents, did they have an angry thought against them, or did they physically attack their parent? etc. It’s good to clarify and be more specific I think… just because there are different things that break each Commandment, not just one. What we think and what’s in our hearts is important, for example Jesus said if someone has lust they already committed adultery, and same with anger / murder, maybe because sin is in the heart and in the intention too… but I was told that for Confession, we should actually name the sin, rather than only saying “I broke the fourth Commandment” etc.I wouldn’t confess to the priest you’ve included him in your fantasy. What would you do if he then replied likewise? :bigyikes: You’d have to get the hell outta there!!:stretcher:
In general, I think you should list sins according to the commandment they fall under eg. say ‘I have 6 sins against the 4th commandment, 3 against the 8th commandment, 2 against the 2 commandment, and 5(oo) against the 6th commandment’. That’s all they need.
Yes you are right here. I just think that in confessing sins you dont want to give unnecessary temptation to the priest (because that is a sin). I could never be a priest cause i could not cope with hearing all the sins.hmm…I was taught that Confession should be more specific in terms of saying what kinds of sin… I was told, to just say what you did, rather than only what Commandment it breaks. Because there are various ways to break a Commandment and we should include anything that affects the gravity of the sin. For example - if a person says they sinned against chastity… do they mean that they had an impure thought, or they had premarital sex, or something else? if they dishonoured their parents, did they have an angry thought against them, or did they physically attack their parent? etc. It’s good to clarify and be more specific I think… just because there are different things that break each Commandment, not just one. What we think and what’s in our hearts is important, for example Jesus said if someone has lust they already committed adultery, and same with anger / murder, maybe because sin is in the heart and in the intention too… but I was told that for Confession, we should actually name the sin, rather than only saying “I broke the fourth Commandment” etc.